登陆注册
15424600000056

第56章 Chapter II(27)

Admitting a deductive method to be necessary,Mill distinguishes the 'direct'and the 'inverse methods.'(118)The direct method is that of reasoning from one 'law of human nature,'considering,of course,the outward circumstances.This justifies the system of political economy,which considers men as acting solely from the desire of wealth.He points out that fallacies may here arise from applying to one state of society what is true of another;but he also holds that one who knows the political economy of England,or even of Yorkshire,knows that of all nations,if he have good sense enough to modify his conclusions.(119)Mill admits fully that this method can only give us 'tendencies'--results which are true if certain conditions,never fully assignable,are actually secured;and that it therefore requires to be constantly checked by verification,that is,by showing that the results are confirmed by direct observation.The admission,however,that such a method is in any case admissible separates him from Comte,who held that we must in all cases start from historical generalisations,not from independent 'laws of human nature.'(120)Comte,in fact,rejected Mill's psychology and political economy as pseudo-sciences,and the difference is really vital.Mill,however,was prepared to accept much of Comte's teaching,and in particular allows the legitimacy of the 'historical method.'Upon this he writes a chapter,(121)which shows no want of appreciation of Comte or of the great French writers by whom,as his Dissertations show,he had been deeply impressed.(122)He complains of the English want of interest in such matters.They know nothing in French literature except the novels of Balzac and Euge Sue,and are not aware that the French historians greatly surpass even the Germans.(123)He points out the importance of the conception of progress and of the great modifications of human character.Still,he charges the French with a misconception.History can never give us a 'law of nature,'only 'empirical laws,'which are not scientific till duly based upon psychology and 'ethology.'Comte alone has seen the necessity of a deeper foundation;and he proceeds to give an admiring account of some of Comte's conclusions.Especially he insists upon the necessity of connecting the social phenomena with the intellectual development of mankind.This Comte alone has attempted systematically,and he ends by emphatically adhering to the doctrine of the three stages --theological,metaphysical,and positive.The essential difference,however,remains.Comte held that we must not explain humanity by man,but man by humanity.(124)To Mill,of course,this savoured of mysticism.

In any case,it marks the divergence of the two:Mill is a thorough individualist.He thinks it absolutely necessary to base sociology upon 'ethology,'that is,a theory of the individual character,and this again must be based upon psychology.

Sympathising with Comte's general purpose,and warmly admiring some of his results,Mill adheres to a doctrine which was sure to bring him into conflict with his master.To create the moral sciences,we must start from a scientific psychology.This means that we must work on the lines of Hartley,James Mill,and his own younger contemporaries,Professor Bain and Mr Herbert Spencer.The corollary from psychology is ethology,or the science of character.This view does not conflict with the admission of the great importance of some historical method.At present,it needs only to be said that Mill accepts that method very cordially,subject to two conditions.First,he holds that some social sciences --political economy being,in fact,the only one to be clearly specified --can be deduced from ethology and psychology independently of history,though requiring verification from history.Secondly,he holds that the historical method cannot reveal true 'laws of nature'unless it is properly connected with psychological data.How far Mill really appreciated the significance of the historical method,or perceived its true relation to other departments of thought,must be left for consideration.

NOTES:

1.Autobiography,p.226.

2.Logic,p.389(bk.iii.ch.xxi,section 1).I quote from the popular edition of 1898.Book,chapter and section are generally applicable to former edition.

3.See letter in note to chapter upon Mill in Taine's History of English Literature.

4.James Mill's Analysis,i.352n.

5.See an interesting article in G.Croom Robertson's Philosophical Remains (1894),pp.28-45.

6.Logic,Introduction,section 5.

7.Ibid.p.29(bk i,ch.iii,section 1).

8.Ibid.p.8section 7.

9.See John Grote's Exploratio Philosophica (1865),p.209n.

This book is,I think,by far the most interesting comtemporary discussion of Mill,Hamilton,and Whewell.It was,unfortunately,desultory and unfinished,but it is full of acute criticism,and charmingly candid and modest.Mill's Logic is especially discussed in chapters viii and ix.Grote holds,and I think truly,that Mill's attempt to divide metaphysics from logic leads to real confusion,and especially to an untenable mode of conceiving the relation between 'things'and thoughts.I cannot discuss Grote's views;but the book is full of interesting suggestions though the result are rather vague.See the excellent account of Grote by the late Croom Robertson in the History of National Biography.

10.Mill,in his review of Whately,refers to Du Trieu (whose treatise had been privately printed by him and his friends),Crakenthorpe and Burgersdyk;and in the Examination of Hamilton's Philosophy (ch.xxii)quotes also Sanderson,Wallis,Aldrich,Keckermann,Bartholinus,and Du Hamel as the 'authorities nearest at hand'.There is nothing,as I am told by the learned,exceptionally interesting in Du Trieu;and the selection was probably accidental.

