登陆注册
14926500000042

第42章 (1)

COMPETITION AND MONOPOLY

"Competition is as essential to Good side of | labor as division.... It is competition| necessary for the advent of | equality."

[I 186, 188]

"The principle is the negation of Bad side of| itself. Its most certain result competition| is to ruin those whom it drags | in its train."

[I 185]

"The drawback which follow General reflection| in its wake, just as the good it | provides... both flow logically | from the principle."

[I 185-86]

"To seek the principle of | accommodation, which must be | derived from a law superior to | liberty itself."

[I 185]

Variant

Problem to be solved | "There can, therefore, be no | question here of destroying | competition, a thing as impos-| sible to destroy as liberty; we | have only to find its equilibrium | I would be ready to say its | police."

[I 223] M . Proudhon begins by defending the eternal necessity of competition against those who wish to replace it by emulation [Engels: The Fourierists].

There is no "purposeless emulation", and as "the object of every passion is necessarily analogous to the passion itself -- a woman for the lover, power for the ambitious, gold for the miser, a garland for the poet --the object of indus- trial emulation is necessarily profit. Emulation is nothing but competition itself."[I 187]

Competition is emulation with a view to profit. Is industrial emulation necessarily emulation with a view to profit, that is, competition?? M.

Proudhon proves it by affirming it. We have seen that, for him, to affirm is to prove, just as to suppose is to deny.

If the immediate object of the lover is the woman, the immediate object of industrial emulation is the product and not the profit.

Competition is not industrial emulation, it is commercial emulation.

In our time industrial emulation exists only in view of commerce. There are even phases in the economic life of modern nations when everybody is seized with a sort of craze for making profit without producing. This speculation craze, which recurs periodically, lays bare the true character of competition, which seeks to escape the need for industrial emulation.

If you had told an artisan of the 14th century that the privileges and the whole feudal organization of industry were going to be abrogated in favor of industrial emulation, called competition, he would have replied that the privileges of the various corporations, guilds and fraternities were organized competition. M. Proudhon does not impose upon this when he affirms that "emulation is nothing but competition itself".

"Decree that from the first of January 1847, labor and wages shall be guaranteed to everybody: immediately an immense relaxation will succeed the high tension of industry."[I 189]

Instead of a supposition, an affirmation and a negation, we have now a decree that M. Proudhon issues purposely to prove the necessity of competition, its eternity as a category, etc.

If we imagine that decrees are all that is needed to get away from competition, we shall never get away from it. And if we go so far as to propose to abolish competition while retaining wages, we shall be proposing nonsense by royal decree. But nations do not proceed by royal decree. Before framing such ordinances, they must at least have changed from top to bottom the conditions of their industrial and political existence, and consequently their whole manner of being.

M. Proudhon will reply, with his imperturbable assurance, that it is the hypothesis of "a transformation of our nature without historical antecedents", and that he would be right in "excluding is from the discussion", we know not in virtue of which ordinance.

M. Proudhon does not know that all history is nothing but a continuous transformation of human nature.

"Let us stick to the facts. The French Revolution was made for industrial liberty as much as for political liberty; and although France, in 1789, had not perceived -- let us say it openly -- all the consequences of the principle whose real- ization it demanded, it was mistaken neither in its wishes nor in its expectations. Whoever attempts to deny this loses, in my view, the right to criticisM. I will never dispute with an adversary who puts as principle the spont- aneous error of 25 million men....

"Why then, if competition had not been a principle of social economy, a decree of fate, a necessity of the human soul, why, instead of abolishing corporations, guilds and brother- hoods, did nobody think rather of repairing the whole??"[I 191, 192]

So, since the French of the 18th century abolished corporations, guilds, and fraternities instead of modifying them, the French of the 19th century must modify competition instead of abolishing it. Since competition was established in France in the 18th century as a result of historical needs, this competition must not be destroyed in the 19th century because of other historical needs. M. Proudhon, not understanding that the establishment of competition was bound up with the actual development of the men of the 18th century, makes of competition a necessity of the human soul , in partibus infidelium [ed: literally, "territory of the infidels"; here, meaning, "beyond the realm of reality".] What would he have made of the great Colbert for the 17th century??

After the revolution comes the present state of affairs. M. Proudhon equally draws facts from it to show the eternity of competition, by proving that all industries in which this category is not yet sufficiently developed, as in agriculture, are in a state of inferiority and decrepitude.

