登陆注册
15416700000085

第85章

The same caution should be observed in construing the terms of an agreement.It is hard to see the propriety of erecting any detriment which an instrument may disclose or provide for, into a consideration, unless the parties have dealt with it on that footing.In many cases a promisee may incur a detriment without thereby furnishing a consideration.The detriment may be nothing but a condition precedent to performance of the promise, as where a man promises another to pay him five hundred dollars if he breaks his leg. The courts, however, have gone far towards obliterating this distinction.Acts which by a fair interpretation of language would seem to have been contemplated as only the compliance with a condition, have been treated as the consideration of the promise. And so have counter promises in an agreement which expressly stated other matters as the consideration. So it should be mentioned, subject to the question whether there may not be a special explanation for the doctrine, that it is said that an assignment of a leasehold cannot be voluntary under the statute of 27 Elizabeth, c.4, because the assignee comes into the obligations of the tenant. Yet the assignee's incurring this detriment may not be contemplated as the inducement of the assignment, and in many cases only amounts to a deduction from the benefit conferred, as a right of way would be, especially if the only obligation is to pay rent, which issues out of the land in theory of law.

But although the courts may have sometimes gone a little far in their anxiety to sustain agreements, there can be no doubt of the Principle which I have laid down, that the same thing may be a consideration or not, as it is dealt with by the parties.This raises the question how a thing must be dealt with, in order to make it a consideration.

It is said that consideration must not be confounded with motive.

It is true that it must not be confounded with what may be the prevailing or chief motive in actual fact.A man may promise to paint a picture for five hundred dollars, while his chief motive may be a desire for fame.A consideration may be given and accepted, in fact, solely for the purpose of making a promise binding.But, nevertheless, it is the essence of a consideration, that, by the terms of the agreement, it is given and accepted as the motive or inducement of the promise.Conversely, the promise must be made and accepted as the conventional motive or inducement for furnishing the consideration.The root of the whole matter is the relation of reciprocal conventional inducement, each for the other, between consideration and promise.

A good example of the former branch of the proposition is to be found in a Massachusetts case.The plaintiff refused to let certain wood be removed from his land by one who had made an oral bargain and given his note for it, unless he received additional security.The purchaser and the plaintiff accordingly went to the defendant, and the defendant put his name upon the note.The plaintiff thereupon let the purchaser carry off the wood.But, according to the testimony, the defendant signed without knowing that the plaintiff was to alter his position in any way on the faith of the signature, and it was held that, if that story was believed, there was no consideration. An illustration of the other half of the rule is to be found in those cases where a reward is offered for doing something, which is afterwards done by a person acting in ignorance of the offer.

In such a case the reward cannot be claimed, because the alleged consideration has not been furnished on the faith of the offer.

The tendered promise has not induced the furnishing of the consideration.The promise cannot be set up as a conventional motive when it was not known until after the alleged consideration was performed. Both sides of the relation between consideration and promise, and the conventional nature of that relation, may be illustrated by the case of the cask.Suppose that the truckman is willing to carry the cask, and the owner to let him carry it, without any bargain, and that each knows the other's state of mind; but that the truckman, seeing his own advantage in the matter, says to the owner, "In consideration of your delivering me the cask, and letting me carry it, I promise to carry it," and that the owner thereupon delivers it.I suppose that the promise would be binding.The promise is offered in terms as the inducement for the delivery, and the delivery is made in terms as the inducement for the promise.It may be very probable that the delivery would have been made without a promise, and that the promise would have been made in gratuitous form if it had not been accepted upon consideration; but this is only a guess after all.The delivery need not have been made unless the owner chose, and having been made as the term of a bargain, the promisor cannot set up what might have happened to destroy the effect of what did happen.It would seem therefore that the same transaction in substance and spirit might be voluntary or obligatory, according to the form of words which the parties chose to employ for the purpose of affecting the legal consequences.

