登陆注册
15792600000005

第5章

This mode of thinking is entirely natural.The training of lawyers is a training in logic.The processes of analogy, discrimination, and deduction are those in which they are most at home.The language of judicial decision is mainly the language of logic.And the logical method and form flatter that longing for certainty and for repose which is in every human mind.But certainty generally is illusion, and repose is not the destiny of man.Behind the logical form lies a judgment as to the relative worth and importance of competing legislative grounds, often an inarticulate and unconscious judgment, it is true, and yet the very root and nerve of the whole proceeding.You can give any conclusion a logical form.You always can imply a condition in a contract.But why do you imply it? It is because of some belief as to the practice of the community or of a class, or because of some opinion as to policy, or, in short, because of some attitude of yours upon a matter not capable of exact quantitative measurement, and therefore not capable of founding exact logical conclusions.Such matters really are battle grounds where the means do not exist for the determinations that shall be good for all time, and where the decision can do no more than embody the preference of a given body in a given time and place.We do not realize how large a part of our law is open to reconsideration upon a slight change in the habit of the public mind.No concrete proposition is self evident, no matter how ready we may be to accept it, not even Mr.Herbert Spencer's "Every man has a right to do what he wills, provided he interferes not with a like right on the part of his neighbors."Why is a false and injurious statement privileged, if it is made honestly in giving information about a servant? It is because it has been thought more important that information should be given freely, than that a man should be protected from what under other circumstances would be an actionable wrong.Why is a man at liberty to set up a business which he knows will ruin his neighborhood? It is because the public good is supposed to be best subserved by free competition.

Obviously such judgments of relative importance may vary in different times and places.Why does a judge instruct a jury that an employer is not liable to an employee for an injury received in the course of his employment unless he is negligent, and why do the jury generally find for the plaintiff if the case is allowed to go to them? It is because the traditional policy of our law is to confine liability to cases where a prudent man might have foreseen the injury, or at least the danger, while the inclination of a very large part of the community is to make certain classes of persons insure the safety of those with whom they deal.Since the last words were written, I have seen the requirement of such insurance put forth as part of the programme of one of the best known labor organizations.There is a concealed, half conscious battle on the question of legislative policy, and if any one thinks that it can be settled deductively, or once for all, I only can say that I think he is theoretically wrong, and that I am certain that his conclusion will not be accepted in practice semper ubique et ab omnibus.

Indeed, I think that even now our theory upon this matter is open to reconsideration, although I am not prepared to say how I should decide if a reconsideration were proposed.Our law of torts comes from the old days of isolated, ungeneralized wrongs, assaults, slanders, and the like, where the damages might be taken to lie where they fell by legal judgment.But the torts with which our courts are kept busy today are mainly the incidents of certain well known businesses.They are injuries to person or property by railroads, factories, and the like.

The liability for them is estimated, and sooner or later goes into the price paid by the public.The public really pays the damages, and the question of liability, if pressed far enough, is really a question how far it is desirable that the public should insure the safety of one whose work it uses.It might be said that in such cases the chance of a jury finding for the defendant is merely a chance, once in a while rather arbitrarily interrupting the regular course of recovery, most likely in the case of an unusually conscientious plaintiff, and therefore better done away with.On the other hand, the economic value even of a life to the community can be estimated, and no recovery, it may be said, ought to go beyond that amount.It is conceivable that some day in certain cases we may find ourselves imitating, on a higher plane, the tariff for life and limb which we see in the Leges Barbarorum.

同类推荐
  • FRECKLES

    FRECKLES

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。
  • 筹河篇

    筹河篇

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。
  • 孟夏纪

    孟夏纪

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。
  • 梦鹤轩楳澥诗钞

    梦鹤轩楳澥诗钞

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。
  • 诗经通论

    诗经通论

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。
热门推荐
  • 高门皇后

    高门皇后

    唐意怎么也没想到,在面对穷凶极恶的毒贩没有嗝屁,却在凯旋时遭遇乱流,坠下数万米高空,光荣穿越了!何其有幸,一朝穿越,竟成西秦国的皇后!一人之下万万人之上,独享专宠。何其不幸,穿越第一天就遭遇破国之灾!富贵荣华如流水,未过眼已成烟云。更不幸的是,新君继位,第一道圣旨就是将她做为祭礼,嫁入东晋为妃,把她变成史上第一个和亲的皇后!他一身明黄,高高地站在她的身前,俊逸如仙,清雅如风,凝望着她的凤眸中透出的却是嗜骨噬心的寒,刻骨铭心地恨……是谁说的?每一个穿越女的背后都站着一个加强排的美男,而每一个穿越女都是打不死的小强,一定会越站越勇,越斗越强的!她走进重重迷雾,层层阴谋,几度生死徘徊,多次命悬一线,只为抚平他眉间的那一点愁,平息他心底的那一缕恨,圆他胸中的那一个梦……然后——看得清的是世情人性,看不透的永远是那颗冰冷的帝王心!
  • 武汉爱情故事

