登陆注册
15486800000078

第78章 9

Zeno's reasoning, however, is fallacious, when he says that if everything when it occupies an equal space is at rest, and if that which is in locomotion is always occupying such a space at any moment, the flying arrow is therefore motionless. This is false, for time is not composed of indivisible moments any more than any other magnitude is composed of indivisibles.

Zeno's arguments about motion, which cause so much disquietude to those who try to solve the problems that they present, are four in number. The first asserts the non-existence of motion on the ground that that which is in locomotion must arrive at the half-way stage before it arrives at the goal. This we have discussed above.

The second is the so-called 'Achilles', and it amounts to this, that in a race the quickest runner can never overtake the slowest, since the pursuer must first reach the point whence the pursued started, so that the slower must always hold a lead. This argument is the same in principle as that which depends on bisection, though it differs from it in that the spaces with which we successively have to deal are not divided into halves. The result of the argument is that the slower is not overtaken: but it proceeds along the same lines as the bisection-argument (for in both a division of the space in a certain way leads to the result that the goal is not reached, though the 'Achilles' goes further in that it affirms that even the quickest runner in legendary tradition must fail in his pursuit of the slowest), so that the solution must be the same. And the axiom that that which holds a lead is never overtaken is false: it is not overtaken, it is true, while it holds a lead: but it is overtaken nevertheless if it is granted that it traverses the finite distance prescribed. These then are two of his arguments.

The third is that already given above, to the effect that the flying arrow is at rest, which result follows from the assumption that time is composed of moments: if this assumption is not granted, the conclusion will not follow.

The fourth argument is that concerning the two rows of bodies, each row being composed of an equal number of bodies of equal size, passing each other on a race-course as they proceed with equal velocity in opposite directions, the one row originally occupying the space between the goal and the middle point of the course and the other that between the middle point and the starting-post. This, he thinks, involves the conclusion that half a given time is equal to double that time. The fallacy of the reasoning lies in the assumption that a body occupies an equal time in passing with equal velocity a body that is in motion and a body of equal size that is at rest; which is false. For instance (so runs the argument), let A, A...be the stationary bodies of equal size, B, B...the bodies, equal in number and in size to A, A...,originally occupying the half of the course from the starting-post to the middle of the A's, and G, G...those originally occupying the other half from the goal to the middle of the A's, equal in number, size, and velocity to B, B....Then three consequences follow:

First, as the B's and the G's pass one another, the first B reaches the last G at the same moment as the first G reaches the last B. Secondly at this moment the first G has passed all the A's, whereas the first B has passed only half the A's, and has consequently occupied only half the time occupied by the first G, since each of the two occupies an equal time in passing each A. Thirdly, at the same moment all the B's have passed all the G's: for the first G and the first B will simultaneously reach the opposite ends of the course, since (so says Zeno) the time occupied by the first G in passing each of the B's is equal to that occupied by it in passing each of the A's, because an equal time is occupied by both the first B and the first G in passing all the A's. This is the argument, but it presupposed the aforesaid fallacious assumption.

Nor in reference to contradictory change shall we find anything unanswerable in the argument that if a thing is changing from not-white, say, to white, and is in neither condition, then it will be neither white nor not-white: for the fact that it is not wholly in either condition will not preclude us from calling it white or not-white. We call a thing white or not-white not necessarily because it is be one or the other, but cause most of its parts or the most essential parts of it are so: not being in a certain condition is different from not being wholly in that condition. So, too, in the case of being and not-being and all other conditions which stand in a contradictory relation: while the changing thing must of necessity be in one of the two opposites, it is never wholly in either.

Again, in the case of circles and spheres and everything whose motion is confined within the space that it occupies, it is not true to say the motion can be nothing but rest, on the ground that such things in motion, themselves and their parts, will occupy the same position for a period of time, and that therefore they will be at once at rest and in motion. For in the first place the parts do not occupy the same position for any period of time: and in the second place the whole also is always changing to a different position: for if we take the orbit as described from a point A on a circumference, it will not be the same as the orbit as described from B or G or any other point on the same circumference except in an accidental sense, the sense that is to say in which a musical man is the same as a man. Thus one orbit is always changing into another, and the thing will never be at rest. And it is the same with the sphere and everything else whose motion is confined within the space that it occupies.

