登陆注册
15754400000001

第1章

HISTORICAL criticism nowhere occurs as an isolated fact in the civilisation or literature of any people. It is part of that complex working towards freedom which may be described as the revolt against authority. It is merely one facet of that speculative spirit of an innovation, which in the sphere of action produces democracy and revolution, and in that of thought is the parent of philosophy and physical science; and its importance as a factor of progress is based not so much on the results it attains, as on the tone of thought which it represents, and the method by which it works.

Being thus the resultant of forces essentially revolutionary, it is not to be found in the ancient world among the material despotisms of Asia or the stationary civilisation of Egypt. The clay cylinders of Assyria and Babylon, the hieroglyphics of the pyramids, form not history but the material for history.

The Chinese annals, ascending as they do to the barbarous forest life of the nation, are marked with a soberness of judgment, a freedom from invention, which is almost unparalleled in the writings of any people; but the protective spirit which is the characteristic of that people proved as fatal to their literature as to their commerce. Free criticism is as unknown as free trade.

While as regards the Hindus, their acute, analytical and logical mind is directed rather to grammar, criticism and philosophy than to history or chronology. Indeed, in history their imagination seems to have run wild, legend and fact are so indissolubly mingled together that any attempt to separate them seems vain. If we except the identification of the Greek Sandracottus with the Indian Chandragupta, we have really no clue by which we can test the truth of their writings or examine their method of investigation.

It is among the Hellenic branch of the Indo-Germanic race that history proper is to be found, as well as the spirit of historical criticism; among that wonderful offshoot of the primitive Aryans, whom we call by the name of Greeks and to whom, as has been well said, we owe all that moves in the world except the blind forces of nature.

For, from the day when they left the chill table-lands of Tibet and journeyed, a nomad people, to AEgean shores, the characteristic of their nature has been the search for light, and the spirit of historical criticism is part of that wonderful Aufklarung or illumination of the intellect which seems to have burst on the Greek race like a great flood of light about the sixth century B.C.

L'ESPRIT D'UN SIECLE NE NAIT PAS ET NE MEURT PAS E JOUR FIXE, and the first critic is perhaps as difficult to discover as the first man. It is from democracy that the spirit of criticism borrows its intolerance of dogmatic authority, from physical science the alluring analogies of law and order, from philosophy the conception of an essential unity underlying the complex manifestations of phenomena. It appears first rather as a changed attitude of mind than as a principle of research, and its earliest influences are to be found in the sacred writings.

For men begin to doubt in questions of religion first, and then in matters of more secular interest; and as regards the nature of the spirit of historical criticism itself in its ultimate development, it is not confined merely to the empirical method of ascertaining whether an event happened or not, but is concerned also with the investigation into the causes of events, the general relations which phenomena of life hold to one another, and in its ultimate development passes into the wider question of the philosophy of history.

Now, while the workings of historical criticism in these two spheres of sacred and uninspired history are essentially manifestations of the same spirit, yet their methods are so different, the canons of evidence so entirely separate, and the motives in each case so unconnected, that it will be necessary for a clear estimation of the progress of Greek thought, that we should consider these two questions entirely apart from one another. Ishall then in both cases take the succession of writers in their chronological order as representing the rational order - not that the succession of time is always the succession of ideas, or that dialectics moves ever in the straight line in which Hegel conceives its advance. In Greek thought, as elsewhere, there are periods of stagnation and apparent retrogression, yet their intellectual development, not merely in the question of historical criticism, but in their art, their poetry and their philosophy, seems so essentially normal, so free from all disturbing external influences, so peculiarly rational, that in following in the footsteps of time we shall really be progressing in the order sanctioned by reason.

AT an early period in their intellectual development the Greeks reached that critical point in the history of every civilised nation, when speculative invades the domain of revealed truth, when the spiritual ideas of the people can no longer be satisfied by the lower, material conceptions of their inspired writers, and when men find it impossible to pour the new wine of free thought into the old bottles of a narrow and a trammelling creed.

From their Aryan ancestors they had received the fatal legacy of a mythology stained with immoral and monstrous stories which strove to hide the rational order of nature in a chaos of miracles, and to mar by imputed wickedness the perfection of God's nature - a very shirt of Nessos in which the Heracles of rationalism barely escaped annihilation. Now while undoubtedly the speculations of Thales, and the alluring analogies of law and order afforded by physical science, were most important forces in encouraging the rise of the spirit of scepticism, yet it was on its ethical side that the Greek mythology was chiefly open to attack.

