登陆注册
15754400000009

第9章

He surely, I mean, must have recognised himself how essentially incomplete his theory was in taking no account of the origin of family life, the position and influence of women, and other social questions, as well as in disregarding those deeper motives of religion, which are such important factors in early civilisation, and whose influence Aristotle seems to have clearly apprehended, when he says that the aim of primitive society was not merely life but the higher life, and that in the origin of society utility is not the sole motive, but that there is something spiritual in it if, at least, 'spiritual' will bring out the meaning of that complex expression [Greek text which cannot be reproduced].

Otherwise, the whole account in the REPUBLIC of primitive man will always remain as a warning against the intrusion of A PRIORIspeculations in the domain appropriate to induction.

Now, Aristotle's theory of the origin of society, like his philosophy of ethics, rests ultimately on the principle of final causes, not in the theological meaning of an aim or tendency imposed from without, but in the scientific sense of function corresponding to organ. 'Nature maketh no thing in vain' is the text of Aristotle in this as in other inquiries. Man being the only animal possessed of the power of rational speech is, he asserts, by nature intended to be social, more so than the bee or any other gregarious animal.

He is [Greek text which cannot be reproduced], and the national tendency towards higher forms of perfection brings the 'armed savage who used to sell his wife' to the free independence of a free state, and to the [Greek text which cannot be reproduced], which was the test of true citizenship. The stages passed through by humanity start with the family first as the ultimate unit.

The conglomeration of families forms a village ruled by that patriarchal sway which is the oldest form of government in the world, as is shown by the fact that all men count it to be the constitution of heaven, and the villages are merged into the state, and here the progression stops.

For Aristotle, like all Greek thinkers, found his ideal within the walls of the [Greek text which cannot be reproduced], yet perhaps in his remark that a united Greece would rule the world we may discern some anticipation of that 'federal union of free states into one consolidated empire' which, more than the [Greek text which cannot be reproduced], is to our eyes the ultimately perfect polity.

How far Aristotle was justified in regarding the family as the ultimate unit, with the materials afforded to him by Greek literature, I have already noticed. Besides, Aristotle, I may remark, had he reflected on the meaning of that Athenian law which, while prohibiting marriage with a uterine sister, permitted it with a sister-german, or on the common tradition in Athens that before the time of Cecrops children bore their mothers' names, or on some of the Spartan regulations, could hardly have failed to see the universality of kinsmanship through women in early days, and the late appearance of monandry. Yet, while he missed this point, in common, it must be acknowledged, with many modern writers, such as Sir Henry Maine, it is essentially as an explorer of inductive instances that we recognise his improvement on Plato. The treatise [Greek text which cannot be reproduced], did it remain to us in its entirety, would have been one of the most valuable landmarks in the progress of historical criticism, and the first scientific treatise on the science of comparative politics.

A few fragments still remain to us, in one of which we find Aristotle appealing to the authority of an ancient inscription on the 'Disk of Iphitus,' one of the most celebrated Greek antiquities, to corroborate his theory of the Lycurgean revival of the Olympian festival; while his enormous research is evinced in the elaborate explanation he gives of the historical origin of proverbs such as [Greek text which cannot be reproduced], of religious songs like the [Greek text which cannot be reproduced] of the Botticean virgins, or the praises of love and war.

And, finally, it is to be observed how much wider than Plato's his theory of the origin of society is. They both rest on a psychological basis, but Aristotle's recognition of the capacity for progress and the tendency towards a higher life shows how much deeper his knowledge of human nature was.

In imitation of these two philosophers, Polybius gives an account of the origin of society in the opening to his philosophy of history. Somewhat in the spirit of Plato, he imagines that after one of the cyclic deluges which sweep off mankind at stated periods and annihilate all pre-existing civilisation, the few surviving members of humanity coalesce for mutual protection, and, as in the case with ordinary animals, the one most remarkable for physical strength is elected king. In a short time, owing to the workings of sympathy and the desire of approbation, the moral qualities begin to make their appearance, and intellectual instead of bodily excellence becomes the qualification for sovereignty.

Other points, as the rise of law and the like, are dwelt on in a somewhat modern spirit, and although Polybius seems not to have employed the inductive method of research in this question, or rather, I should say, of the hierarchical order of the rational progress of ideas in life, he is not far removed from what the laborious investigations of modern travellers have given us.

