登陆注册
15399500000042

第42章

As to the number, then, and kind of sources whence fallacies arise in discussion, and how we are to show that our opponent is committing a fallacy and make him utter paradoxes; moreover, by the use of what materials solescism is brought about, and how to question and what is the way to arrange the questions; moreover, as to the question what use is served by all arguments of this kind, and concerning the answerer's part, both as a whole in general, and in particular how to solve arguments and solecisms-on all these things let the foregoing discussion suffice.It remains to recall our original proposal and to bring our discussion to a close with a few words upon it.

Our programme was, then, to discover some faculty of reasoning about any theme put before us from the most generally accepted premisses that there are.For that is the essential task of the art of discussion (dialectic) and of examination (peirastic).Inasmuch, however, as it is annexed to it, on account of the near presence of the art of sophistry (sophistic), not only to be able to conduct an examination dialectically but also with a show of knowledge, we therefore proposed for our treatise not only the aforesaid aim of being able to exact an account of any view, but also the aim of ensuring that in standing up to an argument we shall defend our thesis in the same manner by means of views as generally held as possible.

The reason of this we have explained; for this, too, was why Socrates used to ask questions and not to answer them; for he used to confess that he did not know.We have made clear, in the course of what precedes, the number both of the points with reference to which, and of the materials from which, this will be accomplished, and also from what sources we can become well supplied with these: we have shown, moreover, how to question or arrange the questioning as a whole, and the problems concerning the answers and solutions to be used against the reasonings of the questioner.We have also cleared up the problems concerning all other matters that belong to the same inquiry into arguments.In addition to this we have been through the subject of Fallacies, as we have already stated above.

That our programme, then, has been adequately completed is clear.

But we must not omit to notice what has happened in regard to this inquiry.For in the case of all discoveries the results of previous labours that have been handed down from others have been advanced bit by bit by those who have taken them on, whereas the original discoveries generally make advance that is small at first though much more useful than the development which later springs out of them.

For it may be that in everything, as the saying is, 'the first start is the main part': and for this reason also it is the most difficult; for in proportion as it is most potent in its influence, so it is smallest in its compass and therefore most difficult to see:

whereas when this is once discovered, it is easier to add and develop the remainder in connexion with it.This is in fact what has happened in regard to rhetorical speeches and to practically all the other arts: for those who discovered the beginnings of them advanced them in all only a little way, whereas the celebrities of to-day are the heirs (so to speak) of a long succession of men who have advanced them bit by bit, and so have developed them to their present form, Tisias coming next after the first founders, then Thrasymachus after Tisias, and Theodorus next to him, while several people have made their several contributions to it: and therefore it is not to be wondered at that the art has attained considerable dimensions.Of this inquiry, on the other hand, it was not the case that part of the work had been thoroughly done before, while part had not.Nothing existed at all.For the training given by the paid professors of contentious arguments was like the treatment of the matter by Gorgias.For they used to hand out speeches to be learned by heart, some rhetorical, others in the form of question and answer, each side supposing that their arguments on either side generally fall among them.And therefore the teaching they gave their pupils was ready but rough.For they used to suppose that they trained people by imparting to them not the art but its products, as though any one professing that he would impart a form of knowledge to obviate any pain in the feet, were then not to teach a man the art of shoe-making or the sources whence he can acquire anything of the kind, but were to present him with several kinds of shoes of all sorts:

for he has helped him to meet his need, but has not imparted an art to him.Moreover, on the subject of Rhetoric there exists much that has been said long ago, whereas on the subject of reasoning we had nothing else of an earlier date to speak of at all, but were kept at work for a long time in experimental researches.If, then, it seems to you after inspection that, such being the situation as it existed at the start, our investigation is in a satisfactory condition compared with the other inquiries that have been developed by tradition, there must remain for all of you, or for our students, the task of extending us your pardon for the shortcomings of the inquiry, and for the discoveries thereof your warm thanks.

