登陆注册
15400000000047

第47章

We must, therefore, turn to the question, what is the manner of their generation from one another? Is it as Empedocles and Democritus say, or as those who resolve bodies into planes say, or is there yet another possibility? (1) What the followers of Empedocles do, though without observing it themselves, is to reduce the generation of elements out of one another to an illusion.They make it a process of excretion from a body of what was in it all the time-as though generation required a vessel rather than a material-so that it involves no change of anything.And even if this were accepted, there are other implications equally unsatisfactory.We do not expect a mass of matter to be made heavier by compression.But they will be bound to maintain this, if they say that water is a body present in air and excreted from air, since air becomes heavier when it turns into water.Again, when the mixed body is divided, they can show no reason why one of the constituents must by itself take up more room than the body did: but when water turns into air, the room occupied is increased.The fact is that the finer body takes up more room, as is obvious in any case of transformation.As the liquid is converted into vapour or air the vessel which contains it is often burst because it does not contain room enough.Now, if there is no void at all, and if, as those who take this view say, there is no expansion of bodies, the impossibility of this is manifest: and if there is void and expansion, there is no accounting for the fact that the body which results from division cfpies of necessity a greater space.It is inevitable, too, that generation of one out of another should come to a stop, since a finite quantum cannot contain an infinity of finite quanta.When earth produces water something is taken away from the earth, for the process is one of excretion.The same thing happens again when the residue produces water.But this can only go on for ever, if the finite body contains an infinity, which is impossible.Therefore the generation of elements out of one another will not always continue.

(2) We have now explained that the mutual transformations of the elements cannot take place by means of excretion.The remaining alternative is that they should be generated by changing into one another.And this in one of two ways, either by change of shape, as the same wax takes the shape both of a sphere and of a cube, or, as some assert, by resolution into planes.(a) Generation by change of shape would necessarily involve the assertion of atomic bodies.For if the particles were divisible there would be a part of fire which was not fire and a part of earth which was not earth, for the reason that not every part of a pyramid is a pyramid nor of a cube a cube.

But if (b) the process is resolution into planes, the first difficulty is that the elements cannot all be generated out of one another.

This they are obliged to assert, and do assert.It is absurd, because it is unreasonable that one element alone should have no part in the transformations, and also contrary to the observed data of sense, according to which all alike change into one another.In fact their explanation of the observations is not consistent with the observations.And the reason is that their ultimate principles are wrongly assumed: they had certain predetermined views, and were resolved to bring everything into line with them.It seems that perceptible things require perceptible principles, eternal things eternal principles, corruptible things corruptible principles; and, in general, every subject matter principles homogeneous with itself.

But they, owing to their love for their principles, fall into the attitude of men who undertake the defence of a position in argument.

In the confidence that the principles are true they are ready to accept any consequence of their application.As though some principles did not require to be judged from their results, and particularly from their final issue! And that issue, which in the case of productive knowledge is the product, in the knowledge of nature is the unimpeachable evidence of the senses as to each fact.

The result of their view is that earth has the best right to the name element, and is alone indestructible; for that which is indissoluble is indestructible and elementary, and earth alone cannot be dissolved into any body but itself.Again, in the case of those elements which do suffer dissolution, the 'suspension' of the triangles is unsatisfactory.But this takes place whenever one is dissolved into another, because of the numerical inequality of the triangles which compose them.Further, those who hold these views must needs suppose that generation does not start from a body.For what is generated out of planes cannot be said to have been generated from a body.And they must also assert that not all bodies are divisible, coming thus into conflict with our most accurate sciences, namely the mathematical, which assume that even the intelligible is divisible, while they, in their anxiety to save their hypothesis, cannot even admit this of every perceptible thing.

For any one who gives each element a shape of its own, and makes this the ground of distinction between the substances, has to attribute to them indivisibility; since division of a pyramid or a sphere must leave somewhere at least a residue which is not sphere or a pyramid.Either, then, a part of fire is not fire, so that there is a body prior to the element-for every body is either an element or composed of elements-or not every body is divisible.

