登陆注册
15424600000030

第30章 Chapter II(1)

Mill's Logic

I.Intuitionism and Empiricism

Mill's System of Logic may be regarded as the most important manifesto of Utilitarian philosophy.It lays down explicitly and in their ripest form the principles implicitly assumed by Bentham and the elder Mill.It modifies as well as expounds.It represents the process by which J.S.Mill,on becoming aware of certain defects in the Utilitarians'philosophy,endeavoured to restate the first principles so as to avoid the erroneous conclusions.The coincidence with his predecessors remains far closer than the divergence.The fundamental tenets are developed rather than withdrawn.The Logic thus most distinctly raises the ultimate issues.It has the impressiveness which belongs in some degree to every genuine exertion of a powerful mind.Mill is struggling with real difficulties;not trying to bolster up a theory commended to him by extraneous considerations.He is doing his best to give an answer to his problem;not to hide an evasion.His honourable candour incidentally reveals the weakness as frankly as the strength of his position.He neither shirks nor hides difficulties,and if we are forced to admit that some of his reasoning is fallacious,the admission scarcely adds to the statement that he is writing a treatise upon philosophical problems.His frankness has made the task of critics comparatively easy.It takes so many volumes to settle what some philosophers have meant that we scarcely reach the question whether their meaning,or rather any of their many possible meanings,was right.In the case of Mill,that preparatory labour is not required.His book,too,has been sufficiently tested by time to enable us to mark the points at which his structure has failed to stand the wear and tear of general discussion.I must try to bring out the vital points of the doctrine.

Mill,I have said,had a very definite purpose beyond the purely philosophical.'Bad institutions,'he says,(1)are supported by false philosophy.The false philosophy to which he refers is that of the so-called 'intuitionist school.'Its 'stronghold,'he thought,lay in appeals to the mathematical and physical sciences.To drive it from this position was to deprive it of 'speculative support';and,though it could still appeal to prejudice,the destruction of this support was an indispenSable step to complete victory.Mill wished to provide a logical armoury for all assailants of established dogmatism,and his success as a propagandist surprised him.The book was read,to his astonishment,even in the universities.Indeed,I can testify from personal observation that it became a kind of sacred book for students who claimed to be genuine Liberals.It gave the philosophical creed of an important section of the rising generation,partly biassed,it may be,by the application to 'bad institutions.'Mill's logic,that is,fell in with the one main current of political opinion.His readings in logic with Grote and other friends enabled him to fashion the weapons needed for the assault.Thus in its origin and by its execution the task was in fact an attempt to give an organised statement of sound philosophy in a form applicable to social and political speculations.

Mill considered that the school of metaphysicians which he attacked had long predominated in this country.(2)When Taine called his view specially English,Mill protested.The Scottish reaction against Hume,he said,which 'assumed long ago the German form,'had ended by 'prevailing universally'in this country.When he first wrote he was almost alone in his opinions,and there were still 'twenty a priori and spiritualist philosophers for every partisan of the doctrine of Experience.'(3)The philosophical world,he says elsewhere,(4)is 'bisected'by the line between the 'Intuitional'and the 'Experiential'schools.Mill's conviction that a majority of Englishmen were really 'intuitionists'in any shape is significant,I think,of his isolated position.Undoubtedly most Englishmen disliked Utilitarians,and respectable professors of philosophy were anxious to disavow sympathy with covert atheism.

Yet the general tendency of thought was,I suspect,far more congenial to Mill's doctrine than he admitted.Englishmen were practically,if not avowedly,predisposed to empiricism.In any case,he was carrying on the tradition which Taine rightly,as Ishould say,regarded as specifically English.Its adherents traced its origin back through James Mill to Hartley,Hume,Locke,Hobbes,and Francis Bacon,and perhaps it might even count among its remoter ancestors such men as William of Ockham and Roger Bacon.The series of names suggests some permanent congeniality to the national character.(5)Although,more over,this tradition had in later times been broken by Reid and his followers,their condemnation did not really imply so fundamental an antithesis of thought as Mill supposed.They and the empiricists had,in their own opinion at least,a common ancestor in Bacon,if not in Locke.But,however this may be,the Scottish school had maintained the positions which Mill thought himself concerned to attack;and for him represented the rejection of 'experience.'

