登陆注册
15754400000019

第19章

There is something, as a rule, slightly contemptible about ancient criticism. The modern idea of the critic as the interpreter, the expounder of the beauty and excellence of the work he selects, seems quite unknown. Nothing can be more captious or unfair, for instance, than the method by which Aristotle criticised the ideal state of Plato in his ethical works, and the passages quoted by Polybius from Timaeus show that the latter historian fully deserved the punning name given to him. But in Polybius there is, I think, little of that bitterness and pettiness of spirit which characterises most other writers, and an incidental story he tells of his relations with one of the historians whom he criticised shows that he was a man of great courtesy and refinement of taste -as, indeed, befitted one who had lived always in the society of those who were of great and noble birth.

Now, as regards the character of the canons by which he criticises the works of other authors, in the majority of cases he employs simply his own geographical and military knowledge, showing, for instance, the impossibility in the accounts given of Nabis's march from Sparta simply by his acquaintance with the spots in question;or the inconsistency of those of the battle of Issus; or of the accounts given by Ephorus of the battles of Leuctra and Mantinea.

In the latter case he says, if any one will take the trouble to measure out the ground of the site of the battle and then test the manoeuvres given, he will find how inaccurate the accounts are.

In other cases he appeals to public documents, the importance of which he was always foremost in recognising; showing, for instance, by a document in the public archives of Rhodes how inaccurate were the accounts given of the battle of Lade by Zeno and Antisthenes.

Or he appeals to psychological probability, rejecting, for instance, the scandalous stories told of Philip of Macedon, simply from the king's general greatness of character, and arguing that a boy so well educated and so respectably connected as Demochares (xii. 14) could never have been guilty of that of which evil rumour accused him.

But the chief object of his literary censure is Timaeus, who had been unsparing of his strictures on others. The general point which he makes against him, impugning his accuracy as a historian, is that he derived his knowledge of history not from the dangerous perils of a life of action but in the secure indolence of a narrow scholastic life. There is, indeed, no point on which he is so vehement as this. 'A history,' he says, 'written in a library gives as lifeless and as inaccurate a picture of history as a painting which is copied not from a living animal but from a stuffed one.'

There is more difference, he says in another place, between the history of an eye-witness and that of one whose knowledge comes from books, than there is between the scenes of real life and the fictitious landscapes of theatrical scenery. Besides this, he enters into somewhat elaborate detailed criticism of passages where he thought Timaeus was following a wrong method and perverting truth, passages which it will be worth while to examine in detail.

Timaeus, from the fact of there being a Roman custom to shoot a war-horse on a stated day, argued back to the Trojan origin of that people. Polybius, on the other hand, points out that the inference is quite unwarrantable, because horse-sacrifices are ordinary institutions common to all barbarous tribes. Timaeus here, as was common with Greek writers, is arguing back from some custom of the present to an historical event in the past. Polybius really is employing the comparative method, showing how the custom was an ordinary step in the civilisation of every early people.

In another place, (21) he shows how illogical is the scepticism of Timaeus as regards the existence of the Bull of Phalaris simply by appealing to the statue of the Bull, which was still to be seen in Carthage; pointing out how impossible it was, on any other theory except that it belonged to Phalaris, to account for the presence in Carthage of a bull of this peculiar character with a door between his shoulders. But one of the great points which he uses against this Sicilian historian is in reference to the question of the origin of the Locrian colony. In accordance with the received tradition on the subject, Aristotle had represented the Locrian colony as founded by some Parthenidae or slaves' children, as they were called, a statement which seems to have roused the indignation of Timaeus, who went to a good deal of trouble to confute this theory. He does so on the following grounds:-First of all, he points out that in the ancient days the Greeks had no slaves at all, so the mention of them in the matter is an anachronism; and next he declares that he was shown in the Greek city of Locris certain ancient inscriptions in which their relation to the Italian city was expressed in terms of the position between parent and child, which showed also that mutual rights of citizenship were accorded to each city. Besides this, he appeals to various questions of improbability as regards their international relationship, on which Polybius takes diametrically opposite grounds which hardly call for discussion. And in favour of his own view he urges two points more: first, that the Lacedaemonians being allowed furlough for the purpose of seeing their wives at home, it was unlikely that the Locrians should not have had the same privilege; and next, that the Italian Locrians knew nothing of the Aristotelian version and had, on the contrary, very severe laws against adulterers, runaway slaves and the like.

