登陆注册
15752600000033

第33章

Primitive Society and Ancient Law

The necessity of submitting the subject of jurisprudence toscientific treatment has never been entirely lost sight of inmodern times, and the essays which the consciousness of thisnecessity has produced have proceeded from minds of very variouscalibre, but there is not much presumption, I think, in assertingthat what has hitherto stood in the place of a science has forthe most part been a set of guesses, those very guesses of theRoman lawyers which were examined in the two preceding chapters.

A series of explicit statements, recognising and adopting theseconjectural theories of a natural state, and of a system ofprinciples congenial to it, has been continued with but briefinterruption from the days of their inventors to our own. Theyappear in the annotations of the Glossators who founded modernjurisprudence, and in the writings of the scholastic jurists whosucceeded them. They are visible in the dogmas of the canonists.

They are thrust into prominence by those civilians of marvellouserudition, who flourished at the revival of ancient letters.

Grotius and his successors invested them not less with brilliancyand plausibility than with practical importance. They may be readin the introductory chapters of our own Blackstone, who hastranscribed them textually from Burlamaqui, and wherever themanuals published in the present day for the guidance of thestudent or the practitioner begin with any discussion of thefirst principles of law, it always resolves itself into arestatement of the Roman hypothesis. It is however from thedisguises with which these conjectures sometimes clothethemselves, quite as much as from their native form, that we gainan adequate idea of the subtlety with which they mix themselvesin human thought. The Lockeian theory of the origin of Law in aSocial Compact scarcely conceals its Roman derivation, and indeedis only the dress by which the ancient views were rendered moreattractive to a particular generation of the moderns; but on theother hand the theory of Hobbes on the same subject was purposelydevised to repudiate the reality of a law of nature as conceivedby the Romans and their disciples. Yet these two theories, whichlong divided the reflecting politicians of England into hostilecamps, resemble each other strictly in their fundamentalassumption of a non-historic, unverifiable, condition of therace. Their authors differed as to the characteristics of theprae-social state, and as to the nature of the abnormal action bywhich men lifted themselves out of it into that socialorganisation with which alone we are acquainted, but they agreedin thinking that a great chasm separated man in his primitivecondition from man in society, and this notion we cannot doubtthat they borrowed, consciously or unconsciously, from theRomans. If indeed the phenomena of law be regarded in the way inwhich these theorists regarded them -- that is, as one vastcomplex whole -- it is not surprising that the mind should oftenevade the task it has set to itself by falling back on someingenious conjecture which (plausibly interpreted) will seem toreconcile everything, or else that it should sometimes abjure indespair the labour of systematization.

From the theories of jurisprudence which have the samespeculative basis as the Roman doctrine two of much celebritymust be excepted. The first of them is that associated with thegreat name of Montesquieu. Though there are some ambiguousexpressions in the early part of the Esprit des Lois, which seemto show its writer's unwillingness to break quite openly with theviews hitherto popular the general drift of the book is certainlyto indicate a very different conception of its subject from anywhich had been entertained before. It has often been noticedthat, amidst the vast variety of examples which, in its immensewidth of survey, it sweeps together from supposed systems ofjurisprudence, there is an evident anxiety to thrust intoespecial prominence those manners and institutions which astonishthe civilised reader by their uncouthness, strangeness, orindecency. The inference constancy suggested is, that laws arethe creatures of climate, local situation, accident, or imposture-- the fruit of any causes except those which appear to operatewith tolerable constancy. Montesquieu seems, in fact, to havelooked on the nature of man as entirely plastic, as passivelyreproducing the impressions, and submitting implicitly to theimpulses, which it receives from without. And here no doubt liesthe error which vitiates his system as a system. He greatlyunderrates the stability of human nature. He pays little or noregard to the inherited qualities of the race, those qualitieswhich each generation receives from its predecessors, andtransmits but slightly altered to the generation which followsit. It is quite true, indeed, that no complete account can begiven of social phenomena, and consequently of laws, till dueallowance has been made for those modifying causes which arenoticed in the Esprit des Lois; but their number and their forceappear to have been overestimated by Montesquieu. Many of theanomalies which he parades have since been shown to rest on falsereport or erroneous construction, and of those which remain not afew prove the permanence rather than the variableness of maw'snature, since they are relics of older stages of the race whichhave obstinately defied the influences that have elsewhere hadeffect. The truth is that the stable part of our mental, moral,and physical constitution is the largest part of it, and theresistance it opposes to change is such that, though thevariations of human society in a portion of the world are plainenough, they are neither so rapid nor so extensive that theiramount, character, and general direction cannot be ascertained.

