登陆注册
15339200000048

第48章 Fallacies

Right understanding consists in the discovery and adherence to truth,and that in the perception of the visible or probable agreement or disagreement of ideas as they are affirmed and denied one of another.From whence it is evident that the right use and conduct of the understanding,w hose business is purely truth and nothing else,is that the mind should be kept in a perfect indifference,not inclining to either side any further than evidence settles it by knowledge or the over-balance of probability gives it the turn of assent and belief;but yet it is very hard to meet with any discourse wherein one may not perceive the author not only maintain (for that is reasonable and fit),but inclined and biased to one side of the question With marks of a desire that should be true.

If it be asked me how authors who have such a bias and lean to it may be discovered,I answer,by observing how in their Writings or arguings they are often led by their inclinations to change the ideas of the question,either by changing the terms or by adding and joining others to them,whereby the ideas under consideration are so varied as to be more serviceable to their purpose and to be thereby brought to an easier and nearer agreement or more visible and remoter disagreement one with another.This is plain and direct sophistry;but I am far from thinking that,wherever it is found,it is made use of with design to deceive and mislead the readers.

It is visible that men's prejudices and inclinations by this way impose often upon themselves;and their affection for truth,under their prepossession in favor of one side,is the very thing that leads them from it.Inclination suggests and slides into their discourse favorable terms which introduce favorable ideas,till at last by this means that is concluded clear and evident,thus dressed up,which taken in its native state,by making use of none but the precise determined ideas,would find no admittance at all.

The putting these glosses on what they affirm,these (as they are thought)handsome,easy and graceful explications of what they are discoursing on,is so much the character of what is called and esteemed writing well,that it is very hard to think that authors will ever be persuaded to leave what serves so well to propagate their opinions and procure themselves credit in the world for a more jejune and dry way of writing,by keeping to the same terms precisely annexed to the same ideas,a sour and blunt stiffness tolerable in mathematicians only,who force their way and make truth prevail by irresistible demonstration.

But yet,if authors cannot be prevailed with to quit the looser,though more insinuating,ways of writing,if they will not think fit to keep close to truth and instruction by unvaried terms and plain unsophisticated arguments,yet it concerns readers not to be imposed on by fallacies and the prevailing ways of insinuation.To do this,the surest and most effectual remedy is to fix in the mind the clear and distinct ideas of the question stripped of words;and so likewise in the train of argumentation,to take up the author's ideas,neglecting his words,observing how they connect or separate those in the question.He that does this will be able to cast off all that is superfluous;he will see what is pertinent,what coherent,what is direct to,what slides by the question.This will readily show him all the foreign ideas in the discourse and where they were brought in;and though they perhaps dazzled the writer,yet he will perceive that they give no light nor strength to his reasonings.

This,though it be the shortest and easiest way of reading books with profit and keeping oneself from being misled by great names or plausible discourses,yet,it being hard and tedious to those who have not accustomed themselves to it,it is not to be expected that everyone (amongst those few who really pursue truth)should this way guard his understanding from being imposed on by the willful or at least undesigned sophistry which creeps into most of the books of argument.They that write against their conviction or that,next to them,are resolved to maintain the tenets of a party they are engaged in cannot be supposed to reject any arms that may help to defend their cause,and therefore such should be read with the greatest caution.And they who write for opinions they are sincerely persuaded of and believe to be true think they may so far allow themselves to indulge their laudable affection to truth as to permit their esteem of it to give it the best colors and set it off with the best expressions and dress they can,thereby to gain it the easiest entrance into the minds of their readers and fix it deepest there.

One of those being the state of mind we may justly suppose most writers to be in,it is fit their readers,who apply to them for instruction,should not lay by that caution which becomes a sincere pursuit of truth,and should make them always watchful against whatever might conceal or misrepresent it.If they have not the skill of representing to themselves the author's sense by pure ideas separated from sounds and thereby divested of the false lights and deceitful ornaments of speech,this yet they should do:they should keep the precise question steadily in their minds,carry it along Faith them through the whole discourse,and suffer not the least alteration in the terms either by addition,subtraction or substituting any other.This everyone can do who has a mind to it;and he that has not a mind to it,it is plain makes his understanding only the warehouse of other men's lumber?Imean false and unconcluding reasonings,rather than a repository of truth for his own use,which will prove substantial and stand him in stead when he has occasion for it.And whether such a one deals fairly by his own mind and conducts his own understanding right,I leave to his own understanding to judge.

