登陆注册
15754400000005

第5章

While, however, we can discern in Herodotus the rise of an historic sense, we must not blind ourselves to the large amount of instances where he receives supernatural influences as part of the ordinary forces of life. Compared to Thucydides, who succeeded him in the development of history, he appears almost like a mediaeval writer matched with a modern rationalist. For, contemporary though they were, between these two authors there is an infinite chasm of thought.

The essential difference of their methods may be best illustrated from those passages where they treat of the same subject. The execution of the Spartan heralds, Nicolaos and Aneristos, during the Peloponnesian War is regarded by Herodotus as one of the most supernatural instances of the workings of nemesis and the wrath of an outraged hero; while the lengthened siege and ultimate fall of Troy was brought about by the avenging hand of God desiring to manifest unto men the mighty penalties which always follow upon mighty sins. But Thucydides either sees not, or desires not to see, in either of these events the finger of Providence, or the punishment of wicked doers. The death of the heralds is merely an Athenian retaliation for similar outrages committed by the opposite side; the long agony of the ten years' siege is due merely to the want of a good commissariat in the Greek army; while the fall of the city is the result of a united military attack consequent on a good supply of provisions.

Now, it is to be observed that in this latter passage, as well as elsewhere, Thucydides is in no sense of the word a sceptic as regards his attitude towards the truth of these ancient legends.

Agamemnon and Atreus, Theseus and Eurystheus, even Minos, about whom Herodotus has some doubts, are to him as real personages as Alcibiades or Gylippus. The points in his historical criticism of the past are, first, his rejection of all extra-natural interference, and, secondly, the attributing to these ancient heroes the motives and modes of thought of his own day. The present was to him the key to the explanation of the past, as it was to the prediction of the future.

Now, as regards his attitude towards the supernatural he is at one with modern science. We too know that, just as the primeval coal-beds reveal to us the traces of rain-drops and other atmospheric phenomena similar to those of our own day, so, in estimating the history of the past, the introduction of no force must be allowed whose workings we cannot observe among the phenomena around us. To lay down canons of ultra-historical credibility for the explanation of events which happen to have preceded us by a few thousand years, is as thoroughly unscientific as it is to intermingle preternatural in geological theories.

Whatever the canons of art may be, no difficulty in history is so great as to warrant the introduction of a spirit of spirit [Greek text which cannot be reproduced], in the sense of a violation of the laws of nature.

Upon the other point, however, Thucydides falls into an anachronism. To refuse to allow the workings of chivalrous and self-denying motives among the knights of the Trojan crusade, because he saw none in the faction-loving Athenian of his own day, is to show an entire ignorance of the various characteristics of human nature developing under different circumstances, and to deny to a primitive chieftain like Agamemnon that authority founded on opinion, to which we give the name of divine right, is to fall into an historical error quite as gross as attributing to Atreus the courting of the populace ([Greek text which cannot be reproduced])with a view to the Mycenean throne.

The general method of historical criticism pursued by Thucydides having been thus indicated, it remains to proceed more into detail as regards those particular points where he claims for himself a more rational method of estimating evidence than either the public or his predecessors possessed.

'So little pains,' he remarks, 'do the vulgar take in the investigation of truth, satisfied with their preconceived opinions,' that the majority of the Greeks believe in a Pitanate cohort of the Spartan army and in a double vote being the prerogative of the Spartan kings, neither of which opinions has any foundation in fact. But the chief point on which he lays stress as evincing the 'uncritical way with which men receive legends, even the legends of their own country,' is the entire baselessness of the common Athenian tradition in which Harmodios and Aristogeiton were represented as the patriotic liberators of Athens from the Peisistratid tyranny. So far, he points out, from the love of freedom being their motive, both of them were influenced by merely personal considerations, Aristogeiton being jealous of Hipparchos' attention to Harmodios, then a beautiful boy in the flower of Greek loveliness, while the latter's indignation was aroused by an insult offered to his sister by the prince.

Their motives, then, were personal revenge, while the result of their conspiracy served only to rivet more tightly the chains of servitude which bound Athens to the Peisistratid house, for Hipparchos, whom they killed, was only the tyrant's younger brother, and not the tyrant himself.

