登陆注册
15421200000052

第52章

CRIMINAL JURIES

Criminal juries--General characteristics of juries--statistics show that their decisions are independent of their composition--The manner in which an impression may be made on juries--The style and influence of argument--The methods of persuasion of celebrated counsel--The nature of those crimes for which juries are respectively indulgent or severe--The utility of the jury as an institution, and the danger that would result from its place being taken by magistrates.

Being unable to study here every category of jury, I shall only examine the most important--that of the juries of the Court of Assize.These juries afford an excellent example of the heterogeneous crowd that is not anonymous.We shall find them display suggestibility and but slight capacity for reasoning, while they are open to the influence of the leaders of crowds, and they are guided in the main by unconscious sentiments.In the course of this investigation we shall have occasion to observe some interesting examples of the errors that may be made by persons not versed in the psychology of crowds.

Juries, in the first place, furnish us a good example of the slight importance of the mental level of the different elements composing a crowd, so far as the decisions it comes to are concerned.We have seen that when a deliberative assembly is called upon to give its opinion on a question of a character not entirely technical, intelligence stands for nothing.For instance, a gathering of scientific men or of artists, owing to the mere fact that they form an assemblage, will not deliver judgments on general subjects sensibly different from those rendered by a gathering of masons or grocers.At various periods, and in particular previous to 1848, the French administration instituted a careful choice among the persons summoned to form a jury, picking the jurors from among the enlightened classes; choosing professors, functionaries, men of letters, &c.At the present day jurors are recruited for the most part from among small tradesmen, petty capitalists, and employes.Yet, to the great astonishment of specialist writers, whatever the composition of the jury has been, its decisions have been identical.Even the magistrates, hostile as they are to the institution of the jury, have had to recognise the exactness of the assertion.M.Berard des Glajeux, a former President of the Court of Assizes, expresses himself on the subject in his "Memoirs" in the following terms:--"The selection of jurymen is to-day in reality in the hands of the municipal councillors, who put people down on the list or eliminate them from it in accordance with the political and electoral preoccupations inherent in their situation....The majority of the jurors chosen are persons engaged in trade, but persons of less importance than formerly, and employes belonging to certain branches of the administration....Both opinions and professions counting for nothing once the role of judge assumed, many of the jurymen having the ardour of neophytes, and men of the best intentions being similarly disposed in humble situations, the spirit of the jury has not changed: ITS VERDICTSHAVE REMAINED THE SAME."

Of the passage just cited the conclusions, which are just, are to be borne in mind and not the explanations, which are weak.Too much astonishment should not be felt at this weakness, for, as a rule, counsel equally with magistrates seem to be ignorant of the psychology of crowds and, in consequence, of juries.I find a proof of this statement in a fact related by the author just quoted.He remarks that Lachaud, one of the most illustrious barristers practising in the Court of Assize, made systematic use of his right to object to a juror in the case of all individuals of intelligence on the list.Yet experience--and experience alone--has ended by acquainting us with the utter uselessness of these objections.This is proved by the fact that at the present day public prosecutors and barristers, at any rate those belonging to the Parisian bar, have entirely renounced their right to object to a juror; still, as M.des Glajeux remarks, the verdicts have not changed, "they are neither better nor worse."Like all crowds, juries are very strongly impressed by sentimental considerations, and very slightly by argument."They cannot resist the sight," writes a barrister, "of a mother giving its child the breast, or of orphans." "It is sufficient that a woman should be of agreeable appearance," says M.des Glajeux, "to win the benevolence of the jury."Without pity for crimes of which it appears possible they might themselves be the victims--such crimes, moreover, are the most dangerous for society--juries, on the contrary, are very indulgent in the case of breaches of the law whose motive is passion.They are rarely severe on infanticide by girl-mothers, or hard on the young woman who throws vitriol at the man who has seduced and deserted her, for the reason that they feel instinctively that society runs but slight danger from such crimes,[24] and that in a country in which the law does not protect deserted girls the crime of the girl who avenges herself is rather useful than harmful, inasmuch as it frightens future seducers in advance.

