登陆注册
15424600000071

第71章 Chapter III(12)

But there is a tacit implication of his argument of no little importance.According to him,the English labourer had been demoralised,and the whole Irish peasantry brought to the edge of starvation,while the French and other peasantries were prosperous and improving.To what historical causes was this vast difference due?The French revolution,however important,can only be understood through its antecedents.Systems of land-tenure,it is obvious,have been connected in the most intricate way with all manner of social,industrial,and political phenomena.Commerce and manufactures may seem in some sense a kind of natural growth-a set of processes at which government can look on from outside,enforcing at most certain simple rules about voluntary contracts.But,in the case of land,we have at every point to consider the action and reaction of the whole social structure and of the institutions which represent all the conflicts and combinations of the great interests of the state.Consequently neither the results actually attained,nor those which we may hope to attain,can be adequately regarded from the purely industrial side alone.Systems have not flourished purely because of their economical merits,nor can they be altered without affecting extra-economical interests.To do nothing is to leave agricultural institutions to be perverted by political or 'sinister'interests.Mill was very little inclined to do nothing.He saw in the superiority of the foreign to the British systems a proof of the malign influence of the 'sinister interests'in our constitution.The landed aristocracy were the concrete embodiment of the evil principle.The nobility and the squirearchy represented the dead weight of dogged obstructiveness.They were responsible for the degradation of the labourer;and the Ricardian doctrine of rent explained why their interests should be opposed to those of all other classes.

Although Mill attributed enormous blessings to the revolution in France,he was far too wise to desire a violent revolution in England,and he was far too just to attribute to individual members of the class a deliberate intention to be unjust.Yet he was prepared to advocate very drastic remedies;and if there were any human being of moderate cultivation from whom he was divided by instinctive repulsion and total incapacity to adopt the same point of view,it was certainly the country squire.The natural antipathy was quaintly revealed when Mill found himself in the House of Commons opposed to thick rows of squires clamouring for protection against the cattle-plague.

So far Mill's position is an expansion or adaptation of Malthus.Obedience to Malthus makes the prosperous French peasant;disobedience,the pauperised English labourer.Malthus,as Mill interprets him,means that all social improvement depends upon a diminished rate of increase,relatively to subsistence;(64)and to diminish that rate the prudential check must be strengthened.'No remedies for low wages,'therefore,'have the smallest chance of being efficacious which do not operate on and through the minds and habits of the people';(65)and every scheme which has not for its foundation the diminution of the proportion of the people to the funds which support them,is 'for all permanent purposes a delusion.'(66)The two propositions taken together sum up Mill's doctrine.Social welfare can be brought about only by stimulating the vis medicatrix or sense of individual responsibility.Every reform which does not fulfil that condition is built upon sand.The application to England is a practical comment.The true remedies for low wages (67)are first an 'effective national education'so designed as to cultivate common-sense.This will affect the 'minds of the people'directly.Secondly,a 'great national measure of colonisation.'This will at once diminish numbers.

Thirdly,a national system for 'raising a class of peasant-proprietors.'This will provide a premium to prudence and economy affecting the whole labouring class.Besides this,Mill approves of the new poor-law,which has shown that people can be protected against the 'extreme of want'without the demoralising influence of the old system.(68)Mill here accepts,though he does not often insist upon,the doctrine upon which Thornton had dwelt in his Over Population:that poverty is self-propagating so far as it makes men reckless:education,as he remarks,is 'not compatible with extreme poverty'.(69)Hence the remedies themselves require another condition to make them effective.He declares emphatically that in these cases small means do not produce small effects,but no effect at all.(70)Nothing will be accomplished,unless comfort can be made habitual to a whole generation.The race must be lifted to a distinctly higher plane,or it will rapidly fall back.Mill,I fancy,would have been more consistent if he had admitted that great social changes must be gradual.But in any case,he was far from accepting the do-nothing principle.Political economy,he says,would have 'a melancholy and a thankless task'if it could only prove that nothing could be done.(71)He holds that a huge dead lift is required to raise the labourers out of the slough of despond,and he demands therefore nothing less than great national schemes of education,of home and foreign colonisation.He speaks,too,with apparent approval of laws in restraint of improvident marriages.(72)It is,indeed,true that upon his schemes government is to interfere in order to make the people independent of further interference.Whether such a compromise be possible is another question.