11.Logic,p.13(bk.i,ch.ii,section 1).

同类推荐
  • 佛说戒德香经

    佛说戒德香经

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。
  • 金箓大斋宿启仪

    金箓大斋宿启仪

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。
  • 紫团丹经

    紫团丹经

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。
  • 西游记补

    西游记补

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。
  • 金光明经玄义

    金光明经玄义

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。
热门推荐
  • 人道大宗主

    人道大宗主

    元甲偶然间获得神农架新出土的古物——定界盘,拥有了可以在高武世界九洲大陆与地球两界来回穿梭的能力,并机缘巧合之下成为一宗之主。身为一宗之主,元甲能否让宗门领袖群伦、称霸武林?然而,当所有人都可以自由穿梭于诸天世界的大时代来临,元甲的优势霎时间荡然无存。这注定是一场血雨腥风的争霸之路!这注定是修行者波澜壮阔的鼎盛时代!感谢阅文书评团提供书评支持!
  • 逗比丫头:约吗

    逗比丫头:约吗

    让你偷本小姐,啊呸,太没风度,重来------让你偷老娘我的棒棒糖,揍屎你!“小偷哥哥顿时欲哭无泪,:"小姐!”“嗯哼?”“啊呸,是我滴乖乖啊亲娘,你那是揍吗?简直是断我子绝我孙好吗?”
  • 大宋僧史略

    大宋僧史略

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。
  • 新末世

    新末世

    曾经的文明时期,如今的黑暗时代。无法打破的一切,无法更改的历史。只有面对,才有一线生机,却并未有多少人敢。……唯一重生的叶天,再次行走末世之路。感受非凡力量,踏上王者巅峰!世间万物,归谁所有?是九重帝尊,还是另有其人……群:312382151
  • 人生代代凤不归

    人生代代凤不归

    云凤兮,上古灵石幻化而成,后因遇仙人伏暮柯收其为徒,赐名云凤兮。多年随师父驱除妖魔终晋神位,封神女侍。后因与师父萌生爱意,玉帝知晓大怒,随女娲用计将云凤兮化为妖魔,玉帝杀之。随后如来将云凤兮的三魂七魄聚集起来使她重生为人。伏暮柯及众位神友自愿下界皆为人身。如来给云凤兮安排了十世情缘,下界以后能遇到谁,不能遇到谁,能跟谁在一起,不能跟谁在一起,十世后,还能不能回到天界,全看她自己的造化……
  • 邪魅妖王乖宝宝

    邪魅妖王乖宝宝

    明明是万妖之尊,一场劫难差点让他神形具灭。明明是男儿之身,一夜断袖旖旎竟然让他怀上了某人的宝宝!怀着身孕的他带着怀里的宝宝逃离妖界六年后,他带着一个白嫩嫩的小娃娃重回妖界“媳妇儿你终于回来啦!啊,儿砸,过来让爹爹抱抱!”“爹,这个傻子是谁?”“他是你娘!”“娘!”
  • 守护甜心之复仇的胚胎

    守护甜心之复仇的胚胎

    因为她,我们被赶了出来,竟然发现我的心灵之蛋是胚胎。我是选择复仇还是让自己忍辱负重,享受自己的青春年华。还是选择复仇,让他们明白是她自己一个人造成的。伟大的胚胎,倾听我的召唤,开放吧,红色蔷薇。
  • 重生之医路荣华

    重生之医路荣华

    重来一次,苏林表示,她如今真不是小绵羊了。敢来觊觎她家传医学,毁她安稳人生,就要做好付出代价的准备。此生,她要守护家人。她要凭借一身的医术,走出荣华之路!
  • 心忆绵绵

    心忆绵绵

    女主爱唱,爱吃,但天赋异禀多彩性格,冷漠无情.调皮可爱.心地善良.在歌唱中进阶吧!即使穿越,也能一展风采!
  • 我的英雄都挺萌

    我的英雄都挺萌

    您好,天气转冷衣服晾不干请按一号键,安妮帮您解决烦恼;家里食物太多吃不完请按二号键,酒桶帮您解决烦恼;情人被拐钱财被偷请按三号键,皮城姐妹花帮您解决烦恼;家里逼婚需假扮男友请按四号键,EZ帮您解决烦恼;父母唠叨得太凶请按五号键,死歌帮您解决烦恼;……积压货物大甩卖请直接联系德玛西亚喊货团,团员包括几十年如一日大嗓门的德玛西亚皇子,以及出了草丛就打转开了大招就瞎喊的德玛西亚第一帅哥盖伦!