登陆注册
15399500000041

第41章

We must also observe that of all the arguments aforesaid it is easier with some to see why and where the reasoning leads the hearer astray, while with others it is more difficult, though often they are the same arguments as the former.For we must call an argument the same if it depends upon the same point; but the same argument is apt to be thought by some to depend on diction, by others on accident, and by others on something else, because each of them, when worked with different terms, is not so clear as it was.Accordingly, just as in fallacies that depend on ambiguity, which are generally thought to be the silliest form of fallacy, some are clear even to the man in the street (for humorous phrases nearly all depend on diction; e.g.'The man got the cart down from the stand'; and 'Where are you bound?'

'To the yard arm'; and 'Which cow will calve afore?' 'Neither, but both behind;' and 'Is the North wind clear?' 'No, indeed; for it has murdered the beggar and the merchant." Is he a Good enough-King?' 'No, indeed; a Rob-son': and so with the great majority of the rest as well), while others appear to elude the most expert (and it is a symptom of this that they often fight about their terms, e.g.

whether the meaning of 'Being' and 'One' is the same in all their applications or different; for some think that 'Being' and 'One'

mean the same; while others solve the argument of Zeno and Parmenides by asserting that 'One' and 'Being' are used in a number of senses), likewise also as regards fallacies of Accident and each of the other types, some of the arguments will be easier to see while others are more difficult; also to grasp to which class a fallacy belongs, and whether it is a refutation or not a refutation, is not equally easy in all cases.

An incisive argument is one which produces the greatest perplexity: for this is the one with the sharpest fang.Now perplexity is twofold, one which occurs in reasoned arguments, respecting which of the propositions asked one is to demolish, and the other in contentious arguments, respecting the manner in which one is to assent to what is propounded.Therefore it is in syllogistic arguments that the more incisive ones produce the keenest heart-searching.Now a syllogistic argument is most incisive if from premisses that are as generally accepted as possible it demolishes a conclusion that is accepted as generally as possible.For the one argument, if the contradictory is changed about, makes all the resulting syllogisms alike in character: for always from premisses that are generally accepted it will prove a conclusion, negative or positive as the case may be, that is just as generally accepted; and therefore one is bound to feel perplexed.An argument, then, of this kind is the most incisive, viz.the one that puts its conclusion on all fours with the propositions asked; and second comes the one that argues from premisses, all of which are equally convincing: for this will produce an equal perplexity as to what kind of premiss, of those asked, one should demolish.Herein is a difficulty: for one must demolish something, but what one must demolish is uncertain.Of contentious arguments, on the other hand, the most incisive is the one which, in the first place, is characterized by an initial uncertainty whether it has been properly reasoned or not; and also whether the solution depends on a false premiss or on the drawing of a distinction; while, of the rest, the second place is held by that whose solution clearly depends upon a distinction or a demolition, and yet it does not reveal clearly which it is of the premisses asked, whose demolition, or the drawing of a distinction within it, will bring the solution about, but even leaves it vague whether it is on the conclusion or on one of the premisses that the deception depends.

Now sometimes an argument which has not been properly reasoned is silly, supposing the assumptions required to be extremely contrary to the general view or false; but sometimes it ought not to be held in contempt.For whenever some question is left out, of the kind that concerns both the subject and the nerve of the argument, the reasoning that has both failed to secure this as well, and also failed to reason properly, is silly; but when what is omitted is some extraneous question, then it is by no means to be lightly despised, but the argument is quite respectable, though the questioner has not put his questions well.

Just as it is possible to bring a solution sometimes against the argument, at others against the questioner and his mode of questioning, and at others against neither of these, likewise also it is possible to marshal one's questions and reasoning both against the thesis, and against the answerer and against the time, whenever the solution requires a longer time to examine than the period available.

同类推荐
热门推荐
  • 无影杀

    无影杀

    由于某些原因《无影杀》正式更名为《无影杀之玉蝶双飞》在这里感谢大家的支持,对于给读者造成的不便作者深表歉意,希望大家一如既往的支持本人,谢谢。
  • 焚天剑

    焚天剑

    浩瀚灵力大陆,大千世界,魔族横行,上古时期的域外邪族是否遗留。无尽火域为何化为灰烬,强大武境消失何处,西极战皇死于谁人之手。一个个传说般的名字,究竟去向何方。消失于这主宰之境,青衫剑圣,北荒之丘,万墓之地,不死之主镇天地。凌驾于乾坤之上,消失于苍穹之中。少年修然得虎印,遇古神,寻父母。灭魔邪,究竟这位少年能否探索上古的遗迹。
  • 冷傲女皇皇夫滚犊子

