登陆注册
14725400000011

第11章 PREFACE TO THE SECOND AND THIRD EDITIONS.(8)

By such a use of language any premises may be made to lead to any conclusion. I am not one of those who believe Plato to have been a mystic or to have had hidden meanings; nor do I agree with Dr. Jackson in thinking that 'when he is precise and dogmatic, he generally contrives to introduce an element of obscurity into the expostion' (J. of Philol.). The great master of language wrote as clearly as he could in an age when the minds of men were clouded by controversy, and philosophical terms had not yet acquired a fixed meaning. I have just said that Plato is to be interpreted by his context; and I do not deny that in some passages, especially in the Republic and Laws, the context is at a greater distance than would be allowable in a modern writer. But we are not therefore justified in connecting passages from different parts of his writings, or even from the same work, which he has not himself joined. We cannot argue from the Parmenides to the Philebus, or from either to the Sophist, or assume that the Parmenides, the Philebus, and the Timaeus were 'written simultaneously,' or 'were intended to be studied in the order in which they are here named (J. of Philol.) We have no right to connect statements which are only accidentally similar. Nor is it safe for the author of a theory about ancient philosophy to argue from what will happen if his statements are rejected. For those consequences may never have entered into the mind of the ancient writer himself; and they are very likely to be modern consequences which would not have been understood by him. 'I cannot think,' says Dr. Jackson, 'that Plato would have changed his opinions, but have nowhere explained the nature of the change.' But is it not much more improbable that he should have changed his opinions, and not stated in an unmistakable manner that the most essential principle of his philosophy had been reversed? It is true that a few of the dialogues, such as the Republic and the Timaeus, or the Theaetetus and the Sophist, or the Meno and the Apology, contain allusions to one another. But these allusions are superficial and, except in the case of the Republic and the Laws, have no philosophical importance. They do not affect the substance of the work.

It may be remarked further that several of the dialogues, such as the Phaedrus, the Sophist, and the Parmenides, have more than one subject. But it does not therefore follow that Plato intended one dialogue to succeed another, or that he begins anew in one dialogue a subject which he has left unfinished in another, or that even in the same dialogue he always intended the two parts to be connected with each other. We cannot argue from a casual statement found in the Parmenides to other statements which occur in the Philebus. Much more truly is his own manner described by himself when he says that 'words are more plastic than wax' (Rep.), and 'whither the wind blows, the argument follows'. The dialogues of Plato are like poems, isolated and separate works, except where they are indicated by the author himself to have an intentional sequence.

同类推荐
热门推荐
  • 千道恋

    千道恋

    屌丝赵磊因一场意外误闯校园禁地被穿越三界,展开一场惊心动魄的故事
  • 总裁,挠我心肝儿

    总裁,挠我心肝儿

    遇到安子濯是她一生最大的劫难,他千方百计的要她爱上他,只为得到她的心。她千躲万藏,甚至差点丢掉性命,却依旧逃不过爱上他的宿命。然而,被夺走了心脏,没有心的她,什么都不是。心灰意冷,破茧成蝶,不再爱亦无恨,她当他是个陌生人,他却逼她在墙角,吻她耳根,沉声说他爱她……
  • 火澜

    火澜

    当一个现代杀手之王穿越到这个世界。是隐匿,还是崛起。一场血雨腥风的传奇被她改写。一条无上的强者之路被她踏破。修斗气,炼元丹,收兽宠,化神器,大闹皇宫,炸毁学院,打死院长,秒杀狗男女,震惊大陆。无止尽的契约能力,上古神兽,千年魔兽,纷纷前来抱大腿,惊傻世人。她说:在我眼里没有好坏之分,只有强弱之分,只要你能打败我,这世间所有都是你的,打不败我,就从这世间永远消失。她狂,她傲,她的目标只有一个,就是凌驾这世间一切之上。三国皇帝,魔界妖王,冥界之主,仙界至尊。到底谁才是陪着她走到最后的那个?他说:上天入地,我会陪着你,你活着,有我,你死,也一定有我。本文一对一,男强女强,强强联手,不喜勿入。
  • 凤临之帝王滚下榻

    凤临之帝王滚下榻

    前世,她识人不明,大婚前夕撞破心爱的男人与宠妃共浴华清池。一场惊天阴谋,害得她国破家亡,全族尽灭,一缕芳魂葬身火海。今世,她涅槃重生归来,人依旧,事翻天。前世尊贵的嫡女千金,今世却是任人欺凌的痴傻小姐。温柔善良到了极点就是蠢,强者之魂重生,必当逆天改命!毁我娘亲容貌,我让你一辈子比猪还丑!向我下毒,我让你自食恶果!跟抢渣男!白送不稀罕,出门左拐,慢走不送!我要嫁的男子必是这天下最优秀的男人!斗恶毒嫡母,灭嚣张姐妹威风,告诉你们,我慕容翎这一世是来华丽复仇的!以我血发誓:慕容翎要逆天逆命,尊凰天下!
  • tfboys之魔法守护使

    tfboys之魔法守护使

    平凡的少女叶紫星意外的有了一段奇遇,不但认识了大明星tfboys和几个完美少女,还学会了魔法!这生活简直不要太好。当然,是在不提拯救这个要命的任务的前提下。
  • EXO广播剧协会

    EXO广播剧协会

    这是由灿白主演的犯二青年的爱情小故事!希望大家喜欢
  • 仙凡两别1死亡宝典

    仙凡两别1死亡宝典

    一本神奇的宝典,故事由此引发。看林凡如何发现宝典的秘密。。。。。。。。。。。。。。。。。。。。。。。。。。。。。。
  • 鼎灭世

    鼎灭世

    无限好书尽在阅文。
  • 青春校舍

    青春校舍

    “青春校舍”是一个神秘的校舍,是大青大学里的一个谜。只有勇敢追梦的少年们出现时,它才会出现,并让他们入住,一旦入住校舍,他们将会得到追梦的力量。所以当你看到校舍外的银杏叶在随风起舞时,恭喜你,你已经看到了代表着梦想的青春校园了。
  • tfboys之三公主的爱恋

    tfboys之三公主的爱恋

    这本书只要写了三位公主来到重庆遇见三只后,历经千辛万苦终于在一起的故事!!!