登陆注册
14817900000002

第2章

He wanders on from one topic to another, careless of the unity of his work, not fearing any 'judge, or spectator, who may recall him to the point' (Theat.), 'whither the argument blows we follow' (Rep.). To have determined beforehand, as in a modern didactic treatise, the nature and limits of the subject, would have been fatal to the spirit of enquiry or discovery, which is the soul of the dialogue...These remarks are applicable to nearly all the works of Plato, but to the Cratylus and Phaedrus more than any others. See Phaedrus, Introduction.

There is another aspect under which some of the dialogues of Plato may be more truly viewed:--they are dramatic sketches of an argument. We have found that in the Lysis, Charmides, Laches, Protagoras, Meno, we arrived at no conclusion--the different sides of the argument were personified in the different speakers; but the victory was not distinctly attributed to any of them, nor the truth wholly the property of any. And in the Cratylus we have no reason to assume that Socrates is either wholly right or wholly wrong, or that Plato, though he evidently inclines to him, had any other aim than that of personifying, in the characters of Hermogenes, Socrates, and Cratylus, the three theories of language which are respectively maintained by them.

The two subordinate persons of the dialogue, Hermogenes and Cratylus, are at the opposite poles of the argument. But after a while the disciple of the Sophist and the follower of Heracleitus are found to be not so far removed from one another as at first sight appeared; and both show an inclination to accept the third view which Socrates interposes between them. First, Hermogenes, the poor brother of the rich Callias, expounds the doctrine that names are conventional; like the names of slaves, they may be given and altered at pleasure. This is one of those principles which, whether applied to society or language, explains everything and nothing. For in all things there is an element of convention; but the admission of this does not help us to understand the rational ground or basis in human nature on which the convention proceeds. Socrates first of all intimates to Hermogenes that his view of language is only a part of a sophistical whole, and ultimately tends to abolish the distinction between truth and falsehood. Hermogenes is very ready to throw aside the sophistical tenet, and listens with a sort of half admiration, half belief, to the speculations of Socrates.

Cratylus is of opinion that a name is either a true name or not a name at all. He is unable to conceive of degrees of imitation; a word is either the perfect expression of a thing, or a mere inarticulate sound (a fallacy which is still prevalent among theorizers about the origin of language).

He is at once a philosopher and a sophist; for while wanting to rest language on an immutable basis, he would deny the possibility of falsehood.

He is inclined to derive all truth from language, and in language he sees reflected the philosophy of Heracleitus. His views are not like those of Hermogenes, hastily taken up, but are said to be the result of mature consideration, although he is described as still a young man. With a tenacity characteristic of the Heracleitean philosophers, he clings to the doctrine of the flux. (Compare Theaet.) Of the real Cratylus we know nothing, except that he is recorded by Aristotle to have been the friend or teacher of Plato; nor have we any proof that he resembled the likeness of him in Plato any more than the Critias of Plato is like the real Critias, or the Euthyphro in this dialogue like the other Euthyphro, the diviner, in the dialogue which is called after him.

Between these two extremes, which have both of them a sophistical character, the view of Socrates is introduced, which is in a manner the union of the two. Language is conventional and also natural, and the true conventional-natural is the rational. It is a work not of chance, but of art; the dialectician is the artificer of words, and the legislator gives authority to them. They are the expressions or imitations in sound of things. In a sense, Cratylus is right in saying that things have by nature names; for nature is not opposed either to art or to law. But vocal imitation, like any other copy, may be imperfectly executed; and in this way an element of chance or convention enters in. There is much which is accidental or exceptional in language. Some words have had their original meaning so obscured, that they require to be helped out by convention. But still the true name is that which has a natural meaning. Thus nature, art, chance, all combine in the formation of language. And the three views respectively propounded by Hermogenes, Socrates, Cratylus, may be described as the conventional, the artificial or rational, and the natural. The view of Socrates is the meeting-point of the other two, just as conceptualism is the meeting-point of nominalism and realism.