同类推荐
热门推荐
  • 爱情公寓之第5季

    爱情公寓之第5季

    一菲和小贤的爱情何去何从?关谷和悠悠是否能顺利结婚?美嘉和吕子乔欢喜冤家能否修成正果?张伟何时摆脱单身?展博宛瑜何时回来?敬请期待。。。。。。
  • 乘风传

    乘风传

    谁说凡人注定受神的主宰,他目睹了太多人间的困苦,百思不得其解为何神灵能移天换海,却不肯给众生减轻一点点的灾祸,若是神灵要用痛苦来统治苍生,那么神灵的存在又有何意义?若是万千生灵终其一生只能被神灵玩弄于鼓掌之间,那么,就逆天吧!宋乘风因不满神灵布下的腐朽秩序,大战天帝,最后相差一招,败于天帝之手,而后神魂转世到云轩城一位纨绔少爷的身上,从而开始逆天弑神的道路
  • 卯上下堂妃

    卯上下堂妃

    再怎么说,自己身前也是一个美女,可是,为何却要穿越到一个身有残疾,还面带疤痕的王妃身上。原以为,遇到了一个面容俊美,温柔如水的夫君,却不想他是一只披着羊皮的狼。她木莲,当朝的轩王妃,被华丽丽的下了堂,成了一个连名分都没有的弃妃!为了再度的华丽脱变,她白天是轩王府新过门的聋哑妃,受尽王爷的冷落和其他姬妾的嘲讽。晚上,她薄纱遮面,宛若一朵罂粟,沾手入毒。她说,“这一耳光,是让你记住我的名字!木莲,莲花的莲。”她说,“只有两种人才能摘我面纱,死人和我的夫君。”她说,“王爷你不过是我丢弃的残次品。”——————————————————————致颜绯色:初见他时,雾雨涟涟,一把油纸伞,一抹绰约红影,便妖媚横生。再见他时,歌舞缭绕,一把琵琶,一抹瑰丽绯色,那一回首,美得潋滟旖旎。<踏莎行>卿卿唧唧一朝穿,遇此真身不得愿;羞辱奚落岂吾辈,朝妇夕姬、踏雪寻梅声鹊起云破月来花弄影,绯莲相思不得识,倾世容颜倾世情,朱颜难改;惟愿相思是良人,奈何流水落花最难全!——(感谢土豆童鞋的词。)*********************************************猫的群,欢迎加入94916270(满)17675875(满)94970406(满)
  • 无常天

    无常天

    一个被转化为亡灵的人,他的命运将会怎样,是欢笑还是泪水。他是否会用手中的剑斩断命运的轮回,斩断那深深的羁绊。本书慢热,但我想我会讲出一个让大家满意的故事。解释下笔名,在此怀念令人尊敬的左光斗和杨涟先人,他们曾面对权势毫不低头,用自己的生命诠释了中国人的脊梁。
  • 开到荼蘼花事了

    开到荼蘼花事了

    最好的爱情,不过我爱你,你爱我,只是在我爱你的时候,凑巧你也爱我,这是谈何容易?爱情里,有一个人置身事外,有一个人飞蛾扑火,有一个人将错就错,还有一个人情意绵绵,太多太多,只希望,在一切结束的时候,你还有我,他还有她,我们还相爱,他们没分开。错乱的爱情,谁拯救谁于花间……
  • 经典古诗文800句新解

    经典古诗文800句新解

    本书共收录中国历史上经典古诗、词、文800句,并将其分为生命真谛、修身养性、求知治学、感情世界、养生舰体五大部分,每一部分又分为若干小专题,每句均有译文和新颖的解析。书中还收录了温家宝总理自2003年起在不同场合的公开讲话、讲演引用的部分古诗词文名句,并加以详细说明。
  • 武极乾坤变

    武极乾坤变

    这里没有绚丽的斗气。也没有霸气的武魂。只有淬炼身体达至极限,挣脱桎梏,破碎虚空,立于九天之上。乱世九州,强者如云,为你诠释神之所以为神,人之所以为人!
  • 未来战争o

    未来战争o

    虽然当今世界和平安康,但强者的野心应不停息,在未来,他们又会有怎样的战争
  • 捡回的忧伤

    捡回的忧伤

    《中国小小说名家档案》百部小小说名家出版工程,旨在打造文体,推崇作家,推出精品。集结杨晓敏、许行、聂鑫森、孙方友、孙春平、刘国芳、谢志强、陈毓、周海亮、海飞、曾颖等当代小小说最华丽的作家阵容和最具经典意味的力作新作,由100名小小说名家一人一册单行本(共100册)组成,兼容不同年龄不同区域不同流派不同内容不同风格,是当代文学史上第一个小小说的系统出版工程,是广大读者特别是青少年读者认识社会人生、充实人文精神,提升文化素养,增强写作能力的最佳读本。
  • 大帝尊皇

    大帝尊皇

    赢竹看着跪在自己面前的二皇弟,笑道:“为什么我会成为皇储?因为我是天生命格与灵魂中的高贵,而你们,不过是血统传承罢了。王朝会因你们而衰败!”普天之下,莫非王土!率土之滨,莫非王臣!