登陆注册
15792600000004

第4章

In the law of contract the use of moral phraseology led to equal confusion, as I have shown in part already, but only in part.Morals deal with the actual internal state of the individual's mind, what he actually intends.From the time of the Romans down to now, this mode of dealing has affected the language of the law as to contract, and the language used has reacted upon the thought.We talk about a contract as a meeting of the minds of the parties, and thence it is inferred in various cases that there is no contract because their minds have not met; that is, because they have intended different things or because one party has not known of the assent of the other.Yet nothing is more certain than that parties may be bound by a contract to things which neither of them intended, and when one does not know of the other's assent.Suppose a contract is executed in due form and in writing to deliver a lecture, mentioning no time.One of the parties thinks that the promise will be construed to mean at once, within a week.The other thinks that it means when he is ready.The court says that it means within a reasonable time.The parties are bound by the contract as it is interpreted by the court, yet neither of them meant what the court declares that they have said.In my opinion no one will understand the true theory of contract or be able even to discuss some fundamental questions intelligently until he has understood that all contracts are formal, that the making of a contract depends not on the agreement of two minds in one intention, but on the agreement of two sets of external signs--not on the parties' having meant the same thing but on their having said the same thing.Furthermore, as the signs may be addressed to one sense or another--to sight or to hearing--on the nature of the sign will depend the moment when the contract is made.If the sign is tangible, for instance, a letter, the contract is made when the letter of acceptance is delivered.If it is necessary that the minds of the parties meet, there will be no contract until the acceptance can be read; none, for example, if the acceptance be snatched from the hand of the offerer by a third person.

This is not the time to work out a theory in detail, or to answer many obvious doubts and questions which are suggested by these general views.

I know of none which are not easy to answer, but what I am trying to do now is only by a series of hints to throw some light on the narrow path of legal doctrine, and upon two pitfalls which, as it seems to me, lie perilously near to it.Of the first of these I have said enough.Ihope that my illustrations have shown the danger, both to speculation and to practice, of confounding morality with law, and the trap which legal language lays for us on that side of our way.For my own part, Ioften doubt whether it would not be a gain if every word of moral significance could be banished from the law altogether, and other words adopted which should convey legal ideas uncolored by anything outside the law.We should lose the fossil records of a good deal of history and the majesty got from ethical associations, but by ridding ourselves of an unnecessary confusion we should gain very much in the clearness of our thought.

So much for the limits of the law.The next thing which I wish to consider is what are the forces which determine its content and its growth.You may assume, with Hobbes and Bentham and Austin, that all law emanates from the sovereign, even when the first human beings to enunciate it are the judges, or you may think that law is the voice of the Zeitgeist, or what you like.It is all one to my present purpose.

Even if every decision required the sanction of an emperor with despotic power and a whimsical turn of mind, we should be interested none the less, still with a view to prediction, in discovering some order, some rational explanation, and some principle of growth for the rules which he laid down.In every system there are such explanations and principles to be found.It is with regard to them that a second fallacy comes in, which I think it important to expose.

The fallacy to which I refer is the notion that the only force at work in the development of the law is logic.In the broadest sense, indeed, that notion would be true.The postulate on which we think about the universe is that there is a fixed quantitative relation between every phenomenon and its antecedents and consequents.If there is such a thing as a phenomenon without these fixed quantitative relations, it is a miracle.It is outside the law of cause and effect, and as such transcends our power of thought, or at least is something to or from which we cannot reason.The condition of our thinking about the universe is that it is capable of being thought about rationally, or, in other words, that every part of it is effect and cause in the same sense in which those parts are with which we are most familiar.So in the broadest sense it is true that the law is a logical development, like everything else.The danger of which I speak is not the admission that the principles governing other phenomena also govern the law, but the notion that a given system, ours, for instance, can be worked out like mathematics from some general axioms of conduct.This is the natural error of the schools, but it is not confined to them.I once heard a very eminent judge say that he never let a decision go until he was absolutely sure that it was right.So judicial dissent often is blamed, as if it meant simply that one side or the other were not doing their sums right, and if they would take more trouble, agreement inevitably would come.

