登陆注册
15792600000008

第8章

Everywhere the basis of principle is tradition, to such an extent that we even are in danger of making the role of history more important than it is.The other day Professor Ames wrote a learned article to show, among other things, that the common law did not recognize the defence of fraud in actions upon specialties, and the moral might seem to be that the personal character of that defence is due to its equitable origin.

But if, as I said, all contracts are formal, the difference is not merely historical, but theoretic, between defects of form which prevent a contract from being made, and mistaken motives which manifestly could not be considered in any system that we should call rational except against one who was privy to those motives.It is not confined to specialties, but is of universal application.I ought to add that I do not suppose that Mr.Ames would disagree with what I suggest.

However, if we consider the law of contract, we find it full of history.

The distinctions between debt, covenant, and assumpsit are merely historical.The classification of certain obligations to pay money, imposed by the law irrespective of any bargain as quasi contracts, is merely historical.The doctrine of consideration is merely historical.

The effect given to a seal is to be explained by history alone.

Consideration is a mere form.Is it a useful form? If so, why should it not be required in all contracts? A seal is a mere form, and is vanishing in the scroll and in enactments that a consideration must be given, seal or no seal.Why should any merely historical distinction be allowed to affect the rights and obligations of business men?

Since I wrote this discourse I have come on a very good example of the way in which tradition not only overrides rational policy, but overrides it after first having been misunderstood and having been given a new and broader scope than it had when it had a meaning.It is the settled law of England that a material alteration of a written contract by a party avoids it as against him.The doctrine is contrary to the general tendency of the law.We do not tell a jury that if a man ever has lied in one particular he is to be presumed to lie in all.Even if a man has tried to defraud, it seems no sufficient reason for preventing him from proving the truth.Objections of like nature in general go to the weight, not to the admissibility, of evidence.Moreover, this rule is irrespective of fraud, and is not confined to evidence.It is not merely that you cannot use the writing, but that the contract is at an end.What does this mean? The existence of a written contract depends on the fact that the offerer and offeree have interchanged their written expressions, not on the continued existence of those expressions.But in the case of a bond, the primitive notion was different.The contract was inseparable from the parchment.If a stranger destroyed it, or tore off the seal, or altered it, the obligee count not recover, however free from fault, because the defendant's contract, that is, the actual tangible bond which he had sealed, could not be produced in the form in which it bound him.About a hundred years ago Lord Kenyon undertook to use his reason on the tradition, as he sometimes did to the detriment of the law, and, not understanding it, said he could see no reason why what was true of a bond should not be true of other contracts.His decision happened to be right, as it concerned a promissory note, where again the common law regarded the contract as inseparable from the paper on which it was written, but the reasoning was general, and soon was extended to other written contracts, and various absurd and unreal grounds of policy were invented to account for the enlarged rule.

I trust that no one will understand me to be speaking with disrespect of the law, because I criticise it so freely.I venerate the law, and especially our system of law, as one of the vastest products of the human mind.No one knows better than I do the countless number of great intellects that have spent themselves in making some addition or improvement, the greatest of which is trifling when compared with the mighty whole.It has the final title to respect that it exists, that it is not a Hegelian dream, but a part of the lives of men.But one may criticise even what one reveres.Law is the business to which my life is devoted, and I should show less than devotion if I did not do what in me lies to improve it, and, when I perceive what seems to me the ideal of its future, if I hesitated to point it out and to press toward it with all my heart.

Perhaps I have said enough to show the part which the study of history necessarily plays in the intelligent study of the law as it is today.

同类推荐
  • 徐霞客游记

    徐霞客游记

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。
  • 清代割地谈

    清代割地谈

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。
  • The Devil's Dictionary

    The Devil's Dictionary

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。
  • 责汉水辞

    责汉水辞

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。
  • 广阳杂记

    广阳杂记

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。
热门推荐
  • 福妻驾到

    福妻驾到

    现代饭店彪悍老板娘魂穿古代。不分是非的极品婆婆?三年未归生死不明的丈夫?心狠手辣的阴毒亲戚?贪婪而好色的地主老财?吃上顿没下顿的贫困宭境?不怕不怕,神仙相助,一技在手,天下我有!且看现代张悦娘,如何身带福气玩转古代,开面馆、收小弟、左纳财富,右傍美男,共绘幸福生活大好蓝图!!!!快本新书《天媒地聘》已经上架开始销售,只要3.99元即可将整本书抱回家,你还等什么哪,赶紧点击下面的直通车,享受乐乐精心为您准备的美食盛宴吧!)
  • 一开口就拿订单:12天掌握成功销售的96个口才技巧