And, indeed, as regards the working of the speculative faculty in the creation of history, it is in all respects marvellous how that the most truthful accounts of the passage from barbarism to civilisation in ancient literature come from the works of poets.

同类推荐
热门推荐
  • 合同警察

    合同警察

    上世纪60到90年代。有一群特殊的警察,他们被称为是合同警察,没有正式的编制,也没有执法资格。在偏远的西南地区,就存在着许多这样的合同警察,他们的生活,黑暗,血腥,热血。有坚持,有背叛,有忠诚。最终走向消亡!
  • 正一法文经护国醮海品

    正一法文经护国醮海品

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。
  • 三国之太平天师

    三国之太平天师

    我是一名普普通通的平常人,靠着半生的努力好不容易成为了一名考古研究员,可还没有等到我为此喜极而泣,正是要报答我那养我育我的老父母时,一件从天而降的大祸却是猛地砸在了我的头上!包含着无穷无尽的怨恨和恶念,我抱着终身遗憾而去,当我的灵魂是在不停的诅咒着这个世界的不公和黑暗之时,可能是上天也听到了我的憎怨之声!它再次赐予了我新生,但也是给了我最大的考验!重回汉末三国,看着那生于乱世之中,活在水深火热里的苦难百姓们,我思回路转,为什么我会来到这里,看着那从天而降的<<太平要道>>,我想我已经明白了,此后,我发誓要为他们撑起一片天!青天已死,黄天当立!这不是我一个人的黄天,是天下人的!我是张角
  • 天揽月.

    天揽月.

    生魂石引来了灭门的灾难,相继集中到凌杰身边的人,到底是真心投靠,还是另有目的,一个个围绕着生魂石展开的阴谋开始浮现……一场心计开始上演。为了生存,凌杰开始不顾一切。天能揽着月,我却不能揽着你!
  • 若华洛沐

    若华洛沐

    《十年》是一首歌,也是一段时光。她,莫名的等了他十年,也莫名的被他夺了初吻,莫名的爱上了他。他,从小就开始和她玩,已深入骨髓,无可救药的爱上了她,夺了她的初吻。“唔........”“不要说话,静静感受”冷洛尘用嘴堵住夏沐雨的嘴。“小念念,别”“音儿,一会就好了”“尧?”“嗯?”“没事,嘻嘻”“没事的话就去床上运动吧。”
  • 默殇花

    默殇花

    父母离异,默薏兄妹与母亲生活。可是当有一天,你发现母亲被父亲的情人害死的时候,你还要继续沉默下去吗?默氏兄妹开始复仇,究竟,她会承认自己是凶手吗?
  • 美世佳人情

    美世佳人情

    碧水潭边。落魄少年。如花儿般的妙龄少女。怎样地缠绵悱恻?怎样地一腔深情?
  • 赤血灭世

    赤血灭世

    “大道难成,历百千劫难,尝尽世间苦。”古往今来,多少梦想飞仙之人苦寻大道仙法,由此开创得成大道的修仙法门不胜枚举,繁衍至今却也只略有小成,得其大道者,寥寥无几。车水马龙的现代化世界,功能繁多的电子产品早已蒙蔽凡人眼耳,大道之术是人们的幻想?还是早已放弃?却都已被平静生活而取代。PS:(赤血灭世QQ交流群:547910761,入群注备:赤血阁。)
  • 网游之勠力同心

    网游之勠力同心

    命运将6个性格迥异的男生汇聚到了同一个寝室中。网游主宰的开服让全世界的游戏迷们沉沦。练级、副本、PVP、工会战争一连串的事件让青涩的6人慢慢的蜕变。一次PVP中主角林肖晨还没上场,就对着队伍里的众人说道,“准备下一场比赛,很快就轮到你们了。”是必输还是必赢?请看林肖晨,一个普通的大学生,如何在游戏中与他的兄弟们混的风声水起。纪念那些年兄弟们一起游戏的时光。
  • 重生之燃烧的年代

    重生之燃烧的年代

    重生将门之后,立志军旅却横生波折,是步入仕途还是纵横商海?在这个燃烧的年代,面对改革的巨变,带着快意恩仇的畅快,用曾经马革裹尸的热血,抒写属于自己的传奇。