登陆注册
15752600000033

第33章

Primitive Society and Ancient Law

The necessity of submitting the subject of jurisprudence toscientific treatment has never been entirely lost sight of inmodern times, and the essays which the consciousness of thisnecessity has produced have proceeded from minds of very variouscalibre, but there is not much presumption, I think, in assertingthat what has hitherto stood in the place of a science has forthe most part been a set of guesses, those very guesses of theRoman lawyers which were examined in the two preceding chapters.

A series of explicit statements, recognising and adopting theseconjectural theories of a natural state, and of a system ofprinciples congenial to it, has been continued with but briefinterruption from the days of their inventors to our own. Theyappear in the annotations of the Glossators who founded modernjurisprudence, and in the writings of the scholastic jurists whosucceeded them. They are visible in the dogmas of the canonists.

They are thrust into prominence by those civilians of marvellouserudition, who flourished at the revival of ancient letters.

Grotius and his successors invested them not less with brilliancyand plausibility than with practical importance. They may be readin the introductory chapters of our own Blackstone, who hastranscribed them textually from Burlamaqui, and wherever themanuals published in the present day for the guidance of thestudent or the practitioner begin with any discussion of thefirst principles of law, it always resolves itself into arestatement of the Roman hypothesis. It is however from thedisguises with which these conjectures sometimes clothethemselves, quite as much as from their native form, that we gainan adequate idea of the subtlety with which they mix themselvesin human thought. The Lockeian theory of the origin of Law in aSocial Compact scarcely conceals its Roman derivation, and indeedis only the dress by which the ancient views were rendered moreattractive to a particular generation of the moderns; but on theother hand the theory of Hobbes on the same subject was purposelydevised to repudiate the reality of a law of nature as conceivedby the Romans and their disciples. Yet these two theories, whichlong divided the reflecting politicians of England into hostilecamps, resemble each other strictly in their fundamentalassumption of a non-historic, unverifiable, condition of therace. Their authors differed as to the characteristics of theprae-social state, and as to the nature of the abnormal action bywhich men lifted themselves out of it into that socialorganisation with which alone we are acquainted, but they agreedin thinking that a great chasm separated man in his primitivecondition from man in society, and this notion we cannot doubtthat they borrowed, consciously or unconsciously, from theRomans. If indeed the phenomena of law be regarded in the way inwhich these theorists regarded them -- that is, as one vastcomplex whole -- it is not surprising that the mind should oftenevade the task it has set to itself by falling back on someingenious conjecture which (plausibly interpreted) will seem toreconcile everything, or else that it should sometimes abjure indespair the labour of systematization.

From the theories of jurisprudence which have the samespeculative basis as the Roman doctrine two of much celebritymust be excepted. The first of them is that associated with thegreat name of Montesquieu. Though there are some ambiguousexpressions in the early part of the Esprit des Lois, which seemto show its writer's unwillingness to break quite openly with theviews hitherto popular the general drift of the book is certainlyto indicate a very different conception of its subject from anywhich had been entertained before. It has often been noticedthat, amidst the vast variety of examples which, in its immensewidth of survey, it sweeps together from supposed systems ofjurisprudence, there is an evident anxiety to thrust intoespecial prominence those manners and institutions which astonishthe civilised reader by their uncouthness, strangeness, orindecency. The inference constancy suggested is, that laws arethe creatures of climate, local situation, accident, or imposture-- the fruit of any causes except those which appear to operatewith tolerable constancy. Montesquieu seems, in fact, to havelooked on the nature of man as entirely plastic, as passivelyreproducing the impressions, and submitting implicitly to theimpulses, which it receives from without. And here no doubt liesthe error which vitiates his system as a system. He greatlyunderrates the stability of human nature. He pays little or noregard to the inherited qualities of the race, those qualitieswhich each generation receives from its predecessors, andtransmits but slightly altered to the generation which followsit. It is quite true, indeed, that no complete account can begiven of social phenomena, and consequently of laws, till dueallowance has been made for those modifying causes which arenoticed in the Esprit des Lois; but their number and their forceappear to have been overestimated by Montesquieu. Many of theanomalies which he parades have since been shown to rest on falsereport or erroneous construction, and of those which remain not afew prove the permanence rather than the variableness of maw'snature, since they are relics of older stages of the race whichhave obstinately defied the influences that have elsewhere hadeffect. The truth is that the stable part of our mental, moral,and physical constitution is the largest part of it, and theresistance it opposes to change is such that, though thevariations of human society in a portion of the world are plainenough, they are neither so rapid nor so extensive that theiramount, character, and general direction cannot be ascertained.