同类推荐
热门推荐
  • 《明月照九州》

    《明月照九州》

    我梦中的江南,满目疮夷;我所在的北方,战火连年。曾经的家人兄弟,或已成白骨,或形同陌路,或已成仇敌,或开疆辟土,建功立业。这片平原,这浩莽九州,百年来未曾寻到平安祥和。月亮清冷光辉消逝了,希望的曙光才会照耀天空与大地。不惧世人误解,拼却数载光阴,愿明月照九州,花灯映万家。
  • 系统女王:拐走男神的百变攻略

    系统女王:拐走男神的百变攻略

    “咿嘻嘻,我知道顾白你是不会舍得让我受苦的。”女子一脸灿烂,男子却微微皱眉,无奈。顾白:我觉得是自己被套路了,当时怎么没发现她原来是这样的宿主。余染:你后悔也没用了,既然选了我,那你就是小爷的宠妻了。顾白:恩?声音中带着些危险。余染讪讪一笑,“爷,我错了~”顾白:冷漠jpg.余染:.......我会乖乖洗白白等你夜访。顾白:恩余染:.......天哪你个闷骚不要再装高冷范了!-[系统流|快穿|甜宠|攻略][甜宠怡情,偶尔重口味]
  • 金刚三昧经

    金刚三昧经

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。
  • 重生海贼之冒险者

    重生海贼之冒险者

    重生海贼王,目标,世界最大的宝藏ONEPLECE!一路的冒险,与刺激!秦风望向大海,喃喃道:“路飞,期待与你相遇”
  • 佛说无量门微密持经

    佛说无量门微密持经

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。
  • 行宫大盗

    行宫大盗

    本书是从作家叶雪松先生已发表的各类小说题材作品中精心筛选出来的,这7篇小说,有数几万字左右的中篇,有数千字的短篇,有侠义柔肠,有抵御外侮,有两情依依,读之令人爱不释手,欲罢不能,或掩卷深思,或催人泪下,无疑是一道不可多得的精食大餐。
  • 花样美男:美男多多

    花样美男:美男多多

    (颜宝是行星饭,那篇小说是颜宝闺蜜写的,闺蜜是四叶草)【女的腹黑,男的更是腹黑】被逼迫上学就算了,还偏偏遇上那群腹黑的花样美男,遇上美男就算了,本以为可以安安静静的生活,那群该死的美男还偏偏不让安静,把我整个半死。。。。每天都会开启新的搞笑,每天搞笑花样翻新
  • 人魔风雨录

    人魔风雨录

    在风岚大陆,人魔争斗一直没有停止,一个小家族也成为争斗的牺牲品,其留下的一粒火种带给了这个大陆另一种思想,争斗是继续还是另一种开始?
  • 丁香谢

    丁香谢

    应届毕业生齐居的奇异梦中世界,永不退却的信念
  • 步步惊婚:诱心前妻

    步步惊婚:诱心前妻

    秦邵煊,是圈内有名的花花公子,明明心有所属,却因父亲一句话不得不娶另一个不爱的女人。慕潆,是被逼得走投无路的私生女,无缘无故成了交易对象。“先生,你够了!旁边不是很多位置么,干嘛老往我这边挤。”“因为这样我们才能更‘了解彼此’。”他笑得一脸不怀好意。她拍案而起,搞砸相亲宴,扔下他扬长而去。他无视餐厅内惊愕的目光,淡然掏出手机,对电话那头的人说:“就她了,我娶。”离婚后一个星期,他高调再婚,结婚对象是他心心念念的女人。