登陆注册
15752600000093

第93章

I have enumerated the four Contracts in their historical order, which order, however, the Roman Institutional writers did not invariably follow. There can be no doubt that the Verbal Contract was the most ancient of the four, and that it is the eldest known descendant of the primitive Nexum. Several species of Verbal Contract were anciently in use, but the most important of all, and the only one treated of by our authorities, was effected by means of a stipulation, that is, a Question and Answer; a question addressed by the person who exacted the promise, and an answer given by the person who made it. This question and answer constituted the additional ingredient which, as I have just explained, was demanded by the primitive notion over and above the mere agreement of the persons interested. They formed the agency by which the Obligation was annexed. The old Nexum has now bequeathed to maturer jurisprudence first of all the conception of a chain uniting the contracting parties, and this has become the Obligation. It has further transmitted the notion of a ceremonial accompanying and consecrating the engagement, and this ceremonial has been transmuted into the Stipulation. The conversion of the solemn conveyance, which was the prominent feature of the original Nexum, into a mere question and answer, would be more of a mystery than it is if we had not the analogous history of Roman Testaments to enlighten us.

Looking to that history, we can understand how the formal Conveyance was first separated from the part of the proceeding which had immediate reference to the business in hand, and how afterwards it was omitted altogether. As then the question and answer of the Stipulation were unquestionably the Nexum in a simplified shape, we are prepared to find that they long partook of the nature of a technical form. It would be a mistake to consider them as exclusively recommending themselves to the older Roman Lawyers through their usefulness in furnishing persons meditating an agreement with an opportunity for consideration and reflection. It is not to be disputed that they had a value of this kind, which was gradually recognised; but there is proof that their function in respect to Contracts was at first formal and ceremonial in the statement of our authorities, that not every question and answer was of old sufficient to constitute a Stipulation, but only a question and answer couched in technical phraseology specially appropriated to the particular occasion.

But although it is essential for the proper appreciation of the history of contract-law that the Stipulation should be understood to have been looked upon as a solemn form before it was recognised as a useful security, it would be wrong on the other hand to shut our eyes to its real usefulness. The Verbal Contract, though it had lost much of its ancient importance, survived to the latest period of Roman juris prudence; and we may take it for granted that no institution of Roman law had so extended a longevity unless it served some practical advantage. Iobserve in an English writer some expressions of surprise that the Romans even of the earliest times were content with so meagre a protection against haste and irreflection. But on examining the Stipulation closely, and remembering that we have to do with a state of society in which written evidence was not easily procurable, I think we must admit that this Question and Answer, had it been expressly devised to answer the purpose which it served, would have been justly designated a highly ingenious expedient. It was the promisee who, in the character of stipulator, put all the terms of the contract into the form of a question, and the answer was given by the promisor. "Do you promise that you will deliver me such and such a slave, at such and such a place, on such and such a day?" "I do promise." Now, if we reflect for a moment, we shall see that this obligation to put the promise interrogatively inverts the natural position of the parties, and, by effectually breaking the tenor of the conversation, prevents the attention from gliding over a dangerous pledge. With us, a verbal promise is, generally speaking, to be gathered exclusively from the words of the promisor. In old Roman law, another step was absolutely required;it was necessary for the promisee, after the agreement had been made, to sum up all its terms in a solemn interrogation; and it was of this interrogation, of course, and of the assent to it, that proof had to be given at the trial -- not of the promise, which was not in itself binding. How great a difference this seemingly insignificant peculiarity may make in the phraseology of contract-law is speedily realised by the beginner in Roman jurisprudence, one of whose first stumbling-blocks is almost universally created by it. When we in English have occasion, in mentioning a contract, to connect it for convenience' sake with one of the parties -- for example, if we wished to speak generally of a contractor -- it is always the promisor at whom our words are pointing. But the general language of Roman law takes a different turn; it always regards the contract, if we may so speak, from the point of view of the promisee. in Speaking of a party to a contract, it is always the Stipulator, the person who asks the question, who is primarily alluded to. But the serviceableness of the stipulation is most vividly illustrated by referring to the actual examples in the pages of the Latin comic dramatists. If the entire scenes are read down in which these passages occur (ex. gra. Plautus, Pseudolus, Act I. sc. i; Act IV. sc. 6; Trinummus, Act V. sc. 2), it will be perceived how effectually the attention of the person meditating the promise must have been arrested by the question, and how ample was the opportunity for withdrawal from an improvident undertaking.

