登陆注册
9671600000082

第82章 论文选萃(63)

Developing Identities,Developing Text

Although teen magazines may be seen as gross influences on girls'identity development,it is important to theorize the effects of the discourse and to examine how readers of these magazines navigate the text.Reader-response theorist Arthur Applebee links readers'responses to text to development,mainly following Piaget's theorized stages of development.During adolescence the“resources of formal operations have a dramatic effect on the child's response”to literature,theorizes Applebee.Applebee,Arthur N.,The Child's Concept of Story,p.125,Chicago:University of Chicago Press,1978.As readers mature,their ability to relate to and draw conclusions from a text increases in scope and complexity.Applebee claims that,as readers enter the initial stages of formal operations,their ability to analyze a text in terms of their own experiences is developed.This one-to-one relationship between reader,experience,and text is complicated as the reader reaches the later stage of formal operations and begins to see the text as“one of many statements of how life might be understood,rather than simply a presentation of life as it is”Applebee,Arthur N.,The Child's Concept of Story,Chicago:University of Chicago Press,1978..The initial period of text relation begins around age 12 or 13-coincidentally in the continuum of most teen magazines'target markets-and grows in analytic complexity around age 16.Here,we may see the window of time marked by personal relation to text-Piaget's initial stage of formal operations and Applebee's early stage of analytic ability-a unique period of vulnerability to developmental influence through text.

Developmentalists,psychologists,and even reader-response theorists characterize the period of adolescence as a period of shifting paradigms.Erikson writes of the painful self-awareness of the teen years and the struggle to attach to a frame of reference outside the self on which to build identity.Piaget associates adolescence with the increasing ability to perform complex tasks,while Applebee applies this cognitive growth to literacy and the experience of reading.Teen magazines,constructed with this convoluted time of physical and cognitive development in mind,do answer the needs of adolescent readers.By providing a framework for identity growth,supplying images of societal perfection,and taking advantage of the one-to-one relationship that can be forged between reader and text,magazines for teenagers,as well as those for adults,effectively guide identity development.The narrowness of this identity framework,as well as the normalcy promised if the guidelines described in the magazines are followed,is a source of critique identified by Driscoll:“Through a cult of normality and an eroticisation of the adolescent woman's concern with normalizing her body,the feminine adolescent body is constructed in girls'magazines as a range of desires trespassed upon by a variety of physiological imperfections.”Driscoll,Catherine,Girls:Feminine Adolescence in Popular Culture and Cultural Theory,p.94,New York:Columbia University Press,2002..Clearly,Driscoll and others acknowledge the successfulness of these publications in defining the parameters of identity and encouraging the marketing of these identities to teenaged readers.The effectiveness of these magazines to shape the identities of readers is rarely called into question;on the contrary,it is the shape of the identities the publications advocate that is more often argued.

After reading earnest letters from the editors of teen magazines to the thousands of readers who purchase the publication each month,it becomes difficult to situate the friendly and helpful intent of the magazine staff within a greater context of capitalism and accusations of exploitation.Joy Leman reminds us that the“incantations of false intimacy are foregrounded-a discourse of friendliness,reassuring and relocating women in an idea of oppression and a position of exploitation,”are present in every issue Leman Joy,“The Advice of a Real Friend:Codes of Intimacy and Oppression in Women's Magazines,”In Women and Media,edited by H.Baehr,p.65,New York:Pergamon,1979..Indeed,according to Leman,the developmental needs of girls can be manipulated to serve the status quo and to maintain the profit motivations that sustain girls'monthlies.In a power relationship mirroring capitalism,the teen magazine creates its own audience and thus its own sustenance.As ideals are marketed and branded within the glossy pages,advertisers pay to incorporate themselves within the identity for sale.According to Ross Ballaster and colleagues,the use of a“feminine”discourse,the manipulation and creation of gendered needs answered by advertised products,and the construction of the female reader as consumer is intrinsic to the survival of the magazines and the market that supports them.“Defining women as‘not men'...is evidently not a sufficient one for the women's magazine,”reports Ballaster in a 1996 analysis of women's publications.“If women are to buy and to be,they cannot be defined solely in the negative;femininity has to be given a particular content.”Ballaster Ros,Beetham Margaret,Frazer Elizabeth,and Hebron Sandra,“A Critical Analysis of Women's Magazines,”In Turning It on,A Reader in Women and Media,edited by H.Baehr and A.Gray,p.91,New York:Arnold,1996..Here,femininity is advertised as a shifting product,an identity dependent on the consumption of goods or the application of products.More important,this advertising is displayed in a uniquely feminine space(Erikson)where,as Ballaster writes,women are more than just“not men.”

同类推荐
  • 不吐槽不快乐:生活就是一场脱口秀

    不吐槽不快乐:生活就是一场脱口秀

    本书内容面极广,所谈论的都是社会的焦点问题或最即时的热门事件:首都房价、中央反腐、公款吃喝、炫富哈韩、精英移民、过度医疗、食品安全、物价飞涨、饭局应酬、有关部门、网络红词……犀利的文字,幽默的吐槽,深邃的思想,难能可贵。以幽默风趣的语言,写丑态百出的社会;用最淡然的调侃,说最艰辛的生活。吐槽不是目的,而是手段;脱口秀不是愤青,而是智者。这是一本有趣味、有思想的书。
  • 2014年厦门文化改革发展蓝皮书

