登陆注册
15754400000005

第5章

While, however, we can discern in Herodotus the rise of an historic sense, we must not blind ourselves to the large amount of instances where he receives supernatural influences as part of the ordinary forces of life. Compared to Thucydides, who succeeded him in the development of history, he appears almost like a mediaeval writer matched with a modern rationalist. For, contemporary though they were, between these two authors there is an infinite chasm of thought.

The essential difference of their methods may be best illustrated from those passages where they treat of the same subject. The execution of the Spartan heralds, Nicolaos and Aneristos, during the Peloponnesian War is regarded by Herodotus as one of the most supernatural instances of the workings of nemesis and the wrath of an outraged hero; while the lengthened siege and ultimate fall of Troy was brought about by the avenging hand of God desiring to manifest unto men the mighty penalties which always follow upon mighty sins. But Thucydides either sees not, or desires not to see, in either of these events the finger of Providence, or the punishment of wicked doers. The death of the heralds is merely an Athenian retaliation for similar outrages committed by the opposite side; the long agony of the ten years' siege is due merely to the want of a good commissariat in the Greek army; while the fall of the city is the result of a united military attack consequent on a good supply of provisions.

Now, it is to be observed that in this latter passage, as well as elsewhere, Thucydides is in no sense of the word a sceptic as regards his attitude towards the truth of these ancient legends.

Agamemnon and Atreus, Theseus and Eurystheus, even Minos, about whom Herodotus has some doubts, are to him as real personages as Alcibiades or Gylippus. The points in his historical criticism of the past are, first, his rejection of all extra-natural interference, and, secondly, the attributing to these ancient heroes the motives and modes of thought of his own day. The present was to him the key to the explanation of the past, as it was to the prediction of the future.

Now, as regards his attitude towards the supernatural he is at one with modern science. We too know that, just as the primeval coal-beds reveal to us the traces of rain-drops and other atmospheric phenomena similar to those of our own day, so, in estimating the history of the past, the introduction of no force must be allowed whose workings we cannot observe among the phenomena around us. To lay down canons of ultra-historical credibility for the explanation of events which happen to have preceded us by a few thousand years, is as thoroughly unscientific as it is to intermingle preternatural in geological theories.

Whatever the canons of art may be, no difficulty in history is so great as to warrant the introduction of a spirit of spirit [Greek text which cannot be reproduced], in the sense of a violation of the laws of nature.

Upon the other point, however, Thucydides falls into an anachronism. To refuse to allow the workings of chivalrous and self-denying motives among the knights of the Trojan crusade, because he saw none in the faction-loving Athenian of his own day, is to show an entire ignorance of the various characteristics of human nature developing under different circumstances, and to deny to a primitive chieftain like Agamemnon that authority founded on opinion, to which we give the name of divine right, is to fall into an historical error quite as gross as attributing to Atreus the courting of the populace ([Greek text which cannot be reproduced])with a view to the Mycenean throne.

The general method of historical criticism pursued by Thucydides having been thus indicated, it remains to proceed more into detail as regards those particular points where he claims for himself a more rational method of estimating evidence than either the public or his predecessors possessed.

'So little pains,' he remarks, 'do the vulgar take in the investigation of truth, satisfied with their preconceived opinions,' that the majority of the Greeks believe in a Pitanate cohort of the Spartan army and in a double vote being the prerogative of the Spartan kings, neither of which opinions has any foundation in fact. But the chief point on which he lays stress as evincing the 'uncritical way with which men receive legends, even the legends of their own country,' is the entire baselessness of the common Athenian tradition in which Harmodios and Aristogeiton were represented as the patriotic liberators of Athens from the Peisistratid tyranny. So far, he points out, from the love of freedom being their motive, both of them were influenced by merely personal considerations, Aristogeiton being jealous of Hipparchos' attention to Harmodios, then a beautiful boy in the flower of Greek loveliness, while the latter's indignation was aroused by an insult offered to his sister by the prince.

