登陆注册
15754400000007

第7章

Now, as regards the means employed generally by Thucydides for the elucidation of ancient history, I have already pointed out how that, while acknowledging that 'it is the tendency of every poet to exaggerate, as it is of every chronicler to seek to be attractive at the expense of truth; he yet assumes in the thoroughly euhemeristic way, that under the veil of myth and legend there does yet exist a rational basis of fact discoverable by the method of rejecting all supernatural interference as well as any extraordinary motives influencing the actors. It is in complete accordance with this spirit that he appeals, for instance, to the Homeric epithet of [Greek text which cannot be reproduced], as applied to Corinth, as a proof of the early commercial prosperity of that city; to the fact of the generic name HELLENES not occurring in the ILIAD as a corroboration of his theory of the essentially disunited character of the primitive Greek tribes; and he argues from the line 'O'er many islands and all Argos ruled,' as applied to Agamemnon, that his forces must have been partially naval, 'for Agamemnon's was a continental power, and he could not have been master of any but the adjacent islands, and these would not be many but through the possession of a fleet.'

Anticipating in some measure the comparative method of research, he argues from the fact of the more barbarous Greek tribes, such as the AEtolians and Acarnanians, still carrying arms in his own day, that this custom was the case originally over the whole country.

'The fact,' he says, 'that the people in these parts of Hellas are still living in the old way points to a time when the same mode of life was equally common to all.' Similarly, in another passage, he shows how a corroboration of his theory of the respectable character of piracy in ancient days is afforded by 'the honour with which some of the inhabitants of the continent still regard a successful marauder,' as well as by the fact that the question, 'Are you a pirate?' is a common feature of primitive society as shown in the poets; and finally, after observing how the old Greek custom of wearing belts in gymnastic contests still survived among the more uncivilised Asiatic tribes, he observes that there are many other points in which a likeness may be shown between the life of the primitive Hellenes and that of the barbarians to-day.'

As regards the evidence afforded by ancient remains, while adducing as a proof of the insecure character of early Greek society the fact of their cities (2) being always built at some distance from the sea, yet he is careful to warn us, and the caution ought to be borne in mind by all archaeologists, that we have no right to conclude from the scanty remains of any city that its legendary greatness in primitive times was a mere exaggeration. 'We are not justified,' he says, 'in rejecting the tradition of the magnitude of the Trojan armament, because Mycenae and the other towns of that age seem to us small and insignificant. For, if Lacedaemon was to become desolate, any antiquarian judging merely from its ruins would be inclined to regard the tale of the Spartan hegemony as an idle myth; for the city is a mere collection of villages after the old fashion of Hellas, and has none of those splendid public buildings and temples which characterise Athens, and whose remains, in the case of the latter city, would be so marvellous as to lead the superficial observer into an exaggerated estimate of the Athenian power.' Nothing can be more scientific than the archaeological canons laid down, whose truth is strikingly illustrated to any one who has compared the waste fields of the Eurotas plain with the lordly monuments of the Athenian acropolis.

(3)

On the other hand, Thucydides is quite conscious of the value of the positive evidence afforded by archaeological remains. He appeals, for instance, to the character of the armour found in the Delian tombs and the peculiar mode of sepulture, as corroboration of his theory of the predominance of the Carian element among the primitive islanders, and to the concentration of all the temples either in the Acropolis, or in its immediate vicinity, to the name of [Greek text which cannot be reproduced] by which it was still known, and to the extraordinary sanctity of the spring of water there, as proof that the primitive city was originally confined to the citadel, and the district immediately beneath it (ii. 16). And lastly, in the very opening of his history, anticipating one of the most scientific of modern methods, he points out how in early states of civilisation immense fertility of the soil tends to favour the personal aggrandisement of individuals, and so to stop the normal progress of the country through 'the rise of factions, that endless source of ruin'; and also by the allurements it offers to a foreign invader, to necessitate a continual change of population, one immigration following on another. He exemplifies his theory by pointing to the endless political revolutions that characterised Arcadia, Thessaly and Boeotia, the three richest spots in Greece, as well as by the negative instance of the undisturbed state in primitive time of Attica, which was always remarkable for the dryness and poverty of its soil.

