登陆注册
15448000000017

第17章 PART II(8)

But I cannot go entirely with him when he lays it down as an absolute and self-evident truth, that whatever is lawful when done by one person, ought not to be an offence when done by a combination of several. He forgets that the number of agents may materially alter the essential character of the act. Suppose, merely for the sake of illustration, that the state of opinion was such as to induce legislators to tolerate, within certain limits, the prosecution of quarrels and the redress of injuries by the party's own hands; as is the case practically, though not legally, in all countries where duelling prevails. If, under cover of this license, instead of a combat between one and one, a band of assailants were to set upon a single person, and take his life, or inflict on him bodily harm, would it be allowable to apply to this case the maxim, that what is permitted to one person ought to be permitted to any number? The cases are not parallel; but if there be so much as one case of this character, it is discussable, and requires to be discussed, whether any given case is such a one; and we have a fresh proof how little even the most plausible of these absolute maxims of right and wrong are to be depended on, and how unsafe it is to lose sight, even for a moment, of the paramount principle--the good of the human race. The maxims may, as the rough results of experience, be regarded as prima facie presumptions that what they inculcate will be found conducive to the ultimate end; but not as conclusive on that point without examination, still less as carrying an authority independent of, and superior to, the end.

My difference with Mr. Thornton is in this case only theoretical; for I do not know of anything that ought to be legally interdicted to workmen in combination, except what would be criminal if done by any of them individually, viz., physical violence or molestation, defamation of character, injury to property, or threats of any of these evils. We hear much invective against Trades' Unions on the score of being infringements of the liberty of those working men on whom a kind of social compulsion is exercised to induce them to join a Union, or to take part in a strike. I agree with Mr. Thornton in attaching no importance whatever to this charge. An infringement of people's liberty it undoubtedly is, when they are induced, by dread of other people's reproaches, to do anything which they are not legally bound to do; but I do not suppose it will be maintained that disapprobation never ought to be expressed except of things which are offences by law. As soon as it is acknowledged that there are lawful, and even useful, purposes to be fulfilled by Trades' Unions, it must be admitted that the members of Unions may reasonably feel a genuine moral disapprobation of those who profit by the higher wages or other advantages that the Unions procure for non-Unionists as well as for their own members, but refuse to take their share of the payments, and submit to the restrictions, by which those advantages are obtained. It is vain to say that if a strike is really for the good of the workmen, the whole body will join in it from a mere sense of the common interest. There is always a considerable number who will hope to share the benefit without submitting to the sacrifices; and to say that these are not to have c brought before them, in an impressive manner, what their fellow-workmen think of their conduct, is equivalent to saying that social pressure ought not to be put upon any one to consider the interests of others as well as his own. All that legislation is concerned with is, that the pressure shall stop at the expression of feeling, and the withholding of such good offices as may properly depend upon feeling, and shall not extend to an infringement, or a threat of infringement, of any of the rights which the law guarantees to all--security of person and property against violation, and of reputation against calumny. There are few cases in which the application of this distinction can give rise to any doubt. What is called picketing is just on the border which separates the two regions; but the sole difficulty' in that case is one of fact and evidence--to ascertain whether the language or gestures used implied a threat of any such treatment as, between individual and individual, would be contrary to law. Hooting, and offensive language, are points on which a question may be raised; but these should be dealt with according to the general law of the country. No good reason can be given for subjecting them to special restriction on account of the occasion which gives rise to them, or to any legal restraint at all beyond that which public decency, or the safety of the public peace, may prescribe as a matter of police regulation.

同类推荐
热门推荐
  • 灭天魂灵

    灭天魂灵

    死不是最可怕的,可怕的是你还活着。幽暗的小道,冰冷的锁链锵锵作响,和着沉重的喘息声,犹如那死神吟唱的一首葬曲。征途就从这里开始……
  • 最真的初中

    最真的初中

    初中最美三年,还没有毕业的我用最朴实的语言,讲述我最真的初中
  • 华盏

    华盏

    前世的一朵清莲,变成这一世人人厌恶的妖花。曾经名动天下的《春江花月》,在她手中变成惊艳世人的《姬舞》。她来自地狱,将噩梦赐予众生。当年落魄之时的那双红蓝异眸,也许是她心中唯一的光明。“你很厉害,玩弄权术,将这天下人都视作棋子,受你一人操控。”“我这一世爱过两个女人,一个是我的娘,另一个便是你。”“告诉我,你到底是陆华灯,还是叶夜心?”痴心视作散烟,这一次是流水有意,无情的,却是那翻飞的落花。
  • 天衍神决

    天衍神决

    林君,一个被心上人背叛了的青年,在临死之前穿越到了一个叫做苍穹大陆的地方,这里没有斗气,没有魔法,有的只是一种叫做元力的一种神奇的力量这种力量可以让一个平凡的人变成一个上天入海的大能强者。而林君会在这个异世界何去何从,是大放异彩还是华丽的陨落。在这个神奇的世界林君会有着怎样的奇遇,练武之路又会碰到怎样的奇人怪事。一部《天衍决》一颗神珠又会在这苍穹大陆发生怎样的故事...............
  • 重生之妙手狂医

    重生之妙手狂医

    几百年后医学疯子米子轩找到了所有致命疾病的治愈办法,闲极无聊下打算单挑秦始皇同志未能通关的副本——长生不老!但理想是丰满的,现实是骨感的,米子轩成功倒在了BOSS的脚下,把自己玩挂了。或许是如来佛祖,又或者是上帝他老人家不忍心让米子轩就这么挂掉,直接把他的灵魂送到了几百年前,也就是当代,附在一个同样叫做米子轩的卫校生身上。从高富帅沦落为现在的穷屌丝,米子轩同志表示很不爽,于是他励志要利用上一世的医疗技术先成为最牛的实习生,然后是本世纪最牛的、最吊的医生!
  • 白色园的那些事

    白色园的那些事

    一个人一生都梦想自己的另一半被自己深深的爱着,可当每次的灾难降临,在学校的那样的环境下,油然而生的初恋也不是那么完全的美好
  • 怨变

    怨变

    这是一部以都市为背景的玄幻小说。一本绝对歪歪的小说。阎胜一位普通的出租车司机,在一场意外中死亡了,已经死亡变成魂魄的他,有太多的不甘心,让他有了很强的怨念,就在他万念俱灰的时候,一道金黄色的光劈向了他,从而改变了他原有的一切。改变后的他,竟然拥有了十八岁的身体、小开的身份、特殊的力量,他究竟会如何演绎自己新的人生呢?本书已有一部分存稿,每天最少更新两章。
  • 幻界圣域

    幻界圣域

    2013年之后,人类的科技技术突然飞速的发展,各种各样的高科技产品如雨后春笋般飞快的发行于世间
  • 禁爱缠宠

    禁爱缠宠

    他们是亲兄弟,还是一对双胞胎。原本纯正的兄弟情不知道什么时候就变了味道...一个是气场超强的恶劣弟弟,一个是冷酷邪魅只会在弟弟面前展现柔情的温柔哥哥。当爱的火焰燃起,他们抛开世俗公然地在全世界面前玩起了暧昧...
  • 美人为皇

    美人为皇

    啦啦啦1望大家看看谢谢!!多赞!!!这篇小说是关于世家的言情故事。。。