登陆注册
15752600000020

第20章

The period of jurists ends with Alexander Severus. FromHadrian to that emperor the improvement of law was carried on, asit is at the present moment in most continental countries, partlyby approved commentaries and partly by direct legislation. But inthe reign of Alexander Severus the power of growth in RomanEquity seems to be exhausted, and the succession of jurisconsultscomes to a close. The remaining history of the Roman law is thehistory of the imperial constitutions, and, at the last, ofattempts to codify what had now become the unwieldy body of Romanjurisprudence. We have the latest and most celebrated experimentof this kind in the Corpus Juris of Justinian.

It would be wearisome to enter on a detailed comparison orcontrast of English and Roman Equity but it may be worth while tomention two features which they have in common. The first may bestated as follows. Each of them tended, and all such systemstend, to exactly the same state in which the old common law waswhen Equity first interfered with it. A time always comes atwhich the moral principles originally adopted have been carriedout to all their legitimate consequences, and then the systemfounded on them becomes as rigid, as unexpansive, and as liableto fall behind moral progress as the sternest code of rulesavowedly legal. Such an epoch was reached at Rome in the reign ofAlexander Severus; after which, though the whole Roman world wasundergoing a moral revolution, the Equity of Rome ceased toexpand. The same point of legal history was attained in Englandunder the chancellorship of Lord Eldon, the first of our equityjudges who, instead of enlarging the jurisprudence of his courtby indirect legislation, devoted himself through life toexplaining and harmonising it. If the philosophy of legal historywere better understood in England, Lord Eldon's services would beless exaggerated on the one hand and better appreciated on theother than they appear to be among contemporary lawyers. Othermisapprehensions too, which bear some practical fruit, wouldperhaps be avoided. It is easily seen by English lawyers thatEnglish Equity is a system founded on moral rules; but it isforgotten that these rules are the morality of past centuries --not of the present-that they have received nearly as muchapplication as they are capable of, and that though of coursethey do not differ largely from the ethical creed of our own day,they are not necessarily on a level with it. The imperfecttheories of the subject which are commonly adopted have generatederrors of opposite sorts. Many writers of treatises on Equity,struck with the completeness of the system in its present state,commit themselves expressly or implicitly to the paradoxicalassertion that the founders of the chancery jurisprudencecontemplated its present fixity of form when they were settlingits first bases. Others, again, complain and this is a grievancefrequently observed upon in forensic arguments -- that the moralrules enforced by the Court of Chancery fall short of the ethicalstandard of the present day. They would have each Lord Chancellorperform precisely the same office for the jurisprudence which hefinds ready to his hand, which was performed for the old commonlaw by the fathers of English equity. But this is to invert theorder of the agencies by which the improvement of the law iscarried on. Equity has its place and its time; but I have pointedout that another instrumentality is ready to succeed it when itsenergies are spent.

Another remarkable characteristic of both English and RomanEquity is the falsehood of the assumptions upon which the claimof the equitable to superiority over the legal rule is originallydefended. Nothing is more distasteful to men, either asindividuals or as masses, than the admission of their moralprogress as a substantive reality. This unwillingness showsitself, as regards individuals, in the exaggerated respect whichis ordinarily paid to the doubtful virtue of consistency. Themovement of the collective opinion of a whole society is toopalpable to be ignored, and is generally too visible for thebetter to be decried; but there is the greatest disinclination toaccept it as a primary phenomenon, and it is commonly explainedas the recovery of a lost perfection -- the gradual return to astate from which the race has lapsed. This tendency to lookbackward instead of forward for the goal of moral progressproduced anciently, as we have seen, on Roman jurisprudenceeffects the most serious and permanent. The Roman jurisconsults,in order to account for the improvement of their jurisprudence bythe Praetor, borrowed from Greece the doctrine of a Natural stateof man -- a Natural society -- anterior to the organisation ofcommonwealths governed by positive laws. In England, on the otherhand, a range of ideas especially congenial to Englishmen of thatday, explained the claim of Equity to override the common law bysupposing a general right to superintend the administration ofjustice which was assumed to be vested in the king as a naturalresult of his paternal authority. The same view appears in adifferent and a quainter form in the old doctrine that Equityflowed from the king's conscience -- the improvement which had infact taken place in the moral standard of the community beingthus referred to an inherent elevation in the moral sense of thesovereign. The growth of the English constitution rendered such atheory unpalatable after a time; but, as the jurisdiction of theChancery was then firmly established, it was not worth while todevise any formal substitute for it. The theories found in modernmanuals of Equity are very various, but all are alike in theiruntenability. Most of them are modifications of the Romandoctrine of a natural law, which is indeed adopted in tenour bythose writers who begin a discussion of the jurisdiction of theCourt of Chancery by laying down a distinction between naturaljustice and civil.

