登陆注册
15421200000035

第35章

[16] My first observations with regard to the art of impressing crowds and touching the slight assistance to be derived in this connection from the rules of logic date back to the seige of Paris, to the day when I saw conducted to the Louvre, where the Government was then sitting, Marshal V----, whom a furious crowd asserted they had surprised in the act of taking the plans of the fortifications to sell them to the Prussians.A member of the Government (G.P----), a very celebrated orator, came out to harangue the crowd, which was demanding the immediate execution of the prisoner.I had expected that the speaker would point out the absurdity of the accusation by remarking that the accused Marshal was positively one of those who had constructed the fortifications, the plan of which, moreover, was on sale at every booksellers.To my immense stupefaction--I was very young then--the speech was on quite different lines."Justice shall be done," exclaimed the orator, advancing towards the prisoner, "and pitiless justice.Let the Government of the National Defence conclude your inquiry.In the meantime we will keep the prisoner in custody." At once calmed by this apparent concession, the crowd broke up, and a quarter of an hour later the Marshal was able to return home.He would infallibly have been torn in pieces had the speaker treated the infuriated crowd to the logical arguments that my extreme youth induced me to consider as very convincing.

Logical minds, accustomed to be convinced by a chain of somewhat close reasoning, cannot avoid having recourse to this mode of persuasion when addressing crowds, and the inability of their arguments always surprises them."The usual mathematical consequences based on the syllogism--that is, on associations of identities--are imperative..." writes a logician."This imperativeness would enforce the assent even of an inorganic mass were it capable of following associations of identities." This is doubtless true, but a crowd is no more capable than an inorganic mass of following such associations, nor even of understanding them.If the attempt be made to convince by reasoning primitive minds--savages or children, for instance--the slight value possessed by this method of arguing will be understood.

It is not even necessary to descend so low as primitive beings to obtain an insight into the utter powerlessness of reasoning when it has to fight against sentiment.Let us merely call to mind how tenacious, for centuries long, have been religious superstitions in contradiction with the simplest logic.For nearly two thousand years the most luminous geniuses have bowed before their laws, and modern times have to be reached for their veracity to be merely contested.The Middle Ages and the Renaissance possessed many enlightened men, but not a single man who attained by reasoning to an appreciation of the childish side of his superstitions, or who promulgated even a slight doubt as to the misdeeds of the devil or the necessity of burning sorcerers.

Should it be regretted that crowds are never guided by reason?

We would not venture to affirm it.Without a doubt human reason would not have availed to spur humanity along the path of civilisation with the ardour and hardihood its illusions have done.These illusions, the offspring of those unconscious forces by which we are led, were doubtless necessary.Every race carries in its mental constitution the laws of its destiny, and it is, perhaps, these laws that it obeys with a resistless impulse, even in the case of those of its impulses which apparently are the most unreasoned.It seems at times as if nations were submitted to secret forces analogous to those which compel the acorn to transform itself into an oak or a comet to follow its orbit.

What little insight we can get into these forces must be sought for in the general course of the evolution of a people, and not in the isolated facts from which this evolution appears at times to proceed.Were these facts alone to be taken into consideration, history would seem to be the result of a series of improbable chances.It was improbable that a Galilean carpenter should become for two thousand years an all-powerful God in whose name the most important civilisations were founded; improbable, too, that a few bands of Arabs, emerging from their deserts, should conquer the greater part of the old Graco-Roman world, and establish an empire greater than that of Alexander; improbable, again, that in Europe, at an advanced period of its development, and when authority throughout it had been systematically hierarchised, an obscure lieutenant of artillery should have succeeded in reigning over a multitude of peoples and kings.

Let us leave reason, then, to philosophers, and not insist too strongly on its intervention in the governing of men.It is not by reason, but most often in spite of it, that are created those sentiments that are the mainsprings of all civilisation--sentiments such as honour, self- sacrifice, religious faith, patriotism, and the love of glory.

