登陆注册
15792400000058

第58章

First of all, it is said that the resolution of all moral approbation into sympathy really makes morality dependent on the mental constitution of each individual, and so sets up a variable standard, at the mercy of personal influences and local custom. Adam Smith says expressly indeed, that there is no other measure of moral conduct than the sympathetic approbation of each individual. "Every faculty in one man is the measure by which he judges of the like faculty iu another ;" and as he judges of other men's power of sight or hearing by reference to his own, so he judges of their love, resentment, or other moral states, by reference to his own consciousness of those several affections.

Is not this to destroy the fixed character of morality, and to deprive itas Protagoras, the Greek sophist, deprived it long ago in his similar teaching that man was the measure of all thingsof its most ennobling qualities, its eternity and immutability? Is it not to reduce the rules of morality to the level merely of the rules of etiquette? Is it not to make our standard of conduct dependent merely on the ideas and passions of those we happen to live with? Does it not justify Brown's chief objection to the system of sympathy, that it fixes morality "on a basis not sufficiently firm"?

Adam Smith's answer to this might have been, that the consideration of the basis of morality lay beyond the scope of his inquiry, and that, if he explained the principle of moral approbation by the laws of sympathy he appealed to, the facts commanded acceptance, whatever the consequences might be. He would have reasserted confidently, that no case of approbation occurred without a tacit reference to the sympathy of the approver; and that the feeling of approbation or the contrary always varied exactly with the degree of sympathy or antipathy felt for the agent. Therefore, if as a matter of fact every case of such approbation implied a reference to the feelings of the individual person approving, then those feelings were the source of moral judgment, however variable or relative morality might thus be made to appear.

He would also have denied that the consequence of his theory did really in any way weaken the basis of morality, or deprive it of its obligatory power over our conduct. The assertion of such a consequence has been perhaps the most persistent objection raised against his system. Sir James Mackintosh, for instance, makes the criticism, that "the sympathies have nothing more of an imperative character than any other emotions. They attract or repel, like other feelings, according to their intensity. If, then, the sympathies continue in mature minds to constitute the whole of conscience, it becomes utterly impossible to explain the character of command and supremacy, which is attested by the unanimous voice of mankind to belong to that faculty, and to form its essential distinction." (10) But as, of all Adam Smith's critics, Jouffroy has been the one who has urged this argument with the greatest force, it will be best to follow his reasoning, before considering the force of the objection.

According to him, no more moral authority can attach to the instinct of sympathy than can attach to any other instinct of our nature. The desire of sympathy, being simply an instinct, can have no claim to prevail over the impulses of our other instincts, whenever they happen to come into conflict, than such as is founded on its possible greater strength. For instance, the instinct of self-love often comes into conflict with, and often prevails over, the instinct of sympathy, the motive of self-interest well-understood being thus superior to our sympathetic impulses both in fact and by right. If then there is a superiority in the instinct of sympathy above all our other instincts, it must come from a judgment of reason, decisive of its title; but since such decision of reason implies a reference to some rule other and higher than instinct, our motive in preferring the inspirations of instinctive sympathy to all other impulses must be derived from this higher motive, or, in other words, from reason and not from instinct.

Hence, since the sympathetic instinct bears no signs of an authority superior to that of other instincts, there is no real authority in the motive which, according to Adam Smith, impels us to right conduct. Instead of proving that the instinct of sympathy is the true moral motive, Adam Smith describes truly and beautifully the characteristics of this moral motive, and then gratuitously attributes them to the instinct of sympathy. But he fails to apply to rules of conduct founded upon such an instinct, that which is the special characteristic of the moral motive, namely, that it alone is obligatoryalone presents us, as an end to be pursued, an end which ought to be pursued, as distinct from other ends suggested by other motives, which may be pursued or not as we please. "Among all possible motives, the moral motive alone appears to us as one that ought to govern our conduct."Jouffroy applies the same reasoning to Adam Smith's explanation of our moral ideas, those, for example, of Right and Duty . For if the motive of sympathy bears with it no authority, it is evident that it cannot explain ideas both of which imply and involve a motive of obligation.

If duty is obedience to rules of conduct that have been produced by sympathy, and these rules are only generalizations of particular judgments of instinctive sympathy, it is plain that the authority of these rules can be no greater than that of the judgments which originally gave rise to them. If it is equally a duty to obey the instinct as to obey the rules it gives rise to, it is superfluous to explain duty as a sense of the authority of these rules, seeing that it is already involved in the process of their formation.

