登陆注册
14827600000048

第48章

The Data of Philosophy §39. Every thought involves a whole system of thoughts and ceasesto exist if severed from its various correlatives. As we cannot isolate asingle organ of a living body, and deal with it as though it had a life independentof the rest, so, from the organized structure of our cognitions, we cannotcut out one, and proceed as though it had survived the separation. The developmentof formless protoplasm into an embryo is a specialization of parts, the definitenessof which increases only as fast as their combination increases. Each becomesa distinguishable organ only on condition that it is bound up with others,which have simultaneously become distinguishable organs. Similarly, fromthe unformed material of consciousness, a developed intelligence can ariseonly by a process which, in making thoughts defined also makes them mutuallydependent -- establishes among them certain vital connexions the destructionof which causes instant death of the thoughts. Overlooking this all-importanttruth, however, speculators have habitually set out with some professedly-- simple datum or data; have supposed themselves to assume nothing beyondthis datum or these data; and have thereupon proceeded to prove or disprovepropositions which were, by implication, already unconsciously asserted alongwith that which was consciously asserted.

This reasoning in a circle has resulted from the misuse of words: notthat misuse commonly enlarged upon -- not the misapplication or change ofmeaning whence so much error arises; but a more radical and less obviousmisuse. Only that thought which is directly indicated by each word has beencontemplated; while numerous thoughts indirectly indicated have been leftout of consideration. Because a spoken or written word can be detached fromall others, it has been inadvertently assumed that the thing signified bya word can be detached from the things signified by all other words. Howprofoundly this error vitiates the conclusions of one who makes it, we shallquickly see on taking a case. The sceptical metaphysician, wishing his reasoningsto be as rigorous as possible, says to himself -- "I will take for grantedonly this one thing." What now are the tacit assumptions inseparablefrom his avowed assumption? The resolve itself indirectly asserts that thereis some other thing, or are some other things, which he might assume; forit is impossible to think of unity without thinking of a correlative dualityor multiplicity. In the very act, therefore, of restricting himself, he takesin much that is professedly left out. Again, before proceeding he must givea definition of that which he assumes. Is nothing unexpressed involved inthe thought of a thing as defined? There is the thought of something excludedby the definition -- there is, as before, the thought of other existence.

But there is much more. Defining a thing, or setting a limit to it, impliesthe thought of a limit; and limit cannot be thought of apart from some notionof quantity extensive, protensive, or intensive. Further, definition is impossibleunless there enters into it the thought of difference; and difference, besidesbeing unthinkable without having two things that differ, implies the existenceof other differences than the one recognized; since without them there cannothave been formed the general conception of difference. Nor is this all. Asbefore potted out (§24) all thought involves the consciousness of likeness: the one thing avowedly postulated cannot be known absolutely as one thing,but can be known only as of such or such kind -- only as classed with otherthings in virtue of some common attribute. Thus, along with the single avoweddatum, we have surreptitiously brought in a number of unavowed data -- existenceother than that alleged, quantity, number, limit, difference, likeness, class,attribute. Now in these unacknowledged postulates, we have the outlines ofa general theory; and that theory can be neither proved nor disproved bythe metaphysician's argument. Insist that his symbol shall be interpretedat every step into its full meaning, with all the complementary thoughtsimplied by that meaning, and you find already taken for granted in the premissesthat which in the conclusion is asserted or denied.

In what way, then, must Philosophy set out? The developed intelligenceis framed upon certain organized and consolidated conceptions of which itcannot divest itself; and which it can no more stir without using than thebody can stir without help of its limbs. In what way, then, is it possiblefor intelligence, striving after Philosophy, to give any account of theseconceptions, and to show either their validity or their invalidity? Thereis but one way. Those of them which are vital, or cannot be severed fromthe rest without mental dissolution, must be assumed as true provisionally.

同类推荐
热门推荐
  • 冰冷世子妃

    冰冷世子妃

    【第一卷】梦浮生凡尘事:楚国,三大王府之一楚王府,十年未归原配嫡女强势回归,原来些对她又打又骂的平母和平母的女儿得到应有的教训,可是却意外的出现了一位不速之客,他,楚国三大王府之首风辰王府的世子,上至八十岁老太太,下至三岁小孩无一不识他,他的强大,睿智,能力,令各国无一不害怕,他的气质,容貌,令各国少女都将他视为梦中情人,可是······
  • 王俊凯的吉他,还有她的吉他谱

    王俊凯的吉他,还有她的吉他谱

    曾经有一个弹吉他的少年,他的身后还有一个带着吉他谱的少女。有一天,带着吉他谱的少女失忆了,忘记了那个弹吉他的少年,忘记了很多人,讨厌上了那个少年。可少年依旧明白,那个一直会跟在他身后的少女还会在原地等待他。
  • 小道士的求道之路

    小道士的求道之路

    在这科学的社会,什么妖魔鬼怪都是迷信,神佛这种东西更是虚无缥缈,有人信有人不信,但是,在这个世界的阴影下,人们的目光之外,有些事有些人总是存在的。
  • 绝剑问天

    绝剑问天

    一个没落的皇族,一本逆乱洪荒的旷世功法,一个坚毅的少年,且看他如何斗破天道,唯我独尊,发出“我命由我不由天”的慨叹。
  • 和NPC恋爱

    和NPC恋爱

    这是一个新奇的世界,主人公无夜在此诞生。失去记忆与力量的他身处于这个并不属于他的世界。战斗并找寻自己的从前。却不料卷入了一个又一个的陷阱中。在迷茫中邂逅了自己的心灵支柱艾莉儿{NPC},并与其展开了一段刻骨铭心的爱情........。
  • 吃货大修仙

    吃货大修仙

    作为一名资深的吃货,叶贝贝决定为美食奋斗一生,谁能给她吃一辈子,她就嫁给谁!因为吃,被坏人嫌弃因为吃,被情敌绑架因为吃,险些丧命!但!因为吃,她碰到了生命中的那个他因为吃,他为她赴汤蹈火在所不惜因为吃,他们喜结良缘爱意满满!吃货的一生永远都不会差!
  • 魂天录

    魂天录

    一位异界重生的亡灵法师,一颗随之而来的神秘宝石,二者的降临,会给这片土地带来怎样的精彩?遵循自我的灵魂,颠覆这方世界的法则!讲述一位佣兵少年在魂天大陆的梦幻之旅。
  • 血色妖娆之永生

    血色妖娆之永生

    血族的时代已经结束了,猎人一族也在日渐凋零。然而,意外却发生了。血族始祖的复活。有着怎样一个不为人知的秘密,七件圣武器又能否聚集起来。贝尔蒙特家族是否会想当初那般的神秘,有是不是可以再一次的击退血族的来袭。落依尼尔克斯与血族之间又有着怎样的纠葛。爱尔雅娜之名的女孩啊,你将拥有怎样的命运,又或者说,你将会是怎样的一个存在。血族,猎人,这将是永恒不变的传说。
  • 六道骸主

    六道骸主

    火影世界被毁灭,而地球上的危险也即将来临,小李殇该如何面对呢。第一次写,写得不好,还请原谅
  • 秦时明月之乌克娜娜

    秦时明月之乌克娜娜

    红色月亮出现,时空之门开启,命运之轮转动,当乌克娜娜变成了蓝芊雨,一切都已经在改变。跨越千年的距离,只为与你相遇,相知,相爱,相守。八年的陪伴,五年的爱恋最终以她的遗忘而结束。当他想要挽回这一切的时候,却发现自己早在百年前就失去了她。百年的等待,她与他是否修成正果