登陆注册
15421200000054

第54章

The orator does not require to convert to his views all the members of a jury, but only the leading spirits among it who will determine the general opinion.As in all crowds, so in juries there are a small number of individuals who serve as guides to the rest."I have found by experience," says the counsel cited above, "that one or two energetic men suffice to carry the rest of the jury with them." It is those two or three whom it is necessary to convince by skilful suggestions.First of all, and above all, it is necessary to please them.The man forming part of a crowd whom one has succeeded in pleasing is on the point of being convinced, and is quite disposed to accept as excellent any arguments that may be offered him.I detach the following anecdote from an interesting account of M.Lachaud, alluded to above:--"It is well known that during all the speeches he would deliver in the course of an assize sessions, Lachaud never lost sight of the two or three jurymen whom he knew or felt to be influential but obstinate.As a rule he was successful in winning over these refractory jurors.On one occasion, however, in the provinces, he had to deal with a juryman whom he plied in vain for three-quarters of an hour with his most cunning arguments; the man was the seventh juryman, the first on the second bench.The case was desperate.Suddenly, in the middle of a passionate demonstration, Lachaud stopped short, and addressing the President of the court said: `Would you give instructions for the curtain there in front to be drawn? The seventh juryman is blinded by the sun.' The juryman in question reddened, smiled, and expressed his thanks.He was won over for the defence."Many writers, some of them most distinguished, have started of late a strong campaign against the institution of the jury, although it is the only protection we have against the errors, really very frequent, of a caste that is under no control.[25] Aportion of these writers advocate a jury recruited solely from the ranks of the enlightened classes; but we have already proved that even in this case the verdicts would be identical with those returned under the present system.Other writers, taking their stand on the errors committed by juries, would abolish the jury and replace it by judges.It is difficult to see how these would-be reformers can forget that the errors for which the jury is blamed were committed in the first instance by judges, and that when the accused person comes before a jury he has already been held to be guilty by several magistrates, by the juge d'instruction, the public prosecutor, and the Court of Arraignment.It should thus be clear that were the accused to be definitely judged by magistrates instead of by jurymen, he would lose his only chance of being admitted innocent.The errors of juries have always been first of all the errors of magistrates.

It is solely the magistrates, then, who should be blamed when particularly monstrous judicial errors crop up, such, for instance, as the quite recent condemnation of Dr.L---- who, prosecuted by a juge d'instruction, of excessive stupidity, on the strength of the denunciation of a half-idiot girl, who accused the doctor of having performed an illegal operation upon her for thirty francs, would have been sent to penal servitude but for an explosion of public indignation, which had for result that he was immediately set at liberty by the Chief of the State.

The honourable character given the condemned man by all his fellow-citizens made the grossness of the blunder self-evident.

The magistrates themselves admitted it, and yet out of caste considerations they did all they could to prevent the pardon being signed.In all similar affairs the jury, confronted with technical details it is unable to understand, naturally hearkens to the public prosecutor, arguing that, after all, the affair has been investigated by magistrates trained to unravel the most intricate situations.Who, then, are the real authors of the error--the jurymen or the magistrates? We should cling vigorously to the jury.It constitutes, perhaps, the only category of crowd that cannot be replaced by any individuality.

It alone can temper the severity of the law, which, equal for all, ought in principle to be blind and to take no cognisance of particular cases.Inaccessible to pity, and heeding nothing but the text of the law, the judge in his professional severity would visit with the same penalty the burglar guilty of murder and the wretched girl whom poverty and her abandonment by her seducer have driven to infanticide.The jury, on the other hand, instinctively feels that the seduced girl is much less guilty than the seducer, who, however, is not touched by the law, and that she deserves every indulgence.

[25] The magistracy is, in point of fact, the only administration whose acts are under no control.In spite of all its revolutions, democratic France does not possess that right of habeas corpus of which England is so proud.We have banished all the tyrants, but have set up a magistrate in each city who disposes at will of the honour and liberty of the citizens.An insignificant juge d'instruction (an examining magistrate who has no exact counterpart in England.--Trans.), fresh from the university, possesses the revolting power of sending to prison at will persons of the most considerable standing, on a simple supposition on his part of their guilt, and without being obliged to justify his act to any one.Under the pretext of pursuing his investigation he can keep these persons in prison for six months or even a year, and free them at last without owing them either an indemnity or excuses.The warrant in France is the exact equivalent of the lettre de cachet, with this difference, that the latter, with the use of which the monarchy was so justly reproached, could only be resorted to by persons occupying a very high position, while the warrant is an instrument in the hands of a whole class of citizens which is far from passing for being very enlightened or very independent.

Being well acquainted with the psychology of castes, and also with the psychology of other categories of crowds, I do not perceive a single case in which, wrongly accused of a crime, Ishould not prefer to have to deal with a jury rather than with magistrates.I should have some chance that my innocence would be recognised by the former and not the slightest chance that it would be admitted by the latter.The power of crowds is to be dreaded, but the power of certain castes is to be dreaded yet more.Crowds are open to conviction; castes never are.

