登陆注册
14723100000180

第180章

Ramsay makes the following remark against Ricardo: ". . . He seems always to consider the whole produce as divided between wages and profits, forgetting the part necessary for replacing fixed capital." ( An Essay on the Distribution of Wealth , Edinburgh, 1836, p. 174.) By fixed capital Ramsay means the same thing that I mean by constant capital: "Fixed capital exists in a form in which, though assisting to raise the future commodity, it does not maintain labourers." ( Ibid ., p. 59.)Adam Smith opposed the necessary conclusion of his resolution of the value of commodities, and therefore also of the value of the social annual product into wages and surplus-value and therefore into mere revenue --the conclusion that in this event the entire annual product might be consumed.

It is never the original thinkers that draw the absurd conclusions. They leave that to the Says and MacCullochs.

Say, indeed, settles the matter easy enough. That which is an advance of capital for one, is or was a revenue and net product for another. The difference between the gross and the net product is purely subjective, and "thus the total value of all products, has been distributed in society as revenue." (Say, Traitè d' Economie Politique , 1817, II, p. 64.) "The total value of every product is composed of the profits of the landowners, the capitalists, and those who ply industrial trades" [wages figure here as profits des industrieux !] "who have contributed towards its production. This makes the revenue of society equal to the gross value produced , not equal to the net products of the soil, as was believed by the sect of the economists" [the physiocrats]. (P. 63.)Among others, Proudhon has appropriated this discovery of Say.

Storch, who likewise accepts Adam Smith's doctrine in principle, finds however that Say's practical application of it does not hold water. "If it is admitted that the revenue of a nation is equal to its gross product, i.e., that no capital" [it should say: no constant capital] "is to be deducted, then it must also be admitted that this nation may consume unproductively the entire value of its annual product without the least detriment to its future revenue. . . . The products which represent the" [constant] "capital of a nation are not consumable." (Storch, Considerations sur la nature du revenu national , Paris, 1824, pp. 147, 150.)However, Storch forgot to tell us how the existence of this constant portion of capital harmonises with the Smithian analysis of prices accepted by him, according to which the value of commodities contains only wages and surplus-value, but no part of any constant capital. He realises only through Say that this analysis of prices leads to absurd results, and his own last word on the subject is "that it is impossible to resolve the necessary price into its simplest elements." ( Cours d'Economie Politique , Petersburg, 1815, II, p. 141.)Sismondi, who occupies himself particularly with the relation of capital to revenue, and in actual fact makes the peculiar formulation of this relation the differentia specifica of his Nouveaux Principes , did not say one scientific word, did not contribute one iota to the clarification of the problem.

Barton, Ramsay, and Cherbuliez attempt to go beyond the formulation of Adam Smith. They founder because they pose the problem one-sidedly from the outset by failing to make clear the distinction between constant and variable capital-value and between fixed and circulating capital.

John Stuart Mill likewise reproduces, with his usual pomposity, the doctrine handed down by Adam Smith to his followers. As a result, the Smithian confusion of thought persists to this hour and his dogma is one of the orthodox articles of faith of Political Economy.

NOTES

[35] Beginning of Manuscript VIII. -- F.

E.

[36] Kapital , Band I, 2. Ausgabe, S.

612, Note 32. [Eng. ed., Moscow, 1954, p. 591, Note 1.]

[37] Some physiocrats had paved the way for him even here, especially Turgot. The latter uses the term capital for avances more frequently than Quesnay and the other physiocrats and identifies still more the avances , or capitaux , of the manufacturers with those of the farmers. For instance: "Like these (the entrepreneurs-manufacturers), they ( les fermiers , i.e., the capitalist farmers) must receive in addition to returning capitals, etc." (Turgot, Oeuvres , Daire edition, Paris, 1844, Vol. I, p. 40.)[38] In order that the reader may not misconstrue the meaning of the phrase "the price of the far greater part of commodities,"the following shows how Adam Smith himself explains this term. For instance, no rent enters into the price of sea fish, only wages and profit, only wages enter into the price of Scotch pebbles. He says: "In some parts of Scotland a few poor people make a trade of gathering, along the sea-shore, those little variegated stones commonly known by the name of Scotch pebbles.

The price which is paid to them by the stone-cutter is altogether the wages of their labour; neither rent nor profit makes any part of it."[39] I reproduce this sentence verbatim from the manuscript, although it seems to contradict, in its present context, both what precedes and immediately follow. This apparent contradiction is resolved further down in No. 4: Capital and Revenue in Adam Smith. -- F. E.

[40] We ignore the fact that Adam Smith was here particularly unfortunate in the choice of his example. The value of the corn resolves itself into wages, profit, and rent only because the food consumed by the labouring cattle is depicted as wages of the labouring cattle, and the labouring cattle as wage-labourers, so that the wage-labourer on his part is also depicted as labouring cattle. (Added from the Manuscript II. -- F. E. )[41] From here to the end of the chapter, a supplement from Manuscript II. -- F. E.