Now, while undoubtedly in these passages we may recognise the first anticipation of many of the most modern principles of research, we must remember how essentially limited is the range of the ARCHAEOLOGIA, and how no theory at all is offered on the wider questions of the general conditions of the rise and progress of humanity, a problem which is first scientifically discussed in the REPUBLIC of Plato.

And at the outset it must be premised that, while the study of primitive man is an essentially inductive science, resting rather on the accumulation of evidence than on speculation, among the Greeks it was prosecuted rather on deductive principles.

同类推荐
热门推荐
  • 阿吒婆拘鬼神大将上佛陀罗尼神咒经

    阿吒婆拘鬼神大将上佛陀罗尼神咒经

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。
  • 天域家族

    天域家族

    在天域大陆的历史里,有一位最强大的吸血鬼伯爵,他代表正义,在三亿年前与自己同级的邪恶大魔王同归于尽,身体化作了十五道光分散在天域大陆。三亿年后,吸血鬼伯爵转世在一位叫潘煜的少年身上。现在天域大陆的大魔王要追杀他。为了可以杀死大魔王,叫潘煜的少年在天域大陆寻找属于自己的十五位守护者。分别是:金,木,水,火,土,冰,风,雷,光,暗,音,幻,梦,念力和血。一边寻找自己的守护者,一边为了自己可以达到最高级而战斗着。
  • 弑神是仙

    弑神是仙

    精彩的情节在后面,不仅仅是修仙,而是真气与人体基因的结合,奇幻的世界还有着科技的存在,弑神?是仙?是最终的结果吗?请看新作《弑神是仙》
  • 狮皇

    狮皇

    禹墟大陆,一个修士的世界,武风彪悍,征战不断,修炼等级划分为:炼体境,锻魂境,蜕凡境,尊者境,灵师境,灵王境,天人境,封号圣者九境。
  • exo之如若一切都编织成梦

    exo之如若一切都编织成梦

    kakakkkakkakkkakakakakakkakakkakkakakakakkakakakakkakaka,黑道文
  • 源道创世录

    源道创世录

    脚踏凡尘,手掌轮回。混沌天道,君临天下!看一代网游天王如何在异世走向巅峰!
  • EXO.BTS.原来你还在这里

    EXO.BTS.原来你还在这里

    “为什么地球一直在转。”“因为几亿年前它吃炫迈的时候被别人扇了一巴掌。”“为什么地球是圆的。”“因为它想让失散的人再次相遇。”无论这世间多纷扰,你依旧把单纯拥抱。我不要全世界都心疼我,我只要一个人舍不得我.望着天空爱是否还活在童年里头,小王子说有些事流浪过才会懂。那些曾经迫切想得到的东西现在一一俱全,可缺少的仍然缺少。关于我内心深处的伤痕,是时间给的,我不需要爱情,我不屑任何生活。.十字路口,我们分着走。你走我的泪,我走你的恨。我无法反击,因为你不知道我爱你。你出谋划策想要攻破我的心,我竭尽全力来防御。.
  • 黎猫

    黎猫

    初见就地咚?现在的粉丝追星都这么丧心病狂了?本以为只是匆匆过客,却曾想,第二次见面在厕所碰上了?广告商赞助试穿服装还被撕坏了!无奈下,第三次见面,递情书,藏衣柜!?这是一个眼里只有钱和男神的逗比女神经追星的故事。这是一个被男神反坑扑倒的甜蜜宠文。初见君子,醉在桃花眼潋。
  • 可否摘星辰

    可否摘星辰

    旁人同情遗憾或惋惜,真心真诚或假意,只有我,懂你初心。记者:“听说你那个青梅竹马的编剧连星交了男朋友,方便透露一下吗?”他笑,“我和你听说的一样多。”记者八卦心起:“你见过那个男生吗?长得是不是很帅?”苏木白凝眸,认真端详着面前的镜子:“大家都说还不错。”
  • 彼岸花开无情杀手寻爱记

    彼岸花开无情杀手寻爱记

    无名无姓的她冷漠无情,那颗冰封的心终于被他融化。“莫溪然,我不爱你。”“没关系,小染,我爱你就足够了。”雪染,我今生最大的心愿是可以看到你开心。