Ancient Law

by Henry Maine

同类推荐
  • Canterbury Pieces

    Canterbury Pieces

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。
  • 沙弥学戒仪轨颂注

    沙弥学戒仪轨颂注

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。
  • 上方大洞真元妙经品

    上方大洞真元妙经品

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。
  • 萃善录

    萃善录

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。
  • 华严经传记

    华严经传记

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。
热门推荐
  • 妇人带下门

    妇人带下门

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。
  • 驱逐舰与登陆舰传奇

    驱逐舰与登陆舰传奇

    本书是针对青少年的军事知识读物,包括必备的军事知识、军事趣闻、战机战舰知识、导弹火炮知识等多个主题。
  • 英雄联盟之技能召唤

    英雄联盟之技能召唤

    艾欧里亚最强王者电脑意外被黑,惊现英雄联盟系统,可以召唤出英雄拥有他们强大的技能,一个网瘾少年能否就此崛起?!
  • 雨之倾城

    雨之倾城

    男人的责任是什么?孝敬父母、爱护妻儿、赚钱养家、回报社会?张雨涵一直没弄懂。为此,他失去了生命回到了三十几年前,重新来过,他想好好补偿前世所欠的债,可是他已不是了他。。。蝶殇,蝶之涅槃。一曲绕梁,一笑倾城。
  • 八荒天

    八荒天

    春秋时期坑杀四十万之巨兵士之绝世杀神白起,楚汉时期威名远赫千古之绝世霸王,三国时期白马银枪纵横无敌之常山赵子龙....这些本已身死无数年的盖世人物,结果却在一个未知的世界发现了他们的踪迹,共处一世的他们会碰撞出怎样的火花?意外得到威道之剑太阿传承的晴天,莫名的降临到此处,开始了属于他的传奇...
  • 撩到一只傲娇鬼

    撩到一只傲娇鬼

    你说,人真的会有轮回吗?当然了,你说的不是废话!如果没有轮回,那她唐小沫是怎么过来的,额…………但是你前世不是纯阴之女啊,这我怎么知道!对了,你还撩到了一个帅鬼做老公呢!行了吧,你就别提他了,不过为什么我感觉,我和他相遇没有那么简单啊!为什么?不知道,反正感觉大事不妙,看一个命格全阴的女主如何一步一步的解开她的身世之谜,看一个痴痴等待了一个女子五千年的男主如何一步一步的挽回女主的心,这一切难道真的是天注定?欢迎加入撩到一只傲娇鬼读者群,群号码:424625834
  • 强势追妻:绯闻女王太危险

    强势追妻:绯闻女王太危险

    她A市顶层富豪圈突然冒出来的一名绯闻女王,据说他交往过五名男神,都是富豪圈的钻石王老五,而且都对她念念不忘。他是A市四大家族中最有钱的欧氏二公子,圈内有名的花花公司,为了看嫩模选秀,放下公司不管,在公司的新品发布会上和嫩模上演激情戏。本只是要调戏她,谁知却一往情深。
  • 倾君侧:惊世毒后

    倾君侧:惊世毒后

    她于他,不过一枚棋子;他于她,不过整个天下。她为他,倾尽一身医药才学,救了他最爱的女人;他为她,放弃所有计划,只为保全她。她爱他,依然;他爱她,未果。当所有计划全部漂浮于水面的时候,她才明白,只有自己才是那个沉浸在一切美梦里的跳梁小丑....
  • 美国留学那些事儿

    美国留学那些事儿

    你一定认为在美国留学是一件既轻松又简单的事情吧?事实上你错了,在这里,你以为没有了父母的唠叨和限制,课同时你也失去了父母照顾你的机会,而在这时,就是考验你的时刻。希望大家别忘了自己出国留学的初心,坚持自己的梦想,要永远自信,不要害怕别人的打击,这些都只是你成功的垫脚石罢了!
  • 惹火萌妃:殿下,我很乖

    惹火萌妃:殿下,我很乖

    秦衿长这么大从来没有见过如此厚颜无耻之人。她一心帮他,他却一门心思只想睡她!“爱妃,为夫无以为报,只有以身相许!”“爱妃,其实我比鸡腿好吃!”“爱妃,我已经洗干净了!”“爱妃,我不只帅,还很能干!”秦衿仰天泪流,某人套路太深!她血薄,扛不住啊……