V.CAPITALISTS AND LABOURERS

同类推荐
  • 七修续稿

    七修续稿

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。
  • 华夷译语

    华夷译语

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。
  • 续高僧传

    续高僧传

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。
  • 前闻记

    前闻记

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。
  • 李清照

    李清照

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。
热门推荐
  • 夙落浮尘

    夙落浮尘

    她,异紫出生,身份显赫,心肠善良,却遭遇了人生不可多得的变故。师门被屠,兄长欺骗,不知父母,被视妖女……本她还有一丝信念,却未曾料想,就连最爱的他,也如此认为。以至于,她化身为邪,屠杀所谓的良善,就连有了孩子,也不告诉他一声……他,身份尊贵,冰冰冷冷,从不视谁为己,却总能让那个女孩,进入自己的眼里。本以为可以与天命拼的一搏,却终是被无情打败。化身为正,逼她为邪,让她对他亦爱亦恨。他与她的爱情,在这五界纷争中,亦清亦浊,亦真亦幻……最终,他们,是否能够执子之手,一起打破命运,携手白头呢?
  • 复仇兄妹

    复仇兄妹

    本人第一次写,这是一篇复仇小说,《复仇兄妹》希望大家喜欢第一章(回忆)安琪的父亲原本是欧阳集团的经理,但因为内心的贪婪,想接手欧阳集团(全球排名第八),一而再再而三的害欧阳集团。有一天,"欧阳璟因非法收购…,这是拘捕令…""不会的,璟不会做出这种事的…""因查明这别墅也是公司的,所以你们收拾一下搬出去,值钱的物品不能拿,会有人跟着你们"妈妈因为受不了这么大的打击,心脏病复发…爸爸被带走了,妈妈也走了。整个世界就只剩下了那两兄妹,手牵着手在大街上走着。安琪带着十几个混混走过来:"这不是我们的欧阳大少爷和大小姐吗?如今你们也有今天啊…
  • 情俊不禁

    情俊不禁

    青春就像一条林荫小道,许多人在你身边匆匆而过,成为了彼此的过客;也有许多人陪在你身边,成为了彼此记忆中的一道风景,,,
  • 宠妻无度爱妃你好叼

    宠妻无度爱妃你好叼

    慕寒儿,罗刹国排名第一位被悬赏一个亿而被追杀的顶级杀手,所有来杀她的人向来有去无回,只不过最后死在了那个口口声声说爱她的那个男人手里,谁知一觉醒来,正在和一个妖孽美男再洗鸳鸯浴,而且这只妖孽还笑她是三无女,士可杀,不可辱,勾起唇角,手指轻挑起美男的下巴,俯在耳边“男人,你家老二长的真挫”
  • 幻终如初

    幻终如初

    八荒六合,神寂千年,信仰的英雄已成传说,现世的大陆又何去何从,血族,幻族,白族,人族,隐族。纠缠了千年的因果。现在一一呈现......
  • 二二三语录

    二二三语录

    不过就是一间大学宿舍里的生活琐事。
  • 婚前婚后365

    婚前婚后365

    现代科学表明,为了避免婚后的不必要的痛苦,恋人们在托付终生之前,务必认真对待婚前检查。通过婚前检查,可以发现一些异常情况和疾病,尤其是影响结婚和生育的疾病,如严重遗传病、指定传染病、有关精神病和其他一些影响结婚和生育的重要脏器疾病以及生殖器官异常。通过婚前医学检查时医务人员提供的咨询及医学指导意见,能做出对男女双方和下一代健康有利的决定和安排。
  • 凤凰羽化

    凤凰羽化

    一夜知秋,形神俱灭。凤凰涅盘,烈火重生。
  • 阳光下的影子

    阳光下的影子

    拥有阴阳眼的简夜夜遇到了一个男鬼,男鬼叫梁溪,梁溪爱上了简夜的朋友..之后会怎么样呢?你猜呀?
  • 化凡成帝

    化凡成帝

    少年长渊师出青云,步步走向武道巅峰,一路追寻自己的身世,却卷入一场万族的争斗,武道之巅是寂寞,称帝之路步步骸骨,回首间,往事如梦,梦醒之时,物是人非。