    2014年厦门文化改革发展蓝皮书

    本书反映了2013年厦门文化体制改革与文化发展的概貌,收入了厦门市宣传文化系统组织的调研成果和其它相关的工作成果,为读者从各个方面了解厦门2013年文化体制改革与文化发展情况提供较为详细、全面的信息,为专家学者进行相关研究提供平台,为厦门市委、市政府相关决策提供服务。本书涵盖了2013年度厦门市文化体制改革和文化发展工作的主要任务,反映了厦门市2013年文化体制改革和文化事业、文化产业发展的进程,提出推动厦门文化体制改革与文化发展的规划、策略,对于推动厦门乃至福建文化产业发展,有一定的实践意义。
  • 中国生存启示录

    中国生存启示录

    这是一本面对现实如何生存的启示录,一本发现人生智慧、追寻幸福生活的指南书。是中国第一部以“培育健康价值观”为专题的心灵励志书。作家、教授梁晓声把他用心灵发展出的生存智慧反哺到精神境界中,再用他从社会生活中发展出的知识浸透到心灵里去,为那些生活在社会各阶层的人们,寻找一份心灵寄托与精神生活的充实,以及能够解决一些现实问题的方法。他以平常心去思考人生和社会中的常态及潜在的问题,用从容的心态做一些新的尝试和突破,力图为大众的现实生活寻找借鉴,在现实与精神的总作用下,告诉我们他自己的生活感受,启迪人们面对各种各样的现实应该拥有怎样的生存态度。
  • 多维视域的大众传媒

    多维视域的大众传媒

    本书是在中国广播电影电视总局的人文社科项目和中国传媒大学“382人才工程”的基础上形成的成果。本书尽量做到有理论有实际,论述深入浅出,适合大众阅读,希望能在传播理论的研究方面起到积极的促进作用。
  • 和谐社会论纲

    和谐社会论纲

    本书为学术性专著。构建社会主义和谐社会是近年来我国社会建设最重要的战略决策之一,社会主义和谐社会理论亦成为中国共产党从革命党转变为执政党之后最重要的马克思主义理论创新成果之一。如何结合中国改革开放三十年来的经济社会发展实际和全球化的时代大背景,深化和谐社会理论,从而为构建社会主义和谐社会实践提供可能的理论支撑,是我和我的学术朋友们近年来共同探讨的问题,这本《和谐社会论纲》就是我们思考的结晶。和谐社会理论理论内容博大精深,实践意义重大深远,我们的思考还是表层的、初步的,是谓"论纲"。如果它能引起人们的关注,并能将关于和谐社会的研究引向深入,我们的目的就达到了。
热门推荐
  • 爱的改变,为你改变

    爱的改变,为你改变

    什么?!同居!!!帅是帅,外表像天使,内心却是魔鬼般邪恶!在外面,温柔!在家里,霸道!天使原来是魔鬼,OMG!林雅静:你装,你继续装,看你能装到多久。
  • 莫要梅落空时言

    莫要梅落空时言

    她是将军小姐,他是太子,两小无猜,可是他是帝皇时,他亲手写下诏书,她父母双亡,他亲手带兵杀了他们俩最好的朋友,他说他爱她,却是为了天下,她笑笑天下。他是邪王,却爱她入骨,天下算什么,你就是我的天下
  • 女帝踏天

    女帝踏天

    为保全亲人,她不惜涉险抛弃肉身。机缘之下,她化身为妖。虽以妖心修炼,却逆转乾坤,家人、朋友、爱人,她竭尽全力去保护;家园、师门、宗派,她不惜生命去守护。她轻轻柔柔,却以不屈的傲骨,坚韧的心独步天下,成为万众瞩目的女帝。天外有天,面对外来的侵略,她将如何取舍?是独走他乡,与亲人朋友遥遥无期的分离,还是生死与共的奋战到底?
  • 媚型妖精建个后宫养男宠
  • 最唯美的文字写爱情

    最唯美的文字写爱情

    全是唯美的文字,看了会哭,不容错过。。。。。。
  • 万灵神主

    万灵神主

    一个从小被药师爷爷收养的孤儿,意外得到一个师傅,结果双双离开自己,是在尘世中沉沦还是迎难而上,成为万灵之主?喜欢此书的可以加扣扣群340707348
  • 杜工部草堂诗话

    杜工部草堂诗话

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。
  • 乱写美漫

    乱写美漫

    “这是必须的牺牲,它将带来我们的新生。”站在不断破灭的巨大天体群外,布莱恩回头看了看仅剩的最后一名挚友,脸上闪过一丝对过去的缅怀,毫不犹豫踏入了面前的光门。前一世的布莱恩是个超级英雄,这一世他将成为最终反派!一切将重新开始!PS:1.美漫版本的杀与...咳咳,美漫版本的冰与火之歌。2.漫威+DC综合。3.力量体系作者自定义,战设定请看作品名。完本老书《艾泽拉斯不灭传说》只管看,不管毒...就这样书友交流群:272817132
  • 埋忧续集

    埋忧续集

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。
  • 全元曲—杂剧(中华传世藏书)

    全元曲—杂剧(中华传世藏书)

    元曲又称夹心。元曲是盛行于元代的一种文艺形式,包括杂剧和散曲,有时专指杂剧。 杂剧,宋代以滑稽搞笑为特点的一种表演形式。元代发展成戏曲形式,每本以四折为主,在开头或折间另加楔子。每折用同宫调同韵的北曲套曲和宾白组成。如关汉卿的《窦娥冤》等。流行于大都(今北京)一带。明清两代也有杂剧,但每本不限四折。 散曲,盛行于元、明、清三代的没有宾白的曲子形式。内容以抒情为主,有小令和散套两种。