登陆注册
15399500000026

第26章

It is evident also how one should solve those refutations that depend upon the division and combination of words: for if the expression means something different when divided and when combined, as soon as one's opponent draws his conclusion one should take the expression in the contrary way.All such expressions as the following depend upon the combination or division of the words: 'Was Xbeing beaten with that with which you saw him being beaten?' and 'Did you see him being beaten with that with which he was being beaten?' This fallacy has also in it an element of amphiboly in the questions, but it really depends upon combination.For the meaning that depends upon the division of the words is not really a double meaning (for the expression when divided is not the same), unless also the word that is pronounced, according to its breathing, as eros and eros is a case of double meaning.(In writing, indeed, a word is the same whenever it is written of the same letters and in the same manner- and even there people nowadays put marks at the side to show the pronunciation- but the spoken words are not the same.)Accordingly an expression that depends upon division is not an ambiguous one.It is evident also that not all refutations depend upon ambiguity as some people say they do.

The answerer, then, must divide the expression: for 'I-saw-a-man-being-beaten with my eyes' is not the same as to say 'Isaw a man being-beaten-with-my-eyes'.Also there is the argument of Euthydemus proving 'Then you know now in Sicily that there are triremes in Piraeus': and again, 'Can a good man who is a cobbler be bad?' 'No.' 'But a good man may be a bad cobbler: therefore a good cobbler will be bad.' Again, 'Things the knowledge of which is good, are good things to learn, aren't they?' 'Yes.' 'The knowledge, however, of evil is good: therefore evil is a good thing to know.'

'Yes.But, you see, evil is both evil and a thing-to-learn, so that evil is an evil-thing-to-learn, although the knowledge of evils is good.' Again, 'Is it true to say in the present moment that you are born?' 'Yes.' 'Then you are born in the present moment.' 'No; the expression as divided has a different meaning: for it is true to say-in-the-present-moment that "you are born", but not "You are born-in-the-present-moment".' Again, 'Could you do what you can, and as you can?' 'Yes.' 'But when not harping, you have the power to harp:

and therefore you could harp when not harping.' 'No: he has not the power to harp-while-not-harping; merely, when he is not doing it, he has the power to do it.' Some people solve this last refutation in another way as well.For, they say, if he has granted that he can do anything in the way he can, still it does not follow that he can harp when not harping: for it has not been granted that he will do anything in every way in which he can; and it is not the same thing'

to do a thing in the way he can' and 'to do it in every way in which he can'.But evidently they do not solve it properly: for of arguments that depend upon the same point the solution is the same, whereas this will not fit all cases of the kind nor yet all ways of putting the questions: it is valid against the questioner, but not against his argument.

同类推荐
热门推荐
  • 至尊修神系统

    至尊修神系统

    秦天裕意外穿越,得到了神秘系统。从此走上人生巅峰。不会修炼?没有关系,我有系统。没有修炼资源?没有关系,我有系统。总之,没有什么是系统解决不了的。
  • 回忆也曾杀过人

    回忆也曾杀过人

    曾经就像一场走过了场的旅程,没到达谢幕的人,在拼命的奔跑找寻那个给过它生命鲜活的人。回忆曾救过命,给奄奄一息的人制造生还的机会会,回忆也曾杀过人?,给活蹦乱跳的心捅过刀子,留下弑血的身心加疲惫。回忆它也曾以宽恕的口吻下令给走不出来的人不予追究的责任,要有多残忍,就有多不仁。
  • 7622

    7622

    一步一步接近战争,才会一点一点明白战争。
  • TFBOYS之莫承诺

    TFBOYS之莫承诺

    凯洛――“去旅游吧。”――“去哪?”――“你心里。”――“你一直都在我心里啊。”玺诺――“玺欢玺欢,比天空还远的是什么?”――“是星星。”――“那……比星星还远的呢?”――“是你。”源沫――“学长,你懂不懂有借有还这个道理啊?”――“懂啊。”――“那么还我的喜欢和爱呢?”
  • 喋血金丹

    喋血金丹

    元朝道教真人陈致虚,有长生不老金丹留存于世。本文讲述了陈致虚的后人陈玉蟾的奇诡经历,故事从一本残缺的《金丹大要》开始。
  • 勘探手记

    勘探手记

    一直以来我都在想,要不要写这个故事。或许随着我将来老去它将逐渐成为一个不为人知的永久秘密。但经过深思熟虑后,最终我还是决定把它公布出来,希望能为将来有幸再发现那里的后人提供一些宝贵的参考。
  • 湘西赶尸鬼事之迎喜神

    湘西赶尸鬼事之迎喜神

    湘西赶尸、衡阳害手、苗族蛊女、炒骷算命、犀照、阴刀,你知道或者不知道的民间异术,你想到或者想不到的道教玄术,跟着本书,走进全新世界,体验前所未有的刺激
  • 呆萌路痴:帝少我害怕

    呆萌路痴:帝少我害怕

    单纯如她,遇到了自己生命中的傲娇王子,从此就过上了为他洗手作羹汤的生活,奈何她是一个路痴!每次出去都会让他陪着。“夕儿,你在那儿?”电话中传来男人急躁的声音。接电话的某个女人望了望身边的高楼大厦,很无辜的眨眨眼睛,“然,我也不知道在哪里,这里全是小区!”“站在那里别动,我马上来!”“那你快点我怕!”
  • 亲亲我的呆萌娇夫

    亲亲我的呆萌娇夫

    她的眼里的那团火焰正在燃烧,强大的王者风范仿佛是与之俱学的,好像天生生活在镜头的闪光灯下的。她,一个被抛弃的小孩,渴望被人疼爱,却换来了一次又一次的欺骗。他,帅气温柔,却只对她一个人好。当一座大冰山遇上一朵棉花糖,他们之间的结局会是什么呢?
  • 弥镜之九狸

    弥镜之九狸

    终于到了弥镜,九狸看着那朱红色的门。这个约定究竟是什么?让我如此执念的一定要来这里。而这里等我的约定又是什么。主人公九狸一只猫妖在春秋战国那个动荡的年代又是有了怎样的经历?这个一路同行的浪荡的公子哥看起来不是那么靠谱!公子哥的妹妹,请不要那么花痴!一只纠结的猫;一个浪荡的公子哥;一个花痴的姑娘。这三人同行必是精彩万分………………