登陆注册
15421200000013

第13章

Analogous examples are innumerable.As I write these lines the papers are full of the story of two little girls found drowned in the Seine.These children, to begin with, were recognised in the most unmistakable manner by half a dozen witnesses.All the affirmations were in such entire concordance that no doubt remained in the mind of the juge d'instruction.He had the certificate of death drawn up, but just as the burial of the children was to have been proceeded with, a mere chance brought about the discovery that the supposed victims were alive, and had, moreover, but a remote resemblance to the drowned girls.As in several of the examples previously cited, the affirmation of the first witness, himself a victim of illusion, had sufficed to influence the other witnesses.

In parallel cases the starting-point of the suggestion is always the illusion produced in an individual by more or less vague reminiscences, contagion following as the result of the affirmation of this initial illusion.If the first observer be very impressionable, it will often be sufficient that the corpse he believes he recognises should present-- apart from all real resemblance--some peculiarity, a scar, or some detail of toilet which may evoke the idea of another person.The idea evoked may then become the nucleus of a sort of crystallisation which invades the understanding and paralyses all critical faculty.

What the observer then sees is no longer the object itself, but the image evoked in his mind.In this way are to be explained erroneous recognitions of the dead bodies of children by their own mother, as occurred in the following case, already old, but which has been recently recalled by the newspapers.In it are to be traced precisely the two kinds of suggestion of which I have just pointed out the mechanism.

"The child was recognised by another child, who was mistaken.

The series of unwarranted recognitions then began.

"An extraordinary thing occurred.The day after a schoolboy had recognised the corpse a woman exclaimed, `Good Heavens, it is my child!'

"She was taken up to the corpse; she examined the clothing, and noted a scar on the forehead.`It is certainly,' she said, `my son who disappeared last July.He has been stolen from me and murdered.'

"The woman was concierge in the Rue du Four; her name was Chavandret.Her brother-in-law was summoned, and when questioned he said, `That is the little Filibert.' Several persons living in the street recognised the child found at La Villette as Filibert Chavandret, among them being the boy's schoolmaster, who based his opinion on a medal worn by the lad.

"Nevertheless, the neighbours, the brother-in-law, the schoolmaster, and the mother were mistaken.Six weeks later the identity of the child was established.The boy, belonging to Bordeaux, had been murdered there and brought by a carrying company to Paris."[4]

[4] L'Eclair, April 21, 1895.

It will be remarked that these recognitions are most often made by women and children--that is to say, by precisely the most impressionable persons.They show us at the same time what is the worth in law courts of such witnesses.As far as children, more especially, are concerned, their statements ought never to be invoked.Magistrates are in the habit of repeating that children do not lie.Did they possess a psychological culture a little less rudimentary than is the case they would know that, on the contrary, children invariably lie; the lie is doubtless innocent, but it is none the less a lie.It would be better to decide the fate of an accused person by the toss of a coin than, as has been so often done, by the evidence of a child.

To return to the faculty of observation possessed by crowds, our conclusion is that their collective observations are as erroneous as possible, and that most often they merely represent the illusion of an individual who, by a process of contagion, has suggestioned his fellows.Facts proving that the most utter mistrust of the evidence of crowds is advisable might be multiplied to any extent.Thousands of men were present twenty-five years ago at the celebrated cavalry charge during the battle of Sedan, and yet it is impossible, in the face of the most contradictory ocular testimony, to decide by whom it was commanded.The English general, Lord Wolseley, has proved in a recent book that up to now the gravest errors of fact have been committed with regard to the most important incidents of the battle of Waterloo--facts that hundreds of witnesses had nevertheless attested.[5]

[5] Do we know in the case of one single battle exactly how it took place? I am very doubtful on the point.We know who were the conquerors and the conquered, but this is probably all.What M.D'Harcourt has said with respect to the battle of Solferino, which he witnessed and in which he was personally engaged, may be applied to all battles--"The generals (informed, of course, by the evidence of hundreds of witnesses) forward their official reports; the orderly officers modify these documents and draw up a definite narrative; the chief of the staff raises objections and re-writes the whole on a fresh basis.It is carried to the Marshal, who exclaims, `You are entirely in error,' and he substitutes a fresh edition.Scarcely anything remains of the original report." M.D'Harcourt relates this fact as proof of the impossibility of establishing the truth in connection with the most striking, the best observed events.

Such facts show us what is the value of the testimony of crowds.

