登陆注册
14830800000015

第15章 CAPITAL PUNISHMENT(7)

Thus, Lord Ellenborough, in 1820, anticipated the worst effects from there being no punishment of death for stealing five shillings worth of wet linen from a bleaching ground. Thus the Solicitor General, in 1830, advocated the punishment of death for forgery, and "the satisfaction of thinking" in the teeth of mountains of evidence from bankers and other injured parties (one thousand bankers alone!)

"that he was deterring persons from the commission of crime, by the severity of the law". Thus, Mr. Justice Coleridge delivered his charge at Hertford in 1845. Thus there were in the criminal code of England, in 1790, one hundred and sixty crimes punishable with death. Thus the lawyer has said, again and again, in his generation, that any change in such a state of things "must needs bring the weal-public into jeopardy and hazard". And thus he has, all through the dismal history, "shaked his head, and made a wry mouth, and held his peace". Except--a glorious exception!--when such lawyers as Bacon, More, Blackstone, Romilly, and--let us ever gratefully remember--in later times Mr. Basil Montagu, have striven, each in his day, within the utmost limits of the endurance of the mistaken feeling of the people or the legislature of the time, to champion and maintain the truth.

There is another and a stronger reason still, why a criminal judge is a bad witness in favour of the punishment of Death. He is a chief actor in the terrible drama of a trial, where the life or death of a fellow creature is at issue. No one who has seen such a trial can fail to know, or can ever forget, its intense interest. I

care not how painful this interest is to the good, wise judge upon the bench. I admit its painful nature, and the judge's goodness and wisdom to the fullest extent--but I submit that his prominent share in the excitement of such a trial, and the dread mystery involved, has a tendency to bewilder and confuse the judge upon the general subject of that penalty. I know the solemn pause before the verdict, the bush and stifling of the fever in the court, the solitary figure brought back to the bar, and standing there, observed of all the outstretched heads and gleaming eyes, to be next minute stricken dead as one may say, among them. I know the thrill that goes round when the black cap is put on, and how there will be shrieks among the women, and a taking out of some one in a swoon;

and, when the judge's faltering voice delivers sentence, how awfully the prisoner and he confront each other; two mere men, destined one day, however far removed from one another at this time, to stand alike as suppliants at the bar of God. I know all this, I can imagine what the office of the judge costs in this execution of it;

but I say that in these strong sensations he is lost, and is unable to abstract the penalty as a preventive or example, from an experience of it, and from associations surrounding it, which are and can be, only his, and his alone.

Not to contend that there is no amount of wig or ermine that can change the nature of the man inside; not to say that the nature of a judge may be, like the dyer's hand, subdued to what it works in, and may become too used to this punishment of death to consider it quite dispassionately; not to say that it may possibly be inconsistent to have, deciding as calm authorities in favour of death, judges who have been constantly sentencing to death;--I contend that for the reasons I have stated alone, a judge, and especially a criminal judge, is a bad witness for the punishment but an excellent witness against it, inasmuch as in the latter case his conviction of its inutility has been so strong and paramount as utterly to beat down and conquer these adverse incidents. I have no scruple in stating this position, because, for anything I know, the majority of excellent judges now on the bench may have overcome them, and may be opposed to the punishment of Death under any circumstances.

I mentioned that I would devote a portion of this letter to a few prominent illustrations of each head of objection to the punishment of Death. Those on record are so very numerous that selection is extremely difficult; but in reference to the possibility of mistake, and the impossibility of reparation, one case is as good (I should rather say as bad) as a hundred; and if there were none but Eliza Fenning's, that would be sufficient. Nay, if there were none at all, it would be enough to sustain this objection, that men of finite and limited judgment do inflict, on testimony which admits of doubt, an infinite and irreparable punishment. But there are on record numerous instances of mistake; many of them very generally known and immediately recognisable in the following summary, which I

copy from the New York Report already referred to.

同类推荐
热门推荐
  • 恶魔boss:宝贝你敢逃

    恶魔boss:宝贝你敢逃

    他来自一个神秘的世界,他是那里的王者,主宰一切,却为了她抛下一切,来到现代这个陌生的世界,只为给她创建一个世界,只为一个迟来的拥抱。她宁家从小快乐无忧的小公主,本以为五年前认识他会是这辈子最让她惊奇与惊喜的一件事,谁知这却只是冰山一角。在那场惊动世界,史无前例的订婚典礼上,女主角却神秘失踪,男主角异常的冷静,没人知道原因。“轩哥哥,婚礼会不会很久啊~试婚纱好累啊…...”撒娇的话语仿佛还在耳边~千年的守护换来的究竟是爱人的拥抱,还是又一次的分离……
  • 提剑斩天

