登陆注册
14827600000067

第67章

A particular planet is identified by its constant power to affect oureyes in a special way. Further, such planet has not been seen to move bythe astronomer; but its motion is inferred from a comparison of its presentposition with the position it before occupied. This comparison proves tobe a comparison between the different impressions produced on him by thedifferent adjustments of his observing instruments. And the validity of theinferences. drawn depends on the truth of the assumption that these massesof matter, celestial and terrestrial, continue to affect his senses in thesame ways under the same conditions. On going a step further back, it turnsout that difference in the adjustment of his observing instrument, and byimplication in the planet's position, is meaningless until shown to correspondwith a certain calculated position which the planet must occupy, supposingthat no motion has been lost. And if, finally, we examine the implied calculation,we find that it takes into account those accelerations and retardations whichellipticity of the orbit involves, as well as those variations of motioncaused by adjacent planets -- we find, that is, that the motion is concludedto be indestructible not from the uniform velocity of the planet, but fromthe constant quantity of motion exhibited after allowances have been madefor the motions communicated to, or received from, other celestial bodies.

And when we ask how this is estimated, we discover that the estimate assumescertain laws of force or energy; which laws, one and all, embody the postulatethat energy cannot be destroyed.

Similarly with the a priori conclusion that Motion is continuous. Thatwhich defies suppression in thought (disciplined thought, of course), isthe force which the motion indicates. We can imagine retardation to resultfrom the actions of other bodies. But to imagine this we must imagine lossof some of the energy implied by the motion. We are obliged to conceive thisenergy as impressed in the shape of reaction on the bodies causing the retardation.

And the motion communicated to them, we are compelled to regard as a productof the communicated energy. We can mentally diminish the velocity or space-elementof motion, by diffusing the momentum or force-element over a larger massof matter; but the quantity of this force-element is unchangeable in thought.*<* This exposition differs in its point of view from the expositionsordinarily given; and some of the words employed, such as strain, have somewhatlarger implications. Unable to learn anything about the nature of Force,physicists have, of late years, formulated ultimate physical truths in suchways as often tacitly to exclude the consciousness of Force: conceiving cause,as Hume proposed, in terms of antecedence and sequence only. "Potentialenergy," for example, is defined as constituted by such relations inspace as permit masses to generate in one another certain motions, but asbeing in itself nothing. While this mode of conceiving the phenomena sufficesfor physical inquiries. It does not suffice for the purposes of philosophy.

In the Principles of Psychology, §§ 347-350, I have shownthat our ideas of Body, Space, Motion, are derived from our ideas of musculartension, which are the ultimate symbols into which all our other mental symbolsare interpretable. Hence to formulate phenomena in the proximate terms ofBody, Space, Motion, while discharging from the concepts the consciousnessof Force, is to acknowledge the superstructure while ignoring the foundation.

When, in 1875, I recast the foregoing chapter, and set forth more fullythe doctrine contained in the answering chapters of preceding editions, Isupposed myself to be alone in dissenting from the prevailing doctrine. Buta year after, in the Philosophical Magazine for October, 1876, I wasglad to see the same view enunciated and defended by Dr. Croll, in an essay"On the Transformation of Gravity." I commend his arguments tothose who are not convinced by the arguments used above.

Let me add a remark concerning the nature of the question at issue. Itis assumed that, as a matter of course, it is a question falling within thesphere of the mathematicians and physicists. I demur to the assumption. Itis a question falling within the sphere of the psychologists -- a questionconcerning the right interpretation of our ideas.>

Chapter 6

The Persistence of Force (*)

<* Some explanation of this title is needful. In the text itself aregiven the reasons for using the word "force" instead of the word"energy" and here I must say why I think "persistence"preferable to "conservation." Some two years ago (this was writtenin 1861) I expressed to my friend Prof. Huxley, my dissatisfaction with the(then) current expression -- "Conservation of Force," assigningas reasons, first, that the word "conservation" implies a conserverand an act of conserving; and, second, that it does not imply the existenceof the force before the particular manifestation of it which is contemplated.

