登陆注册
15424600000100

第100章 Chapter IV(10)

But,stated absolutely,it implies pure self-interest.Robinson Crusoe was responsible in the sense that if he did not work he would starve.And,if we could,in fact,mark off each man's separate sphere,or regard society as a collection of Robinson Crusoes,the principle might be applied.Each man should have a right to what he has himself 'created.'But when a man 'creates'nothing;when his 'environment'is not a desert island but an organised society,the principle must be differently stated.

'Responsibility,'indeed,always implies liberty --the existence of a sphere within which a man's fortunes depend upon his personal character,and his character should determine his fortune.But,as Mill can most clearly recognise,social responsibility means something more.One most 'certain incident'of social progress is the growth of co-operation,and that involves,as he says,the 'subordination of individual caprice'to a 'preconceived determination'and the performance of parts allotted in a 'combined undertaking.'(25)The individual,then,is part of an organisation,in which every individual should play his part.The over-centralisation which would crush him into an automaton is not more fatal than the individual independence which would be incompatible with organisation.The desirable 'responsibility'is not that of a Robinson Crusoe but that of the soldier in an army.It should be enforced by other motives than mere self-interest,for it affects the interests of the whole body corporate.Now Mill,believing even to excess in the power of education,included in education the whole discipline of life due to the relations of the individual to his social environment;and it is his essential principle that this force should be directed to enforcing a sense of 'responsibility'in the widest acceptation of the word.

V.POLITICAL APPLICATION

A similar doctrine is implied in his political writings,of which the Representative Government is the most explicit.The book is hardly on a level with his best work.Treatises of 'political philosophy'are generally disappointing.The difficulty lies,I suppose,in combining the practical with the general point of view.In some treatises,the 'philosophy'is made up of such scraps about the social contract or mixture of the three forms of government as excited Bentham's contempt in Blackstone's treatise.They are a mere juggle of abstractions fit only for schoolboys.Others,like James Mill's,are really party pamphlets,masquerading as philosophy,and importing obvious principles into the likeness of geometrical axioms.A good deal of wisdom no doubt lurks in the speeches of statesmen;but it is not often easy to extricate it from the mass of personal and practical remarks.Mill's treatise might suggest some such criticism;and yet it is interesting as an indication of his leading principles.Some passages show how long experience in a public office affects a philosophic thinker.Mill's exposition,for example,of the defects of the House of Commons in administrative legislation,(26)his discussion of the fact (as he takes it to be)that governments remarkable for sustained vigour and ability have generally been aristocratic,(27)and his panegyric upon the East India Company,(28)record the genuine impressions of his long administrative career,and are refreshing in the midst of more abstract discussions.I have,however,only to notice a general principle which runs through the book.

Mill starts by emphasising the distinction applied in the Political Economy between the natural and the artificial.

Political institutions are the work of men and created by the will.The doctrine that governments 'are not made,but grow,'would lead to 'political fatalism'if it were regarded as true exclusively of the other.In fact,we might reply,there is no real opposition at all.'Making'is but one kind of 'growing.'

Growing by conscious forethought is still growing,and the antithesis put absolutely is deceptive.Mill is striving to enlarge the sphere of voluntary action.He wishes to prove that he can take the ground generally supposed to imply the doctrine of 'freewill.'Institutions,he fully admits,presuppose certain qualities in the people;but,given those qualities,they are 'a matter of choice.'(29)In politics,as in machinery,we are turning existing powers to account;but we do not say that,because rivers will not run uphill,'water-mills are not made but grow.'The political theorist can invent constitutions as the engineer can invent machinery,which will materially alter the results;and to inquire which is the best form of government 'in the abstract'is 'not a chimerical but a highly practical employment of the scientific intellect.'The illustration is difficult to apply if the 'river'means the whole society,and the 'water-mill'is itself,therefore,one part of the 'river.'

The legislator is not an external force but an integral part of internal forces.

In the next place,Mill rejects a distinction made by Comte(30)between order and progress.Comte had made a distinction between 'statics'and 'dynamics'in sociology,which are to each other like anatomy and physiology.The conditions of existence,and the conditions of continuous movement of a society correspond to 'order and progress.'(31)Mill replies that 'progress'includes 'order,'and that the two conditions cannot give independent criteria of the merits of the institutions.

