登陆注册
15424600000062

第62章 Chapter III(3)

To appreciate Mill's position,it is necessary briefly to notice the prejudices which he had to encounter and the sympathies upon which he could reckon.Political economy had been exultant in the days of James Mill.He and his allies were entering the promised land.They took the science to be in the same stage as astronomy just after the publication of Newton's Principia.The main truths were established,though prejudice and sentiment still blinded the outside world to the clearest demonstration.A narrow and unpopular circle naturally retorts dislike by fanaticism.The Utilitarians were,and knew themselves to be,bitterly hated;though they took the hatred to be an unconscious tribute to their real authority --the homage of the stupid to irresistible logic.Richard Jones in the preface to his Treatise on Rent (1831),says,that the Ricardians had not only put forward 'startling and in some instances,unhappily,disgusting and most mischievous paradoxes,'but that they had thus alienated mankind and caused a distrust of political economy.When J.S.Mill's treatise appeared,this position was modified.The 'philosophical Radicals'had declined as a party;but the assault upon protectionism in which they had acted as forlorn hope had conquered a much wider circle.Their ideas had spread,whether by stress of argument or congeniality to the aspirations of the newly enfranchised classes.The conspicuous instance,of course,is the free trade movement.The triumph over the corn-laws seemed to establish the truth of the economic theory.Doctrines preached by professors and theorists had been accepted and applied by politicians on a grand scale.The result,as Cairnes,one of Mill's chief followers observes,was not altogether an advantage to the science.(5)The popular mind identified political economy with free trade,and thought that all difficulties could be solved by a free use of the sacred words 'supply and demand.'The strict economic doctrine had been,as Cairnes held,adulterated in order to suit the tastes of the exoteric audience.This remark suggests the problem,not strictly soluble,as to the causes of the free trade victory.Did it mark a triumph of logic,or was it due to the simple fact that the class which wanted cheap bread was politically stronger than the class which wanted dear bread?Cobden admitted fully that the free trade propaganda was a 'middle-class agitation.'(6)The genuine zealots were the manufacturers and merchants;and it was so far a trial of strength between the leaders of industry and the owners of the soil --a class struggle not between rich and poor,but between the 'plutocracy'and the 'aristocracy.'Cobden was proud of the order to which he belonged,and held that the aristocracy represented blind prejudice.Some verses often quoted by popular orators declared that the landowners'motto was 'down with everything'(including health,wealth,and religion)'and up with rent';and Bright in 1842told the workmen that 'the greatest enemy of the remorseless aristocracy of Britain must almost of necessity be their firmest friend.'(7)As usual in such cases,a legend arose which regarded the victory as due exclusively to the force of truth.Beyond all doubt,argument played its part as well as class prejudice.Cobden,though little interested in abstract theories,was an admirable,cogent,and clear reasoner.He was fully competent to assimilate so much political economy as was required for his purpose,and used it most effectively.Later history,however,has shown that in such matters pure reason cannot by itself win the battle against interested prejudice.For the time,the victory,taken by the winners to be a victory of reason,reflected glory upon the economists who from the days of Adam Smith had been labouring to indoctrinate the public mind.The triumph of the agitation was thus due to sheer force of argument and the Consequent recognition of the principles of justice to the poor and goodwill to all mankind.Science and philanthropy had joined hands.The enthusiasm which soon afterwards greeted the Exhibition of 1851showed the widespread conviction that the millennium of peace and liberty,of which the Wealth of Nations marked the dawn,was at last appearing in full daylight.And Mill was regarded as the authorised representative in philosophy of the principles now at last fully applied to practice.

Mill himself did not fully shire the optimistic exultation which helped to strengthen his authority;nor was it accepted by the class most immediately affected.The 'big loaf'was a cry,it might be thought,which should appeal most strongly to the hungriest.Yet the Chartists,whose agitation was beginning when the Anti-Corn Law League was founded,were lukewarm or positively hostile.They interrupted free trade meetings and looked askance at the agitation.(8)The Chartists thought that the middle class,having got into power by their help,were throwing them over and monopolising all the fruits of victory.Their ablest leaders admitted,indeed,that free trade would be desirable,but desirable only on condition that the charter should first be conceded and democracy invested with political power to guard against misappropriation of the economic advantages.The employers,as they suspected,wanted cheap bread,because,as Lord Shaftesbury once put it,'cheap bread means low wages.'(9)The free-traders,indeed,had constantly to meet this argument.