同类推荐
  • 忠义集

    忠义集

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。
  • 四分尼戒本

    四分尼戒本

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。
  • 醒梦骈言

    醒梦骈言

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。
  • 顾华玉集

    顾华玉集

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。
  • 广州记

    广州记

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。
热门推荐
  • 中国经济转型中的政府或有负债研究

    中国经济转型中的政府或有负债研究

    本书对政府或有负债问题特别是政府或有负债的产生根源进行了积极探索,并将经济转型的大背景与中国政府对国有企业、金融机构,中央政府对地方政府以及政府对基础设施建设领域所提供的隐性担保结合起来,分析了在此背景下我国政府或有负债的积累情况。
  • 我自年少,宜其室家

    我自年少,宜其室家

    人有七苦:生老病死,怨憎会,爱别离,求不得。都尝过了才明白幸运如我,身体康健,父母安在,学业早成,亲友恭和……我慢慢学会品尝这杯美酒,却苦涩的不知是何滋味。没有你,我从不曾明白爱有多深刻,原来早已离不开……
  • 冷爆残王无情妃

    冷爆残王无情妃

    她是权力背后的牺牲品。当冷暴的君王附在她的身上,强行索取时,她依旧淡漠地浅笑,用那纤细的柔荑轻轻抚过他的嘴唇。“决,你的心里到底藏了什么?”他抓住她不安的手指,送至唇边落下一片温柔细语,“你如此想知道,何不亲自剖开看看……”三年,千百个日夜,春宵一度过,她从卑微的宫人位及皇妃,地位直逼皇后。然而她冰封的心却一点一点地崩解,不知从何时起,已经深深地陷在了柔情蜜意里,无法自拔。到头来,她不过是他无数女人之中的一瓢清水,女人,除了是生育和泄欲的工具还能是什么?眼中那遗世独立的身影离她越来越远,她伸出手,眼角留下最后一滴泪。
  • 这边的领袖

    这边的领袖

    一个主神空间的NPC,发现了自己的世界只是一个虚拟的空间,他能否踏破万重险关得到新生。
  • 魔王盛宠:倾城狂妃

    魔王盛宠:倾城狂妃

    一夕穿越,金牌萌杀手穿越成寄养在别人家的“灰姑娘”?爹爹推她去道歉,笑话!她字典里从来就没有“道歉”这个词!在这异世大陆,狂傲依旧!可是,为毛一穿越异世,魔君大人死缠着她不放啊混蛋!逛六界,斗六王,驯神兽,从此携手并肩,永不分离!!
  • 皇上不坏皇后不爱(完结)

    皇上不坏皇后不爱(完结)

    借着手机的光芒与手上水晶的光芒就这样穿了.穿到古代同样遇到皇帝,遇到帅哥,可是,那皇帝居然认错人了,误认为我是来陪侍的,差一点就被那啥掉了……皇帝诱逼我做他贵妃,要做就做皇后,不要做贵妃……这个皇上有点坏……都说男人不坏,女人不爱。同样的,皇上不坏,皇后怎么会爱呢?
  • 闷骚校草:丫头别跑

    闷骚校草:丫头别跑

    他和她都生活在家族的利益之中。他说,她是一个有趣的人,亦是一个孤独的人,从此以后,他会陪在她身边,让孤独远离她;她说,他是一个霸道的人,亦是一个懂她的人,从此以后,她愿伴着她。他和她都不知道未来会怎么样,但,那又怎样?以后,他陪她,她伴他。第一次见面,他只留给了她一个背影,她只是看着他从窗口望着他离开的背影……
  • EXO之纯白色的爱

    EXO之纯白色的爱

    俊绵,你的所有,都是我今生无法触及的一切。
  • 半吊子道士

    半吊子道士

    法术?神通?他统统没有!一个被赋予重责的无道士能否不负师恩把昔日的妖怪打入地狱?纯洁的女孩,憨厚的徒弟,无辜的村民是否能逃过次劫?每日更新
  • 与冰山殿下的薰衣草之约

    与冰山殿下的薰衣草之约

    那一她6岁,他7岁,两个相互相识,却被一旁的姐姐撞见。暗恋他许久的姐姐见妹妹与他相处融洽,嫉妒成狂,陷害她与他,被迫分离……当她强势归来,却见他与姐姐成好成对,当他得知她回来后是否能够将她追回???当姐姐的身份拆穿,母亲被害凶手得知,他是否会与她一同面对???当他一次次的背叛,她一次次的忍受。当她心灰意冷的带着姐妹离开……在她走后的一月后他得知真相会如何?当她再度归釆,性情大变,开始了她的复仇之计。当她对他冷漠相对时,他是否能唤回她的心???一部你追我赶的校园戏剧再度上演。几对爱人是否能渡过重重困难,最终有情人终成眷属呢???