同类推荐
热门推荐
  • 永远的六二班

    永远的六二班

    六(2)班是一个有趣的集体,她(他)们在班级里嬉戏打闹,因此创建了美好而纯真的友谊。友谊将她(他)们串成一串珠子。但她(他)们的友谊并不像普通的线,那么容易就扯断。她(他)们采用的线可是扯不断,分不开的友谊线。你们准备好了吗?我们要出发去看她(他)们有趣的校园生活了!
  • 为你自己学习

    为你自己学习

    本书通过大量富于哲理性、故事性和趣味性的事例予以说明,让广大青少年读者真正认识到读书的目的、读书的重要性及读书和自己未来人生命运的关系等,是一本值得广大青少年朋友认真阅读的课外读物。
  • 守护甜心之喵星人的爱恋

    守护甜心之喵星人的爱恋

    【已完结】“只要是你,我都喜欢。”“无论你变成什么样子,叫什么名字,还记不记得我,我都会一直喜欢你。”“一直一直喜欢你。”
  • 大涅磐

    大涅磐

    人生在世只有短短百年。修炼却可以不断的将人的寿命延长。然而,世上之人真的能达永生吗?一炼体:强筋炼骨,引气沸血,血肉凝聚,直至肉体圆满。二炼劲:威拳力,修拳势,达拳意,拳拳横行人世。三炼神:通达心志,明悟本心,直破人意,可达千年不灭。四炼虚:以身化虚,天人合一,踏碎虚空,游离天地之外。然天地亦灭,况人呼?天地不仁,则天地不永存;人道不正,则人不可永生。人道仍存,则人道需涅磐;强者横行,则强者亦涅磐;天地依在,天地焉能不涅磐?涅磐,涅磐,大涅磐……改人命,争气运,万物破而后立,谁人大涅磐重生?
  • 末世之天继

    末世之天继

    承继于虚幻的洪荒,所衍生出接近现实却又近乎荒诞的真实。末日之时,群魔降世。吸食鲜血的同时,还要吸食灵魂的巨大蝙蝠怪,嗜血残暴,却又尚存着些许理智的行尸走肉,巨大恐怖,却智商低劣以至被它物所奴役的多足怪物。还有无数前所未见的奇异生态,千奇百怪的妖魔鬼怪。濒临危困的人族,是否继续苟延残喘?传承已久的华夏汉族,能否最终力挽狂澜?蝙蝠妖,丧尸,异能,失德,国战,群殴,灭倭,苍天,胖子,三国,这些,本书都有。萝莉,美女,美少女,熟女,少妇,女学生,女老师,女博士,这些,嗯,本书都可以有。
  • 珠玉传奇

    珠玉传奇

    看中国的超级英雄是怎么炼成的!一个拍卖行首席顾问,一个古瓷店的老板,一个鉴定中心的老师,再加上一个神秘的心理学家,四个人为了寻找传说中的稀世珍宝而踏上了一条探寻人类文明起源的道路。
  • 网游之万古长存

    网游之万古长存

    游戏其实就另一种生活。玩游戏的人就像是在另一个世界中生活的人。真正的梦想不会因为节奏和冷眼而发生改变。正因如此,杜抗可以抛却一切去古国中开荒;正因如此,颜水月可以一怒滔天两战墨方;正因如此,欧阳一个在古国大门外徘徊的新人可以去继承前辈们光辉的信念,带着诸多与他一道的朋友在那个世界中为了希望,共同成长。
  • 暮春之令

    暮春之令

    架空汉朝,和亲公主去世,公主身边大龄未婚女史归汉遇见真爱的故事。
  • 迷雾惊天

    迷雾惊天

    黄晨逸出生于刑警世家,他爸爸是被停职的刑警队长,叔叔是重案组,身为初中生的他却连连破案,小说的很多细节都是推出最后幕后黑手的重要线索,希望各位读者细细琢磨。
  • 守鼎1643

    守鼎1643

    太监了,不用看了,嗯,就是这样子的。哎没满20字很尴尬