同类推荐
  • 金氏文集

    金氏文集

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。
  • 下第述怀

    下第述怀

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。
  • 产宝

    产宝

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。
  • 湛然禅师宗门或问

    湛然禅师宗门或问

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。
  • 医贯

    医贯

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。
热门推荐
  • 痴人福

    痴人福

    讲述丑陋的田义连娶三个美丽娇妻,因善行得享福寿的故事。
  • 从重生到永生

    从重生到永生

    常言道:人死不可复生。重生不易,永生更是痴人说梦,可人们还是一直梦想着去追求长生。从死亡到重生,再到永生,在全新的世界里实现现实世界的奢望。
  • 绽放在心底的花

    绽放在心底的花

    为什么在我心灵脆弱的时候遇到她,为什么她在我心里久挥不去,为什么我要赌那个未知的结果。这是一个男孩暗恋一个女孩的故事。
  • 绝处逢生之黑暗侵袭

    绝处逢生之黑暗侵袭

    如果说世上有地狱,堕天城绝对当仁不让。暴力,淫乱,毒品,折磨...每一个生活在堕天城的人都是恶魔,血腥只是他们的日常。他们的人生毫无希望,他们在狂欢中等待灭亡。也许,是神终于厌烦了这个藏污纳垢的黑暗深渊,天罚...降临了......丧尸,失却了灵魂的躯体死而复生。地狱已满,凡人的末世仿佛降临。
  • 踏雪寻仙

    踏雪寻仙

    鬼门大开,魔王雄心勃勃,势必统一三界。终南山隐士奇才一身,与八大派一同把守着终南山的通天之路。天庭安逸千年,众仙天天醉生梦死,夜夜纸醉金迷。莺歌燕舞中浑然不知魔域的动乱即将来临,待魔军踏入天庭时,为时已晚。魔王一统三界,天地变色,日月无光。隐士徒儿踏雪强忍丧师之痛,踏上了寻仙拯救三界之路。
  • 苍窘之恋

    苍窘之恋

    顾浩一个不算太帅,家庭条件一般的男人,以为这样的男人就会给自己幸福,没想到却编织了一场假婚假爱的谎言。伤的体无完肤的时候,这样的自己还有资格拥有真爱吗?
  • EXO同人:世界尽头

    EXO同人:世界尽头

    狼族,有一个传说,每隔一千年狼族会出现十二子召唤生命之树延续狼族生命,但从来没有人见过生命之树和十二子..........【作者是新手啊,写小说比较慢,各位读者,不喜勿看】
  • 刀剑风流

    刀剑风流

    故人归来。肩落漫天白雪,且看我如何轻轻拂去。——-看惯了升级打怪,品够了yy无限,来一杯作者为您诚恳砌成的茶可好?茶水不烫,喜爱最好。
  • 没关系,我们都一样

    没关系,我们都一样

    我相信许多年以后,总会有人提起;“当年师哥说过的,这些都没什么。原来,真是这样!”是的当你感觉人生没那么如意,当你对自己的表现没那么满意,当你觉得自己再也坚持不下去了。请记得对自己说,没关系,我们都是这样,慢慢长大。
  • 末世颂歌

    末世颂歌

    崩塌的世界再次重开,生与死不再被自己掌控。一群最强大的人一次又一次与天地意志展开战争,当成功的那一刻,世界必将永远属于我们自己!