登陆注册
15448000000010

第10章 PART II(1)

In a former article it has been seen how Mr. Thornton, in the first chapter of his First Book, disproved, on grounds of pure political economy, the supposed natural law by which, in the opinion of many, the price of labour is as strictly determined as the motion of the earth, and determined in a manner unalterable by the will or effort of either party to the transaction.

But whatever in the affairs of mankind is not peremptorily decided for them by natural laws, falls under the jurisdiction of the moral law. Since there is a certain range, wider than has been generally believed, within which the price of labour is decided by a conflict of wills between employers and labourers, it is necessary, as in every other case of human voluntary action, to ascertain the moral principles by which this conflict ought to be regulated. The terms of the bargain not being a matter of necessity, but, within certain limits, of choice, it has to be considered how far either side can rightfully press its claims, and take advantage of its opportunities. Or, to express the same ideas in other phraseology, it has to be decided whether there are any rights, of labour on the one hand, or of capital on the other, which would be violated if the opposite party pushed its pretensions to the extreme limits of economic possibility.

To this Mr. Thornton answers, -- None. As a matter of mere right, both the employer and the labourer, while they abstain from force or fraud, are entitled to all that they can get, and to nothing more than what they can get. The terms of their contract, provided it is voluntary on both sides, are the sole rule of justice between them. No one being under any obligation of justice to employ labour at all, still less is any one bound in justice to pay for it any given price.

Except under the terms of some mutual agreement, the employer is not bound to give anything. Before joining in the agreement he was under no obligation to furnish the labourer with occupation. Either he might not have required his or any one else's services, or he might have preferred to employ some one else. But if he was not bound to furnish employment at all, a fortiori he was not bound to furnish it on any particular terms. If, therefore, he did consent to furnish it, he had a right to dictate his own terms; and whatever else those terms might be, however harsh, illiberal, exorbitant, or what you will, they could not, at any rate or by any possibility, be unjust. For they could only be unjust in so far as they deviated from some particular terms which justice might have exacted. But, as we have seen, there were no such terms, and it is manifestly absurd to condemn a thing merely because its limits do not coincide with those of an abstraction incapable of being realised or defined, incapable, that is to say, of having any limits at all. (Thornton, p. 111.)

The counter-theory, on which the labourer's side of the question is usually argued, "that every man who has not by crime forfeited the right, and who has no other means of living, has a right to live by labour," Mr. Thornton entirely rejects.

Although [he says] these pages have little other object than that of determining how the labouring classes may most easily and effectually obtain fully as much as they ever dreamt of asking, the writer is constrained, even in the interest of those classes, to protest against the theory set up in their behalf. No cause can be permanently maintained that is suffered to rest on fallacies; and one pervading fallacy, beginning at the very first link, runs through the whole chain of reasoning of which the theory consists.

同类推荐
热门推荐
  • 重生极品——缘分解不开

    重生极品——缘分解不开

    她本来是一个新世纪每天奔波于职场风雨的大学生职员,一番奇遇穿越到一个平行架空世界后竟然身负命案,索性就一查到底,结果一个个杀人连环案被她跟她的忠实极品助手逐一击破。而她在收获极品爱情的同时也收获了许多的桃花艳遇,但最终都被极品助手成功挡在了墙外。这是一篇轻松的悬疑作品,个中精妙须待各位亲自体验!
  • 盗墓行迹

    盗墓行迹

    一个平凡的人,一个奇异的梦,因为一个意外,老舅把我卷入了一场盗墓的风云之中,五凶护墓并不是结局只是起点,我一直以为,在这个故事里我只是个配角,最后我才知道真正的主角现在才开始。。。作者有话说:这本书整体是按照第一人称的模式写的,我也算是一个盗墓的书迷,但这本书内容胆大、新颖,绝不逊色。里面一切有关历史、人文、地理、以及相关知识等等,均为个人幻想瞎编的,大家看完哈哈一乐就完了,不必深究。
  • 雷霆特战队

    雷霆特战队

    卧底暴露,雇佣兵设陷,雷霆特战队陷入敌人陷阱,狙击手猎鹰断后,最终陷入绝境……疯狂训练只为胜利曙光,雷霆霹雳斩断万千凌魔,超级狙击手绝地求生出生入死,为国效力,一切尽在雷霆特战队。
  • 无耻乞丐

    无耻乞丐

    失去一切的人,成为了一名乞丐。不怕流氓可怕,就怕流氓有文化。那么有文化的无耻乞丐,又会是怎样呢?世界那么大,我想去乱乱!
  • 用另一种身份去爱你

    用另一种身份去爱你

    她认识他十五年,亦喜欢了他十五年。十五年,她从不敢承认她喜欢他,她怕失去他。
  • 重生洪荒之至尊

    重生洪荒之至尊

    看主角如何在洪荒走出一片天地,且看主角日后的命运如何!
  • 福尔摩斯探案集4

    福尔摩斯探案集4

    《福尔摩斯探案全集》是英国作家阿瑟·柯南道尔创作的一部长篇侦探小说,主角名为夏洛克·福尔摩斯(Sherlock Holmes,又译作歇洛克·福尔摩斯),共有4部长篇及56个短篇。第一部长篇《血字的研究》完成于1889年,隔年与其它作品合集出版于《比顿圣诞年刊》。被多次改编为电影与电视剧。
  • 柔情战士之最强系统

    柔情战士之最强系统

    来到亮剑的世界手下的兵战斗力不行?中国可是很厉害的哦
  • 紫千影

    紫千影

    共工的怒气折断不周;汇聚的七星南北坤移;一个女孩在风中挺立;一段故事在向你絮语。
  • 夜迷宫:生民命卷

    夜迷宫:生民命卷

    马易是一家游戏公司的老板,从几个人的小工作室开始,不停地奋斗成为大娱乐集团的总裁,碰了多少壁,摔了多少跟头,吃了多少苦,绕过去多少坑……