登陆注册
15754400000007

第7章

Now, as regards the means employed generally by Thucydides for the elucidation of ancient history, I have already pointed out how that, while acknowledging that 'it is the tendency of every poet to exaggerate, as it is of every chronicler to seek to be attractive at the expense of truth; he yet assumes in the thoroughly euhemeristic way, that under the veil of myth and legend there does yet exist a rational basis of fact discoverable by the method of rejecting all supernatural interference as well as any extraordinary motives influencing the actors. It is in complete accordance with this spirit that he appeals, for instance, to the Homeric epithet of [Greek text which cannot be reproduced], as applied to Corinth, as a proof of the early commercial prosperity of that city; to the fact of the generic name HELLENES not occurring in the ILIAD as a corroboration of his theory of the essentially disunited character of the primitive Greek tribes; and he argues from the line 'O'er many islands and all Argos ruled,' as applied to Agamemnon, that his forces must have been partially naval, 'for Agamemnon's was a continental power, and he could not have been master of any but the adjacent islands, and these would not be many but through the possession of a fleet.'

Anticipating in some measure the comparative method of research, he argues from the fact of the more barbarous Greek tribes, such as the AEtolians and Acarnanians, still carrying arms in his own day, that this custom was the case originally over the whole country.

'The fact,' he says, 'that the people in these parts of Hellas are still living in the old way points to a time when the same mode of life was equally common to all.' Similarly, in another passage, he shows how a corroboration of his theory of the respectable character of piracy in ancient days is afforded by 'the honour with which some of the inhabitants of the continent still regard a successful marauder,' as well as by the fact that the question, 'Are you a pirate?' is a common feature of primitive society as shown in the poets; and finally, after observing how the old Greek custom of wearing belts in gymnastic contests still survived among the more uncivilised Asiatic tribes, he observes that there are many other points in which a likeness may be shown between the life of the primitive Hellenes and that of the barbarians to-day.'

As regards the evidence afforded by ancient remains, while adducing as a proof of the insecure character of early Greek society the fact of their cities (2) being always built at some distance from the sea, yet he is careful to warn us, and the caution ought to be borne in mind by all archaeologists, that we have no right to conclude from the scanty remains of any city that its legendary greatness in primitive times was a mere exaggeration. 'We are not justified,' he says, 'in rejecting the tradition of the magnitude of the Trojan armament, because Mycenae and the other towns of that age seem to us small and insignificant. For, if Lacedaemon was to become desolate, any antiquarian judging merely from its ruins would be inclined to regard the tale of the Spartan hegemony as an idle myth; for the city is a mere collection of villages after the old fashion of Hellas, and has none of those splendid public buildings and temples which characterise Athens, and whose remains, in the case of the latter city, would be so marvellous as to lead the superficial observer into an exaggerated estimate of the Athenian power.' Nothing can be more scientific than the archaeological canons laid down, whose truth is strikingly illustrated to any one who has compared the waste fields of the Eurotas plain with the lordly monuments of the Athenian acropolis.

(3)

On the other hand, Thucydides is quite conscious of the value of the positive evidence afforded by archaeological remains. He appeals, for instance, to the character of the armour found in the Delian tombs and the peculiar mode of sepulture, as corroboration of his theory of the predominance of the Carian element among the primitive islanders, and to the concentration of all the temples either in the Acropolis, or in its immediate vicinity, to the name of [Greek text which cannot be reproduced] by which it was still known, and to the extraordinary sanctity of the spring of water there, as proof that the primitive city was originally confined to the citadel, and the district immediately beneath it (ii. 16). And lastly, in the very opening of his history, anticipating one of the most scientific of modern methods, he points out how in early states of civilisation immense fertility of the soil tends to favour the personal aggrandisement of individuals, and so to stop the normal progress of the country through 'the rise of factions, that endless source of ruin'; and also by the allurements it offers to a foreign invader, to necessitate a continual change of population, one immigration following on another. He exemplifies his theory by pointing to the endless political revolutions that characterised Arcadia, Thessaly and Boeotia, the three richest spots in Greece, as well as by the negative instance of the undisturbed state in primitive time of Attica, which was always remarkable for the dryness and poverty of its soil.

