登陆注册
14730900000020

第20章 Christmas and the Aesthetes(1)

The world is round, so round that the schools of optimism and pessimism have been arguing from the beginning whether it is the right way up.

The difficulty does not arise so much from the mere fact that good and evil are mingled in roughly equal proportions; it arises chiefly from the fact that men always differ about what parts are good and what evil.

Hence the difficulty which besets "undenominational religions."They profess to include what is beautiful in all creeds, but they appear to many to have collected all that is dull in them.

All the colours mixed together in purity ought to make a perfect white.

Mixed together on any human paint-box, they make a thing like mud, and a thing very like many new religions. Such a blend is often something much worse than any one creed taken separately, even the creed of the Thugs.

The error arises from the difficulty of detecting what is really the good part and what is really the bad part of any given religion.

And this pathos falls rather heavily on those persons who have the misfortune to think of some religion or other, that the parts commonly counted good are bad, and the parts commonly counted bad are good.

It is tragic to admire and honestly admire a human group, but to admire it in a photographic negative. It is difficult to congratulate all their whites on being black and all their blacks on their whiteness.

This will often happen to us in connection with human religions.

Take two institutions which bear witness to the religious energy of the nineteenth century. Take the Salvation Army and the philosophy of Auguste Comte.

The usual verdict of educated people on the Salvation Army is expressed in some such words as these: "I have no doubt they do a great deal of good, but they do it in a vulgar and profane style;their aims are excellent, but their methods are wrong."To me, unfortunately, the precise reverse of this appears to be the truth. I do not know whether the aims of the Salvation Army are excellent, but I am quite sure their methods are admirable.

Their methods are the methods of all intense and hearty religions;they are popular like all religion, military like all religion, public and sensational like all religion. They are not reverent any more than Roman Catholics are reverent, for reverence in the sad and delicate meaning of the term reverence is a thing only possible to infidels.

That beautiful twilight you will find in Euripides, in Renan, in Matthew Arnold; but in men who believe you will not find it--you will find only laughter and war. A man cannot pay that kind of reverence to truth solid as marble; they can only be reverent towards a beautiful lie. And the Salvation Army, though their voice has broken out in a mean environment and an ugly shape, are really the old voice of glad and angry faith, hot as the riots of Dionysus, wild as the gargoyles of Catholicism, not to be mistaken for a philosophy.

Professor Huxley, in one of his clever phrases, called the Salvation Army "corybantic Christianity." Huxley was the last and noblest of those Stoics who have never understood the Cross. If he had understood Christianity he would have known that there never has been, and never can be, any Christianity that is not corybantic.

And there is this difference between the matter of aims and the matter of methods, that to judge of the aims of a thing like the Salvation Army is very difficult, to judge of their ritual and atmosphere very easy. No one, perhaps, but a sociologist can see whether General Booth's housing scheme is right.

But any healthy person can see that banging brass cymbals together must be right. A page of statistics, a plan of model dwellings, anything which is rational, is always difficult for the lay mind.

But the thing which is irrational any one can understand.

That is why religion came so early into the world and spread so far, while science came so late into the world and has not spread at all.

History unanimously attests the fact that it is only mysticism which stands the smallest chance of being understanded of the people.

Common sense has to be kept as an esoteric secret in the dark temple of culture. And so while the philanthropy of the Salvationists and its genuineness may be a reasonable matter for the discussion of the doctors, there can be no doubt about the genuineness of their brass bands, for a brass band is purely spiritual, and seeks only to quicken the internal life. The object of philanthropy is to do good;the object of religion is to be good, if only for a moment, amid a crash of brass.

And the same antithesis exists about another modern religion--I mean the religion of Comte, generally known as Positivism, or the worship of humanity. Such men as Mr. Frederic Harrison, that brilliant and chivalrous philosopher, who still, by his mere personality, speaks for the creed, would tell us that he offers us the philosophy of Comte, but not all Comte's fantastic proposals for pontiffs and ceremonials, the new calendar, the new holidays and saints' days.

He does not mean that we should dress ourselves up as priests of humanity or let off fireworks because it is Milton's birthday.

To the solid English Comtist all this appears, he confesses, to be a little absurd. To me it appears the only sensible part of Comtism.

As a philosophy it is unsatisfactory. It is evidently impossible to worship humanity, just as it is impossible to worship the Savile Club;both are excellent institutions to which we may happen to belong.