    冷傲女皇皇夫滚犊子

    她,是闻名天下,艳冠一时的青凤国女皇,惊才艳艳,却为一个人迷了心,送了情,一朝背叛,魂归苍冥。再次睁开眼,她眼睛里满是淡然,孽缘啊!只愿今生再不相见!他,是当年学识惊人的少年卿相,某一天,被她看中,强掳入宫。青梅惨死,母亲失踪,相依为命的人俱都化为一抔黄土!从此,他就只记得仇恨!汲汲营营五年,将那个人杀害,心,却仿佛空了。他,强大神秘的洛南国国主,一次,为她所救,在她身边隐姓埋名,爱极了她狡黠浅笑的模样!恢复身份后,看见她惊讶又冷漠的样子,他惶惶解释,冷静瞬间瓦解,那时,他才明白,原来,自己一颗心,早就遗落在了那个聪慧善良的人身上。(本文纯属虚构,请勿模仿。)
  • 千古豪情帝王梦

    千古豪情帝王梦

    【穿越文】风沙起,黄沙漫地;浪势起,滔天席地;权势有何?不如你为我一笑。这精彩,因我而起,这变化莫测的风云事,还须看我!
  • 家有仙狸

    家有仙狸

    一次上山的采果子,也许是命中注定让刘云无意当中救了一只狐狸,看起来平凡的狐狸身份缺却不平凡,一场家园保卫战就此拉开序幕......
  • 医学破译百科(科学探索百科)

    医学破译百科(科学探索百科)

    人类社会和自然世界是那么丰富多彩,使我们对于那许许多多的难解之谜,不得不密切关注和发出疑问。人们总是不断地去认识它,勇敢地去探索它。虽然今天科学技术日新月异,达到了很高程度,但对于许多谜团还是难以圆满解答。人们都希望发现天机,破解无限的谜团。古今中外许许多多的科学先驱不断奋斗,一个个谜团不断解开,推进了科学技术的大发展,但又发现了许多新的奇怪事物和难解之谜,又不得不向新的问题发起挑战。科学技术不断发展,人类探索永无止境,解决旧问题,探索新领域,这就是人类一步一步发展的足迹。
  • 心理常识速读(速读直通车)

    心理常识速读(速读直通车)

    心理是指生物对客观物质世界的主观反应,心理现象包括心理过程和人格,人的心理活动都有一个发生,发展,消失的过程。人们在活动的时候,通常各种感官认识外部世界事物,通过头脑的活动思考着事物的因果关系,并伴随着喜,怒,哀,乐等情感体验等。关于心理的一些小常识你了解吗?《心理常识速读》这本书从“感官生理心理”、“感官神经特殊能力”、“心灵不可知”等等方面来向大家介绍心理的常识;快来了解这些关于心理的常识吧!
  • 《桃花劫来了快逃》

    《桃花劫来了快逃》

    “哇哈哈,我只带这些东西,那边不会介意吧!”女主带物穿,一穿成女尊国太子,接着美男一把一把来,邪魅、冷酷、正太、温柔、霸道等等美男皆有!本文一女多男!女主强、有身份,男主有外貌、有身份、有才华。喜者欢进,厌者绕道!
  • 我的人生哲学:任正非献给年轻人的12堂创业经营课

    我的人生哲学:任正非献给年轻人的12堂创业经营课

    《我的人生哲学:任正非献给年轻人的12堂创业经营课》是一本成功励志书,也是一本创业教辅书。华为作为中国商界的传奇,其成功的内部运营模式长期不为世人所知。本书从多方面入手,叙述了任正非经营管理华为的策略、方法、手段,即他带领华为从创业走向业界巨头的方方面面的经验。本书从企业文化讲到人员培训,又从人员培训讲到制度管理,之后又讲到了企业的逆境求生和海外市场的拓展等等。总之,这本书可以让人认识到传奇的任正非、了解到全面的华为,又可以让人掌握到全球领先企业的成功经验。
  • 2013年诗歌排行榜

    2013年诗歌排行榜

    编选了2013年发表在各类文学刊物及诗人博客上的优秀诗歌,全面展现了2013年中国诗歌创作成绩和美学风貌。在选编和评选过程中,编者坚持性、思想性和文学性的良知。从作品的价值上反复斟酌、碰撞、判断、从而披沙拣金,把具有广泛影响的、具有经得起时间考验的优秀作品评选出来,汇编成册。