登陆注册
14830800000012

第12章 CAPITAL PUNISHMENT(4)

"Whoever will undergo the pain," says Mr. Wakefield, "of witnessing the public destruction of a fellow-creature's life, in London, must be perfectly satisfied that in the great mass of spectators, the effect of the punishment is to excite sympathy for the criminal and hatred of the law. . . I am inclined to believe that the criminals of London, spoken of as a class and allowing for exceptions, take the same sort of delight in witnessing executions, as the sportsman and soldier find in the dangers of hunting and war. . . I am confident that few Old Bailey Sessions pass without the trial of a boy, whose first thought of crime occurred whilst he was witnessing an execution. . . And one grown man, of great mental powers and superior education, who was acquitted of a charge of forgery, assured me that the first idea of committing a forgery occurred to him at the moment when he was accidentally witnessing the execution of Fauntleroy. To which it may be added, that Fauntleroy is said to have made precisely the same declaration in reference to the origin of his own criminality.

But one convict "who was within an ace of being hanged", among the many with whom Mr. Wakefield conversed, seems to me to have unconsciously put a question which the advocates of Capital Punishment would find it very difficult indeed to answer. "Have you often seen an execution?" asked Mr. Wakefield. "Yes, often." "Did it not frighten you?" "No. Why should it?"

It is very easy and very natural to turn from this ruffian, shocked by the hardened retort; but answer his question, why should it?

Should he be frightened by the sight of a dead man? We are born to die, he says, with a careless triumph. We are not born to the treadmill, or to servitude and slavery, or to banishment; but the executioner has done no more for that criminal than nature may do tomorrow for the judge, and will certainly do, in her own good time, for judge and jury, counsel and witnesses, turnkeys, hangman, and all. Should he be frightened by the manner of the death? It is horrible, truly, so horrible, that the law, afraid or ashamed of its own deed, hides the face of the struggling wretch it slays; but does this fact naturally awaken in such a man, terror--or defiance? Let the same man speak. "What did you think then?" asked Mr. Wakefield.

"Think? Why, I thought it was a--shame."

Disgust and indignation, or recklessness and indifference, or a morbid tendency to brood over the sight until temptation is engendered by it, are the inevitable consequences of the spectacle, according to the difference of habit and disposition in those who behold it. Why should it frighten or deter? We know it does not.

We know it from the police reports, and from the testimony of those who have experience of prisons and prisoners, and we may know it, on the occasion of an execution, by the evidence of our own senses; if we will be at the misery of using them for such a purpose. But why should it? Who would send his child or his apprentice, or what tutor would send his scholars, or what master would send his servants, to be deterred from vice by the spectacle of an execution?

If it be an example to criminals, and to criminals only, why are not the prisoners in Newgate brought out to see the show before the debtors' door? Why, while they are made parties to the condemned sermon, are they rigidly excluded from the improving postscript of the gallows? Because an execution is well known to be an utterly useless, barbarous, and brutalising sight, and because the sympathy of all beholders, who have any sympathy at all, is certain to be always with the criminal, and never with the law.

I learn from the newspaper accounts of every execution, how Mr. So-

and-so, and Mr. Somebody else, and Mr. So-forth shook hands with the culprit, but I never find them shaking hands with the hangman. All kinds of attention and consideration are lavished on the one; but the other is universally avoided, like a pestilence. I want to know why so much sympathy is expended on the man who kills another in the vehemence of his own bad passions, and why the man who kills him in the name of the law is shunned and fled from? Is it because the murderer is going to die? Then by no means put him to death. Is it because the hangman executes a law, which, when they once come near it face to face, all men instinctively revolt from? Then by all means change it. There is, there can be, no prevention in such a law.

It may be urged that Public Executions are not intended for the benefit of those dregs of society who habitually attend them. This is an absurdity, to which the obvious answer is, So much the worse.

If they be not considered with reference to that class of persons, comprehending a great host of criminals in various stages of development, they ought to be, and must be. To lose sight of that consideration is to be irrational, unjust, and cruel. All other punishments are especially devised, with a reference to the rooted habits, propensities, and antipathies of criminals. And shall it be said, out of Bedlam, that this last punishment of all is alone to be made an exception from the rule, even where it is shown to be a means of propagating vice and crime?

But there may be people who do not attend executions, to whom the general fame and rumour of such scenes is an example, and a means of deterring from crime.

