登陆注册
15451600000016

第16章 15(1)

If one premiss is a simple proposition, the other a problematic, whenever the major premiss indicates possibility all the syllogisms will be perfect and establish possibility in the sense defined; but whenever the minor premiss indicates possibility all the syllogisms will be imperfect, and those which are negative will establish not possibility according to the definition, but that the major does not necessarily belong to any, or to all, of the minor. For if this is so, we say it is possible that it should belong to none or not to all. Let A be possible for all B, and let B belong to all C. Since C falls under B, and A is possible for all B, clearly it is possible for all C also. So a perfect syllogism results. Likewise if the premiss AB is negative, and the premiss BC is affirmative, the former stating possible, the latter simple attribution, a perfect syllogism results proving that A possibly belongs to no C.

It is clear that perfect syllogisms result if the minor premiss states simple belonging: but that syllogisms will result if the modality of the premisses is reversed, must be proved per impossibile.

At the same time it will be evident that they are imperfect: for the proof proceeds not from the premisses assumed. First we must state that if B's being follows necessarily from A's being, B's possibility will follow necessarily from A's possibility. Suppose, the terms being so related, that A is possible, and B is impossible. If then that which is possible, when it is possible for it to be, might happen, and if that which is impossible, when it is impossible, could not happen, and if at the same time A is possible and B impossible, it would be possible for A to happen without B, and if to happen, then to be. For that which has happened, when it has happened, is. But we must take the impossible and the possible not only in the sphere of becoming, but also in the spheres of truth and predicability, and the various other spheres in which we speak of the possible: for it will be alike in all. Further we must understand the statement that B's being depends on A's being, not as meaning that if some single thing A is, B will be: for nothing follows of necessity from the being of some one thing, but from two at least, i.e. when the premisses are related in the manner stated to be that of the syllogism. For if C is predicated of D, and D of F, then C is necessarily predicated of F. And if each is possible, the conclusion also is possible. If then, for example, one should indicate the premisses by A, and the conclusion by B, it would not only result that if A is necessary B is necessary, but also that if A is possible, B is possible.

Since this is proved it is evident that if a false and not impossible assumption is made, the consequence of the assumption will also be false and not impossible: e.g. if A is false, but not impossible, and if B is the consequence of A, B also will be false but not impossible. For since it has been proved that if B's being is the consequence of A's being, then B's possibility will follow from A's possibility (and A is assumed to be possible), consequently B will be possible: for if it were impossible, the same thing would at the same time be possible and impossible.

Since we have defined these points, let A belong to all B, and B be possible for all C: it is necessary then that should be a possible attribute for all C. Suppose that it is not possible, but assume that B belongs to all C: this is false but not impossible. If then A is not possible for C but B belongs to all C, then A is not possible for all B: for a syllogism is formed in the third degree. But it was assumed that A is a possible attribute for all B. It is necessary then that A is possible for all C. For though the assumption we made is false and not impossible, the conclusion is impossible.

It is possible also in the first figure to bring about the impossibility, by assuming that B belongs to C. For if B belongs to all C, and A is possible for all B, then A would be possible for all C. But the assumption was made that A is not possible for all C.

We must understand 'that which belongs to all' with no limitation in respect of time, e.g. to the present or to a particular period, but simply without qualification. For it is by the help of such premisses that we make syllogisms, since if the premiss is understood with reference to the present moment, there cannot be a syllogism. For nothing perhaps prevents 'man' belonging at a particular time to everything that is moving, i.e. if nothing else were moving: but 'moving' is possible for every horse; yet 'man' is possible for no horse. Further let the major term be 'animal', the middle 'moving', the the minor 'man'. The premisses then will be as before, but the conclusion necessary, not possible. For man is necessarily animal. It is clear then that the universal must be understood simply, without limitation in respect of time.

