登陆注册
15752600000010

第10章

Yet the moment the judgment has been rendered and reported, weslide unconsciously or unavowedly into a new language and a newtrain of thought. We now admit that the new decision has modifiedthe law. The rules applicable have, to use the very inaccurateexpression sometimes employed, become more elastic. In fact theyhave been changed. A clear addition has been made to theprecedents, and the canon of law elicited by comparing theprecedents is not the same with that which would have beenobtained if the series of cases had been curtailed by a singleexample. The fact that the old rule has been repealed, and that anew one has replaced it, eludes us, because we are not in thehabit of throwing into precise language the legal formulas whichwe derive from the precedents, so that a change in their tenor isnot easily detected unless it is violent and glaring. I shall notnow pause to consider at length the causes which have led Englishlawyers to acquiesce in these curious anomalies. Probably it willbe found that originally it was the received doctrine thatsomewhere, in nubibus or in gremio magistratuum, there existed acomplete, coherent, symmetrical body of English law, of anamplitude sufficient to furnish principles which would apply toany conceivable combination of circumstances. The theory was atfirst much more thoroughly believed in than it is now, and indeedit may have had a better foundation. The judges of the thirteenthcentury may have really had at their command a mine of lawunrevealed to the bar and to the lay-public, for there is somereason for suspecting that in secret they borrowed freely, thoughnot always wisely, from current compendia of the Roman and Canonlaws. But that storehouse was closed so soon as the pointsdecided at Westminster Hall became numerous enough to supply abasis for a substantive system of jurisprudence; and now forcenturies English practitioner have so expressed themselves as toconvey the paradoxical proposition that, except by Equity andStatute law, nothing has been added to the basis since it wasfirst constituted. We do not admit that our tribunals legislate;we imply that they have never legislated; and yet we maintainthat the rules of the English common law, with some assistancefrom the Court of Chancery and from Parliament, are coextensivewith the complicated interests of modern society.

A body of law bearing a very close and very instructiveresemblance to our case-law in those particulars which I havenoticed, was known to the Romans under the name of the ResponsaPrudentum, the "answers of the learned in the law." The form ofthese Responses varied a good deal at different periods of theRoman jurisprudence, but throughout its whole course theyconsisted of explanatory glosses on authoritative writtendocuments, and at first they were exclusively collections ofopinions interpretative of the Twelve Tables. As with us, alllegal language adjusted itself to the assumption that the text ofthe old Code remained unchanged. There was the express rule. Itoverrode all glosses and comments, and no one openly admittedthat any interpretation of it, however eminent the interpreter,was safe from revision on appeal to the venerable texts. Yet inpoint of fact, Books of Responses bearing the names of leadingjurisconsults obtained an authority at least equal to that of ourreported cases, and constantly modified, extended, limited orpractically overruled the provisions of the Decemviral law. Theauthors of the new jurisprudence during the whole progress of itsformation professed the most sedulous respect for the letter ofthe Code. They were merely explaining it, deciphering it,bringing out its full meaning; but then, in the result, bypiecing texts together, by adjusting the law to states of factwhich actually presented themselves and by speculating on itspossible application to others which might occur, by introducingprinciples of interpretation derived from the exegesis of otherwritten documents which fell under their observation, they educeda vast variety of canons which had never been dreamed of by thecompilers of the Twelve Tables and which were in truth rarely ornever to be found there. All these treatises of the jurisconsultsclaimed respect on the ground of their assumed conformity withthe Code, but their comparative authority depended on thereputation of the particular jurisconsults who gave them to theworld. Any name of universally acknowledged greatness clothed aBook of responses with a binding force hardly less than thatwhich belonged to enactments of the legislature; and such a bookin its turn constituted a new foundation on which a further bodyof jurisprudence might rest. The responses of the early lawyerswere not however published, in the modern sense, by their author.

They were recorded and edited by his pupils, and were nottherefore in all probability arranged according to any scheme ofclassification. The part of the students in these publicationsmust be carefully noted, because the service they rendered totheir teacher seems to have been generally repaid by his sedulousattention to the pupils' education. The educational treatisescalled Institutes or Commentaries, which are a later fruit of theduty then recognised, are among the most remarkable features ofthe Roman system. It was apparently in these Institutional works,and not in the books intended for trained lawyers, that thejurisconsults gave to the public their classifications and theirproposals for modifying and improving the technical phraseology.

