登陆注册
14817900000006

第6章

Hermogenes replies that this is the only way in which he can conceive that names are correct; and he appeals to the practice of different nations, and of the different Hellenic tribes, in confirmation of his view. Socrates asks, whether the things differ as the words which represent them differ:--Are we to maintain with Protagoras, that what appears is? Hermogenes has always been puzzled about this, but acknowledges, when he is pressed by Socrates, that there are a few very good men in the world, and a great many very bad; and the very good are the wise, and the very bad are the foolish; and this is not mere appearance but reality. Nor is he disposed to say with Euthydemus, that all things equally and always belong to all men; in that case, again, there would be no distinction between bad and good men.

But then, the only remaining possibility is, that all things have their several distinct natures, and are independent of our notions about them.

And not only things, but actions, have distinct natures, and are done by different processes. There is a natural way of cutting or burning, and a natural instrument with which men cut or burn, and any other way will fail;--this is true of all actions. And speaking is a kind of action, and naming is a kind of speaking, and we must name according to a natural process, and with a proper instrument. We cut with a knife, we pierce with an awl, we weave with a shuttle, we name with a name. And as a shuttle separates the warp from the woof, so a name distinguishes the natures of things. The weaver will use the shuttle well,--that is, like a weaver; and the teacher will use the name well,--that is, like a teacher. The shuttle will be made by the carpenter; the awl by the smith or skilled person. But who makes a name? Does not the law give names, and does not the teacher receive them from the legislator? He is the skilled person who makes them, and of all skilled workmen he is the rarest. But how does the carpenter make or repair the shuttle, and to what will he look? Will he not look at the ideal which he has in his mind? And as the different kinds of work differ, so ought the instruments which make them to differ. The several kinds of shuttles ought to answer in material and form to the several kinds of webs. And the legislator ought to know the different materials and forms of which names are made in Hellas and other countries. But who is to be the judge of the proper form? The judge of shuttles is the weaver who uses them; the judge of lyres is the player of the lyre; the judge of ships is the pilot. And will not the judge who is able to direct the legislator in his work of naming, be he who knows how to use the names--he who can ask and answer questions--in short, the dialectician? The pilot directs the carpenter how to make the rudder, and the dialectician directs the legislator how he is to impose names; for to express the ideal forms of things in syllables and letters is not the easy task, Hermogenes, which you imagine.

'I should be more readily persuaded, if you would show me this natural correctness of names.'

Indeed I cannot; but I see that you have advanced; for you now admit that there is a correctness of names, and that not every one can give a name.

But what is the nature of this correctness or truth, you must learn from the Sophists, of whom your brother Callias has bought his reputation for wisdom rather dearly; and since they require to be paid, you, having no money, had better learn from him at second-hand. 'Well, but I have just given up Protagoras, and I should be inconsistent in going to learn of him.' Then if you reject him you may learn of the poets, and in particular of Homer, who distinguishes the names given by Gods and men to the same things, as in the verse about the river God who fought with Hephaestus, 'whom the Gods call Xanthus, and men call Scamander;' or in the lines in which he mentions the bird which the Gods call 'Chalcis,' and men 'Cymindis;' or the hill which men call 'Batieia,' and the Gods 'Myrinna's Tomb.' Here is an important lesson; for the Gods must of course be right in their use of names. And this is not the only truth about philology which may be learnt from Homer. Does he not say that Hector's son had two names--'Hector called him Scamandrius, but the others Astyanax'?

同类推荐
热门推荐
  • 脱离命运我就是天

    脱离命运我就是天

    一个高材生,不相信命运的安排,而意外的得到了一份传承。从此脱离了命运的掌控,通过自己的努力,在异界一步步的慢慢崛起,为了自己的爱人一怒之下做出了一个决定,成为了整个修真界的公敌。过上了被四处追杀逃亡的日子,也在被追杀中一次次经历生死战斗中突破至更高境界。
  • 看得见的我们

    看得见的我们

    我们拼尽全力,为的就是与命运抗衡,老天可以给我们生命,也可以夺走我们的生命,但绝不能阻拦我们选择的权利。
  • 外柔内坚武林萌主

    外柔内坚武林萌主

    杉杉来了没看够?柠萌让你看到完!女主苏美美,男主张枔
  • 惊雷榜上千秋雨

    惊雷榜上千秋雨

    一纸惊雷榜激起江湖千秋雨。德帝无德失尽人心,皇宫内苑起风浪。虽说巧舌如簧话语如刀。可无奈时光境迁,真相渐渐浮水面。皇位争夺,终将归于何人手?帝位、民心、天下..........一切尽在不言中,一切尽在他之手。秋雨即来,终将散去。
  • 卐古盘月

    卐古盘月

    《意诀》意道,幻也,想到及做到。只有你想不到,没有你做不到。《物诀》一发一世界,一毛一宇宙。集万千宇宙与一身。《盘诀》.............《力诀》.............太古大陆。今夜,不再寂静,魔兽山脉,无数魔兽仰天而啸,无数强者仰望星空深处,一脸无奈的悲痛,今夜魔神出世。天际。云丝游带似乎想与月争辉,久久的,遮挡着流淌的月光,不肯离去。而今夜还是月光的世界,故谓之为“月夜”,如梦如幻。不过这片银色的美不代表“天罚”劫云的意志。
  • 高冷王子的呆萌丫头

    高冷王子的呆萌丫头

    第一次见面,他把她撞了,她还没说什么,他就说了一声“滚”。她回了班级,谁料两人竟是一个班,还成为了同桌。她不小心弄脏了他的衣服,就这样,她就成了他的“小女仆”。她终于发现自己喜欢上了他,想向他告白,却看见他在和另一个女人接吻,她哭着离开,可自己为了告白的情书却掉了,被他发现了。三年后,她回来了……
  • 他的中学时代

    他的中学时代

    “他”其实是我,2016年的元旦,加班归来,突发奇想,想要把“他”的生活记录下来,因为我开始发现,自己已然在慢慢老去,曾经以为可以铭记一辈子的事情,却在渐渐模糊,渐渐地被时光抚平了,而我不想忘记“他”,所以便有了它。
  • 那些年属于我们的爱情

    那些年属于我们的爱情

    善良如可,爱情的突然降临让可儿初尝幸福的甜蜜,不了朋友不但背叛了自己还以死相逼,面对友情和爱情她该何去何从……
  • 霸道小明星,你够了

    霸道小明星,你够了

    “老公,求放过”某人可怜兮兮的说,某男扯了扯领带说:“老婆,我已经两天没碰你了,我可以放过你但是它不行啊”
  • 中国近代史

    中国近代史

    本书为诚之先生中国近代史著述精选集,包括:中国近代史讲义、中国近世史前编、中国近百年史概说、中国近百年史补编、中国近世文化史补编、日俄战争六部分。其中只有《日俄战争》曾于1928年由商务印书馆出过单行本。书中六部分内容虽分别写于不同时期,有交叉、有延续、也有断裂,但每部分都是组成中国近代史这个整体不可或缺的部分。尤其值得一提的是,诚之先生写这些近代史著作的目的在于大声疾呼,唤起大家进一步抵抗侵略的精神。全书字里行间涌溢着先生对中华民族命运的乐观和自信,其拳拳赤子之心尤令人感动。