Cobden constantly and earnestly denied the imputation.He desired free trade,as he asserted with unmistakable sincerity,above all in justice to workmen,and ridiculed the notion that wages sank with the price of corn.(10)Cobden,however,appeals rather to obvious facts than to economic theorems;and Chartists who read Ricardo and M'Culloch might find some excuse for their opinion.

同类推荐
热门推荐
  • 十三与黄昏

    十三与黄昏

    十三,一个无论在西方还是东方,都是一个不吉利的数字,而我们就是十三,十三十三班,此生我们平凡,但我们的前世路人皆知,东方的二郎神,孙悟空,龙,嫦娥,西方的美杜莎,吸血鬼,撒旦。而我们今生的任务就是——完成[诸神的黄昏]——弑神
  • 重生之影后再临

    重生之影后再临

    上辈子,顾湘为了一个男人,青春不要了,美貌不要了,骄傲不要了,就连影后的地位也不要了。结果,被人黑,被人黑,被人黑,沦为下堂妇,退出娱乐圈。重生回十年前,青春还在,美貌还在,骄傲还在……我们的目标是:玩转娱乐圈!
  • 鬼门关

    鬼门关

    树林下神秘的地宫,街边的红衣女人,传说中的守尸人,死而复生的好友,一只会说话的老猫……接踵而至的恐怖让我处在崩溃的边缘;然而直到看见另一个“我”从棺材里爬出来之后,我才知道这一切只是刚刚开始……
  • 逆袭女配之我本神帝

    逆袭女配之我本神帝

    堂堂一代神帝竟然带有天生疾病,十六岁时便会如中媚药,必须与两男子交欢,还是已定好的男子?那我去寻解药总可以了吧?可以,但是提前交欢了。还导致解药,那朵“神倾花”并蒂之一成魔了,我造的什么孽?解药的方法真离奇,让那货成魔也就罢了,为什么还要返回神道?请给我历史借鉴一下,怎么返?我宁愿做一个暴君。还有众多逆袭系统中的美男,为什么都那么深情?招架不住就接招吧。创造系统那神医和那系统入囊中。美男后宫是我创,美男豆腐是我吃。
  • 凌夏府主

    凌夏府主

    当异世少年,遇上玄幻修真,当男主遇到奇葩师傅,这两者之间会擦出怎样的火花。
  • 重生豪门:总裁的双面宠妻

    重生豪门:总裁的双面宠妻

    【推姐妹篇《名门私宠:总裁,请节制》】她是世界顶尖的骇客Zrine,重生成为豪门贵族的私生女。他是纵横黑白两道,叱咤风云的人物,段氏的总裁。当冷静睿智的她遇上冷酷邪肆的他,将会上演如何的好戏?
  • 锦绣刀

    锦绣刀

    小时候,很小的时候。父亲给了他一把剑,长、锋、透着寒。剑身上有两个字,他摸着这两个字。锦绣。(看过五章,即可评论。差评好评,概不删除。)
  • 橡皮:中国先锋文学

    橡皮:中国先锋文学

    13个先锋小说家、43个先锋诗人、11个先锋评论家——共278篇各种题材的先锋作品凝结成这吓人的《橡皮(中国先锋文学)》读本。这是中国当前最有写作才华的作者队伍,每一个人都那样特立独行、不拘常规、又敏锐多情。翻开杨黎主编的《橡皮(中国先锋文学)》,您将由他们带领,走进中国先锋文学大本营,领略目前中国文学最前沿的动态,关于当下中国先锋文学 ,无论是题材、文本结构,还是语言才华和思想张力,您都将有一个全新的认识,获得一次丰富的精神滋养。
  • 浚恒

    浚恒

    《周易·恒卦第三十二》曰:初六,浚恒,贞凶,无攸利。浚恒,变换不定之意也,亦有求之太过之意。。然而浚,亦有疏通、深邃之意。如何建立一个强大的国家?如何构筑起伟大的文明?如何成为一个绝世的强者?为天地立心,为民生立命,为往圣继绝学,为万世开太平!世界上没有任何事物是绝对的,包括这句话它本身。——政治家、军事家、魔法师楼榕剑
  • 世纪魔战

    世纪魔战

    重生七年,宅男宿命。坚毅无双,魔王争霸风云起。决战东京,傲然华夏,荣登世界之巅。拓魔纹,召魔物,杀戮十方魔王路。