And I may now add, as a further fault, the tacit assumption that, withoutsome act of conservation, force would disappear. All these implications areat variance with the conception to be conveyed. In place of "conservation"Prof. Huxley suggested persistence. This meets most of the objections; andthough it may be urged that it does not directly imply pre-existence of theforce at any time manifested, yet no word less faulty in this respect canbe found. In the absence of a word coined for the Purpose, it seems the best;and as such I adopt it.> §60. In the foregoing two chapters, manifestations of force of twofundamentally-different classes have been dealt with -- the force by whichmatter demonstrates itself to us as existing, and the force by which it demonstratesitself to us as acting.

同类推荐
热门推荐
  • 万剑魔宗

    万剑魔宗

    剑,在我手中不为剑,为生命、为命运。只有我手中有剑,我才能保护我所要珍爱之人。倘若,我手中没有剑,我拿什么保护你?倘若我手中没有剑,我会更加珍惜你。
  • 盛宠世子妃

    盛宠世子妃

    一朝穿越,腹黑狡诈的她成为沐国公府嫡出千金。沐国公府平妻掌权,嫡妹横行,嫡弟嚣张,姨娘欺诈,下人刁钻,她是21世纪金牌特工,从来只有她算计别人,何时轮到他们横行霸道了。可没想到,她去制不住那位腹黑的主,“娘子啊,你准备往哪里逃?”本文纯属虚构,请勿模仿。
  • 地源心经

    地源心经

    从古至今,人们都在追求着无尽的生命和永恒的世界。自盘古先祖开天辟地以来,洪荒大陆经历了开天大劫、龙凤大劫、道魔大劫、巫妖大劫、封神大劫、宇宙大劫、西游大劫等一个个劫难,一直到了末法大劫。但一代又一代的人们都渴望没有束缚,走向更加广阔的世界。
  • 传奇之天问

    传奇之天问

    末法时代,天道崩溃,三界动乱,妖邪横行,群魔乱舞。天道为何崩溃?天道崩溃之后到底隐藏着什么?天地人三界又将面临怎样的命运?
  • 梦幻紫水晶之恋

    梦幻紫水晶之恋

    分别10年从小青梅竹马长大的人在次相遇,韩天宇带着一颗幸福的心从法国回来完成和小罗菲小时候的约定.罗菲因为失忆,忘记了天宇.半路又杀出了一个李哲莠.....
  • 萝想大陆

    萝想大陆

    和你度过的点点滴滴······美丽得像一幅梦里的画。
  • 安之悦:回忆梦想摩天轮

    安之悦:回忆梦想摩天轮

    她只是想要一个完美的家庭。有人给了她,她就这样,进入了一个不属于自己的完美家庭。你们应该都知道,有一种痛,叫做不能和自己爱的人在一起。你们应该也知道,被别人欺骗了,这种痛苦,非常的令人失望。一个16年的谎言,破坏了一个家庭,不会了,两个孩子的爱情。但是只要他们开心......欢迎大家入坑,薇薇在小说里面等着你们(???`)??
  • 神通大陆传

    神通大陆传

    对于一个从小看着哆啦A梦长大的人来说,杨一无论如何也想不到有一天他会随身携带着任意门在另外一个神奇的大陆上打架泡妞,经历各种匪夷所思的际遇。“拥有神通,就拥有了整个世界!”穿越众杨一如此说道。且看主角如何在异界风生水起,叱咤风云!
  • 呔!妖孽哪里逃!

    呔!妖孽哪里逃!

    阴差阳错与原来的世界背道而驰;楚旖旎懵懂赤诚一片,对人唯真心相待,可若人不能信我、护我、独宠于我,那么弃之又何妨!重回东方,唯我本心不变!“仙道之路漫漫,吾将上下而求索!”“小和尚,倘若我能翻了这天,覆了这地,是不是我就能抓住你的心,束住你的人。”“呔!妖孽休得狂言!”
  • 圣沌覆天

    圣沌覆天

    踏破天极,虽凌驾众生,却止于半步。君神毅然自毁,只为求见那混沌之上。轮回重生,尽为圣沌覆天。