Their motives, then, were personal revenge, while the result of their conspiracy served only to rivet more tightly the chains of servitude which bound Athens to the Peisistratid house, for Hipparchos, whom they killed, was only the tyrant's younger brother, and not the tyrant himself.

To prove his theory that Hippias was the elder, he appeals to the evidence afforded by a public inscription in which his name occurs immediately after that of his father, a point which he thinks shows that he was the eldest, and so the heir. This view he further corroborates by another inscription, on the altar of Apollo, which mentions the children of Hippias and not those of his brothers;'for it was natural for the eldest to be married first'; and besides this, on the score of general probability he points out that, had Hippias been the younger, he would not have so easily obtained the tyranny on the death of Hipparchos.

同类推荐
热门推荐
  • 灵动苍天

    灵动苍天

    灵动三界天地颤动至九霄云震撼苍茫大陆任我闯天地之间谁敢挡
  • TFBOYS之不完美的爱

    TFBOYS之不完美的爱

    虽然这个故事是纯属虚构的,但一定是每个四叶草都想发生在自己身上的。可谁又能知道,最后会是谁成为那三个被我们含泪祝福的人呢?
  • 网游之最强小怪

    网游之最强小怪

    第一次玩游戏,竟然转生在新手村最弱的小怪身上,郝龙非常不服气,他是绝不会删号重来的。凭他曾经世界第一杀手的身份,就算是一只小怪也要是最厉害的一只...
  • 萌宝来袭:爹地挡不住

    萌宝来袭:爹地挡不住

    “宝贝,不能动粗哦,女孩纸要温柔”转身就走了总裁的一位秘书“宝贝,上课要认真哦”低头就睡觉但我们的总裁依旧是宠着她,唉~没办法离家出走了,刚开始,不管不问,到了晚上却失眠了唉~~没办法,人家太爱这个娃纸了,离开了他,他就无法生存
  • 羽落夏未央

    羽落夏未央

    当宅女遇上高冷王爷当猫咪遇上卷毛狮子彼此会有怎样的碰撞宅女和猫咪会不会回到那个时代卷毛狮子和高冷王爷又会何去何从?一场奇葩的穿越又会迎来怎样的故事?
  • 尸海浮沉

    尸海浮沉

    先天心率过快因而习武之途不得寸进的方天无法回应爷爷对他的期盼,来到了离家千里的冰城念大学,但病毒突然间爆发了,丧尸遍野。独在异乡为异客,每逢危难倍思亲。方天脚步坚定,踏上返乡之路。在这茫茫尸海,半吊子的方天会是浮还是沉?
  • 九三六说三国

    九三六说三国

    九三六说三国,不为钱,只为大家开心。看看别人眼中的历史
  • 携手相伴

    携手相伴

    袁熙琳一个粗心大意的人,只求过着米虫的生活,一个吃货,为人很好,可是她因为粗心大意,迷糊,而被人算计,她是否会度过难关?接下来会发生什么呢?
  • 贝多芬

    贝多芬

    本书主要以贝多芬成长历程和人生发展为线索,通过日常生活中富于启发性的小故事来传达他成功的道理,主要内容包括:童年时代、拜师学艺、勇敢生活、追求上进、敢于创新、战胜苦痛、晚年生活等。
  • 神喻封天

    神喻封天

    时间是不可逆转的,如果把时间看成一条线。从地球的形成当做时间的起点,那么,时间就是一条射线,没有终点。或许,当地球毁灭的那条时间就走向了终点。当然,时间是没有起点的,宇宙形成的那一刻,时间线就启动了,或者说在宇宙形成之前时间线就已经开始行走了……如果把时间比喻成线的话,时间就是一条直线,没有起点也没有终点……那么,如果时间的起点和终点连接到一起呢?变成一个圆,没有起点没有终点,不断行走环绕,无穷无尽!这便是轮回!而我们今天要讲述的,便是着时间圆上的一段……