登陆注册
15441000000027

第27章 XXVI

The question may be raised whether the Epic or Tragic mode of imitation is the higher. If the more refined art is the higher, and the more refined in every case is that which appeals to the better sort of audience, the art which imitates anything and everything is manifestly most unrefined. The audience is supposed to be too dull to comprehend unless something of their own is thrown by the performers, who therefore indulge in restless movements. Bad flute-players twist and twirl, if they have to represent 'the quoit-throw,' or hustle the coryphaeus when they perform the Scylla.

Tragedy, it is said, has this same defect. We may compare the opinion that the older actors entertained of their successors.

Mynniscus used to call Callippides 'ape' on account of the extravagance of his action, and the same view was held of Pindarus.

Tragic art, then, as a whole, stands to Epic in the same relation as the younger to the elder actors. So we are told that Epic poetry is addressed to a cultivated audience, who do not need gesture;

Tragedy, to an inferior public. Being then unrefined, it is evidently the lower of the two.

Now, in the first place, this censure attaches not to the poetic but to the histrionic art; for gesticulation may be equally overdone in epic recitation, as by Sosistratus, or in lyrical competition, as by Mnasitheus the Opuntian. Next, all action is not to be condemned- any more than all dancing- but only that of bad performers. Such was the fault found in Callippides, as also in others of our own day, who are censured for representing degraded women. Again, Tragedy like Epic poetry produces its effect even without action; it reveals its power by mere reading. If, then, in all other respects it is superior, this fault, we say, is not inherent in it.

And superior it is, because it has an the epic elements- it may even use the epic meter- with the music and spectacular effects as important accessories; and these produce the most vivid of pleasures. Further, it has vividness of impression in reading as well as in representation. Moreover, the art attains its end within narrower limits for the concentrated effect is more pleasurable than one which is spread over a long time and so diluted. What, for example, would be the effect of the Oedipus of Sophocles, if it were cast into a form as long as the Iliad? Once more, the Epic imitation has less unity; as is shown by this, that any Epic poem will furnish subjects for several tragedies. Thus if the story adopted by the poet has a strict unity, it must either be concisely told and appear truncated; or, if it conforms to the Epic canon of length, it must seem weak and watery. [Such length implies some loss of unity,] if, I mean, the poem is constructed out of several actions, like the Iliad and the Odyssey, which have many such parts, each with a certain magnitude of its own. Yet these poems are as perfect as possible in structure; each is, in the highest degree attainable, an imitation of a single action.

If, then, tragedy is superior to epic poetry in all these respects, and, moreover, fulfills its specific function better as an art- for each art ought to produce, not any chance pleasure, but the pleasure proper to it, as already stated- it plainly follows that tragedy is the higher art, as attaining its end more perfectly.

Thus much may suffice concerning Tragic and Epic poetry in general; their several kinds and parts, with the number of each and their differences; the causes that make a poem good or bad; the objections of the critics and the answers to these objections....

同类推荐
  • 古诗源

    古诗源

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。
  • All For Love

    All For Love

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。
  • 太清玉碑子

    太清玉碑子

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。
  • 千金裘

    千金裘

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。
  • HECUBA

    HECUBA

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。
热门推荐
  • 美人蒹葭

    美人蒹葭

    流年花香折枝雪,多少面靥笑无声?卿本佳人珠泪挂,终成葱茏忆无痕。“浔止,你给所有人都撒了一张网,却因她而失了天下。”“可我,不曾后悔”
  • 等待星花绽放

    等待星花绽放

    这本书是根据我个人的真实故事改编的。也许,你会从书中看到你自己的影子:也许,这本书能够治愈你的内心。我用最平实的文字写下我的故事。
  • 守护甜心之苦涩咖啡

    守护甜心之苦涩咖啡

    因为她的到来,那家咖啡店,成为了少女常光顾的地方。“咖啡虽苦,但仍比不上我心里的苦,但这份苦,我会双倍,十倍,百倍的奉还!”少女把手放在嘴边,做出了一个“嘘”的手势。【咳咳,这是依写的第二部守护文了】
  • 日月星辰决

    日月星辰决

    太阳真火,焚尽八荒!太阴之魂,魂镇九天!星辰圣体,辗压万域!看少年林纪,以无上神功为引,吞噬日月星辰,掌控逆天之力,惊世崛起,一步步问鼎武道之巅。
  • 替嫁成妃:太子,求放手

    替嫁成妃:太子,求放手

    因为本人自身原因,此书废坑,亲们就不要点击阅读了。
  • 笑看媚颜倾天下

    笑看媚颜倾天下

    前世七岁那年娘亲被害,连同一母同胞的龙凤妹弟一出世便夭折孤身一身虽被祖母庇护但仍被庶妹和姨娘陷害闺誉被侮清白被毁容貌尽无那些爱护自己的照看自己的无一幸免祖母…奶娘…贴身丫头…一一在自己面前死去而自己本因一身才气闺名远播相府嫡女最后沦落街头当看到已贵为太子妃的庶妹出现所有真相明了自裁溢血麒麟簪断用尽所有力气喊出那句,“苏云柔,若有来世,我定与你不死不休!”再度重生看她如何打压姨娘毁庶妹护得胞弟胞妹祖母奶娘丫头一生安好……苏媚颜重生再来创造出一番独属于自己的别样时代。
  • 易命成仙

    易命成仙

    你是百年不遇的人才?你是千年不遇的天才?你是万年不遇的鬼才?都是废物!!!玄天界,人才辈出,天才不知凡几,鬼才如过江之鲫。但是修行之路最重要的却不是这些,而是命格气运。大气运者,行事百无禁忌,如不死小强。任你是千年一遇,还是万年一遇的的天才鬼才也不及气运强盛之辈。是以,万千大道,皆是以气运为核心。陆明先天有大气运,却不想被人夺取,沦为家族笑柄。可是当他得到神物——《命书》之时,又将创造出怎样的精彩?
  • 佛说十支居士八城人经

    佛说十支居士八城人经

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。
  • 万魔天渡传

    万魔天渡传

    六道轮回,因果循环,我佛慈悲,普渡众生……万年前,宝光琉璃佛普度众生,世间进入最祥和的正法时代。但是世间任何事物都不曾能够得以永恒。佛纵使是法力无边,却也终有寂灭!还得从佛涅槃后开始说起。盛法不再,而众生却开始有了分别之心。因心性不同化为六道,其中天道(神)与阿修罗(魔)开启始了无休止的争斗。宝光琉璃佛坐下第一弟子护法天龙菩萨,慈悲为怀,散尽法身,化为九道龙气守护世间推迟末法黑暗时代万年。如今万年已至,末法黑暗时代开始,宝光琉璃佛与护法天龙菩萨尽不在世。又是一段乱世纷争,如今又有谁能给予众生新的希望?
  • 蠢萌小郡主晨曦传说

    蠢萌小郡主晨曦传说

    米虫唐糖玩穿越,简直亮辖她的钛合金狗眼:小乞丐秒变最受宠小郡主,还有桃花一朵朵,美得简直不要不要。瞧我一笑一动作,获得美男一枚枚。晓看她如何玩转十世,笑看人生。(注意:前方高能,高情商请勿入内。)