登陆注册
15744200000004

第4章

Then has he enquired for himself? He may have, if he was ever aware of a time when he was ignorant. But he never was ignorant; for when he played with other boys at dice, he charged them with cheating, and this implied a knowledge of just and unjust. According to his own explanation, he had learned of the multitude. Why, he asks, should he not learn of them the nature of justice, as he has learned the Greek language of them? To this Socrates answers, that they can teach Greek, but they cannot teach justice;for they are agreed about the one, but they are not agreed about the other:

and therefore Alcibiades, who has admitted that if he knows he must either have learned from a master or have discovered for himself the nature of justice, is convicted out of his own mouth.

Alcibiades rejoins, that the Athenians debate not about what is just, but about what is expedient; and he asserts that the two principles of justice and expediency are opposed. Socrates, by a series of questions, compels him to admit that the just and the expedient coincide. Alcibiades is thus reduced to the humiliating conclusion that he knows nothing of politics, even if, as he says, they are concerned with the expedient.

However, he is no worse than other Athenian statesmen; and he will not need training, for others are as ignorant as he is. He is reminded that he has to contend, not only with his own countrymen, but with their enemies--with the Spartan kings and with the great king of Persia; and he can only attain this higher aim of ambition by the assistance of Socrates. Not that Socrates himself professes to have attained the truth, but the questions which he asks bring others to a knowledge of themselves, and this is the first step in the practice of virtue.

The dialogue continues:--We wish to become as good as possible. But to be good in what? Alcibiades replies--'Good in transacting business.' But what business? 'The business of the most intelligent men at Athens.' The cobbler is intelligent in shoemaking, and is therefore good in that; he is not intelligent, and therefore not good, in weaving. Is he good in the sense which Alcibiades means, who is also bad? 'I mean,' replies Alcibiades, 'the man who is able to command in the city.' But to command what--horses or men? and if men, under what circumstances? 'I mean to say, that he is able to command men living in social and political relations.'

And what is their aim? 'The better preservation of the city.' But when is a city better? 'When there is unanimity, such as exists between husband and wife.' Then, when husbands and wives perform their own special duties, there can be no unanimity between them; nor can a city be well ordered when each citizen does his own work only. Alcibiades, having stated first that goodness consists in the unanimity of the citizens, and then in each of them doing his own separate work, is brought to the required point of self-contradiction, leading him to confess his own ignorance.

But he is not too old to learn, and may still arrive at the truth, if he is willing to be cross-examined by Socrates. He must know himself; that is to say, not his body, or the things of the body, but his mind, or truer self.

The physician knows the body, and the tradesman knows his own business, but they do not necessarily know themselves. Self-knowledge can be obtained only by looking into the mind and virtue of the soul, which is the diviner part of a man, as we see our own image in another's eye. And if we do not know ourselves, we cannot know what belongs to ourselves or belongs to others, and are unfit to take a part in political affairs. Both for the sake of the individual and of the state, we ought to aim at justice and temperance, not at wealth or power. The evil and unjust should have no power,--they should be the slaves of better men than themselves. None but the virtuous are deserving of freedom.

And are you, Alcibiades, a freeman? 'I feel that I am not; but I hope, Socrates, that by your aid I may become free, and from this day forward Iwill never leave you.'

The Alcibiades has several points of resemblance to the undoubted dialogues of Plato. The process of interrogation is of the same kind with that which Socrates practises upon the youthful Cleinias in the Euthydemus; and he characteristically attributes to Alcibiades the answers which he has elicited from him. The definition of good is narrowed by successive questions, and virtue is shown to be identical with knowledge. Here, as elsewhere, Socrates awakens the consciousness not of sin but of ignorance.

Self-humiliation is the first step to knowledge, even of the commonest things. No man knows how ignorant he is, and no man can arrive at virtue and wisdom who has not once in his life, at least, been convicted of error.

The process by which the soul is elevated is not unlike that which religious writers describe under the name of 'conversion,' if we substitute the sense of ignorance for the consciousness of sin.

In some respects the dialogue differs from any other Platonic composition.

同类推荐
热门推荐
  • 司马光与《资治通鉴》

    司马光与《资治通鉴》

    丁明秀编著的《司马光与<资治通鉴>》为丛书之一,介绍了司马光与《资治通鉴》的有关内容。《司马光与<资治通鉴>》中优美生动的文字、简明通俗的语言、图文并茂的形式,把中国文化中的物态文化、制度文化、行为文化、精神文化等知识要点全面展示给读者。点点滴滴的文化知识仿佛颗颗繁星,组成了灿烂辉煌的中国文化的天穹。能为弘扬中华五千年优秀传统文化、增强各民族团结、构建社会主义和谐社会尽一份绵薄之力。
  • 穿越:界皇传说

    穿越:界皇传说

    一件传说中的神器,一位知能是敌人的朋友,一场出乎意料的冒险。
  • 卑爱:隔壁竹马等等我!