同类推荐
  • 文心雕龙集校

    文心雕龙集校

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。
  • ELISSA

    ELISSA

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。
  • 类证普济本事方续集

    类证普济本事方续集

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。
  • 通俗编

    通俗编

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。
  • 重令

    重令

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。
热门推荐
  • 红狗与地下城

    红狗与地下城

    无影剑在手,天下任我走!这是一个学渣在异界迅速崛起的故事。战神大陆修炼等级为:武徒、武师、武将、武王、武皇、武帝、武神。
  • 花开花落半浅夏

    花开花落半浅夏

    本来很平静的生活却被他给打乱了,她怎么逃也逃不过他。。。。。
  • 莲惑

    莲惑

    她原本有个幸福的家庭,一个深爱她的丈夫,一个可爱的女儿。可是由于阎王的失误一夕之间,与家人天人永隔。重生后的她胸含血莲而生,一出生就被视为杨家天命之女的传人,更是南齐国严太宰唯一的孙女。而这位严太宰就是前世她深爱的丈夫。爷爷对她疼爱有加。取名严慕雪。当雪儿成为天女宫宫主时,才知道原来南齐皇族君家世代身重至命绝情蛊,中了该蛊不仅自己深受蛊毒痛苦,寿命不超过45岁,而且还遗传给其儿子。而天命之女因为天生至阴之血,只有她与君家子孙所生的孩子的脐血才是的绝情蛊的唯一解药,而她的使命就是替君家解毒。一个从小与她青梅竹马在11岁时就以其母妃的传家之宝梅花镯送她做为定情物的瑞王爷君子墨,另一个是帅气睿智深受陛下宠爱的明王爷君子轩。她并不知道自己面临命运的选择。无意中命运把她推上了太子妃的宝座。而明王爷在与她定婚当天被皇上命为皇太子。本十分不愿嫁入皇家的她,知道了子轩对她的情深意重,尤其是婚后子轩为她放弃了整个后宫后,也渐渐地爱上了君子轩。并告诉了他自己是杨家天命之女传人的身份。当雪儿怀上子轩的孩子后,一次未遂的下毒事件才使她知道梅花镯原来是子墨送给他王妃的定情物,而且只有在怀上子墨的孩子后才能拿下来。与其同时,子轩与其大哥欣亲王的夺位之争也处于白日化的状态。在严太宰与子轩的运筹帷幄下,子轩最后赢得了胜利。但皇上却因此而重病不起。临终之前,皇上密见雪儿并求她一定要救救瑞亲王君子墨。然后皇上当着文武百官的面宣布皇太子君子轩继位。亲封雪儿为皇后。最后皇上给了瑞亲王君子墨一根御杖,称该杖上可打昏君下可打佞臣。子轩即位后,雪儿产下一子,顺利解了子轩体内的毒。同时雪儿也以健康为代价解救了墨。此时邻国狄夷国趁南齐新君继位,国事未稳,发动战争。子墨殿前请樱带兵前去御敌。一年后前方传来南齐军在合州被围的消息,而子墨身重毒箭命在旦夕。 雪儿带领其表兄神医之后、天女宫成员与国丈一起去解合州之围。在雪儿的指挥下,合州之围被解。狄夷国灭亡。雪儿衣不解带的照顾子墨,二人因此而产生了感情。可雪儿想到子轩的情深意重,克制了这份还处在朦胧中的感情。
  • 君生浮梦

    君生浮梦

    君生我未生,我生君已老;我离君天涯,君隔我海角;我穿越了生死,也许只为遇见你,爱上你,追随你,最后。。。守护你。
  • 异界之地球三兄弟

    异界之地球三兄弟

    一次阴差阳错的机会地球三人组穿越到了异界,短暂的迷茫之后,三人利用自己的知识智慧与天赋,在这个与地球截然不同的大陆上,展开了自己的奇幻之路,斗恶霸,救矿工,开公司,建军团……看三人如何在异界争霸世界。
  • 神秘的召唤师大陆

    神秘的召唤师大陆

    这是本人第一次发表的作品,不足之处请大家多多包涵
  • 妃太撩人爷要负责

    妃太撩人爷要负责

    他说我愿倾尽这天下只为你她说我愿为你倾尽这天下他们说祸水配祸害,绝配
  • 重生帝子

    重生帝子

    帝子重生,誓要伐天,前世未了心愿,今生必不负卿。
  • 做最出色的经理人

    做最出色的经理人

    初出茅庐和久经沙场的职业经理必不可少的人生和职场指南。心理学、经济学和法律,这是经理人日常工作中时常涉及的三大领域。掌握了这三大领域的知识,也就等于拥有斩荆披棘的武器。我们只想对你说:请阅读这本书,这样,武器就永远在你手上。
  • 无为寻道录

    无为寻道录

    十数年的隐忍,数千个日夜里的坚持,万般的欺辱刁难,谁道不尽修仙梦?难道我所有努力和决心仅仅因为你想杀便杀,就可以画上句点,就可以终结的吗?!少年心有血,即使匍匐在地也要大吼道:“我此生必杀你!!【我的弟弟啊——】”一切从这里开始,少年带着决心。光怪陆离,洪荒遗存,烟绕浩瀚,万道争锋,无奇不有的大千世界将随着许方的一步步走来徐徐展开……然道途漫漫,修之不尽。天道不悟,圣道何存?众生谓道,何以我道?且看《无为寻道录》。