同类推荐
热门推荐
  • 王俊凯:总裁宠溺倔强妻

    王俊凯:总裁宠溺倔强妻

    想她沐依然也真是倒霉,反正遇见王俊凯她就没赶上什么好事。一步一步的被他打包吃掉也就算了,特么她还沦陷了其中。阴谋啊阴谋,连她和他结婚都是某凯策划的一场计。说好的暖男呢?她怎么看着这位特别不要脸呢?把她骗到手之前装的那叫一个正人君子,那叫一个善良可爱,那叫一个纯洁无害![片段一]论某然如何一步步沦陷:某凯:“依然,我爱你。”某然:“哦”某凯:“就这么完了?”心碎的声音。[片段二]论某凯如何装可怜:某然:“你躺地上干什么?”某凯:“……”某然:“不会是低血糖犯了吧?”刚走过去就被某凯一把扯如怀中。某凯一脸无害:“有你我感觉好多了。”是的,你没看错,就是这么不要脸。
  • 自在神路

    自在神路

    一个程序员因为抹去屏幕上的一粒砂子而穿越到了异界,从此走上修真路。身具三丈灵台的他却有着致命的缺点,他将如何排除万难,取得五元圣宝,成就自在大神,拯救崩裂的世界?
  • 复仇有误:大叔你在骚扰我试试

    复仇有误:大叔你在骚扰我试试

    她,萧氏集团总裁表姐,借着相亲的名义来找父亲报仇。他,是她相亲对象,知道她要来复仇,却一而再再而三的妨碍她。“喂!别以为你是总裁了不起,我照样打你”她说。“呵!你来试试,我等你”他轻笑道。几天后,他发给她一些资料,她看后知道,她输了几年后,她依偎在他怀里,问道:”黎~你当初~是怎么爱上我的?“”夫人~你要相信,你的魅力足以让看到你第一眼的人爱上你!“他望向她的眼里,满满的宠溺和情意。。
  • 赞·金钱·荷尔蒙(财蜜eMook)

    赞·金钱·荷尔蒙(财蜜eMook)

    心理学上有一种解释,认为人类行为的三大动机是求生本能、性冲动和渴望伟大,放到网络社交中,同样适用—— 求生本能对应着无所不在的寻找机会的意识; 性冲动在于约炮之类的荷尔蒙飙升的行为; 渴望伟大很好理解,找认同感、刷存在感、求赞的心理无处不在。 对照这三点看看自己po的自拍照、食物照、风景照、恩爱照……有木有想捂脸的冲动? 本期周刊将教你利用社交网络寻找工作机会、维护自己的人际圈;也跟你八卦一个“谁的荷尔蒙在飘”的故事。最后我们来严肃地谈一谈,渴望伟大没有错,想让点赞来得更猛一点,先装好你的逼格。别浪费时间刷屏啦,来,一起干点儿正事儿!
  • 六国之巅

    六国之巅

    上古时期,有一段不为人知的传说。当时妖魔横行,神魔大战一触即发,神兽五爪金龙被魔君利用,堕入魔道,祸害苍生,遇神杀神遇佛杀佛,死伤无数。断阡殇身为上古战神,拥有上神之躯,铤而走险,用自己的上神之躯将金龙禁锢于六国之巅,并重新将它封印起来。妖魔两道都被仙道一一击退,从此被禁锢于妖之国,不得重返人间祸害苍生。好不容易安定了上千年的宁静,却被一个少女的出现给打破了……凤凰涅槃重生,妖王重现人间,身边却多了一个美轮美奂的妖姬。若有来生,苍生我不顾,六国之王我不要,我只要你妖漓汐一人。
  • 本吾

    本吾

    我是我?我为什么是我?我是我,我就是我。
  • 宇智波

    宇智波

    他叫宇智波文灏,从出生就有六勾玉轮回眼,他是宇智波少族长可再一次普通人的学校中认识了一个与众不同女孩,她让他本来平淡的修炼生活变得丰富多彩,人一生之中有无数选择,而他对感情的选择却只有一次,他一出生就注定一人之下万人之上,但在她的面前只有卸下所有伪装俯首称臣。
  • 40岁男人最应该注意的事

    40岁男人最应该注意的事

    本书内容包括:40岁的男人,健康和事业同样重要、40岁的男人,可以再创成功的奇迹、40岁的男人,要攒钱更要赚钱、40岁的男人,要解决好职场中的各种问题等。
  • 穿越三国:红颜无心

    穿越三国:红颜无心

    她是二十一世纪的新人类,却意外穿越。他是另版三国中最弱国家的皇帝,却是一个勤政爱民的好皇帝。他前世是她的恋人,却抛弃了她,后来又成为了她的敌人。他是一只白鹰,为了她,连鹰王的王位也不要,只求能看着她;当她与他相对,她该如何面对她前世最爱的人?而那个看似柔弱的皇帝,他又要如何留住他名义上的女人?那个为她放弃一切的鹰妖,又要如何保护他生命中最重要的人?她,要如何抉择?红尘中兜兜转转,却不知,还停留在原地。
  • 我的美艳总裁老婆

    我的美艳总裁老婆

    踏上无限逆袭之路!