    一开口就拿订单:12天掌握成功销售的96个口才技巧

    本书旨在让销售员在*短的时间内掌握*有效的销售口才技巧,走进本书,你就会明白,不需要演说家的长篇大论,只言片语也能引起客户的共鸣;不需要辩论家的慷慨激昂,平铺直叙也能打动客户的心。销售口才就是这样,一句真诚的问候,就能敲开客户的心门;一句巧妙的提问,就能探知客户的需求;一句灵活的引导,就能打开客户的口袋……
  • 本未成年

    本未成年

    这是一本描写85后出生的人在高中生活的小说,故事和人物都有原型。他们都善良的生活在我身边,有些人现在依旧可以嗅出青春的味道更多的是成熟的气息。成年,似乎很慢,也很快。我们在感受着青春的飘荡和风雨里长大了,或是悔恨过去,或是感恩过往,但是那都是不能改变的记忆,那是我们真实地青春舞步,希望能得到每一位的共鸣。
  • 大唐圣国传

    大唐圣国传

    不一样的大唐圣国传,不一样的群雄争霸。朝廷与仙侠,风云莫测的官府和江湖故事。
  • 往川三途

    往川三途

    人的经历总是这样奇妙。有的地方似乎与我或者说我们有着说不清道不明的缘分。兜兜转转终于还是到了这里。
  • 婚后婚前

    婚后婚前

    他,是众人眼中的天之骄子,偶然中在路边捡到她,她,是他眼中的灰姑娘,两人迅速步入婚姻的殿堂。又是什么让她远走他乡,三年后的她是回来重续前缘,还是上演恩怨情仇
  • 佞凰

    佞凰

    她是南楚单骑逐敌的红颜将军,艳如红莲,迅疾似箭!他是北隅呼声最高的皇子储君,叱咤疆场,意气风发!二人的婚约是世人口中的门当户对,珠联璧合,然而,一场皇权覆乱,他被陷家破人亡,她被害株连九族。十三年后,他铅华散尽,终日醉生梦死,她归来,化身为“他”,翻出一场往事残烟,陷太子,夺帝位,在算计与被算计中不断沉浮。——“要快乐是多么简单的事,只要找一处深山乐谷隐居,交得二三好友,往来串联,没有尔虞我诈,没有波谲云诡,只是每当我想起硝烟淡处,折戟沉沙,白骨露野,就再也克制不住镌入骨髓的滔天恨意,我才意识到,我的快乐早在十三年前的今天就结束了。”——“绿蛮救不了你,还有我,我救不了你,我还有江山,如果连江山都救不了你,我要它何用?!”
  • 天才魔妃别逃跑

    天才魔妃别逃跑

    她,顾青霜,前世是一个金牌催眠师,却在执行任务时遭遇了爆炸,意外穿越到玄云大陆,那里没有魔法,没有斗气,只有魔师。她身怀异术,异兽相伴,在学院里战绿茶,虐渣男,日子过得逍遥自在。他,百里重歌。来历不明,身份神秘,实力超群,万年冰山,腹黑之神却唯独对她上了心。初次见面,他把她当路人。再次见面,却一不小心夺走了她的初吻。“霜儿,别跑了!”某男无奈。“不跑?我不跑等你打我啊!”某女才不信呢。谁知,他勾起邪魅微笑,声音性感得惹人犯罪,“我不会打你,只会……吃了你。”【新文求推荐,求收藏,求评论!构思庞大,美男多多~】
  • 球王大帝

    球王大帝

    J联赛?大帝刘彻已经征服了!德甲?大帝刘彻也已经征服了!西甲?大帝刘彻毫无悬念的征服了!英超?大帝刘彻饶有兴致的征服了!法甲?这个大帝刘彻就没有多少兴致去征服了!刘彻:足球先生拿到手软,还是给其他球员们一些机会吧,从今天开始,我退出各种足球先生的评选!
  • 孔子改制考

    孔子改制考

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。