To prove his theory that Hippias was the elder, he appeals to the evidence afforded by a public inscription in which his name occurs immediately after that of his father, a point which he thinks shows that he was the eldest, and so the heir. This view he further corroborates by another inscription, on the altar of Apollo, which mentions the children of Hippias and not those of his brothers;'for it was natural for the eldest to be married first'; and besides this, on the score of general probability he points out that, had Hippias been the younger, he would not have so easily obtained the tyranny on the death of Hipparchos.

同类推荐
热门推荐
  • 浊世界

    浊世界

    烈日煮熟绿海,风暴肆虐荒漠,就连钢铁丛林也快要被黑雨融化,与日俱增的问题和隐藏在暗处的危机使得地球已经变得不再适合人类居住,人类的命运将会在哪里?是逃避,还是拯救?是重启,还是改造?鲍勃:“我在也不想看见这个污浊的世界了!”安然:“这个世界,已没有净土。”庄子羽:“我的姐姐说过,心之所在,便是净土所在。”
  • 墨倾天下:废材惊世五小姐

    墨倾天下:废材惊世五小姐

    她为现代杀手组织王牌杀手,一朝穿越,成为将军府最无用的五小姐。他为天下无双的凛王,天赋无人可匹,却唯独倾心于她。她与他相情相悦,奈何误会重重,这看似如履薄冰的爱情,将何去何从……至魔之兽苏醒,身世之迷解开,身为圣女的她,做何选择……是牺牲自己,保他与天下平安亦或是与他同生共死……
  • 末日之卡牌世界

    末日之卡牌世界

    这个世界原本平静而和谐有一天一切都变了位面崩溃而到这不同的位面撞到了一起。人类,精灵,兽人,卡片,魔法,变异兽,由不同位面的世界撞到了一起的世界,期待了是不是那么就和少爷一起来看这个庞大的世界。
  • 穿越之穿越够了没

    穿越之穿越够了没

    为什么我就不能像穿越小说中的主角一样,每天喝酒泡妞打怪升级呢?
  • 魔王宠妻

    魔王宠妻

    魂穿异世,醒来时身边多了一个包子。偶遇强者,收之为徒。学艺六年终有小成。天下风起云涌之时,她带包子闯荡江湖之日,势要谋一席安逸之地。他冷酷绝然,手段残暴,从不以真容示人,人称魔王。当她遇上他,又会擦出何种火花……天下大势又将如何
  • 一符成仙

    一符成仙

    衣上云,一个天赋属性五行皆具,但却极其稀薄,被断定终生无法成为一名符师的少年,凭借自己的聪颖和坚毅,花费十年时间参悟出一枚神秘木符,以此为开端,走出了一条与众不同的灵符师修炼之路。一符成仙,生灭天地万物,创造宇宙乾坤!
  • 茅山术之三人行

    茅山术之三人行

    三个高中生,一次烦恼的旅行,他们意外地学会了茅山术,本着少年的好奇心,开始了他们的诡异旅行!
  • 青颈观自在菩萨心陀罗尼经

    青颈观自在菩萨心陀罗尼经

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。
  • 我家师傅被宅女拐跑了

    我家师傅被宅女拐跑了

    “永琳被我拐跑了,不服的话就来追妾身吧~by蓬莱山辉夜”“我要去找师匠啊,不要拦我!”“乖乖和我走吧,叔叔给你糖吃,世界在等着你拯救~by某氪金系统”注:不能坑死队友的歌姬不是好歌姬,治疗不带毒的奶不是好奶作为一名职业制药师夜见表示制药不带副作用真的很难,谁爱吃谁吃,反正自己做的药都不是给自己吃的
  • 憎爱君惜别

    憎爱君惜别

    她,曾是冥皇手下的白无常,因为刺杀他不成功,被贬至人间成为一个襁褓中的婴儿。她恨他,却止不住爱上他,她问:“茫茫人海怎么看上你?”他答:“我有魅力呗”其实…当个人还是很好的…来生还愿和你在一起(渣文,是个坑,咳咳)