    卑爱:隔壁竹马等等我!

    青梅竹马,令很多人都羡慕的关系。她追了他八年,爱了他一辈子。他爱了她一生,却不得不把她推给别人。记得那年,有人追青梅,就因为竹马的一句“谁敢追她,我就废了谁!”从此青梅的初中生涯再也没有一个追求者。记得那年,竹马亲手把青梅的一片真心蹂躏,可谁有知道,其实最痛的人是竹马。记得那年,他们很相爱……
  • TFBOYS少女与王子

    TFBOYS少女与王子

    因父母关系,年仅15岁的她被送往父母朋友家住,就在她刚进屋里时,发现了......(moon先卖个官司,不告诉你们!)
  • 福妻驾到

    福妻驾到

    现代饭店彪悍老板娘魂穿古代。不分是非的极品婆婆?三年未归生死不明的丈夫?心狠手辣的阴毒亲戚?贪婪而好色的地主老财?吃上顿没下顿的贫困宭境?不怕不怕,神仙相助,一技在手,天下我有!且看现代张悦娘,如何身带福气玩转古代,开面馆、收小弟、左纳财富,右傍美男,共绘幸福生活大好蓝图!!!!快本新书《天媒地聘》已经上架开始销售,只要3.99元即可将整本书抱回家,你还等什么哪,赶紧点击下面的直通车,享受乐乐精心为您准备的美食盛宴吧!)
  • 妖精相公

    妖精相公

    琼水国九经元年,夜如凝紫,子时,一记流星划过,夜白如昼。“皇上,微臣有要事求见。”泰安殿外一白胡老头半跪。“皇上,微臣有要事求见”白胡老头又提高了声音,没一会,一名红衣太监步出门外。“大国师快请起,皇上召了。”太监捏着嗓子作势要扶。老国师不着痕迹的避开了手,径自起身步入大殿。红衣太监啐了一口,暗骂“以为你是什么东西,也不瞧瞧自己配不配得上,山村野夫!”。2:空中出现了一个白衣女孩,罗裙随着热风飞扬。艳阳在她头顶洒出一片光晕,一瞬间,人们有点恍惚,是天使吗?树下的人看的清她的脸,那是多么让难以忘记的一双眼,黑漆漆若子时的夜空,湿漉漉如清晨雾气。黛眉微挑,红唇若朱,细腻通透的皮肤在阳光下泛着光。这是小的的新书《涩爱》希望多多支持哦!http://novel.hongxiu.com/a/313864/3:石头光滑平整,紧挨着石头的是一条潺潺的小溪,河水清凌凌的,在太阳的照射下反射着耀眼的光,光有些微刺,妖福眯了眯眼,却在恍惚间看见水里迅速的游过的红鲤,连忙睁大眼睛再看,那红鲤却又没了踪影,刚别过头去,却又看见另一条游了过去,到底是刚才那一条还是另一条,妖福有些分不清,但总是觉得在和她作对。赌气的别开眼,又看向四周。一打眼,分不清什么,只知道都是绿,深绿,浅绿,嫩绿,全都郁郁葱葱,细看来,才知道,什么柳树、杨树都不分季节,不分地域的长在一起。乱七八糟,却又是那么美。吹来的风里夹杂着不知多少种的花,不刺鼻,沁人心脾得很,这就是地狱?多好呀!好想就这样一辈子待下去!4:雪白的藕臂微微伸展,一滴晶莹的的水珠慢慢滑落,滑过小肘,滑向那纤细白嫩的脖颈。几丝乌黑的头发紧紧地贴在颈上,那水珠顺着发丝滑到那优雅的锁骨。然后,慢慢的慢慢的滑到那半露的饱满酥胸然后没入了清澈的湖水。与湖水融为一体。
  • 极品仙夫

    极品仙夫

    她,异世一缕孤魂穿到修仙世家,睁眼已不再是花痴废物。"月月,你可要对人家负责"某妖孽男委屈的拉着被子,无辜的看着那个不可置信的女人,苏月头痛的扶额心里却翻天覆地"现在怎么办呢?嗯,三十六计,走为上策。"于是某男开始了漫漫追妻路。
  • 千总无情:我爱你,与你无关

    千总无情:我爱你,与你无关

    谁的毅然转身,谁的潸然泪下,谁的一颦一笑乱了谁的心又湿了谁的眼?易烊千玺,我们都没错,错的是时间;愿来世,你我互不相干。
  • 远古寻仙记

    远古寻仙记

    远古法术横行,诸多仙人汇聚一时,少年无意获得神器,从此走上修仙之路.....
  • 恶魔狂少

    恶魔狂少

    我是豪门大少,被逼坠入魔道,从此踏上屠神之路……