同类推荐
  • Book of Pirates

    Book of Pirates

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。
  • 西藏风俗记

    西藏风俗记

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。
  • 送崔侍御之岭南二十

    送崔侍御之岭南二十

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。
  • 凤山县采访册

    凤山县采访册

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。
  • 树杞林志

    树杞林志

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。
热门推荐
  • 极品护花狂医

    极品护花狂医

    乡村高中生,意外得仙祖传承,体质强悍悟性超人……追校花,踩恶霸,纵横都市。
  • 霸道校草的独特丫头

    霸道校草的独特丫头

    这是一场由初中开始的爱恋……她与他,初一相识;初二相爱;初三因为一场误会,她心痛离开了,他也因此伤透了心。待她发现时已晚;一年后她回来与他重新开始,他又是否愿意原谅她呢?
  • 邪王独宠:废材也倾城

    邪王独宠:废材也倾城

    她乃大陆上最厉害的天才,他乃大陆上最不堪的废材。前世,他被他爱的人所害。今世,她被她最爱的人所害。一个天赋异禀的女子,一个不鸣则已一鸣惊人的皇子,命运的安排,让他们走在一起。..................“若是谁敢害你我定让他生不如死。”他站在那头,冲她喊,“我爱你,比永远还要久。”
  • 桃花笑之君若见怜时

    桃花笑之君若见怜时

    一笑倾城,再笑倾国,他的桃花一笑,倾尽她此生的爱情。世上情花万种,有一种叫生死相随。你以命殉我,我便拿命还你。“欢若见怜时,棺木为侬开”,这是柳陌上对顾怀城曾说过的一句话,当初的一句戏言,终成了柳陌上的最后的结局。多少人都期盼着人生能如初见,无奈最后只是一场锦郎薄幸!爱没有值不值得,只有愿不愿意,红尘陌上,会有人与你同行,也会有人和你走散,可以相濡以沫,也可以相忘于江湖。所以爱了就是爱了,别要天长地久,别要海枯石烂,如若真的爱,生死何惧?天下负尽又何妨!
  • 我的爷爷是特务

    我的爷爷是特务

    大部分故事情节根据真实故事改编,特务——不一定是坏人。为了重现先辈热血,小编特整理了一些发生在蒙山的抗日故事,再现先辈惨烈艰苦的一面。
  • 中二仙

    中二仙

    人间的小仙你尽力了敢站在本仙面前已经证明了你的勇气诸君可愿随本仙乘风起舞滑天下之大稽无纲亦敢成神否?
  • EXO之遇见你爱上你

    EXO之遇见你爱上你

    无意中喜欢上一首歌继而饭上那个组合,不知不觉过去四年。一次车祸,两个不同的人生就此互换。之前还要靠攒钱看演唱会才能看到的男神,现在却真是的站在了眼前。什么?和我互换了灵魂的女生居然这么有钱!哥哥居然还是......
  • 美男集结号之红尘纷飞

    美男集结号之红尘纷飞

    这是一段发生在洛阳城内一群小人物身上的故事,虽不大喜,虽耐人寻味,却是小资有趣。本文结合了穿越、男宠等等当下时尚的元素,让你瞠目结舌。她是简单的被败落的家室丢出来的千金小姐,在他的娇生惯养下,越发胆大妄为。却又不知如何成为当今的泰安公主,进入一段又一段荒谬的圈套谎言中,无力抽身,只得沉陷。他是她捡来的所谓的小弟,却被她视为生命至宝,失去便如同失去呼吸。可是奈何身份无奈,终得离开,负她一生,却又许她一生,痴痴等了一生。他是身份不明的乐师,仿佛事事都有他掺足,他在想,若不是遇见她,也许自己这一生一定过得安逸快活,可偏命运弄人,她是他心上的朱砂痣,为她拆了自己的步步为营,深陷险境,只为爱她。
  • 万甲之王

    万甲之王

    一个废材少年,遇到一个落魄的太古神兽,从此他的命运被彻底改写。修炼王功,身披神甲,凭借一身惊世猛力,战遍地海空三界!
  • 能受委屈,才是大才

    能受委屈,才是大才

    本书运用富有人生哲理的论述以及大量日常生活与工作中鲜活的事例,围绕如何战胜挫折与困苦以及受得了委屈是获取成功的重要因素展开详细的论述,向读者深刻地揭示了“能受委屈,才是人才”的主旨,从而使读者用平和的心态以及顽强的精神战胜人生中的一切困苦,成为真正的“人才”。