登陆注册
15448000000010

第10章 PART II(1)

In a former article it has been seen how Mr. Thornton, in the first chapter of his First Book, disproved, on grounds of pure political economy, the supposed natural law by which, in the opinion of many, the price of labour is as strictly determined as the motion of the earth, and determined in a manner unalterable by the will or effort of either party to the transaction.

But whatever in the affairs of mankind is not peremptorily decided for them by natural laws, falls under the jurisdiction of the moral law. Since there is a certain range, wider than has been generally believed, within which the price of labour is decided by a conflict of wills between employers and labourers, it is necessary, as in every other case of human voluntary action, to ascertain the moral principles by which this conflict ought to be regulated. The terms of the bargain not being a matter of necessity, but, within certain limits, of choice, it has to be considered how far either side can rightfully press its claims, and take advantage of its opportunities. Or, to express the same ideas in other phraseology, it has to be decided whether there are any rights, of labour on the one hand, or of capital on the other, which would be violated if the opposite party pushed its pretensions to the extreme limits of economic possibility.

To this Mr. Thornton answers, -- None. As a matter of mere right, both the employer and the labourer, while they abstain from force or fraud, are entitled to all that they can get, and to nothing more than what they can get. The terms of their contract, provided it is voluntary on both sides, are the sole rule of justice between them. No one being under any obligation of justice to employ labour at all, still less is any one bound in justice to pay for it any given price.

Except under the terms of some mutual agreement, the employer is not bound to give anything. Before joining in the agreement he was under no obligation to furnish the labourer with occupation. Either he might not have required his or any one else's services, or he might have preferred to employ some one else. But if he was not bound to furnish employment at all, a fortiori he was not bound to furnish it on any particular terms. If, therefore, he did consent to furnish it, he had a right to dictate his own terms; and whatever else those terms might be, however harsh, illiberal, exorbitant, or what you will, they could not, at any rate or by any possibility, be unjust. For they could only be unjust in so far as they deviated from some particular terms which justice might have exacted. But, as we have seen, there were no such terms, and it is manifestly absurd to condemn a thing merely because its limits do not coincide with those of an abstraction incapable of being realised or defined, incapable, that is to say, of having any limits at all. (Thornton, p. 111.)

The counter-theory, on which the labourer's side of the question is usually argued, "that every man who has not by crime forfeited the right, and who has no other means of living, has a right to live by labour," Mr. Thornton entirely rejects.

Although [he says] these pages have little other object than that of determining how the labouring classes may most easily and effectually obtain fully as much as they ever dreamt of asking, the writer is constrained, even in the interest of those classes, to protest against the theory set up in their behalf. No cause can be permanently maintained that is suffered to rest on fallacies; and one pervading fallacy, beginning at the very first link, runs through the whole chain of reasoning of which the theory consists.

同类推荐
热门推荐
  • 微笑背后的离弃

    微笑背后的离弃

    这部小说很悲催,虽然她们是好姐妹,但是她们因为一些原因离弃了彼此但是她们最后和好了
  • 倾世之宠:容翎月

    倾世之宠:容翎月

    容翎月说:我活着,只是为了看着你好好活着。我生来便是无情之人,除了你。于是她被谋杀了。于是苦逼的高三狗葛汀穿越成了她。葛汀说:想追本姑奶奶?拿江山来换!
  • 都市狂龙

    都市狂龙

    原本以为自己想要靠着自己的异能改变自己的生活,却没有想到一次次的探险将自己卷入到一场场的战斗之中,逼迫着他不得不成为强者,从此便走上了霸主的道路。
  • 月临世纪录

    月临世纪录

    十二年空白的记忆,被告知是与曾被覆灭的国家有关。而这个国家的灭亡却无人知晓。日复一日的噩梦,一切血腥斑驳的回忆,打开真相的钥匙散落在了其他时空。而这三个少年,带着困扰数年的疑问,踏上了穿越位面的旅程。
  • 封印神戒

    封印神戒

    这是一本内容健康、思想向上、激励斗志、燃烧热情且充满正能量的猥琐、阴损、邪恶、搞笑的大后宫种马文。话说为什么这两种相反的调调会糅合在一起呢?因为,一个是梦想,一个是幻想。曾经纯真过的我梦想着一切美好的事情都会梦想成真,然而已经习惯幻想的我则会臆想着所有男人都会幻想的事情。一枚戒指,满足你的所有梦想和幻想。
  • 始系统

    始系统

    世界的起点是什么,宇宙的尽头又在哪里?神魔是否就是尽头?猪脚李明二十一世纪伪宅男一名,机缘巧合之下穿越到始之大陆东域第一帝国龙神帝国镇国公李世国的孙子……(还未出生的)随他而来的还有揭开宇宙最终秘密的神秘系统“始”……看猪脚如何一步一步揭开宇宙的秘密………
  • 二狗和三八

    二狗和三八

    慕容二狗和死三八之间不得不说的故事,故事只是想象中的武侠世界
  • 暮色寻你

    暮色寻你

    她是皇室中的精灵鬼才,为摆脱皇室命运一生曲折;他在她身边默默付出,却从未开口对她说喜欢她;他是她最讨厌的表哥,但他为了她的幸福愿意放弃她;她是他偶然碰到的,日日相处之下,他已习惯有她的生活......
  • 九世龙神

    九世龙神

    武侠的世界从没有少年轻狂,只有胜者为王。他如同一片汪洋,虽然身处低处却是百谷之王。世上从没有走不通的路,有的也只是不敢走的人!
  • 武炼凌霄

    武炼凌霄

    无尽大陆,强者为尊,万族林立!在这个天才多如狗,妖孽满地走的武道盛世,少年秦峰身怀荒古霸体,从卑微中崛起,一人一剑,杀尽世间敌,踏着天才妖孽的尸骨,登临至强巅峰。