登陆注册
15752600000026

第26章

But though the philosophy founded on the hypothesis of astate of nature has fallen low in general esteem, in so far as itis looked upon under its coarser and more palpable aspect, itdoes not follow that in its subtler disguises it has lostplausibility, popularity, or power. I believe, as I have said,that it is still the great antagonist of the Historical Method;and whenever (religious objections apart) any mind is seen toresist or contemn that mode of investigation, it will generallybe found under the influence of a prejudice or vicious biastraceable to a conscious or unconscious reliance on anon-historic, natural, condition of society or the individual. Itis chiefly, however, by allying themselves with political andsocial tendencies that the doctrines of Nature and her law havepreserved their energy. Some of these tendencies they havestimulated, other they have actually created, to a great numberthey have given expression and form. They visibly enter largelyinto the ideas which constantly radiate from France over thecivilised world, and thus become part of the general body ofthought by which its civilisation is modified. The value of theinfluence which they thus exercise over the fortunes of the raceis of course one of the points which our age debates most warmly,and it is beside the purpose of this treatise to discuss it.

Looking back, however, to the period at which the theory of thestate of nature acquired the maximum of political importance,there are few who will deny that it helped most powerfully tobring about the grosser disappointments of which the first FrenchRevolution was fertile. It gave birth, or intense stimulus, tothe vices of mental habit all but universal at the time, disdainof positive law, impatience of experience, and the preference ofa priori to all other reasoning. In proportion too as thisphilosophy fixes its grasp on minds which have thought less thanothers and fortified themselves with smaller observation, itstendency is to become distinctly anarchical. It is surprising tonote how many of the Sophismes Anarchiques which Dumont publishedfor Bentham, and which embody Bentham's exposure of errorsdistinctively French, are derived from the Roman hypothesis inits French transformation, and are unintelligible unless referredto it. On this point too it is a curious exercise to consult theMoniteur during the principal eras of the Revolution. The appealsto the Law and State of Nature become thicker as the times growdarker. They are comparatively rare in the Constituent Assembly;they are much more frequent in the Legislative; in theConvention, amid the din of debate on conspiracy and war, theyare perpetual.

There is a single example which very strikingly illustratesthe effects of the theory of natural law on modern society, andindicates how very far are those effects from being exhausted.

There cannot, I conceive, be any question that to the assumptionof a Law Natural we owe the doctrine of the fundamental equalityof human beings. That "all men are equal" is one of a largenumber of legal propositions which, in progress of time, havebecome political. The Roman jurisconsults of the Antonine era laydown that "omnes homines natura aequales sunt," but in their eyesthis is a strictly juridical axiom. They intend to affirm that,under the hypothetical Law of Nature, and in so far as positivelaw approximates to it, the arbitrary distinctions which theRoman Civil Law maintained between classes of persons cease tohave a legal existence. The rule was one of considerableimportance to the Roman practitioner, who required to be remindedthat, wherever Roman jurisprudence was assumed to conform itselfexactly to the code of Nature, there was no difference in thecontemplation of the Roman tribunals between citizen andforeigner, between freeman and slave, between Agnate and Cognate.

The jurisconsults who thus expressed themselves most certainlynever intended to censure the social arrangements under whichcivil law fell somewhat short of its speculative type; nor didthey apparently believe that the world would ever see humansociety completely assimilated to the economy of nature. But whenthe doctrine of human equality makes its appearance in a moderndress it has evidently clothed itself with a new shade ofmeaning. Where the Roman jurisconsult had written "aequalessunt," meaning exactly what he said, the modern civilian wrote"all men are equal" in the sense of "all men ought to be equal."The peculiar Roman idea that natural law coexisted with civil lawand gradually absorbed it, had evidently been lost sight of, orhad become unintelligible, and the words which had at mostconveyed a theory conceding the origin, composition, anddevelopment of human institutions, were beginning to express thesense of a great standing wrong suffered by mankind. As early asthe beginning of the fourteenth century, the current languageconceding the birthstate of men, though visibly intended to beidentical with that of Ulpian and his contemporaries, has assumedan altogether different form and meaning. The preamble to thecelebrated ordinance of King Louis Hutin enfranchising the serfsof the royal domains would have sounded strangely to Roman ears.