-THE END-

同类推荐
热门推荐
  • 无敌圣医

    无敌圣医

    叶小天得到了一个至尊神医系统,系统的目标,居然是征服星辰大海,做这个世界上最伟大的神医!于是乎,叶小天的春天来了……
  • 非善即恶

    非善即恶

    女孩来过教堂三次第一次,在梦中。她身着洁白婚纱与爱人在教堂之中手挽着手,如此幸福。他从来都不曾想过能拯救世界,他只是想贯彻自己活着的信念,保护自己活着的理由,保护自己最重要的人们。我曾经也是温柔身躯后的一员,那是一种无法言喻的荣耀和幸福。第二次,曾经那天。从来只信爱之人的她,跪在教堂,低声抽泣,无数次的祈祷救赎。抱歉,我不是基督呢,以前现在都不是,只是一个希望成为和基督一模一样的女孩罢了。第三次,若即若离的未来。利剑贯穿,她静躺教堂,眼望渐渐淡化的两个身影,默默献上最美的祝福。向那光芒四丈的灵魂,向那独一无二的存在,向那痴痴迷恋着的人,献出一切。"下一世,我绝不会再次爱上你。"
  • 一觉睡醒变成蛙

    一觉睡醒变成蛙

    小白一觉醒来变成了卵,故事由此开始,小白变成蛙后,发生的故事
  • 相遇人海黄昏

    相遇人海黄昏

    我从来不认为和他会就此完结
  • 冬天也有绽放的回忆

    冬天也有绽放的回忆

    【冬季也有绽放的回忆】:如果说让苏晓暖在这一年的春夏秋冬中,选一个她最喜欢的季节的话。那她一定会选那冰雪纷飞,冷冰冰的冬季。请大家不要问她为什么,因为那里有,她们最美好的回忆。一个专属于她们美好的回忆。回忆一:如果说回忆能因时间的长短,慢慢地变淡的话,那么,她想,在她的青春里,将不在会在有她们的身影。回忆二:我不会忘记她们,因为那是我过去最美好的回忆。回忆三:天地为证,我苏晓暖,我顾安安,我林潇彤,我苏暖夏,从此我们成为最好的姐妹,不离不弃,不互相欺骗。天地为证,永不改变。
  • 八千女鬼乱朝纲

    八千女鬼乱朝纲

    明朝万历四十八年,九月初六,明熹宗朱由校在东林党帮助下登基,定年号为天启,东林党也得到重用。但一个复杂无比,却又精妙绝伦的时代就此开始。八千女鬼,乃一个“魏”字,魏也,乃魏忠贤。
  • 校花恋曲

    校花恋曲

    细数闪烁的星辰,占卜恋爱的结果,我们生在同一国度,不可思议的罗曼史,心中始终坚信,不可思议的罗曼史!无论过去、现在或将来,我只为你而痴狂,深深怀念初次的相逢,难以忘却你的目光,满天繁星之中,有幸与你相遇,把握偶然,创造机遇,喜欢这样的生活方式,奇迹为我在此汇聚,命中注定你我的缘分。
  • 婉云夫人

    婉云夫人

    有人说,人的出生不能选择,但是以后究竟要成为哪种人,还是可以努力一下的。但是这话落在穿到了古代家生子奴婢身上的婉云来说,好像有点困难。无故逃家,打死。干活不努力,打死。不会体察上意,打死。作为一个小奴婢,以后会长成一个大奴婢的婉云,命运基本已经对她恶意满满了。不过,即便这辈子差不过也就能够看见未来究竟是个什么走法的婉云,还是深沉的表示,也许,这辈子自己也许还可以,挽救,一下?
  • 兄弟的宿命之复仇之路

    兄弟的宿命之复仇之路

    一个继承神龙血脉的古氏家族,遭火山门派灭族,主角白小飞和哥哥西夜穿越到将来的世界,俩人的命运开始了。
  • 山海踏妖行

    山海踏妖行

    有人说过,门里的世界跟门外的世界是不一样的。也有人说过,看不见比看的见要幸运。有人告诉他,他不是妖怪。可是他自己知道就是妖怪,我本来就是妖怪,即便进了门,我依然还是妖怪……