登陆注册
14730900000066

第66章 Slum Novelists and the Slums(3)

We are undemocratic, then, in our religion, as is proved by our efforts to "raise" the poor. We are undemocratic in our government, as is proved by our innocent attempt to govern them well.

But above all we are undemocratic in our literature, as is proved by the torrent of novels about the poor and serious studies of the poor which pour from our publishers every month.

And the more "modern" the book is the more certain it is to be devoid of democratic sentiment.

A poor man is a man who has not got much money. This may seem a simple and unnecessary description, but in the face of a great mass of modern fact and fiction, it seems very necessary indeed;most of our realists and sociologists talk about a poor man as if he were an octopus or an alligator. There is no more need to study the psychology of poverty than to study the psychology of bad temper, or the psychology of vanity, or the psychology of animal spirits.

A man ought to know something of the emotions of an insulted man, not by being insulted, but simply by being a man. And he ought to know something of the emotions of a poor man, not by being poor, but simply by being a man. Therefore, in any writer who is describing poverty, my first objection to him will be that he has studied his subject.

A democrat would have imagined it.

A great many hard things have been said about religious slumming and political or social slumming, but surely the most despicable of all is artistic slumming. The religious teacher is at least supposed to be interested in the costermonger because he is a man;the politician is in some dim and perverted sense interested in the costermonger because he is a citizen; it is only the wretched writer who is interested in the costermonger merely because he is a costermonger. Nevertheless, so long as he is merely seeking impressions, or in other words copy, his trade, though dull, is honest.

But when he endeavours to represent that he is describing the spiritual core of a costermonger, his dim vices and his delicate virtues, then we must object that his claim is preposterous;we must remind him that he is a journalist and nothing else.

He has far less psychological authority even than the foolish missionary.

For he is in the literal and derivative sense a journalist, while the missionary is an eternalist. The missionary at least pretends to have a version of the man's lot for all time;the journalist only pretends to have a version of it from day to day.

The missionary comes to tell the poor man that he is in the same condition with all men. The journalist comes to tell other people how different the poor man is from everybody else.

If the modern novels about the slums, such as novels of Mr. Arthur Morrison, or the exceedingly able novels of Mr. Somerset Maugham, are intended to be sensational, I can only say that that is a noble and reasonable object, and that they attain it. A sensation, a shock to the imagination, like the contact with cold water, is always a good and exhilarating thing; and, undoubtedly, men will always seek this sensation (among other forms) in the form of the study of the strange antics of remote or alien peoples. In the twelfth century men obtained this sensation by reading about dog-headed men in Africa.

In the twentieth century they obtained it by reading about pig-headed Boers in Africa. The men of the twentieth century were certainly, it must be admitted, somewhat the more credulous of the two.

For it is not recorded of the men in the twelfth century that they organized a sanguinary crusade solely for the purpose of altering the singular formation of the heads of the Africans. But it may be, and it may even legitimately be, that since all these monsters have faded from the popular mythology, it is necessary to have in our fiction the image of the horrible and hairy East-ender, merely to keep alive in us a fearful and childlike wonder at external peculiarities.

But the Middle Ages (with a great deal more common sense than it would now be fashionable to admit) regarded natural history at bottom rather as a kind of joke; they regarded the soul as very important.

Hence, while they had a natural history of dog-headed men, they did not profess to have a psychology of dog-headed men.

They did not profess to mirror the mind of a dog-headed man, to share his tenderest secrets, or mount with his most celestial musings.

They did not write novels about the semi-canine creature, attributing to him all the oldest morbidities and all the newest fads.

It is permissible to present men as monsters if we wish to make the reader jump; and to make anybody jump is always a Christian act.

But it is not permissible to present men as regarding themselves as monsters, or as making themselves jump. To summarize, our slum fiction is quite defensible as aesthetic fiction;it is not defensible as spiritual fact.

One enormous obstacle stands in the way of its actuality.

同类推荐
  • 发觉净心经卷上

    发觉净心经卷上

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。
  • 陈清端公文选

    陈清端公文选

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。
  • 春雪

    春雪

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。
  • 奇闻类记

    奇闻类记

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。
  • 天马山房遗稿

    天马山房遗稿

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。
热门推荐
  • 异界之神魄传说

    异界之神魄传说

    异界大陆,强者为尊。普天之下,为武纵横。法道巅峰,为魔纵横。天穹大陆,适者生存。异界巅峰,魔武纵横。看少年身怀破字绝学,百强争霸,脱颖而出。
  • 成长纪念

    成长纪念

    女主从出生都结婚的故事,整天跟着邻居青梅竹马打着,而邻居小哥也是小腹黑,每天都欺负她,却从没正视自己的这份情感......直到另一人的出现才让他正视了他自己的情感,有了这份危机感,每天对女主灌输除了他世界上的男生有多坏......
  • 青春学院季