同类推荐
热门推荐
  • 福妻驾到

    福妻驾到

    现代饭店彪悍老板娘魂穿古代。不分是非的极品婆婆?三年未归生死不明的丈夫?心狠手辣的阴毒亲戚?贪婪而好色的地主老财?吃上顿没下顿的贫困宭境?不怕不怕,神仙相助,一技在手,天下我有!且看现代张悦娘,如何身带福气玩转古代,开面馆、收小弟、左纳财富,右傍美男,共绘幸福生活大好蓝图!!!!快本新书《天媒地聘》已经上架开始销售,只要3.99元即可将整本书抱回家,你还等什么哪,赶紧点击下面的直通车,享受乐乐精心为您准备的美食盛宴吧!)
  • 诅咒面具

    诅咒面具

    无论你是平凡或者伟大,在生命中,总会遇到各种选择。有时,你会为了做正确的选择拍手庆幸;有时,却又为错误的选择后悔不已。不管怎样,这都是由你自己决定,喜悦或痛苦都由你来承担。但是当你遇到一生中最重要的选择,你必须做出正确的的决定,因为它不但能改变你的命运,甚至会改变整个世界。
  • 王俊凯之星空闪烁

    王俊凯之星空闪烁

    新书发布《捞个男票会天庭》,欢迎入坑。女孩看着眼前的某凯“我发现你好傻啊”“哪有?”“我发现你好2啊”“哪有?”“我发现你应该是我的”“不是应该,是肯定”某兮一脸黑线
  • 重生之魔女倾天下

    重生之魔女倾天下

    她,来自异世的废柴公主。他,邻国的体弱王爷。当废柴公主和体弱王爷在一起会发生什么?当废柴公主灵魂换了以后,体弱王爷卸下伪装后又会发生什么?
  • 重阳分梨十化集

    重阳分梨十化集

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。
  • 诗经里的植物

    诗经里的植物

    认识《诗经》里的植物,能够让人不经意间想象出中华文明曾经生成的场所:心里的一爱一恨、容颜里的一擦一笑、山风里的一呼一吸、雪雨中的一飘一落,虽然已 经相隔两千多年,伴随这样的心路历程,让我对生活于其中的家乡土地、山、河流,比所看的,要更为厚重,更为缥缈,更为神秘。因此,在这种亲切感里,爱的心也更真实一些。
  • 邪王宠妃:腹黑爷的废材妃

    邪王宠妃:腹黑爷的废材妃

    她前世是一名特工,遭爱人伤害,一朝穿越成了小小的丞相之女,但也凭着自己前世的经验创建一个组织。无意中遇到了腹黑睿智的邪王,两人又会擦出怎样的火花?命运多舛,两人最后会在一起吗?
  • 我的23岁美女房客

    我的23岁美女房客

    你想杀我,对不起,十个顶级杀手正向你狂奔而去;你想追求我,大姐,我这里有校花一打,你自认比得过谁?你富甲天下,好吧,这个我比不过。不过,我瞧你印堂发黑,三日内必有血光之灾,想逆天改命吗?拿一半财富出来,我助你长命百岁,仙福永享!
  • 现实生活中要懂的人脉操纵术

    现实生活中要懂的人脉操纵术

    本书内容除讲述人脉的建立、深度开发、维护等常识外,还包含心理学、营销学和哲学、礼仪文化等方面的知识,以生动具体的实例,重点阐释了构建人脉的意义、理念、方法和实战技巧。这些方法和技巧能够帮助我们结识工作中的亲密挚友,赢得领导的青睐,创造惊人的业绩,最终借助人脉杠杆的力量撬开自己的财富之门。
  • Hail神盾局

    Hail神盾局

    变种人VS异人族,哪边看起来更酷更炫?万磁王对战反磁力钢铁侠,谁更有把握?性别男爱好女的小蜘蛛遇上双性恋的某死侍,求观众们的心理阴影?还有旧九头蛇、新九头蛇的争端,真神盾局、假神盾局等乱象,外星人与地球人的to-be-or-not-to-be,到底会玩出怎样的火花?作者君也不知道,你呢?