同类推荐
热门推荐
  • 小小的世界,小小的我们

    小小的世界,小小的我们

    小情侣间的小日常,用平凡与简单书写我们的爱
  • 有一条只能向前的路叫时光

    有一条只能向前的路叫时光

    那一条不能回头的路里,有欢笑,有泪水,有你,有我。如果有一天能从新来过,你还会你的坚持么。
  • 圣影系统

    圣影系统

    南决,高中毕业前得到圣影系统,取得全国状元,以优异成绩踏入华夏学府……你说你的身世比我强吗?来比比!你说你身家雄厚?来比比!你说你智商比我高?来比比!不管你想比什么,南决奉陪到底!
  • 考拉

    考拉

    本文一对一,甜宠,HE,请放心入坑。作为一个拥有无敌嘴炮技能的小小说书人,成小小竟然被从房顶拎着了扔到小馆馆——南风馆。而且还正好砸到了传说中的馆主尽欢公子封锦欢的床上!只是……这公子好像正在被痴女强扑啊……公子你实在是太好心了,收留无家可归的我,小小一定会忠心耿耿的!可是公子你这是要干嘛……公子公子你别急啊……千万别急!
  • 就当作是游戏

    就当作是游戏

    张文进入到一个数据化的世界,渐渐发现原来这个世界的数据化竟是外来人为制造生物武器所散播的病毒,被病毒感染的生物逃不掉被外来人控制的命运,张文决心要逃离外来人的控制,然后……
  • 妃常嘚瑟

    妃常嘚瑟

    穿越女楚文玉,前世因为被父母抛弃,而自暴自弃,最后被人欺骗染上了毒品临终,悔恨的流下眼泪。一场莫名其妙的穿越,让她成为楚朝的皇女,本想默默无闻,可在这内中终逃不过命运。斗皇姐、杀奸臣、做皇帝!~~收美男~~(剧透:别朝质子轩辕铭,自第一眼见她起,从她眼中看到了相同的悲哀,决定保护她。宰相之子莫离,"楚文玉,你要我也要我,不要我也得要我"…………嘿嘿,请期待。
  • 排毒养生:人体环保使用手册

    排毒养生:人体环保使用手册

    你知道身上有多少毒素吗?空气、土壤、水和食物中的毒素,在体内不断地沉积,若不及时排除出来,健康就要拉警报了。 排毒是一种全面维护身体健康与平衡的健康观念。它能有效预防疾病,净化身心,帮助体内排除各种毒素,让营养素健康地循环运作,减少脂肪囤积,消灭有害细菌,活化身体机能,减缓老化。 本书着重从饮食、运动、按摩、精神等方面,全面讲解各种自然排毒的原理和方法,并附有大量的“排毒小提示”,告知各种注意事项、禁忌和专家提醒等要点,内容生动活泼,注重实用性。 如果你想在生活中用最自然、最有效的方式来保持健康,那么请跟随本书开始你的健康排毒之旅吧。
  • 万劫剑神

    万劫剑神

    纵万劫沉沦,我仍执剑杀神!回首已是百年身,陈昊重回少年时代,前世的不甘与悔恨我要让它荡然无存!霸道的开始,必然要完美的结束!这一世,我要败尽天下、傲啸六道、剑指苍天!这一世,我要世间都是我的传说!【—《万劫剑神》急求支持!—】
  • 轻触不到的恋人

    轻触不到的恋人

    每个人都有一位触不到的恋人……爱ta,却触不到ta,当想到ta的时候,是否无奈过……
  • 神源道种

    神源道种

    一颗神秘的种子,一个消失的世界。三百万年前,仙皇帝国覆灭,始地化为巨阙天宫消失于混沌,本源沉寂。圣皇元年,神荒之地,婴儿的啼哭声惊动石木村的村长,同样惊动了盘古混沌界。仙种萌芽,天道初现,人阻我,我杀人,神档我,我弑神,天要灭我,我必灭天。更多章节起点搜索《混沌仙种》