But we perceive clearly that the Savile Club did not make the stars and does not fill the universe. And it is surely unreasonable to attack the doctrine of the Trinity as a piece of bewildering mysticism, and then to ask men to worship a being who is ninety million persons in one God, neither confounding the persons nor dividing the substance.

同类推荐
  • Henry VI

    Henry VI

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。
  • 千松笔记

    千松笔记

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。
  • 闲居录

    闲居录

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。
  • 佛说甚希有经

    佛说甚希有经

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。
  • 众妙集

    众妙集

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。
热门推荐
  • 黄泉修罗

    黄泉修罗

    成为组织的棋子,并被无情的抛弃;生如何?死又如何?与其黄泉路上走,不如转世从头来!
  • TF之为你我愿转粉

    TF之为你我愿转粉

    身为高中学生的竹浅浅是一枚黑粉,是一枚不同凡响的黑粉。TFBOYS?小鲜肉?待我把你们搞成臭气哄哄的老腊肉!母亲的错误,父亲的离世,竹浅浅已经学会坚强,可偏偏他的出现使得竹浅浅原本营造的正常生活被打乱,就连几年不见的眼泪也在他面前轻易流下!他笑,她便哭,这是怎么回事?人人赞颂的乖少年在他眼里是毒!直到后来,竹浅浅才发现——原来,噬上毒,竟戒不掉!本文纯属虚构,请勿抄袭。
  • 城市猎妖者

    城市猎妖者

    人们都在传说,城市猎人的传奇。那个勇敢的猎人。就是他,为了希望和荣光,为了复仇与梦想,他站在风中挑战烈火,为了人类共同的家,面对强敌他不害怕,穿越荆棘不畏艰险,他像磐石一样坚强,为了心中不变梦想,城市猎人努力奋斗,跨越海角,飞过天涯,只为守护人类的家
  • 五味青匆

    五味青匆

    你护我一时,我护你一世。一句简简单单誓言,我沉睡千年,保你千年不衰。今朝醒,我依旧傲然。青春,我再添一笔,让你明白。我。在你之上。
  • 溺宠萌妃:妖王滚下榻

    溺宠萌妃:妖王滚下榻

    宠文+爽文+爆笑,一对一,男女主身心干净,喜欢的亲们可以点击【加入书架】,多多支持宝宝哦!轻纱红帐,烛光冉冉,满室旖旎。某红衣男子骨节如玉的手指勾了勾身下人儿的下颚,邪魅的笑道:“小丫头,今晚就从了爷吧,爷会对你好的。”身下某女挑眉轻笑:“来,让老娘伺候伺候你。”单臂撑床凌空翻转,姿势瞬间交换,她压着他,眉眼含笑的瞬间将银针刺进他颈部,封了他的穴道,妖孽一笑:“来人啊,好好伺候他。”门外应声而入数十名庸脂俗粉长得歪瓜裂枣的红尘女子,蜂拥而上…某男青筋暴起,呵斥道:“女人,你给我等着,爷定然要你为今日付出代价的!”
  • 遇见你是星光的开始

    遇见你是星光的开始

    世界那么大走过的人遇见的事就像石沉大海没有一点回声.青春是一场妙不可言的旅行比如我遇见你遇见他遇见她总要好好努力生活
  • 集诸经礼忏仪

    集诸经礼忏仪

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。
  • 一定要吃的家常菜288例

    一定要吃的家常菜288例

    《一定要吃的家常菜288例》就是在多年来积累的美食菜谱的基础上,加以精心策划而形成的,适合家庭使用的新版菜谱,所收录的菜谱兼顾美味和营养,做法简单易学,内容贴心实用,有很高的性价比。
  • 女王重生,伪天使归来

    女王重生,伪天使归来

    上一世,被继母,继妹欺压,这一世,看她如何还回?人不犯我,我不犯人,人若犯我,我必百倍待之。白青曼,季云柔,我回来了呢……季云柔,你不是会装吗,这一世,我也要做那个人人称赞完美的——天使。伪天使归来,做好准备了吗?——季初涵
  • 一代文宗

    一代文宗

    在扑街了N本书之后,终于在另开一本书的时候,受到人家的可怜。发来签约的通知。激动之下,努力和编辑沟通,努力填写合约。谁知道,在将合约寄出去之后。却看到官网上一个消息,该编辑的企鹅被盗……一气之下,吐血而亡。大概是老天爷可怜,在死了之后,直接穿越了。来到一个平行空间,没有金大侠,没有那些网络大神,也没有那些在文坛留下浓墨重彩的大师们。然后……然后,一代文宗诞生了。