同类推荐
  • 撼龙经

    撼龙经

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。
  • 全闽诗话

    全闽诗话

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。
  • 治世龟鉴

    治世龟鉴

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。
  • 哭麻处士

    哭麻处士

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。
  • 银色女经

    银色女经

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。
热门推荐
  • 绝色魔妃:魔尊轻点爱

    绝色魔妃:魔尊轻点爱

    她注定为天下苍生而死,却阴差阳错的爱上了他。他是魔界至尊,一统妖魔二界,却遇到了她。他无情无欲,她精灵古怪。他为她成魔,她为护他而死。“血债便要血偿,杀父之仇不共戴天。”“你想不到吧!我就是你要找的天女。”“若你可以爱我,我便可以放弃一切。我只要你!”“待到彼岸花开之时,便是你我重逢之日。”她嘴角含笑,看着他缓声说道。
  • 狱血之翼

    狱血之翼

    小飘新手上路,请大家多多照顾,万分感激。
  • 鬼推磨之寒谷象牙

    鬼推磨之寒谷象牙

    我是一个土夫子,一个盗墓的,但我也是一个做头的,如今的我一贫如洗,身上没有半分钱。为了我和我爱的人,我重操旧业。这天的我洗了个澡,洗了好久好久,洗去了我身上的伤痕,可胸口的那小小的一道伤口却怎么样愈合不了,我重新带上了降魔杵,下了长长的,深不见底的墓道。为爱盗墓。每天早上起来的我第一件事,把我床头的降魔杵取下来,放在北边的祖宗神位上上香,虔诚叩拜,说着来自天国的语言。我叫左斗星,左边北斗星星的意思,听起来很可笑,这是我很小很小的时候就一直在我耳边灌输的。
  • 神魔九玄天

    神魔九玄天

    他是伊斯塔拉帝国三大家族之一萧家的大少爷,人们口中的混世魔王,世人皆怕的修罗殿殿主之一的修,但这些都不是他真正的身份,他真正身份乃魔神之子,新任魔神!当家族惨遭迫害,他历经磨难,终于站在了九玄天之上,一家团聚。正如命运罗盘所显示:魔族重现,新神诞生,新帝降世,天地变色,神族陨落!(本文为已完结作品《玄天乾》正文)
  • 星暖人心,影帝老公碗里来

    星暖人心,影帝老公碗里来

    【我姓安却不能按住你的心】本文纯属宠文我从来都没有想过自己会走上这么一条不归路,原本可以一切从优,但我却要去一步步自己完成。我爱他同是也恨他,我们不能做普通人做的事,但我们也能做普通人不能做的事,我理解他,因为我爱他
  • 绝色偃师:腹黑王爷废柴妃

    绝色偃师:腹黑王爷废柴妃

    朱门酒肉臭,路有冻死骨。朱门酒肉臭,路有冻死骨。
  • TFboy请原谅我的爱

    TFboy请原谅我的爱

    .如果世界上曾经有那个人出现过,其他人都会变成将就!而我不愿意将就。
  • His Last Bow

    His Last Bow

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。
  • 薄荷色爱情

    薄荷色爱情

    韩静熙,王学敏,张静三人是闺蜜。可是当韩静煕和端木幽遇见的时候,她们发现,原来自己真的喜欢的人在这里。三人从甜蜜到了隔阂。让我们猜一猜谁和谁到底会在一起呢?薄荷绿的爱情,薄荷蓝的青春,薄荷色的我们,来继续着完美的爱情。
  • 无双歪传

    无双歪传

    曾经走过的青春,曾经经历的网游,现实与虚拟的交替,你我都曾有过类似的经历,向走过的青春以及那个纯真激情的年代致敬,更向无双的开发者致敬,因为无双真的让人们体验了另类的人生,游戏是虚拟的,而感情是真实的,青春是真实的。当然,还有经历过天下无双的你们,我的兄弟姐妹们。