同类推荐
  • 王惺所集

    王惺所集

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。
  • 明伦汇编交谊典盟誓部

    明伦汇编交谊典盟誓部

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。
  • 惠远外传

    惠远外传

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。
  • 禹贡

    禹贡

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。
  • 大集譬喻王经

    大集譬喻王经

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。
热门推荐
  • 血浴狂飙

    血浴狂飙

    这是由一群起于草莽而纵横捭阖的人留传下来的令人开卷唏嘘掩卷深思的真实故事。在他们的故事里,包含着山规盟约、侠义豪情、绿林暗语、英雄相惜、江湖规则……在他们的故事里,充斥着涕泪交流、血肉横飞、明争暗斗、刀光剑影、枪林弹雨……在他们的故事里,交织着爱与恨、恩与怨、血与火、情与仇、沉与浮、生与死……他们,就是豫西蹚将!
  • 五重局

    五重局

    为了寻找写作灵感,他来到这个村子,但却意外的发现村子里面怪事频出,他遇到一重又一重险象,碰到一个又一个人,以至于最后陷入了一个巨大的谜团之中,最后才发现原来一切从一开始都被设计着,而他也才真正明白,当初那一切的一切究竟是为什么。
  • 我师父真是亚索

    我师父真是亚索

    一剑,一念。我命由我不由天。当方正看着手中已折断的剑,身后是倒成一片的追杀者。葫芦里的酒还剩最后一口。咽下。“装x,真他x的累!”方正道。疾风剑豪亚索传承了他剑术,也传承了他命运,且看没玩过lol的异世少年,如何凭手中剑,携风杀九霄!
  • 羽倾

    羽倾

    他发誓认识这女人是他最倒霉的事,三天两头给他惊喜就算了。现在居然操心他的婚姻大事,拜托,她不害他娶不到就要偷笑了。。。不过看她这架势,怎么也不像是帮忙做媒,这女人又在搞什么啊!
  • 福妻驾到

    福妻驾到

    现代饭店彪悍老板娘魂穿古代。不分是非的极品婆婆?三年未归生死不明的丈夫?心狠手辣的阴毒亲戚?贪婪而好色的地主老财?吃上顿没下顿的贫困宭境?不怕不怕,神仙相助,一技在手,天下我有!且看现代张悦娘,如何身带福气玩转古代,开面馆、收小弟、左纳财富,右傍美男,共绘幸福生活大好蓝图!!!!快本新书《天媒地聘》已经上架开始销售,只要3.99元即可将整本书抱回家,你还等什么哪,赶紧点击下面的直通车,享受乐乐精心为您准备的美食盛宴吧!)
  • 因为这是不能说的秘密

    因为这是不能说的秘密

    千万不要忘记我们每个人都有秘密That'ssomethingcan'tbesaid.时间会沉淀有些人终究会在心里慢慢模糊不管我们能不能相见我只想告诉你一个秘密......
  • 傲娇鬼圣:邪王绝宠纨绔妻

    傲娇鬼圣:邪王绝宠纨绔妻

    一朝穿越,叱咤风云鬼家家主鬼离鸢魂穿至华夏?当鬼离鸢在华夏呼风唤雨之际,天又戏她,让她再次穿回?穿回也就罢了,但这天生废柴无法聚灵的废物之称,拜托睁大你们的眼睛好好看看行吗?若她废物,天下便再无天才。十指相扣,灵根全开,异世两魂,携手同行。哼,废物?看她如何颠覆风云!他,凤幂异姓王,身中奇毒,容貌尽毁,双腿残废,邪功称世,传言不近女色,似有短袖之癖却唯对她死皮赖脸,冰山王化身邪魅少主开展妻奴路?这大陆嫌她,毁了又如何?这天下与她为敌,灭了又如何!倾尽生命,护她成长。天阻,诛天!地拦,灭地!同为御灵师,携手掌天下未来路艰险,有我护你。_____
  • 创造之源

    创造之源

    这是一个一切都由“源素”组成的新世界。表现为火的称火源素表现为时间的称时间源素表现为语言的称语言源素表现为情绪的则称情绪源素总之源素是一切的基础和本质。而当人类感悟并凝练出“本源”的时候,便可以拥有感知和引导源素的能力,被称为源能力的觉醒。奇妙的能力,奇幻的经历,是毁灭还是创造,是谎言还是真理且看源能力者们如何呼风唤雨,创世成神......
  • 护你,以爱之名

    护你,以爱之名

    他们的相识从一场异地地震灾区的相遇开始。自那惊鸿一瞥,爱慕的花朵在她的心间悄然绽放。而她却不知,从捡起那个U盘的瞬间,两个人的命运就紧紧的联系在了一起。所有的危险开始无孔不入的渗入她的生活。她因他而开始变得不幸,危险接踵而至,唯一的亲人也惨遭歹人毒手。原以为生命中最后一束爱情的篝火能够照亮她的未来,却不曾想更大的磨难正在等待着她。面对那布满荆棘似乎总是斩不断的光明之路,面对黑暗势力的重重打击与摧残,他们的爱情能否固若金汤?
  • 隋唐五代风云人物大观

    隋唐五代风云人物大观

    本书分帝王后妃宫廷人物、文臣武将、起义领袖人物、文化科技思想人物和社会民间人物四类。