登陆注册
14926500000005

第5章 (4)

What M. Proudhon calls use value is called estimation value by other economists, and with just as much right. We shall quote only Storch ( Cours d'economie politique , Paris 1823, pp.48 and 49).

According to him, needs are the things for which we feel the need; values are things to which we attribute value. Most things have value only because they satisfy needs engendered by estimation. The estimation of our needs may change; therefore the utility of things, which expresses only the relation of these things to our needs, may also change.

Natural needs themselves are continually changing. Indeed, what could be more varied than the objects which form the staple food of different peoples!

The conflict does not take place between utility and estimation;it takes place between the marketable value demanded by the supplier and the marketable value supplied by the demander. The exchange value of the product is each time the resultant of these contradictory appreciations.

In final analysis, supply and demand bring together production and consumption, but production and consumption based on individual exchanges.

The product supplied is not useful in itself. It is the consumer who determines its utility. And even when its quality of being useful is admitted, it does not exclusively represent utility. In the course of production, it has been exchanged for all the costs of production, such as raw materials, wages of workers, etc., all of which are marketable values. The product, therefore, represents, in the eyes of the producer, a sum total of marketable values. What he supplies is not only a useful object, but also and above all a marketable value.

As to demand, it will only be effective on condition that it has means of exchange at its disposal. These means are themselves products, marketable value.

In supply and demand, then, we find on the one hand a product which has cost marketable values, and the need to sell; on the other, means which have cost marketable values, and the desire to buy.

M. Proudhon opposes the free buyer to the free producer. To the one and to the other he attributes purely metaphysical qualities. It is this that makes him say:

"It is proved that it is man's free will that gives rise to the opposition between use value and exchange value."[I 41]

The producer, the moment he produces in a society founded on the division of labor and on exchange (and that is M. Proudhon's hypothesis), is forced to sell. M. Proudhon makes the producer master of the means of production;but he will agree with us that his means of production do not depend on free will. Moreover, many of these means of production are products which he gets from the outside, and in modern production he is not even free to produce the amount he wants. The actual degree of development of the productive forces compels him to produce on such or such a scale.

The consumer is no freer than the producer. His judgment depends on his means and his needs. Both of these are determined by his social position, which itself depends on the whole social organization. True, the worker who buys potatoes and the kept woman who buys lace both follow their respective judgments. But the difference in their judgements is explained by the difference in the positions which they occupy in the world, and which themselves are the product of social organization.

Is the entire system of needs on estimation or on the whole organization of production? Most often, needs arise directly from production or from a state of affairs based on production. Thus, to choose another example, does not the need for lawyers suppose a given civil law which is but the expression of a certain development of property, that is to say, of production?

It is not enough for M. Proudhon to have eliminated the elements just mentioned from the relation of supply and demand. He carries abstraction to the furthest limits when he fuses all producers into one single producer, all consumers into one single consumer, and sets up a struggle between these two chimerical personages. But in the real world, things happen otherwise.

The competition among the suppliers and the competition among the demanders form a necessary part of the struggle between buyers and sellers, of which marketable value is the result.

After having eliminated competition and the cost of production, M. Proudhon can at his ease reduce the formula of supply and demand to an absurdity.

"Supply and demand," he says, "are merely two ceremonial forms that serve to bring use value and exchange value face to face, and to lead to their reconciliation. They are the two electric poles which, when connected, must produce the phenomenon of affinity called exchange."(Volume I, pp.49 and 50)

One might as well say that exchange is merely a "ceremonial form" for introducing the consumer to the object of consumption. One might as well say that all economic relations are "ceremonial forms" serving immediate consumption as go-betweens. Supply and demand are neither more nor less relations of a given production than are individual exchanges.

What, then, does all M. Proudhon's dialectic consist in? In the substitition for use value and exchange value, for supply and demand, of abstract and contradictory notions like scarcity and abundance, utility and estimation, one producer and one consumer, both of them knights of free will.

And what was he aiming at?

At arranging for himself a means of introducing later on one of the elements he had set aside, the cost of production, as the synthesis of use value and exchange value. And it is thus that in his eyes the cost of production constitutes synthetic value or constituted value.