同类推荐
  • 漱玉词

    漱玉词

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。
  • 滇略

    滇略

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。
  • An Old-Fashioned Girl

    An Old-Fashioned Girl

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。
  • 佛说布施经

    佛说布施经

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。
  • 佛说净意优婆塞所问经

    佛说净意优婆塞所问经

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。
热门推荐
  • 庶妃当嫁:王爷该吃药啦

    庶妃当嫁:王爷该吃药啦

    穿越第一年,他将十万两银票丢在她的面前,轻蔑冷笑:“你是尚书府嫡女?我还以为是哪家卑贱商妇。”穿越第二年,他甩给她一纸婚书:“好不容易怀了我的孩子,我一定会让你物尽其用。”穿越第三年,他笑意盈盈:“爱妃,我家的宝宝是个天才,你看,他想让父皇亲亲娘亲呢。”月秦淡淡地抱过啃着两个小爪子直笑的包子:“乖,别跟这个叔叔玩儿,他有病!!”【情节虚构,请勿模仿】
  • 默默侠骨情

    默默侠骨情

    明末红丸迷案,万千诡奇疑云。时局波澜壮阔,江湖暗流涌动。痴情梁上君子,苦恋暴走魔头。妖女面具之下,匿藏倾世容颜少年巧得神功,斗破乱世群雄。执念天下苍生,不料人心无常。爱别离,伤心头,难为一笑泯恩仇。守情谊,逆天行,尽在脉脉侠骨情。
  • 恐龙百科

    恐龙百科

    本书以一种全新的视角向人们展示了神秘的恐龙世界,分为“难以置信的恐龙”、“恐龙时代”、“恐龙探秘”、“寻找恐龙”、“恐龙的趣味问题”等5部分,详细讲解了恐龙的分类、生活的时代、基本情况、化石、关于恐龙的趣味问题等内容。
  • 恶魔校草的霸气学妹

    恶魔校草的霸气学妹

    于菲菲第一天来到这个贵族学校,,便受到了校草的欺负,于菲菲霸气的把书往课桌上一摔,愤怒的说:“破校草,你拽什么拽。”袁萧戏谑一下,轻缈的说:“是吗?你在欲擒故纵,可惜,本少爷不屑。”说完,潇洒的走了。在以后相处的日子里,到底是谁先爱上了谁,又是谁伤害了谁……
  • 武逆风暴

    武逆风暴

    普普通通的山村少年,机缘巧合之下融合了神秘道珠,踏上那瞩目万分的辉煌之路。修行路上经历爱、恨、情、仇。最终,经过种种磨练,踏上那武道巅峰!……行就收藏
  • 穿越之嫡女也风华

    穿越之嫡女也风华

    她是一个冷清的杀手,但却拥有了一场阴谋的爱情。爱情亲情与她双双背道而驰。看着那些昔日共同战斗的伙伴,她选择了同归于尽。当她成为她,凤凰涅槃,欲火重生,一手炼灵药,一手驭万兽,她发过誓言,势必要站在整个大陆的顶端。而他,霸道腹黑,雍容高贵,他是整个大陆都不敢得罪的大人物,却不知道从何时起,他的眼里,心里,就存在了那一抹身影,就再也放不下别人。
  • 品茶拒绝表面功夫

    品茶拒绝表面功夫

    品茶,其实更是一种生活艺术!中国几千年的茶文化可以说是博大精深,从《神农本草经》中记载了茶的起源,到如今,茶已经遍及全世界,成为了风靡世界的饮品之一,甚至还形成了不同风情的茶文化。让我们我们从茶的起源,著名的十大名茶,沏茶,品茶,各国特色饮法,各式茶具等方面让大家品茶拒绝表面功夫……
  • 不凋花

    不凋花

    一度让人羡慕的富豪家族,遭受奸人的陷害后,至沦落为平凡家庭,看家族后辈如何力挽狂澜。。。。。。
  • 喧嚣中沉浮

    喧嚣中沉浮

    她二的离奇她冰雪聪明她痞气十足她情钟深处她叫许二,爱过三个男人:情窦、错杂、无耐;她冷眼看着人是人非,却总是被人情纷扰;她坚信梦想,却总被现实开玩笑;她爱恨分明,却总是在妥协中挣扎;每一段路程她看到不同的风景、不同的人、不同的自己。喧嚣的社会成全了许二的年化,浮浮沉沉到底哪一个是你
  • 汉魏六朝百三家集张华集

    汉魏六朝百三家集张华集

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。