同类推荐
  • 双槐岁钞

    双槐岁钞

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。
  • 玉箓资度设醮仪

    玉箓资度设醮仪

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。
  • 明实录穆宗实录

    明实录穆宗实录

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。
  • 靖海志

    靖海志

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。
  • 太清经断谷法

    太清经断谷法

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。
热门推荐
  • 御天庭

    御天庭

    天地有四灵,各自镇守一方,建天庭以统御众生。天道居中,沉寂万载之久。众生意念所化,天地所生,杨青本一介布衣,却有神秘师尊指点,踏上修炼一途。
  • 叹穷——暂无

    叹穷——暂无

    只为打造最钟情的人,十七八岁爱上的人往往是最爱却得不到的。
  • 波粒世界

    波粒世界

    曾志扬是一个太空事故的难民,双亲去世后,他就想通过高科技复活他的父亲,在他的工作进展顺利时,却被迫卷入一场星际战争中······
  • 我是异界召唤师

    我是异界召唤师

    召唤是我的爱好,装逼是我的本性,你若不服,跟我的小弟练练啊~
  • 荼锦素蕤

    荼锦素蕤

    当今社会连穿越都成潮流,她苏双双肯定要走在时尚的前端,这不,就穿越到没爹疼没娘爱又没子民爱戴的痴傻小姐身上。好吧,就算没爹疼没娘爱又没子民爱戴,她苏双双也是有尊严的!然而此时。非常有尊严的苏双双正在冲某男装可怜:“本宝宝和别人下象棋,宝宝的帅被人吃了。”“所以呢?”某男挑眉,苏双双的心思,他还能不知道?“你帅死了?”“嗯!我帅死了!”某女一脸无耻。男人邪魅勾唇,俯身将她拥入怀中,“再帅你也是我的。”高(逗)冷(比)攻穿越成痴傻受,遇上万年大总攻。自古以来,受下有受,攻上有攻。痴傻受翻身成为傲娇受还是高冷攻?谁上谁下?谁攻谁受?(《荼锦素蕤》正确读音:第一个荼tu第二声,第四个蕤rui第二声)
  • 不可能是英雄联盟

    不可能是英雄联盟

    职业玩家王胜穿越到了一个平行世界,而这个世界的英雄联盟联赛的火爆程度跟NBA有的一拼,职业玩家和明星一样受人追捧。作为职业玩家的王胜本来准备大展拳脚一番,然而,一次意外的邂逅让他努力积攒起来的气场全乱了!“少年,我看你骨骼清奇,绝对是百年难得一遇的撸啊撸天才!有没有兴趣加入我的代练团队啊?你来我就把我闺蜜介绍给你怎么样?”看着眼前这个长相神似纯洁小白兔,可内心却如同大灰狼一般邪恶的女孩,王胜无奈扬天长叹。“这不可能是英雄联盟!”
  • 嫡女风华:皇的神秘宠妃

    嫡女风华:皇的神秘宠妃

    她身份成谜,他却费尽心思后宫空置,此生只一人足矣。上一世辛苦劳碌做着高危职业,这辈子她只想赚赚钱喝喝酒,这一切却被一个冰块脸黑心肠的男人给搅和了,闯进来看了她的身子却倒打一耙“原来大小姐对在下觊觎已久,是在下太迟钝了。”满脸歉疚的某男笑的,很,欠,扁。【情节虚构,请勿模仿】
  • 福妻驾到

    福妻驾到

    现代饭店彪悍老板娘魂穿古代。不分是非的极品婆婆?三年未归生死不明的丈夫?心狠手辣的阴毒亲戚?贪婪而好色的地主老财?吃上顿没下顿的贫困宭境?不怕不怕,神仙相助,一技在手,天下我有!且看现代张悦娘,如何身带福气玩转古代,开面馆、收小弟、左纳财富,右傍美男,共绘幸福生活大好蓝图!!!!快本新书《天媒地聘》已经上架开始销售,只要3.99元即可将整本书抱回家,你还等什么哪,赶紧点击下面的直通车,享受乐乐精心为您准备的美食盛宴吧!)
  • 雁翔红楼

    雁翔红楼

    此文已半价红楼一出,为之辗转反侧痛彻心扉之人不知几许!“情”之一字,千回百转,却又有谁能料得到,参得透?林雪,以一个弱女子的身份穿越到红楼,成为那个世外仙姝林黛玉的婢女----雪雁.熟知历史进程的她,竭尽全力去改写红楼女儿的悲情命运。到最后,她能否于愿以偿呢?谁又是她最终停驻呢?看秀丽睿智的女子翱翔红楼,如何在红楼闯出一片自在广阔的天空!
  • 帝少的可爱萝莉

    帝少的可爱萝莉

    冷漠,人称帝少,从成年时,事业被他带入巅峰,对所有人冷漠至极,但对萧小樱这个小女佣却宠爱有佳。萧小樱是从孤儿院院里带回来的,她的身世真的有那么简单吗?快来看看……