Who are they? We have seen that around Capital Punishment there lingers a fascination, urging weak and bad people towards it, and imparting an interest to details connected with it, and with malefactors awaiting it or suffering it, which even good and well-

同类推荐
热门推荐
  • 斩群仙

    斩群仙

    为了父母宗族、她玩命修炼!为了守护爱情,她怒斩群仙!为了天下黎民,她另创位面!李霄意外穿越,身上背负着巨大的责任。这里是一个没有鲜花,没有糖果的世界。让我们一起陪着女主,升级打怪谈恋爱!亲!一起笑傲江湖吧!
  • 福妻驾到

    福妻驾到

    现代饭店彪悍老板娘魂穿古代。不分是非的极品婆婆?三年未归生死不明的丈夫?心狠手辣的阴毒亲戚?贪婪而好色的地主老财?吃上顿没下顿的贫困宭境?不怕不怕,神仙相助,一技在手,天下我有!且看现代张悦娘,如何身带福气玩转古代,开面馆、收小弟、左纳财富,右傍美男,共绘幸福生活大好蓝图!!!!快本新书《天媒地聘》已经上架开始销售,只要3.99元即可将整本书抱回家,你还等什么哪,赶紧点击下面的直通车,享受乐乐精心为您准备的美食盛宴吧!)
  • 仙剑奇侠传5续文——静待

    仙剑奇侠传5续文——静待

    千年等待,只为那一瞬……当诸事已了,静待庭前花开花落,望天上云卷云舒,经年苍茫,恍惚之间,那一场盛世繁华,犹如昨日重现。箜篌弦动水无声,逝往夕,追琼独,笙吹半场执荼靡,难断言,来未渺渺,此非梦,谁与谓君同。
  • 丛神之路

    丛神之路

    从小镇出来的少年,走向成神的道路。学院修炼,魔兽森林从横。终成为最强的神位。
  • 史上最弱系统

    史上最弱系统

    有一个系统,带着自己的宿主,碎了光环,没让他修仙,灭了主神,没让他修仙,抢了商城,没让他修仙,吃了大神,没让他修仙,到最后宿主发现,自己已经是仙。(新人新书,求支持,求大家指教。)
  • 吹土根

    吹土根

    就连小学生也能看出来,“吹土根”三个字连在一起,实在是有些不知所云。然而,就是这三个字,却让古一民长时间地痴迷,发呆,茶饭不思,夜不成寐……
  • 岐月

    岐月

    远去的灵魂再度为爱而觉醒,一起编织出新的传奇史诗物语。
  • 重生刁蛮影后:总裁的心尖宠

    重生刁蛮影后:总裁的心尖宠

    一朝被狗咬,十年怕狗粮。正是青葱的夏未央刚跟竹马干了一架口水战,谁知一转身就遇见了无聊至极的猥琐追求者,挥手拒绝后竟“无辜”遭骂,叔可忍,婶婶都不能忍!正要跟他干架,谁知一脚踩到了万能的香蕉皮,摔了个头破血流!头昏脑涨迷迷糊糊间,她只记得当时想,谁家的猴子跑出来乱扔香蕉皮的,站出来,看姑奶奶我不砸你一桶烂苹果?!太虐心了有木有?一“觉”醒来,她竟然成了另一个人,而她所在的这个地方原来的她竟然根本不存在?我去,年度大戏啊这是,不过,为什么她能够自主穿梭于两个时空呢?究竟,她,到底是谁?最后,她的归属,是这方的天空?还是那岸的蓝天?
  • 盛宠医妃:素莲缘

    盛宠医妃:素莲缘

    军医林筱雅一朝穿越:“我天,别人穿都有一高贵身份,为什么了我穿了还差点被摔死”还好,医术还在,看她如何救人济世,巧斗恶霸。然而好景不常,自从救了微服私访的腹黑太子后,林筱雅发现自己掉进了一个无比大的大坑中
  • 亲爱的徐医生

    亲爱的徐医生

    你还记得第一次表白完对方是怎么回答你的吗?秦安乐:徐医生,我似乎从第一次见面就喜欢上你了。徐慕迟:然后呢?秦安乐:为了证明我是真心真意的,我们结婚吧!徐慕迟:……明天下午两点民政局见。这是一个一见钟情,二见倾心,三见结婚的治愈系故事。