同类推荐
热门推荐
  • 顾我余生

    顾我余生

    怎么说呢?顾南城和余生的爱情就像是薛之谦的《刚刚好》。就像是浓香的咖啡被冲淡了气息。只留下淡淡的清香。谈不上轰轰烈烈,但也是刻骨铭心。这是一个男女主相互误会所促成的虐恋1v1……
  • 不孕不育中医治疗学

    不孕不育中医治疗学

    本书分为三篇16章。上篇简要介绍了中医治疗不孕不育经典理论著作的主要内容;中篇和下篇分别系统论述了不孕不育的中医发病机制、辨证分型及治疗方法,其中的方药大多是作者30余年从事不孕不育临床工作与研究的经验总结,立方遣药平允而无偏颇,疗效显著。现代研究进展部分介绍了国内许多著名中医学家治疗不孕不育的宝贵经验。本书的特点是突出中医整体观念,辨证论治,辨病与辨证相结合,是一部临床实用性很强的参考书,可供中医临床医师、中医院校师生及专业科研人员和不孕不育的患者阅读参考。
  • 静心倾诉

    静心倾诉

    与DOTA有关,与DOTA无关。
  • 这世界,我只喜欢你

    这世界,我只喜欢你

    爱的世界是一首永远唱不完的歌,有一种爱只能在文字里相守。行走岁月感受世间冷暖,在时光的交错中看芸芸众生的爱恨情仇,聚散离合的悲喜是尘世中无法避开的伤口。那些隐藏在微笑的背后的沧桑不为人知,只能用柔软的笔触去抒发一个人的坚强。爱情、旅途都是一个人的地老天荒,这些孤独的吟唱在你捧起的手心勾起如烟的往事……
  • 末世荣耀系统

    末世荣耀系统

    2003年,2月1日,一颗天外陨石的坠入,导致地球上变异生物当道,从此拉开了末世的序幕。张轩,0级天赋,无法升级成为战士,一次重生使他拥有了荣耀系统,从此他的人生开了外挂,脚踏天才尸骨,一路披荆斩棘,惩奸除恶,带领人类夺回属于他们的家。群聊:703573253
  • 苍芒大帝

    苍芒大帝

    至尊体魄的少年却是废材?天道变了,他成了被遗弃的至尊!少年本想在家族的庇护下安稳的度过余生,可事与愿违,在面对族人讥讽践踏,旁人白眼嘲笑,硬是扣上莫名的黑锅,将他一次次推上风口浪尖,以命抵命!面对天命的不公,厄运的桎梏,他又该何去何从,踏上强者之路?问:苍茫大地,谁主沉浮?
  • 潋生华年:安择良木栖

    潋生华年:安择良木栖

    男二:当你爱的她不在是她,当为你心痛的不再心痛,好吧,你成功了,你彻底移情别恋了,但你却可能永远都不知道,你现在爱的那个女人依旧是她女二:这个世界上我最相信的人就是你,可你却一次又一次的背叛我,让我怎么不恨她?还是把对他的爱化作一阵风就随它想要的自由飞去吧男主:无论你是谁,我依然爱你,因为我爱的是你而不是你的身份爱到最后的最后你才会发现真正放不下的是你,而不是她,嘴角苦涩着笑的是她而不是你女主:在这场爱与爱的阴谋中,不知是你胜了,还是我赢了,最后的最后还是情这个字羁绊住了我们彼此前进的脚步你还记得你所过的话吗:想的是你的人,爱的是你的灵魂当年的情话,现在都是过去了
  • 越位

    越位

    这是一本以足球记者视角、围绕中国足球写就的小说。小说从2001年十强赛开始,主人公马亮和一帮足球记者们,亲眼见证了米卢在西亚对阵卡塔尔的怪异阵型,也亲耳听闻了关于某些人赌球的传闻,也见证了著名央视名嘴黄剑导致自己下课的质疑。之后,又凭借对内幕的了解,在国足对阵阿曼1:0时,成功帮人押注成功,获赠奔驰一辆。2005年,马亮见证德国名帅克劳琛带领国青风头正劲时,却被足协和部分媒体联合驱逐……2008年,奥运会前夕,由于杜伊的阵容中没有迪阿丹斯签约队员大智,这家国际知名体育品牌做出了必须撤杜伊以保大智的决策,谢亚龙巧设“狗肉宴”,临阵换掉国奥队主教练杜伊,马亮写稿公开揭露内情,被剥夺了采访男足的权力……同时,小说也展现了各大门户网站之间的体育新闻大战,尤其是新潮和搜狸之间你死我活的角逐,将体育媒体界的风云往事做了精彩重现。小说里穿插的爱情故事,也大放异彩,也真实呈现了足球记者的情爱世界。最终,马亮和众多记者兄弟一样,带着对中国足球的痛惜,和那一段快意恩仇的青春,离开了绿茵场。不久,中国足坛一场前所未有的反腐风暴掀开了帷幕……
  • 位面穿越修行录

    位面穿越修行录

    来自农村的一个普通少年,因意外获得的一块儿神秘玉佩,竟然使他拥有了穿越于异世大陆和现实世界的能力。且看主角刘叶如何通过自己的努力,收服兵王,脚踩纨绔,一步步爬上两个世界的巅峰!Ps:美女,会有的。热血,会有的。摆脱俗套,从现在开始!
  • 王俊凯少年我们私奔可好

    王俊凯少年我们私奔可好

    “王俊凯,你是不是喜欢我?”“怎么可能。”“那你是不是爱我?”“impossible.”“那你为什么对我那么好?”“我只是想你以后嫁不出去。”这个小说是主凯的,希望大家可以支持啦!