登陆注册
15685100000071

第71章 LAPSES AND ERRORS IN CRITICISM(2)

It is a pity, too, that Mr Hammerton has no records of some portions of the life at Davos Platz.Not only was Stevenson ill there in April 1892, but his wife collapsed, and the tender concern for her made havoc with some details of his literary work.It is good to know this.Such errata or omissions throw a finer light on his character than controlling perfection would do.Ah, I remember how my old friend W.B.Rands ("Matthew Browne" and "Henry Holbeach") was wont to declare that were men perfect they would be isolated, if not idiotic, that we are united to each other by our defects - that even physical beauty would be dead like later Greek statues, were these not departures from the perfect lines.The letter given by me at p.28 transfigures in its light, some of his work at that time.

And then what an opportunity, we deeply regret to say, Mr Hammerton wholly missed, when he passed over without due explanation or commentary that most significant pamphlet - the ADDRESS TO THE SCOTTISH CLERGY.If Mr Hammerton had but duly and closely studied that and its bearings and suggestions in many directions, then he would have written such a chapter for true enlightenment and for interest as exactly his book - attractive though it is in much -

yet specially lacks.It is to be hoped that Mr Sidney Colvin will not once more miss the chance which is thus still left open to him to perfect his LIFE OF STEVENSON, and make it more interpretive than anything yet published.If he does this, then, a dreadful LACUNA in the EDINBURGH EDITION will also be supplied.

Carefully reading over again Mr Arthur Symons' STUDIES IN TWO

LITERATURES - published some years ago - I have come across instances of apparent contradiction which, so far as I can see, he does not critically altogether reconcile, despite his ingenuity and great charm of style.One relates to Thoreau, who, while still "sturdy" as Emerson says, "and like an elm tree," as his sister Sophia says, showed exactly the same love of nature and power of interpreting her as he did after in his later comparatively short period of "invalidity," while Mr Symons says his view of Nature absolutely was that of the invalid, classing him unqualifiedly with Jefferies and Stevenson, as invalid.Thoreau's mark even in the short later period of "invalidity" was complete and robust independence and triumph over it - a thing which I have no doubt wholly captivated Stevenson, as scarce anything else would have done, as a victory in the exact ROLE he himself was most ambitious to fill.For did not he too wrestle well with the "wolverine" he carried on his back - in this like Addington Symonds and Alexander Pope? Surely I cannot be wrong here to reinforce my statement by a passage from a letter written by Sophia Thoreau to her good friend Daniel Ricketson, after her brother's death, the more that R.L.

Stevenson would have greatly exulted too in its cheery and invincible stoicism:

"Profound joy mingles with my grief.I feel as if something very beautiful had happened - not death; although Henry is with us no longer, yet the memory of his sweet and virtuous soul must ever cheer and comfort me.My heart is filled with praise to God for the gift of such a brother, and may I never distrust the love and wisdom of Him who made him and who has now called him to labour in more glorious fields than earth affords.You ask for some particulars relating to Henry's illness.I feel like saying that Henry was never affected, never reached by it.I never before saw such a manifestation of the power of spirit over matter.Very often I heard him tell his visitors that he enjoyed existence as well as ever.The thought of death, he said, did not trouble him.

His thoughts had entertained him all his life and did still....He considered occupation as necessary for the sick as for those in health, and accomplished a vast amount of labour in those last few months."

A rare "invalidity" this - a little confusing easy classifications.

I think Stevenson would have felt and said that brother and sister were well worthy of each other; and that the sister was almost as grand and cheery a stoic, with no literary profession of it, as was the brother.

The other thing relates to Stevenson's HUMAN SOUL.I find Mr Symons says, at p.243, that Stevenson "had something a trifle elfish and uncanny about him, as of a bewitched being who was not actually human - had not actually a human soul" - in which there may be a glimmer of truth viewed from his revelation of artistic curiosities in some aspects, but is hardly true of him otherwise;

and this Mr Symons himself seems to have felt, when, at p.246, he writes: "He is one of those writers who speak TO US ON EASY TERMS, with whom we MAY EXCHANGE AFFECTIONS." How "affections" could be exchanged on easy terms between the normal human being and an elfish creature actually WITHOUT A HUMAN SOUL (seeing that affections are, as Mr Matthew Arnold might have said, at least, three-fourths of soul) is more, I confess, than I can quite see at present; but in this rather MALADROIT contradiction Mr Symons does point at one phase of the problem of Stevenson - this, namely that to all the ordinary happy or pleasure-endings he opposes, as it were of set purpose, gloom, as though to certain things he was quite indifferent, and though, as we have seen, his actual life and practice were quite opposed to this.

I am sorry I CANNOT find the link in Mr Symons' essay, which would quite make these two statements consistently coincide critically.

As an enthusiastic, though I hope still a discriminating, Stevensonian, I do wish Mr Symons would help us to it somehow hereafter.It would be well worth his doing, in my opinion.