    青春学院季

    一个长相出众的白霄染,一个家财万贯的沐清翼,竟同时爱上了一个长相平平,家境平平的杨贝倍。在一个十分有空间限度的空间--学校,他她他三个人的爱情要以什么方式发展?
  • 重生之一品庶女

    重生之一品庶女

    前世,嫡母当权,亲弟早夭,她遇人不淑,沦为世人嘲笑的丧门星。步步为营,九死一生,只为心爱之人夺得太子之位,雄图霸业,却不想,真心人爱的是嫡姐,刻意接近为的是她孟家祖传的传世兵书,换得的却是沉溺湖底,含恨而终……今生,她虐嫡母,欺嫡姐,定要将踩下这乾坤,让他们尝尝掏空了真心,却不得善终的滋味!
  • 初傲江湖:莫少得了妻管严

    初傲江湖:莫少得了妻管严

    “公子~你就收留如家嘛!”翠花扭动小蛮腰不断朝莫孤辰娇羞地抛媚眼。莫孤辰红了脸正欲开口,某女便冒出来一脚踹飞翠花,用力拽住莫孤辰的衣领,举着粉拳骂道:“好你个负心汉,亏老娘对你那么好,你倒跑来偷小三,看老娘怎么收拾你!”莫孤辰慌了神,“滚滚,我……”话还没说完,只见翠花奋力推开某女大义凛然地说:“像你这种悍妇根本配不上如家的小辰辰!实话告诉你,小辰辰是为了偷你研制出的套子才娶你的!你趁早死心吧!”某女顿时五雷轰顶,咬牙切齿地说:“算你们狠!”莫孤辰从震惊中渐渐缓过神来,急忙追上前,“滚滚,你听我解释!”某女板着脸转过身,直打得他鼻青脸肿。“放开如家的小辰辰!”翠花震动大胸,展开双手飞奔过来……
  • 末世重生:破茧成蝶

    末世重生:破茧成蝶

    被丈夫圈养在象牙塔里成为人人羡慕的基地夫人!却因为她一个选择不止失去了孩子,还背负着十万人的性命。意外重生有了上辈子到死都不知道的逆天空间,却无法改变未来,反而成了幕后推手。她姜羽怎会就此作罢?她用行动告诉愚蠢的人类:真相只有一个,它永远属于胜利的一方!而他死缠烂打“小羽,难道我对你不够好么?宝宝我们一定会再有的。”某男冷笑“我的女人自有我护着,至于宝宝嘛,爹地只能是我!”姜羽圈住某男脖颈送上一吻“我需要的是暖男,不是中央空调。”PS:虽是末世文姐弟恋,绝对1v1,身心纯洁。可以放心收藏。
  • 傲紫天狂

    傲紫天狂

    泱泱大国之内,终有那么一部分,让人无法触及,而四灵,便是那么一种人。灵力至上,强者为尊!作为四灵之一,她是四灵之王,青龙!而她,亦是家族的下任刑堂堂主,傲紫灵!她,为了堂兄而牺牲了性命,只为他下任的继承,为了他所做的事,只因她的愧疚。而她,又如何会就此结束?看她,在异世找到另一半,如何将天压下!
  • 网游之穷途末路

    网游之穷途末路

    四个意气风发的少年走到了这一步,直到他们进退维谷的时候。《世界》的出现带给了他们新的希望!可《世界》却并非他们想象的那么简单,一次意外的触碰让整个地球陷入了变故,加入了一场属于整个宇宙的游戏。在这亿万个星球组成的大陆中,他们又会闯出怎样一番天地呢?
  • TFBOY:霸道总裁你别逃

    TFBOY:霸道总裁你别逃

    大学生活是美好的,这里没有明星大牌,只有唯美青春校园故事…她,叶一夏,21岁的她考进北京戏剧学院从大学里和他们相遇,从那时开始,全校所有女生都是她的死对头,但有tf保护谁敢动她呢?他,王俊凯,24岁,煽情王子,对叶一夏的喜爱很明显,但那个笨蛋怎么知道?他,王源,23岁,薄荷王子,叶一夏的荧幕CP,不过在现实生活中,对叶一夏的爱也不少于王俊凯一分一毫。他,易烊千玺,23岁,高冷王子,叶一夏的学霸学长,他没有王俊凯那么霸气,也没有王源那么直白,他就是他,独一无二,默默的关心着叶一夏,那颗萌动的心开始慢慢发芽…
  • 断桥明月

    断桥明月

    自盛唐来,中原大陆群雄并起,各大武林门派欲求天地奥妙之法,正邪黑白两道相融相生,一片腥风血雨的武林风云,一代传奇剑侠的成长经历,演绎一场别样的奇门遁甲,五行八卦之江湖。