同类推荐
热门推荐
  • 陈桥兵变

    陈桥兵变

    陈桥兵变是赵匡胤建立宋朝的政变。公元960年后周大将赵匡胤借口北汉与辽联合南侵率军出大梁(今河南开封),至陈桥驿(今开封东北)授意将士给他穿上黄袍拥立他为帝。此次兵变最后导致了后周的灭亡和宋朝的建立,推动了历史的发展。
  • 百年之后千年之旅

    百年之后千年之旅

    这是一个关于星际流浪的故事,宇宙如一副巨大棋盘,有生命的星球是一颗颗棋子,地球只是一颗弃子,弃子的命运,是甘愿充当马前卒化为炮灰?还是在宇宙兴衰中无声湮灭?
  • 荒芜禁忌

    荒芜禁忌

    “千年之约,终将完结。山河无极,荒芜禁忌。时空之门,破空无痕。屠天灭苍,倾天之上!”怎样的惊世绝密?当千年的约定开启,命运的齿轮转动,谁能阻挡,谁能抗衡………………本书描述主角万影传承家族功法,同时也背负了家族的使命。怎样的家族使命要生命去背负…………当家人远走他乡去完成家族使命时,万影当何去何从………神州大陆被妖兽占领,幻梦大陆成为人们的栖息地,万影前往这里,等待他的将是什么呢?恩怨情仇,悲欢离合,伤感黯然,古怪搞笑,无声叹息,世间百态………不一样的仙侠,由不一样的小创出品。敬请关注…………
  • 傲世剑尊传

    傲世剑尊传

    剑尊乃九天至尊,因徒弟背叛,而废弃修为放弃圣人之躯,差点魂飞魄散。好在早有准备,重新修剑开始了传奇之旅
  • 谋士养成计划

    谋士养成计划

    一个身在汉末的世族少年意外的拥有了属于后世的记忆,还莫名其妙的得到了一个古怪系统,于是,少年的成长之路即将开启。在这风起云涌的乱世,英雄辈出,豪杰并起。想那江东美周郎,谈笑间樯橹灰飞烟灭,卧龙诸葛孔明,隆中笑言天下三分,魏武曹孟德,东临碣石有遗篇......生在这个波涛澎湃的时代里,不仅要做历史的见证者,更要做历史的参与者,一睹这些乱世豪杰的绝代风采。
  • Hello,叶澜曦

    Hello,叶澜曦

    你敢跑,我就敢追;你敢嫁,我就敢娶;你敢说对不起,我就敢说没关系;你敢死心塌地,我就敢不离不弃;你敢不争不吵,我就敢白头偕老。你敢说我是你的一切,我就敢说你是我的世界!......13岁的叶澜曦,本来是叶澜集团的千金小姐,可父母却离婚了;但她的选择是随着母亲一起生活,他们来到了另一座城市,在这里她认识了永远也不只会成为她生命中的过客的人——夏炽!他们同学了将近七年的时光。最后一句”对不起,我恨你!“打破了夏炽原本所有想对澜曦说的话......后来她跟夏炽说遇上他是她生命中最开心的一件事儿
  • 穿越之白痴小姐变妖孽王后

    穿越之白痴小姐变妖孽王后

    走在半路上不知不觉晕了莫名其妙穿越了居然还是个白痴后宫家族的斗争让我无可奈何明枪易躲暗箭难防遇上了他冰山腹黑王爷“贱人你这么心狠手辣连本王的小世子都敢害,来人押到柴房关起来”四王爷并没有因为她是他的王妃而心慈手软,要不是因为白若曦的父亲是朝中大臣先皇的得力左右手在朝中实力不一般不然四王爷怎么会取这个白痴
  • 腹黑:高冷男神等等我

    腹黑:高冷男神等等我

    他是一位可望而不可及的总裁加男神她是一个小绵羊,任大灰狼宰割她不服她不服她不服,重要的事情说三遍“哼,林敬轩,我总有一天会让你拜倒在我的石榴裙下的”某人开始说梦话....
  • 婚不可破

    婚不可破

    前男友卷款逃逸,一夜之间,黎洛成了人人喊打的黑心商人,杀人犯,锒铛入狱。入狱途中她被段寒之囚禁,只因他心爱的女人差点死在她的手上。黎洛苦笑着为自己辩解:“如果我说不是我做的,你信不信?”段寒之眼神冷漠如寒冬:“你这样恶毒的女人,我凭什么信你?”很久之后,黎洛绝望地望着段寒之:“如果我说我爱你也是真的,你信不信?”这一次,他用力地将她抱紧:“我信。”情节虚构,请勿模仿
  • 凤逆九天之调教腹黑帝王

    凤逆九天之调教腹黑帝王

    她,是惊才绝艳,最强的杀手,被人陷害,可她命不该绝;一朝穿越,废柴嫡女,世人耻笑?看她如何凤临九天逆天下!他,是妖孽入股,才貌双绝的极品腹黑帝王,天下臣服!此世等待,至死不渝!永不分离!