同类推荐
  • Amphitryon

    Amphitryon

    Amphitryon was played for the first time in Paris, at the Theatre du Palais-Royal, January 13, 1668.It was successfully received, holding the boards until the 18th of March, when Easter intervened.
  • The Crossing

    The Crossing

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。
  • 官箴集要

    官箴集要

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。
  • 西升经

    西升经

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。
  • Areopagitica

    Areopagitica

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。
热门推荐
  • exo之你我之间的缘分

    exo之你我之间的缘分

    夏恩贤一次被迫离开她的哥哥(吴世勋,鹿晗)等回来时已经不记得了,一次机缘巧合自己当上了妈妈,他成了爸爸,共同照顾一个宝宝,也和他的感情慢慢升温,从讨厌他到喜欢甚至爱上他。。。
  • 无法对你说再见

    无法对你说再见

    谈过恋爱的都知道,你先爱上了别人,你首先就是弱势群体。杨溪以为自己的爱情隔着世俗偏见和现实差距,永远只能活在暗恋的漩涡里。却不知上天也会垂青于她,暗恋对象已经分手,进入单身行列,这个时候要是还搞暗恋,就上对不起天,下对不起地,中间还对不起自己的良心。谁说女追男只隔一层纱?受苦受累受委屈也只能打落了牙齿往嘴里咽。
  • 仙人必须死

    仙人必须死

    青山小城,南风小筑;静水流深,沧笙踏歌;三生阴晴圆缺,一朝悲欢离合,一座城里锁了一个人。一段可悲可泣可叹可恨可笑的修仙史。总以为自己总将刀枪不入,到头来还是不堪一击。有朝一日,天赐辉煌,我若得道,仙人,必、须、死!
  • 意中人,星愿有你

    意中人,星愿有你

    ?三生有幸遇见你?不管是浅洛亦那句傻傻的承诺,还是虞南背后默默的守护,他们心中都有住着那个意中人。你,是我的意中人。我只在意你一个,一辈子只爱你一个,生生世世永不后悔......
  • 贵宁

    贵宁

    年幼母丧,寿宁从此掌家,昔日安稳的生活瞬间成为镜中花。亲密无间的挚友意外惨死,朝中局势危如累卵喂!还有你,那个半夜爬到我家房顶的锦衣卫,你给我下来!且看世家贵女寿宁,如何拨开重重迷雾,揭露其中的魑魅魍魉!锦衣卫:嫁给我,什么杀手真凶都不在话下。寿宁一脸娇羞,捂脸遁走~
  • 倾尽天下之负焱天下

    倾尽天下之负焱天下

    风扬纱衣,七重纱衣,血溅白纱,霞白纱衣绽开冰血蔷薇,蔷薇眯眼,眯眼血染蒹葭。焱国江山岌岌可危,就在周军将要进入焱国首都的前十天,颖雪再次回到了焱国,看到了傅邵仪。他面容还是不曾改变,依旧是倾国倾城,此时的正搂着颖铃欣赏美人笙歌。相见已是无话,对酒当歌,咫尺天涯。再回玄天阁,拂去一身雪花,并肩看天下,只是今日的天下不再昔日繁华。血染江山又怎敌眉间一点朱砂,说爱折花,不爱竹马,终是为你负焱天下。
  • tfboys之我要你的真心

    tfboys之我要你的真心

    当天真的林静玥,活泼的李雅琪,高冷的叶紫沫同时也是忠诚的四叶草的她们遇上。。。。。
  • 敬礼班长

    敬礼班长

    《敬礼,班长》全面总结了他作为一名班长的“带兵之道”,深入展示了他带兵育人的理念升华和方法创新,较好地体现了他把当兵当事业、把带兵当专业的军旅追求,值得更多的一线带兵人学习借鉴。我们真切希望,能够借此为引,唤起更多一线带兵人的思考和探索,在追逐强军梦的岗位实践中放飞好“个人梦”。
  • 佛说圣最胜陀罗尼经

    佛说圣最胜陀罗尼经

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。
  • 星心锁爱,预定终身

    星心锁爱,预定终身

    如果说用擦肩而过形容陌生人的相遇,那么,天长地久就是形容他和她的相遇。十年前分离,十年后相聚。他,步步为谋;循循善诱;她,半信半疑;身心论陷。一个回眸,一个转身,掉入他设计的温柔陷阱中。于是关于她的消息每天在他耳边响起,“请问BOSS,今天是送老板娘鲜花还是钻石?”“请问BOSS,明天是陪老板娘还是上班?”“报告BOSS,穿婚纱的老板娘和穿校服的老板娘让你选一个!”“敬爱的BOSS与老板娘公众场合能别秀了吗?”对于此,他对她始终的要求是:“你不需记住我的好,你只需记住我就好!”“做我的女人你不需太过完美!”【原则:无大虐无误会甜死人不偿命】