    武汉爱情故事

    即将大学毕业的诺成在和女朋友分手后进入一家地产公司,遇到了他的美女经理林溪,从此开始了一段有趣的爱情故事。
  • 江山策:凰权天下

    江山策:凰权天下

    前世,她是太子的一颗棋子,他承诺,我若为皇,你便为后。她为他谋划江山,不想却是亲手为自己铺就一条黄泉路,弑君谋逆之罪,将她处死。重生一世,她步步为营,只有皇权在手,才能够呼风唤雨,江山在手,试问谁还敢跟她斗?
  • 重生之富商之王

    重生之富商之王

    前世一事无成杜轩,穿越到平行世界,开启屌丝逆袭之路这里还没出现“斗罗大陆”“斗破苍穹”“择天记”“凡人修仙传”玄幻巨作没有“还珠格格”“花千骨”“甄嬛传”“来自星星的你”家喻户晓的电视剧偶尔也写出不是这个时间段会出现歌曲,同桌的你,海阔天空,江南style,一不小心,这些歌曲,却成为人人人会唱的歌曲至于他闲的没事创建,书脸,小米,阿里,晶东,甲骨文,微软,成为全球最为神秘的富豪。他无聊时拍的电影,变形金刚,阿凡达,死神系列,速度与激情,囧系列,拿到小金人,拿到手软,成为全球票房最高的导演他是文以致富,他是全球富豪之首,文学领导者,捧星之王他的财富及身价,可以让整个世界陷入恐慌
  • 殒身剑神再生

    殒身剑神再生

    你以为他是你朋友,你却不知道他的心有多深;你以为他是你师傅,你却不知道他的阴谋有多狠毒;你以为白道皆正义,却是真正的魔。背叛,一念之间,一看见一代天骄铸剑成神,面对这人心叵测的世界,如何苟活……
  • 脉灵传说

    脉灵传说

    这片大陆没有绚丽的魔法,没有多彩的斗气。这是一片属于武者的大陆。他,武者中的异类?脉灵师?本书慢热,非,无限循环的打宝升级。。。
  • 一品巫妃

    一品巫妃

    落月国京城在神武十八年发生两件大事:大将军府的六小姐蓄谋谋害自己的未婚夫四皇子,将军以一半的兵权换回六小姐的性命;大皇子和三皇子江南巡查归来时,大皇子遇刺身亡,三皇子双目失明。某男邪笑:“你治好了本王的眼,本王准备以身相许。”某女冷笑:“本姑娘治好的男人都这么说,你算老几!”他本以为此生孑然,直到遇到她。她躲避爱恋,却甩不掉他。看这乱世中的爱恋,是否挡的住硝烟。男主女主强强联手,袖转天下…………………………国仇家难,上辈恩怨,他们能否并肩一生?如何爱,才能没有伤害?
  • 变异死神

    变异死神

    十步杀一人,千里不留行,事了拂衣去,深藏身与名!世界第一杀手“恶魔之手”凯乐(killer)意外穿越到主位面,荆轲、扁鹊、华佗、项羽、孟浩然还有他的红颜知己貂蝉等历史名人以及六道之说一一出现在了他的人生当中。人外有人,天外有天。凯乐发现,这个世界,并不是他想象中的样子,传说中的魔王斯巴达陨落,神秘的雪国风族还有死神界的那些强大死神等一一出现在他的认知范围之中,随之也扯出了他和银色小猫咪的神秘身世....现代位面的虚宗竟是正义者联盟,还有未知神秘且强大的存在---混沌空间。凯乐有太多的疑惑要去探寻。随着实力的增长,他感觉他所背负的责任也变的沉重起来。
  • 末世之我是救世主

    末世之我是救世主

    2050年,一颗奇怪的陨石突然向地球冲来,奇怪的是,这颗陨石没有对地球造成撞击,而是发出了一种奇怪的能量,地球上30岁的人都全部死亡,只有几亿幼儿和青年存活了下来,但是危机没有解除,地球上的所有生物都发生了变异,许多人都被杀死,但是在俩年之后一个少年的身体发生了惊人的变化,他!将拯救世界!
  • 湛蓝之位面战争

    湛蓝之位面战争

    那你是否做过哪怕付出生命也不后悔的选择呢。十几年前我带着我的小队在这片主神空间这中征战,为了生存而战,为了活着而战。几年后我们因为选择分成两派,为了摧毁她和为了保护她。而现在我要做出自己的选择,抱歉了各位我们一定会在见面的。兑换权限生命兑换,所有生命权限进行兑换。确定兑换10个生命权限吗?看着手中写着猫有9命的卡,我回答了是。再见了我的朋友我们一定有一天会在见的。