同类推荐
  • 证类本草

    证类本草

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。
  • 维摩经略疏

    维摩经略疏

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。
  • 雷峰宝卷

    雷峰宝卷

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。
  • 明道篇

    明道篇

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。
  • The Governess

    The Governess

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。
热门推荐
  • 宋家客厅:从钱锺书到张爱玲

    宋家客厅:从钱锺书到张爱玲

    本书是宋以朗围绕其父宋淇的一部传记。宋淇(1919—1996),笔名林以亮等,文艺评论家和翻译家,在文学批评、红学研究、翻译、电影等诸多领域均有建树;与张爱玲、钱锺书、傅雷、吴兴华、夏志清等有深交,长期以朋友身份担任张爱玲的文学经纪人和顾问,张爱玲去世前将遗物(包括遗稿)交给宋淇、邝文美夫妇保管。作者在私家资料、家族记忆和公开资料的基础上完成本书的叙述,书中涉及的大量细节不仅还原了宋淇的一生,披露了那一代文化人的相知相惜,破解了不少疑团和误解,也构建了一部“细节文化史”,使读者可以看到20世纪华语文学、翻译、电影和大时代的一个侧影。
  • 骨科医生

    骨科医生

    这是一个普通的骨科医生成为亡灵法师的故事!
  • EXO之勋寻悦

    EXO之勋寻悦

    本书的原名叫《EXO:男神你别跑》,有机会我会把书名修改一下。金沐雅,是亚洲大势男团EXO的成员kai的妹妹,通过sm公司的选秀,让你加入EXO成为第十三位成员,之后和成员吴世勋暗生情愫,经历了重重考验,两人终于在一起。ps:我不会弃更,因为我是学生党,不定期更新
  • 苍穹剑君

    苍穹剑君

    赤州有剑名周,得周者,既是周天子!这是一方剑之世界,百家罢黜,独尊剑道!少年苏白为替母亲申冤,遁入百里林海学剑,遇天河、识剑猿、得剑宝,成就惊才绝艳之名。剑者登剑台,辟剑府,入剑宫,再进一步若能得周天子封剑君之位,便是剑者之极。苏白不停步,他要求的是剑道之真!---扣扣群:427286129,有问必答,有催必更。
  • 火澜

    火澜

    当一个现代杀手之王穿越到这个世界。是隐匿,还是崛起。一场血雨腥风的传奇被她改写。一条无上的强者之路被她踏破。修斗气,炼元丹,收兽宠,化神器,大闹皇宫,炸毁学院,打死院长,秒杀狗男女,震惊大陆。无止尽的契约能力,上古神兽,千年魔兽,纷纷前来抱大腿,惊傻世人。她说:在我眼里没有好坏之分,只有强弱之分,只要你能打败我,这世间所有都是你的,打不败我,就从这世间永远消失。她狂,她傲,她的目标只有一个,就是凌驾这世间一切之上。三国皇帝,魔界妖王,冥界之主,仙界至尊。到底谁才是陪着她走到最后的那个?他说:上天入地,我会陪着你,你活着,有我,你死,也一定有我。本文一对一,男强女强,强强联手,不喜勿入。
  • 大世行修

    大世行修

    大道轮转,天地运行。沐家少年在家族长辈的推动下走出了自小生活长大的山村。在这大世将起的大背景下,身负家传玄功的他又要如何行走天地间.修身、修心、修行。通过文字,尽量完整的把心中的故事表现出来。我将为了让每一个愿意看这本书的读者,能在书中找到那一份属于他或她的悸动而努力。
  • 我才不是闪闪萝

    我才不是闪闪萝

    意外穿越到一个奇葩地方的宅猛然发现自己变成了萝莉金闪闪。总之我才不是那只傲娇中二的闪闪萝呢哼!主角大声宣布。这大概是一个有些轻松,有些热血,又有些悲伤的故事。新人新书,请大家多多指教
  • 豪门千金:腹黑女王

    豪门千金:腹黑女王

    十九年前你害我母亲死,还害我的家庭破碎,好,十九年后,我要你血债血偿,虐小三,虐白莲花,某女“帮我,我只有一个目的,害我母亲者全部都要付出代价”“好,不愧是我的女人,这事以后再说,现在有重要的事。”“啊”“干你”然后眼前一晃,就被某只老狐狸按倒在床
  • 呆萌黑化录之白发妖王

    呆萌黑化录之白发妖王

    莫羽空:“夫君,为什么总有人追杀我们?”墨九天:“大概你因为你炸了人家老窝吧。”莫羽空:“不对!”墨九天:“那是因为什么?”莫羽空:“因为他们嫉妒我们貌美如花!”这是一个轻松搞笑、脑洞乱开的故事。读者:“永远不知道下一章会发生什么。”作者:“因为寡人自己都不知道!”
  • 福妻驾到

    福妻驾到

    现代饭店彪悍老板娘魂穿古代。不分是非的极品婆婆?三年未归生死不明的丈夫?心狠手辣的阴毒亲戚?贪婪而好色的地主老财?吃上顿没下顿的贫困宭境?不怕不怕,神仙相助,一技在手,天下我有!且看现代张悦娘,如何身带福气玩转古代,开面馆、收小弟、左纳财富,右傍美男,共绘幸福生活大好蓝图!!!!快本新书《天媒地聘》已经上架开始销售,只要3.99元即可将整本书抱回家,你还等什么哪,赶紧点击下面的直通车,享受乐乐精心为您准备的美食盛宴吧!)