To say that there are industries which have not yet reached the stage of competition, that others gains are below the level of bourgeois production, is drivel which gives not the slightest proof of the eternity of competition.

同类推荐
  • 修西闻见录

    修西闻见录

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。
  • 寄卢载

    寄卢载

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。
  • Remember the Alamo

    Remember the Alamo

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。
  • MOSSES FROM AN OLD MANSE

    MOSSES FROM AN OLD MANSE

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。
  • 周易

    周易

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。
热门推荐
  • 舍利子传奇

    舍利子传奇

    一个民间传奇,佛家正果之一“舍利子”的故事!
  • 六界乱世之妖女乱天下

    六界乱世之妖女乱天下

    真的是。。。。今天出门一定是没有看黄历,处处倒霉不说,竟然就怎么被撞死了!!!心情狠不爽啊。。。也许是上天怜悯,我竟然就此穿越了???原以为是傻白甜的种田文,但是种下去的种子和长出来的果实怎么不是一个品种啊!!!到底是怎么回事,,,看来这个世界比我想的有意思多了-------------------
  • 蛇王的绝宠娇妻

    蛇王的绝宠娇妻

    女主:染陌璃男主:凰紫宸本文多喜,,稍有悲情戏哈!这素系第一次写穿越文,希望看官亲们多赞一个,多多收藏哦!不喜勿喷!灰常感谢!!!染陌璃经过穿越君的选择,来到了异世,往日在商场叱咤风云的她竟然也有迷糊的时候,精明时的她狡诈如狐,迷糊时的她可爱呆萌。什么?她竟然穿了,还穿成了一只火红色小狐狸。不受宠的草包美人。而那个整天抱着她的腹黑美男又是谁?天,你玩我呢吧?皇帝难道嫌她太悠闲了,竟在10年前给原主和那啥皇子定下了婚约,一只狐狸怎么和别人成亲?逃婚呢?还是逃婚呢?而那个浑身充满酸味的腹黑又想干什么?“啊.........唔,”某女尖叫声嘎然而止。原来他和她是上世情缘,花开又能否结果????
  • 短线炒股100招

    短线炒股100招

    全书共分10章,包括如何根据基础理论知识寻找短线买点、正确认识并建立短线操作系统和短线逃顶等三大部分。寻找短线买点部分包括:技术指标买点、均线买点、K线组合买点、量能形态买点、黄金分割率买点和形态买点等内容。正确认识并建立短线操作系统部分包括:短线操作的概念、短线操作理念和心态、短线操作的市场环境和短线操作的基本步骤等内容。短线逃顶部分包括:K线顶、轨道线顶、均线顶和短线共振卖点等内容。
  • 不死神武

    不死神武

    【免费新书】【火爆热门】九州大陆,宗门林立,武道为尊。弱者庸碌,受人欺辱。强者一怒,血流成河。一名弱小书生自青州而出,修炼体之法,其曰:“吾有一体,可抗世间万法!!!”【神武群号可提前看小说:463131666】
  • 最异世

    最异世

    一场意外,一位天才,降临觉醒于异世的大地,开启一场传奇之旅
  • 尘之渊

    尘之渊

    创世之神,神创六界,生死不弃;天帝之女,以身捍道,终失他人;魔之帝姬,万念虽空,遗心念君;再世神女,不离不弃,衷心侍主;僵尸女童,视兄如命,不改初衷;——你拯救苍生,却从未拯救过自己
  • 彼岸:青春誓言

    彼岸:青春誓言

    她,是折断了翅膀的天使,是人间最柔情的恶魔。他,是生活在天堂的恶魔,有着天使的外表。她的漠然,执着。他的狂妄,不羁。仇恨迫使她掩埋内心的情感,天生的高傲使他几乎折断了两人手中的红线。最后的选择,又该如何?
  • 妖夜莲华传

    妖夜莲华传

    这是一个玄幻与言情交错的奇幻故事,莲华学艺有成之后,为了寻找多年前灭门惨案的真相,踏上了对魔界暗罗刹城城主夜迦的复仇之路。途中结识了狐狸变成的男子朱离,两人在患难中产生了深厚的友情。小说悬念层层叠叠,一切真相大白之后,却是令人意想不到的结果。
  • 少室山房集

    少室山房集

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。