同类推荐
热门推荐
  • 浮幽

    浮幽

    我,有属于我的世界。在众多天才之中,他年少成名,演绎着一场关于他的传奇。跳出三界,不在五行。他的名,仍让天下震惊。
  • 男主不按剧本演

    男主不按剧本演

    虽然一直都很清楚自己穿的这本书是披着励志文皮的种马文,担当真正的接触这匹种马时,连月开始迟疑了,这真的是种马文么?真的好像励志文啊。就算是马,也应该是千里马或赤兔啊。
  • 福妻驾到

    福妻驾到

    现代饭店彪悍老板娘魂穿古代。不分是非的极品婆婆?三年未归生死不明的丈夫?心狠手辣的阴毒亲戚?贪婪而好色的地主老财?吃上顿没下顿的贫困宭境?不怕不怕,神仙相助,一技在手,天下我有!且看现代张悦娘,如何身带福气玩转古代,开面馆、收小弟、左纳财富,右傍美男,共绘幸福生活大好蓝图!!!!快本新书《天媒地聘》已经上架开始销售,只要3.99元即可将整本书抱回家,你还等什么哪,赶紧点击下面的直通车,享受乐乐精心为您准备的美食盛宴吧!)
  • tfboys之两个十年之约

    tfboys之两个十年之约

    那一年,我们约定十年相伴,有一个人,她住在王俊凯的心里,这也是属于他们的十年之约。
  • 水滴的无限旅程

    水滴的无限旅程

    “唔,怎么有人从楼上扔砖头?哎!那边那个戴眼镜的小弟弟你滑板滑那么快容易摔倒!小心啊!哎~现在的年轻人。”随手扔掉手里的铅块走向毛利侦探事务所。“喵帕斯!”小女孩高高伸出右手打招呼。“喵,喵帕斯。”怎么回事?!乱入?!左拂尘右飞剑,八荣八耻记心间,三观正,六识全,山居道士抱枕眠,离尘世,话机缘,何不抿心问道源,千年修得此道机,不窥天道莫伦长辞于世间。道不在肉胎五形,四肢百骸,何处求之?呜呼哀哉,你且看!
  • 沐沐含情之暖冬

    沐沐含情之暖冬

    父亲早年的一段风流史,便有了和家人貌合神离的易奥。特殊的身份和童年的经历,让他早年老成,喜怒不形于色,他和同父异母的大哥矛盾重重,互相防备,并莫名卷入一场凶杀案。他冷漠、隐忍,曾经二十几年里,都在大哥和名义上的母亲的刁难里步步退让,默默承受,直到,他遇见江小左……
  • 奇奇怪怪闯江湖

    奇奇怪怪闯江湖

    邢周大地,北武当山,太极宗师张三丰曾来此处传道,恰逢一野猪偷听,得窥天道,身体四肢幻化为人形,只剩头颅部分,未能幻化成功。不料惊吓到从此经过的商旅,新上任的县官为了政绩,派出衙役们四处捕杀野猪,野猪精的孩子都被捕杀而亡,野猪精凶性大发,大闹邢周城,县官被吓死。此事传到张三丰耳中,张三丰收伏了野猪精,镇压在北武当山中。千年以后,一个名叫王鼎奇的男孩,一泡童子尿解了符篆,野猪精趁机脱逃,组建獠牙帮,发誓要掀起血雨腥风,报仇雪恨。王鼎奇得到张三丰托弟子玄怪子送来的宝书,两人奇遇连连,但面对修炼千年的野猪精,他们还是道行太浅,连遭挫折,如何战胜野猪精,成为他们似乎不可完成的任务。
  • 异族恋之狐狸的独家宠物

    异族恋之狐狸的独家宠物

    妖妖这个文是从今生写的哦不喜欢主角进展缓慢和虐恋的就不要点进来看了但是妖妖可以保证结局是完美的我是一只猫妖有一天一只狐狸跑过来要跟我成亲我不喜欢他的狐狸眼还没有猫族男子的一半好看于是我说我只会嫁个仙人之后我就见不到他了我以为他放弃了可是...千年后...那只小狐狸真的成为了仙人而我早已是猫族的皇后他怨我不等他怨我无情可是那只小狐狸从来不知道我为了他背叛了所有人
  • 星耀之主

    星耀之主

    一道锁链,锁成一世羁绊。一抹执念,化成一生牵挂。他因雷而死,得以穿越,却又因雷而生,习得上古大能之法,从此一飞冲天。魔域魔塔之巅,他傲然而立,邪界邪之圣地,他啸声震天。一个不甘平凡的少年,为了一生承诺,一世羁绊,谱写出一个时代的传奇,成就了一个联盟的时代。
  • 青辰公元

    青辰公元

    每个人都在成长的路上不断地跌倒,然后爬起来,再跌倒,再爬起来,直到你买了车~~~~~~