同类推荐
  • 法集名数经

    法集名数经

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。
  • 大般涅槃经论

    大般涅槃经论

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。
  • 国朝宋学渊源记

    国朝宋学渊源记

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。
  • Socialism

    Socialism

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。
  • A Dog's Tale

    A Dog's Tale

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。
热门推荐
  • 许你长相厮守

    许你长相厮守

    她说:如果,这是个梦,那我愿此生都醒不过来。他说:“我没有女朋友,老婆倒有一个。”当许诺头次与孟澶相遇时,他们便已被月老的红线牵扯住了即使分开再久,他与她,也终不会散了
  • 我真是唐伯虎

    我真是唐伯虎

    有才就是风流,鉴宝,做画,吟诗,唐门绝学——风流倜傥无敌霸王枪。有钱就是任性,建工厂,盖大楼,承包好莱坞,称霸月球。有德就是帅气,城城哥,腾腾兄,云云表亲,巴巴老弟,都来给我敬茶。游戏华夏,枪挑英伦,调戏老美,碾压日本。大国文化,上下五千年,四海来朝。人好金银贵,我慕桃花仙。仙人种桃树,摘花换酒钱。酒醒花前坐,醉卧花中眠。愿为酒花死,不鞠车马前。(大国文化,励志霸气。)
  • 无相苍天

    无相苍天

    冷玉龙经历人生之中的大变,却在无意之中得到了天下间数一数二的绝世功法!震西域,擒蛮王!
  • 世纪战圣

    世纪战圣

    一个少年,两个种族的结合,不为世人认可。面对命运之门无情的碾压,面对诸多嘲讽,面对前途艰险,少年依旧高昂头颅,仰天呼啸:“欺老莫欺少年,男儿雄心朝。”
  • 腹黑宠妻无下限:军师娘子

    腹黑宠妻无下限:军师娘子

    当玩世不恭、情商毫无、智商超群的女军师,穿越到白痴加花痴的双痴少女身上,将会如何?拭目以待!
  • 人生哲理枕边书

    人生哲理枕边书

    本书内容分六章,具体包括:要善于学习和思考、做事要先学会做人、实现人生的目标、机会属于有准备的人、找准成功之路、寻找生命的意义。
  • 网游之超级都市

    网游之超级都市

    这是一个虚拟度100%的网游。这里可以惩恶扬善,这里可以称霸三国,这里也可以拯救人类,这是一个屌丝重生得到金手指后,在网游中建立全新超级都市收获幸福的故事
  • 沙滩贝壳的忧伤

    沙滩贝壳的忧伤

    冷酷的苏安溪,调皮的金夜雨,恶毒的苏宁,拽到死的夏晗沫,她们之间发生了太多太多的事,金夜雨和苏安溪永远不可能和好,一心想报仇的苏安溪,又怎样地开启她的复仇游戏,夏晗沫又会怎样的帮助苏安溪?让我们拭目以待
  • 陌上云暮迟迟归

    陌上云暮迟迟归

    安以陌是名副其实的狗仔队,如果她再调查不出当红天后的神秘男朋友是谁,她就可以直接滚出报社了。被主编逼得快跳楼的以陌,却发现,天后的神秘男友是她当年甩了的初恋情人!她是该出卖前男友发布这条新闻,还是装成不知道躲得他远远的?可惜,云暮寒显然没打算善罢甘休,他不会放过这个6年前将他伤害的女人。他不要她好过,6年前他就发誓,要让她付出代价!可是她身边,已经有了一个不好对付的男人——陆韶迟!面对昔日恋人的咄咄相逼,以陌该不该说出当年分手的秘密?真相一步步被揭开,他们的感情又该去何从?
  • 世纪练兵场

    世纪练兵场

    在这个世纪,只要你有战功,你就可以变得声明远扬,声名显赫。而练兵,却是为了更大的阴谋,地球之上的原始文明。战争的烙印,迟早会降临。