Now, while undoubtedly in these passages we may recognise the first anticipation of many of the most modern principles of research, we must remember how essentially limited is the range of the ARCHAEOLOGIA, and how no theory at all is offered on the wider questions of the general conditions of the rise and progress of humanity, a problem which is first scientifically discussed in the REPUBLIC of Plato.

And at the outset it must be premised that, while the study of primitive man is an essentially inductive science, resting rather on the accumulation of evidence than on speculation, among the Greeks it was prosecuted rather on deductive principles.

同类推荐
热门推荐
  • 白帝崛起

    白帝崛起

    李善:“如果说这世上有谁能让我看得起,那么很抱歉,都没有。”
  • 公子给我笑一个

    公子给我笑一个

    苏木秋平生有三好,美食、美酒还有连檀。听闻城西柳木巷的风来阁有新菜品?还每日限量五份?睡懒觉起晚了吃不到怎么办?城东清河酒坊有陈年佳酿要出售?作为南罗城最大的土地主家唯一的女儿,苏木秋表示这都不是事!风来阁,我家开的。清河酒坊,虽然不是我家开的但是我可以买下来呀。连檀小哥不从怎么办?公子,一万两在这,买你够不够?
  • 宇宙外的世界

    宇宙外的世界

    本书的主人公无意中在学校发现了一个秘密,学校可以穿越到宇宙外!第一次穿越,令她难以相信,自己生活的,谜一样的宇宙,在这个世界里竟然如同池塘般大小!在无意中穿越回来后,她以为这是一个梦,却发现他在那里的朋友给他的礼物,象牙项链还在这里······
  • 御千魂者

    御千魂者

    在灭亡的世界中无人知晓的剧场上,嘉许之光悬于天顶,而受属意的仅我一人。我的长枪犹如天脊,正面迎击席卷世界的恐怖。我的法力遍及八方,敌寇的首级与我的永生不朽皆已是我囊中之物。血流成河的地方便是我的国土,我是掌控毁灭的圣者,手握火焰沐浴颂歌的黑暗之主。本卷标题:砸门团之法环武圣
  • 未来之都

    未来之都

    谁能告诉我,结束不是意味着新的开始呢——凌清云
  • 那样的歌

    那样的歌

    原创微小说,回荡的,不止青春。如果可以的话,你可以点一下加入书架收藏哦。注:作者QQ1513221978
  • 那年四班

    那年四班

    你有经历过青春吗?那种缠绵而又不舍的情感,忽的如同烟花在天空爆开:青涩的爱情,执着的友谊,随着岁月被磨尽,它们拉起手,笑着约定下一次的重逢,也许是在未来的某一天,也许根本不会在未来出现,但是未来不就因为未知才更加美丽吗?这个夏天,我和你约定好了。
  • 快穿系统:男配,来互相伤害

    快穿系统:男配,来互相伤害

    至于死后穿越什么她楚寻安不信,被系统抓去做苦力干攻略什么的....她不信也得信。说好的身体软萌好扑倒,智商下线好拐跑的系统呢!为什么给她的却是一个腹黑吝啬+专坑宿主的系统呢!?喂!老板!我强烈要求换一个系统继续攻略啊亲!本文又名:【炮灰系统:男配,请上榻】【坑爹的系统】本文不小白,欢迎小可爱们进群哦~黑粉就不用了哦~群号:454599433作者玻璃心,拒绝黑粉黑文,辱骂此文(作者),贬低此文(作者),而且请不喜欢本文的人不要故意拉低评分!
  • 731次动车

    731次动车

    看着那举止怪异的女子,我没有在意,然而,最终我会后悔的……【看了《釜山行》后的灵感,小说名两个月后改】
  • 无限天选

    无限天选

    无限的世界;无限的可能;在冰霜大地下见证血与火的阴谋!在钢铁军团里目睹变与革的对峙!在交杯换盏中看破新与旧的交锋!这里是生与死的边缘,这里是罪与缚的终点。在主神世界里,他的王朝已然开始!(PS:先别吐槽别不耐烦丨讨论群:418620547)