登陆注册
14725400000011

第11章 PREFACE TO THE SECOND AND THIRD EDITIONS.(8)

By such a use of language any premises may be made to lead to any conclusion. I am not one of those who believe Plato to have been a mystic or to have had hidden meanings; nor do I agree with Dr. Jackson in thinking that 'when he is precise and dogmatic, he generally contrives to introduce an element of obscurity into the expostion' (J. of Philol.). The great master of language wrote as clearly as he could in an age when the minds of men were clouded by controversy, and philosophical terms had not yet acquired a fixed meaning. I have just said that Plato is to be interpreted by his context; and I do not deny that in some passages, especially in the Republic and Laws, the context is at a greater distance than would be allowable in a modern writer. But we are not therefore justified in connecting passages from different parts of his writings, or even from the same work, which he has not himself joined. We cannot argue from the Parmenides to the Philebus, or from either to the Sophist, or assume that the Parmenides, the Philebus, and the Timaeus were 'written simultaneously,' or 'were intended to be studied in the order in which they are here named (J. of Philol.) We have no right to connect statements which are only accidentally similar. Nor is it safe for the author of a theory about ancient philosophy to argue from what will happen if his statements are rejected. For those consequences may never have entered into the mind of the ancient writer himself; and they are very likely to be modern consequences which would not have been understood by him. 'I cannot think,' says Dr. Jackson, 'that Plato would have changed his opinions, but have nowhere explained the nature of the change.' But is it not much more improbable that he should have changed his opinions, and not stated in an unmistakable manner that the most essential principle of his philosophy had been reversed? It is true that a few of the dialogues, such as the Republic and the Timaeus, or the Theaetetus and the Sophist, or the Meno and the Apology, contain allusions to one another. But these allusions are superficial and, except in the case of the Republic and the Laws, have no philosophical importance. They do not affect the substance of the work.

It may be remarked further that several of the dialogues, such as the Phaedrus, the Sophist, and the Parmenides, have more than one subject. But it does not therefore follow that Plato intended one dialogue to succeed another, or that he begins anew in one dialogue a subject which he has left unfinished in another, or that even in the same dialogue he always intended the two parts to be connected with each other. We cannot argue from a casual statement found in the Parmenides to other statements which occur in the Philebus. Much more truly is his own manner described by himself when he says that 'words are more plastic than wax' (Rep.), and 'whither the wind blows, the argument follows'. The dialogues of Plato are like poems, isolated and separate works, except where they are indicated by the author himself to have an intentional sequence.

同类推荐
热门推荐
  • 九洲异闻录

    九洲异闻录

    天下风云出我辈,一入江湖岁月催;皇图霸业谈笑间,不胜人生一场醉。提剑跨骑挥鬼雨,白骨如山鸟惊飞;尘事如潮人如水,只叹江湖几人回。
  • 伟大的凝聚力:世界500强精英团队制胜之道

    伟大的凝聚力:世界500强精英团队制胜之道

    刚刚过去的20世纪,是一个风云变幻的时代。在全世界范围内涌现出一大批大大小小、各行各业、知名或不知名的企业。它们在世界经济大舞台上演绎着精彩纷呈而又激烈竞争的大戏,其态势丝毫不亚于狼烟滚滚、群雄四起的中国春秋、战国时代。如今,随着全球经济一体化趋势的日益加快和知名跨国品牌的快速渗入,随着市场竞争体制的进一步规范和竞争的不断升级,随着网络时代的到来和知识更新速度的加快,企业间的竞争愈演愈烈,“物竞天择、优胜劣汰”的生存定律得到充分印证。与狼共舞,就要先学会狼的本领。以中国人的聪明才智,一定会培育出中国的世界级企业,凝聚成中国的国际化精英团队。
  • 感动学生的品德故事

    感动学生的品德故事

    “少年强则国强”,为了中华民族的崛起,我们有责任也有必要培养体魄健康、意志坚强、乐观进取的亿万青少年。根据青少年的成长特点和需要,在参照了大量的专业书籍、通俗读物的基础上,精心编写了这本《感动学生的品德故事》一书,希望能够为青少年塑造优秀品质、成就卓越人生起到积极的推动作用。
  • 宫廷美女养颜心经

    宫廷美女养颜心经

    《宫廷美女养颜心经》这是一本从头到脚的全方位美容秘籍,一本由内而外的养颜圣经。
  • 避免开始和结束

    避免开始和结束

    从前的你喜欢单曲循环,现在的你已经不再听音乐了!我们彼此最好的状态就是分享自己喜欢的歌,自己喜欢的故事。你承受太多,不想放弃的太多,了解得太多,就是看不开罢了。宁愿自己伤心难过,我也要把最好最美的那一面去生活,难过也要假装开心,没什么的,只是不希望自己悲伤的情绪影响其他人!
  • 千衣胜雪后传之寒江雪

    千衣胜雪后传之寒江雪

    江左千里迢迢从楚国来塞外寻人,与雪绒儿、寒暄经历一段奇遇,偶遇父辈故人,探索二十年前的故事。。。
  • 杠上腹黑男神

    杠上腹黑男神

    古人云:人生不如意,十之八九。可有的时候错过,便是永远。幸好,我们彼此都没有错过。我的年少有你,你的青春,有我。
  • 冷总裁的逃妻

    冷总裁的逃妻

    本以为嫁给他会得到幸福。不想却成为一场恶梦。他是一个恶魔,仇恨的种子在心里滋生。对她疯狂折磨。直到有天,她无法忍受,选择了逃离。所有的一切都能成为过去吗?她在,他视而不见,她走,他狂追不舍,收回的心还能放出去吗?
  • 异界最强草根

    异界最强草根

    法名空难的小道士,却遇到了真空难穿越到了异界大陆上,为了回家,为了回到地球上,只有努力的修行到大成,然后穿越时空,却不想在异界遇到了魔女,精灵,魔龙,更与光明圣教斗的你死我活,这是一个逗比的异界,更是一个让人温暖的异界
  • 渡魂官

    渡魂官

    听别人说我叫韩清颜,代号月灵。我并不关心这些,因为我不了解我的过去,也不想了解。我在冥界任——“渡魂官”一职,就是每日在往生门旁监管者轮回的亡灵们。