同类推荐
热门推荐
  • 后来我们都懂了爱

    后来我们都懂了爱

    后来才发现并不是所有的喜欢都会有结果…理智说我该放手感情劝我再等等…可你又怎会知道,我想要的不多…夏苡奚,余生有你,仅此而已…
  • 多情兵王无情伤

    多情兵王无情伤

    陆凡征服美女总裁,打造属于自己的商业帝国,与敌人斗智斗勇、爱恨情仇的交织中绝决的反击、、、
  • 福妻驾到

    福妻驾到

    现代饭店彪悍老板娘魂穿古代。不分是非的极品婆婆?三年未归生死不明的丈夫?心狠手辣的阴毒亲戚?贪婪而好色的地主老财?吃上顿没下顿的贫困宭境?不怕不怕,神仙相助,一技在手,天下我有!且看现代张悦娘,如何身带福气玩转古代,开面馆、收小弟、左纳财富,右傍美男,共绘幸福生活大好蓝图!!!!快本新书《天媒地聘》已经上架开始销售,只要3.99元即可将整本书抱回家,你还等什么哪,赶紧点击下面的直通车,享受乐乐精心为您准备的美食盛宴吧!)
  • 葬海念天

    葬海念天

    有这样一片海,无数纪年来,进入后无人可出。便以它为起点吧!
  • 风痕卡战记

    风痕卡战记

    风神大陆圣历300年空间位面:深渊,通往物质位面:风神大陆的通道被打开了,那些来自深渊的异界邪道众疯狂的开始屠杀者风神大陆上的子民,发泄着自己在黑暗的深渊的邪气。三分之二的风神大陆的一切有生命体已被邪道众屠杀光了,这些来自深渊的可怕种族,让人们深深地恐惧。爆发了,那些拥有圣洁的人们,带着愤怒的心情,激发了自己的潜能,终于创造出了,能是圣洁变为攻击能量的转换工具——圣纹主卡,这张主卡可以炼化出无数张能量卡,用于攻击那些邪道众。诞生了,能与恶魔作斗争的存在:驱魔师!远在现实世界的一位少年,在监狱里获得了一张圣纹主卡,穿越到了这个奇妙的大陆,三分之一的风神大陆:岚武大陆。他是怎样靠这张卡片造就辉煌的呢?驱魔师等级:F级-E级-D级-C级-B级-A级-S级降魔师等级:F级-E级-D级-C级-B级-A级-S级
  • 青春不败之血

    青春不败之血

    他曾经是华中国神秘903特种部队让人闻风丧胆,令人胆寒的魔鬼教官,就连曾经受训于他的超级特种兵们谈起他黄龙飞都会为之颤抖。就算是整个华中国最优秀的特种兵见到他,不得不为他黄龙飞折腰三尺,鞠躬一瘁。而他林磊,曾是全班受尽欺负的初二学生,本是两个命运无法交集的人,却又因为一次跳楼事件而紧紧牵连着彼此。“我想变强,变的很强,守护我想守护的人。”林磊言。自此龙城中学史上第一个特种兵学生林磊就此锻造了。
  • 甘肃少数民族风俗文化

    甘肃少数民族风俗文化

    甘肃地处黄土高原、蒙古高原和青藏高原的交接处,自古以来就是多民族杂居的地方,也是中华民族的发祥地之一。甘肃历史悠久,,地形复杂,民族文化丰富,风俗独特。
  • 祸国小毒妃

    祸国小毒妃

    一朝重生,身怀逆天医毒之术,沐染霜磨刀霍霍准备治渣男,虐白莲。可没想到,一不小心却在青楼睡了传闻中的邪王!“娘子,我已经是你的人了,你要对我负责!”某男将她压到墙角,一本正经的胡说八道。沐染霜满头黑线,“王爷,我们可连衣服都没脱。你这么不要脸,就不怕我弄死你!”某男勾唇邪魅一笑,迅速宽衣翻身上床躺好,“娘子,求弄!”
  • 宇辰传说

    宇辰传说

    莫名来到这个世界,凌宇辰举步维艰。层出不穷的敌人,玩不转的阴谋诡计,漫漫无尽的武道之路,这是强者的世界,想要活下去,就要变强、变强、变强!布阵、炼丹、制器、驯兽……斗气、玄气、玄元……荒兽、魔兽、圣兽、神兽……神之左手、神之右手、神之头脑、神之心脏……特尔霖夫、灭魄殒神珠、灭世剑灵……“你凭什么变强?”“就凭我是凌宇辰!”如果有一日,我真正站在了巅峰,届时,请记下我的名字——凌宇辰。这是属于我的传说!
  • 盗手

    盗手

    一朝穿越......人生就变得如无底洞一般,看不到也猜不到故事的结局。人生如戏,大概便是如此吧!