同类推荐
  • Phantastes

    Phantastes

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。
  • 洞渊集-长筌子

    洞渊集-长筌子

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。
  • 林泉高致

    林泉高致

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。
  • 下第述怀

    下第述怀

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。
  • 太上洞渊神咒经

    太上洞渊神咒经

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。
热门推荐
  • 带着追随神迹闯异界

    带着追随神迹闯异界

    这是九死一生后的清琅带着世界之心穿越后如何群殴各种不服的故事。光明主神:你怎么会有天使。暗黑主神:你怎么会有这么多龙巫妖。法师:哇!这就是传说中的炼金最高产品泰坦巨人吗。龙王:好多美女龙,叫单身龙赶紧去找龙美女去,快点。清琅:单挑谁不服看我雷鸣爆弹。哦!还不服竟然叫人那就看我末日审判。我晕人太多,打不过啊。赶紧召唤小弟,只见大片的身影出现了。
  • 史上第一宠:毒夫狂妻

    史上第一宠:毒夫狂妻

    她,慕容将军之孙女—慕容盈,传言花痴草包,恶毒跋扈,无人敢娶。她,现代军事国际佣兵女王,穿越成慕容盈。刚穿越,便因为前身爬床,被谪仙权相扔出了大门。还没消化穿越的事实,便被一纸诏书流放边境,路上更是被各种追杀。这穿越的日子没法过了,靠,非逼着姑奶奶反击,从此她杀伐斗强,样样在行,佛曰:只有想不到的,没有她不会的。他,江灵城江家少主,妖娆魅色,泣血倾城,却冷心冷情,一颦一笑勾人心魂,然为她一生无悔。她曾为他,抛却所有,争风吃醋,闹的将军府一门倾倒。旧爱追杀,生死不休。她从杀戮中崛起,入了江家江绯军,这一世的杀戮和决绝,惊天动地。当烟火灭时,人们才懂,那个让人心疼的女子最后为了江家少主,一世倾城。
  • 环球风情

    环球风情

    《巅峰阅读文库·我的第一本探索书
  • 都市异能在异界

    都市异能在异界

    带着异能来到异界。赌石?哥逢赌必赢。天才?貌似不够看啊!煅器师,很稀少?可哥背靠高科技新球,完全没问题啊!至于其他方面,这个怎么说呢……用小胖子的话来说就是:“老大,你这有点开挂啊!”叶宁瞥了他一眼:“你懂个毛,装逼要严肃,打脸要认真。”
  • 相思谋:妃常难娶

    相思谋:妃常难娶

    某日某王府张灯结彩,婚礼进行时,突然不知从哪冒出来一个小孩,对着新郎道:“爹爹,今天您的大婚之喜,娘亲让我来还一样东西。”说完提着手中的玉佩在新郎面前晃悠。此话一出,一府宾客哗然,然当大家看清这小孩与新郎如一个模子刻出来的面容时,顿时石化。此时某屋顶,一个绝色女子不耐烦的声音响起:“儿子,事情办完了我们走,别在那磨矶,耽误时间。”新郎一看屋顶上的女子,当下怒火攻心,扔下新娘就往女子所在的方向扑去,吼道:“女人,你给本王站住。”一场爱与被爱的追逐正式开始、、、、、、、
  • 神之界主

    神之界主

    太空飞船神秘消失,太空执勤的他被神秘力量牵引到在这个以灵气为武的世界,强者之路在何方,这个以灵气主要一共分初级,中级,高级,分别是,开界、灵界、地界、空界、天界……
  • 时隔经年说再见

    时隔经年说再见

    天真无知的好年华,谁还会去想那些以后。时过境迁之后再回首,余下的七分心酸三分无奈,更与何人说?
  • 火澜

    火澜

    当一个现代杀手之王穿越到这个世界。是隐匿,还是崛起。一场血雨腥风的传奇被她改写。一条无上的强者之路被她踏破。修斗气,炼元丹,收兽宠,化神器,大闹皇宫,炸毁学院,打死院长,秒杀狗男女,震惊大陆。无止尽的契约能力,上古神兽,千年魔兽,纷纷前来抱大腿,惊傻世人。她说:在我眼里没有好坏之分,只有强弱之分,只要你能打败我,这世间所有都是你的,打不败我,就从这世间永远消失。她狂,她傲,她的目标只有一个,就是凌驾这世间一切之上。三国皇帝,魔界妖王,冥界之主,仙界至尊。到底谁才是陪着她走到最后的那个?他说:上天入地,我会陪着你,你活着,有我,你死,也一定有我。本文一对一,男强女强,强强联手,不喜勿入。
  • 误惹腹黑99次:男神大人求放过

    误惹腹黑99次:男神大人求放过

    【本书全文免费!禁止转载抄袭!】第一次见面,她就吐了他一身,还各种花式‘撩汉’!第二次见面,她就泼了他一身的咖啡,附带一杯冰可乐,两人正式杠上;第三次见面,她毫不犹豫当着他的面为别的男生加油鼓掌,欢喜冤家序幕正式开始。“金小艾,你再也逃不出我的手掌心。”“叶洛泽,你这么腹黑霸道,你妈知道吗!”“金小艾,你的胸怎么这么小?”“有本事你来摸摸大啊!”“好啊。”某男腹黑一笑“那就来么么哒吧。”
  • 万如禅师语录

    万如禅师语录

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。