同类推荐
  • 佛顶最胜陀罗尼经

    佛顶最胜陀罗尼经

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。
  • 佛说佛医经

    佛说佛医经

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。
  • 鸿雁之什

    鸿雁之什

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。
  • 佛说银色女经

    佛说银色女经

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。
  • 唐人万首绝句选

    唐人万首绝句选

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。
热门推荐
  • 谁在舰上行走

    谁在舰上行走

    不一样的水兵视角,更真实的军同情感。谁在舰上行走?一个受过感情挫折的新兵丛彬,热情率真的战友余大可,两个海军战士之间有着什么样的情感生活?期待你的关注。
  • 殊途未归

    殊途未归

    木冉说过你难道就不能不走你难道在我最困难的时候丢下我你难到不会听我一次对不起我太自作多情对不起是我不好对不起我并不知道对不起我爱你
  • 树妖之女婴的怨灵

    树妖之女婴的怨灵

    闪电过后,雷神一声发出了震耳欲聋的怒吼,女人剧烈地颤抖着,瞬间,一切又恢复正常,桃花林中万籁般寂静,月亮从云里钻出来,如圆盘般悬挂在天空中,照得大地仿如白昼,女人飞奔着跑到桃树下,看见刚才埋葬女婴地方的泥土被闪电烧得一片漆黑,然而地下,也变得坚硬无比,像从没被人挖开过。女人怔怔地站了一会,转过身,继续走着她要走的道路。
  • 影子刀

    影子刀

    影子门门下一弟子因在一次意外得江湖失踪已久的影子刀,练就一身神功,持影子刀惩奸除恶,无意之间卷入了武林中的惊天阴谋之中,刀与剑争锋,血与汗的融合!捍卫武林,谁敢不从……
  • 血狼祭

    血狼祭

    一个被狼群养大的孩子,一曲动人心魄的复仇之歌,白强,血狼的创建人,养育他的狼群被残忍诛杀之后,他离奇失踪,三十年后,带有血狼标志的匕重现江湖……当年参与剿灭血狼的人一个个死于标有血狼标志的匕首之下,办案的公安干警在前往白强所在的村子后,一个个离奇死亡,双胞胎姐妹的神秘现身,非人非狼怪物屡次救助,使得整个事件更加的诡异,凶险……还有多少人要在这血腥的复仇中死去……要解开这其中的秘密,还要付出怎样沉重的代价……
  • 重生巨星之男神归来

    重生巨星之男神归来

    身为女子,便是镜星阑最大的罪过。被亲生父母送人,被养父母遗弃,只因她不是男子。受到同学欺辱死亡,来自地球的镜星阑带着刷脸系统重生而来。在这个重男轻女的世界,镜星阑改头换面,勇闯娱乐圈,成为娱乐圈的全民男神!(本文纯属虚构,请勿模仿。)
  • 播般曩结使波金刚念诵仪

    播般曩结使波金刚念诵仪

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。
  • 灵犀

    灵犀

    东海有龙,名曰灵犀。“那两人是你仇家?”灵犀闷闷道:“算是吧。”“连你都怕……他们什么人?”“左边那个是双头蛟,右边是三头蛟,千万不能让他们看到我。”--情节虚构,请勿模仿
  • 白色眷恋

    白色眷恋

    因为不满皇马6比2的比分,中国青年律师沈星怒砸啤酒瓶,结果电光火石间,他穿越成了佛罗伦蒂诺的儿子,且看来自09年的小伙子如何玩转03年的欧洲足坛
  • 此生非你莫属

    此生非你莫属

    有多少人,以朋友的名义爱着一个人;有多少爱,只差一句“余生请多多指教”。