    提剑斩天

    仙道渺茫,路在何方,以血为引,以魂指路。心之所向,剑破苍茫天道崩殂,升仙无路。吾欲登天,谁人敢阻。
  • 我在你世界的另一边

    我在你世界的另一边

    一对青梅竹马与另一对两小无猜,他们在错过与被错过中成长,在爱与被爱中遗憾。人性的弱点与感情想碰撞,战胜的到底是哪一方?当两对排除千难万阻在一起时,到底发生了什么让几个人各安天涯?我以为你在地球的南极,而你却去了北极。歉疚的感情不是爱,我们不能让时间荒芜。能陪在你身边分享你的一切喜怒哀乐,对于我,足矣。有你存在的天涯,没我继续的海角。只要你还在,我就继续爱。
  • 世界在变小与现代交通(新编科技知识全书)

    世界在变小与现代交通(新编科技知识全书)

    面对浩瀚广阔的科普知识领域,编者将科普类的内容归纳总结,精心编纂了一套科普类图书,使读者能够更全面、更深入的了解科普知识,以便解开心中的种种谜团。阅读本套图书,犹如聆听智者的教诲,让读者在轻松之余获得更加全面深刻的理论教育,使自己的思想更严谨,更无懈可击。相信每一个看过这套书的读者都会为之受益。
  • 虚无灭世决

    虚无灭世决

    混沌分五行,五行分阴阳!劫难现!五行出!合混沌!破万劫!
  • 修真教科书

    修真教科书

    江子齐很倒霉!身为“仙道教科书”之称的他,带着一堆顶尖仙法,却一头撞进玄幻世界。没事,我有超过万年的修仙经验,顶尖仙法无数。抱歉,我们玄幻时代不讲修仙!那说好的退婚就送老爷爷?抱歉,单身狗没资格得到退婚的机会,您可以到那边取号,预约一个跳崖的名额。江子齐懵逼了!穿越没有金手指,想要待遇靠自己?这剧本不讲道理啊!
  • 星际大英雄

    星际大英雄

    疯子老头逢人就说,他当过机甲战斗兵,也做过星际雇佣兵,宇宙中最强大的物种不是身高百米,力大无穷的威尔族,也不是数量众多,来去无踪的太空幽灵,而是刚刚进入准星际时代,被外星人当做野蛮土著的地球人——人类。一个无业少年,在得到一个上古战争卫星后,开始了他传奇的星际之旅,他最终诠释了疯子老头的话——地球人才是宇宙中最强的进化种族。因为他们的进化,没有极限!本书就是为大家描写一个善良但又狠心,猥琐却也正义,好色而不靡乱的草根英雄,为了赚钱,为了人类生存,一边高喊泡尽星际美女,一边疯狂向外扩张势力。在这个星际时代的丛林法则之中,不断登上更高峰。【本书交流群:96089573,请各位来此畅所欲言!】
  • 见闻杂记

    见闻杂记

    茅盾(1896年7月4日—1981年3月27日),原名沈德鸿,笔名茅盾、郎损、玄珠、方璧、止敬、蒲牢、微明、沈仲方、沈明甫等,字雁冰,浙江省嘉兴市桐乡市人。 茅盾出生在一个思想观念颇为新颖的家庭里,从小接受新式的教育。后考入北京大学预科,毕业后入商务印书馆工作,从此走上了改革中国文艺的道路,他是新文化运动的先驱者、中国革命文艺的奠基人。
  • 魔尊千千岁

    魔尊千千岁

    一朝穿越,两度涅槃。医术在手,美男在怀。但,一不小心居然被歹人算计。容貌尽毁,经脉全断?人界天界走一遭,魔界地狱抢一回。额,好像抢来的是个美男!
  • 一吻成瘾:温柔老公么么哒

    一吻成瘾:温柔老公么么哒

    结婚之前,她还是一个刚刚大学毕业的设计师,忽然间,她知道自己要结婚的事情。她想要逃跑,可是最终还是被捉回来了。被捉回来后,某男就把她关在了家里。等待婚礼的到来。结婚之后,某女笑着说:老公,亲一个。说完,某男直接把她压在身下,重重的吻了下去。本来某女还想说些什么,可是嘴唇被堵住了说不出来。第二天早上。某女抱怨起来了说;我再也不要了。某男故意说;不要什么?某女顿时脸红了起来。突然间一个小宝贝插进来说:不要什么啊?。他们居然忘了昨天晚上他们的小宝贝,是和他们住在房间里了。