同类推荐
热门推荐
  • 圣道之巅

    圣道之巅

    正始元年,百族混战,人族九圣乱世横空而出,封印百族,建立九方天域。万年后,平庸少年得到一枚玉石,自此少年鱼跃龙门,新的乱世到来,少年一人一剑踏上那圣道巅峰,超越九圣!!
  • 相遇香格里拉

    相遇香格里拉

    初见时,韩笑21岁,在校大二学生,孙然24岁,已经工作一年,某国营企业小文员。香格里拉相遇,上演啼笑皆非的爆笑故事。一个月的打工旅行结束后,二人从此天各一方。但故事并没有就此结束,四年后,韩笑厌倦了原来的工作,面试北京“不期而遇”旅行杂志的外拍摄影师,随着“咔嚓”的快门声,四年前的那一幕又重新上演。本以为从此再无纠葛的两个人,不想却又相遇,只是韩笑一开始并没有认出孙然。此时的孙然已经不是当初那个有些落拓,有些不羁的懵懂少年了,现在的孙然多了些成熟男人的睿智冷静。现在,孙然是夏华企业销售部的经理。
  • 重生之倒追男神

    重生之倒追男神

    永远不要低估一个女生和你同甘共苦的决心,但也别忘记一个女生最怕的是在你身上看不到希望
  • 阴世界记录

    阴世界记录

    你所看到的世界是真实的吗?这里有你平常见不到的阴暗,这里有你所不了解的奇异,这里还有你想知道的传说,一个个阴谋,一个个疑惑,都将在这里解开。
  • 傲骄丫鬟之尔玉

    傲骄丫鬟之尔玉

    她无依无靠,她历经风雨,但她却在残垣断壁的微薄土壤中绽放了属于她的刹那芳华。当瘦弱的尔玉又一次两眼昏花饿晕在街头时,因为死死的拽住眼前偶然飘过的“馒头”让她成为了南家的小丫鬟。为了吃饱饭她曾经想成为烧火丫头、甚至厨子的小妾……曾经的孤独与饥饿差点就让尔玉彻底迷失了。好在总有“贵人”相助,这个傲骄的小丫鬟在举步维艰的人生道路上,跌跌撞撞总算找到了方向,她立志决不做小妾一定要做妻!(本文纯属虚构,请勿模仿。)
  • 超级仓管员

    超级仓管员

    透视药水?仓库里有……航母大舰?仓库里有……治病救命?仓库里有……超级仓库,无珍不有!无奇不有!坑蒙拐骗?有我仓管!巧取豪夺?有我仓管!偷抢盗取?有我仓管!我是仓管,我为自己代言!
  • 风水师笔记

    风水师笔记

    继承了胡半仙爷爷的工作之后,我走上了风水师的道路,全村人的红白喜事都由我操持。风水说白了就是为活人找阳宅,为死人找阴宅,在做风水师这些年,我都会记录下我遇到的每一件奇事、怪事。故事的开头从那头水猴子说起....
  • 肆意挥霍的那些年

    肆意挥霍的那些年

    那一年,我们肆意挥霍的青春。那一年,我们痛过,也无悔的爱过。那一年,我曾默默为你付出过。那一年,我们走失了吗?
  • 至尊红颜:高冷王爷太妖孽

    至尊红颜:高冷王爷太妖孽

    新书《快穿炮灰:反派大人求放过》已连载,欢迎新老读者跳坑哦!(本文已完结)穿越前,背叛的出现,只是因为筹码不够。那么,都不要了,滚可好?穿越后,明明是嫡小姐,过得还不如条狗,废材?我云昕颜,教教你什么叫废材好吗?“呵呵,小颜儿,乖!”某无良女子看着某男嬉皮笑脸的容颜,指着周围的人群道:“谁,是谁说这货高冷似男神的,出来,我保证不打死他。”读者群:156103968
  • 暖情速递:闫总,真爱包邮

    暖情速递:闫总,真爱包邮

    发现老公出轨后,林微安依然决定离婚。戏剧性的是,离婚当天她才知道自己怀孕了,更戏剧的是,她的出轨老公在民政局门口出了车祸,当场死亡。虽然渣男已死,可她的悲惨命运也才刚刚开始。恶毒的前公婆,得知她怀的是儿子后,随时都要抢回去。而她的亲生父亲胆小懦弱,跟继母想尽各种方式压榨她。亲生母亲却一直不肯认她,一出现就要让她打掉孩子,为的就是要林微安捐出肝脏救她。好在极品众多的生活中,始终有一个人一直站在她身边,宠她爱她呵护她,让她安稳度日。