登陆注册
14926500000011

第11章 (3)

"Say and the economists after him have observed that labor being itself subject to valuation, being a commodity like any other commodity, it is moving in a vicious circle to treat it as the principle and the determining cause of value. In so doing, these economists, if they will allow me to say so, show a prodigious carelessness. Labor is said to have value not as a commodity itself, but in view of the values which it is supposed potentially to contain. The value of labor is a figurative expression, an anticipation of the cause for the effect. It is a fiction of the same stamp as the productivity of capital. Labor produces, capital has value....

By a sort of ellipsis one speaks of the value of labor....

Labor like liberty... is a thing vague and indeterminate by nature, but defined qualitatively by its object, that is to say, it becomes a reality by the product."[I 61]

"But is there any need to dwell on this? The moment the economist (read M. Proudhon) changes the name of things, vera rerum vocabula [the true name of things], he is implicitly confessing his impotence and proclaiming himself not privy to the cause."(Proudhon, I, 188)

We have seen that M. Proudhon makes the value of labor the "determining cause" of the value of products to such an extent that for him wages, the official name for the "value of labor", form the integral price of all things: that is why Say's objection troubles hiM. In labor as a commodity, which is a grim reality, he sees nothing but a grammatical ellipsis. Thus the whole of existing society, founded on labor as a commodity, is henceforth founded on a poetic licence, a figurative expression. If society wants to "eliminate all the drawbacks" that assail it, well, let it eliminate all the ill-sounding terms, change the language; and to this end it has only to apply to the Academy for a new edition of its dictionary. After all that we have just seen, it is easy for us to understand why M. Proudhon, in a work on political economy, has to enter upon long dissertations on etymology and other parts of grammar. Thus he is still learnedly discussing the antiquated derivation of servus from servare . These philological dissertations have a deep meaning, an esoteric meaning -- they form an essential part of M. Proudhon's argument.

Labor [4] , inasmuch as it is bought and sold, is a commodity like any other commodity, and has, in consequence, an exchange value. But the value of labor, or labor as a commodity, produces as little as the value of wheat, or wheat as a commodity, serves as food.

Labor "is worth" more or less, according to whether food commodities are more or less dear, whether the supply and demand of hands exist to such or such a degree, etc., etc.

Labor is not a "vague thing"; it is always some definite labor, it is never labor in general that is bought and sold. It is not only labor that is qualitatively defined by the object; but also the object which is determined by the specific quality of labor.

Labor, in so far as it is bought and sold, is itself a commodity.

Why is it bought? "Because of the values it is supposed potentially to contain." But if a certain thing is said to be a commodity, there is no longer any question as to the reason why it is bought, that is, as to the utility to be derived from it, the application to be made of it. It is a commodity as an object of traffic. All M. Proudhon's arguments are limited to this: labor is not bought as an immediate object of consumption. No, it is bought as an instrument of production, as a machine would be bought.

As a commodity, labor has no value and does not produce. M. Proudhon might just as well have said that there is no such thing as a commodity, since every commodity is obtained merely for some utilitarian purpose, and never as a commodity in itself.

In measuring the value of commodities by labor, M. Proudhon vaguely glimpses the impossibility of excluding labor from this same measure, in so far as labor has a value, as labor is a commodity. He has a misgiving that it is turning the wage minimum into the natural and normal price of immediate labor, that is is accepting the existing state of society. So, to get away from this fatal consequence, he faces about and asserts that labor is not a commodity, that it cannot have value. He forgets that he himself has taken the value of labor as a measure, he forgets that his whole system rests on labor as a commodity, on labor which is bartered, bought, sold, exchanged for produce, etc., on labor, in fact, which is an immediate source of income for the worker. He forgets everything.

To save his system, he consents to sacrifice its basis.

Et propter vitam vivendi perdere causas!

We now come to a new definition of "constituted value".

"Value is the proportional relation of the products which constitute wealth."Let us note in the first place that the single phrase "relative or exchange value" implies the idea of some relation in which products are exchanged reciprocally. By giving the name "proportional relation" to this relation, no change is made in the relative value, except in the expression. Neither the depreciation nor the enhancement of the value of a product destroys its quality of being in some "proportional relation" with the other products which constitute wealth.

Why then this new term, which introduces no new idea?

"Proportional relation" suggests many other economic relations, such as proportionality in production, the true proportion between supply and demand, etc., and M. Proudhon is thinking of all that when he formulates this didactic paraphrase of marketable value.

In the first place, the relative value of products being determined by the comparative amount of labor used in the production of each of them, proportional relations, applied to this special case, stand for the respective quota of products which can be manufactured in a given time, and which in consequence are given in exchange for one another.

Let us see what advantage M. Proudhon draws from this proportional relation.

同类推荐
  • 亦玉堂稿

    亦玉堂稿

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。
  • 乙酉岁舍弟扶侍归兴

    乙酉岁舍弟扶侍归兴

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。
  • 月真歌

    月真歌

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。
  • 诸葛忠武书

    诸葛忠武书

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。
  • 佛说阿弥陀经要解

    佛说阿弥陀经要解

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。
热门推荐
  • 上古之再起之风

    上古之再起之风

    “即使一切都被毁灭,风也会再次吹起。”一个由现实世界穿越而去的人类灵魂,在猎鹰高原的风迹部落中降生,那一天,风雷掠地,十七名古老的酋长,单手捂胸跪地行礼,对婴儿的兽灵英雄塔阳血脉献上最高的敬意。婴儿名为鲁德斯·图灵,猎鹰高原风迹部落酋长的儿子,是一个来自于现实的人类。古老的预言中,兽灵两千多年的血泪历史将在塔阳的后人手上终结,古老的塔弥帝国将重现辉煌,在预言中的天选者之门开启之时,塔阳的后人将带着兽灵一族重回原大陆。然而,鲁德斯点开自己的人物属性面板,看着自己身前来自于“现实”名为【天选者】的玩家们,幽幽地叹了一口气:“为什么我是个拥有玩家面板的NPC?”作为一名拥有了发布任务权力、影响世界剧情、无视装备佩戴等级的NPC玩家,鲁德斯觉得这个感觉真是让他酸爽的六体投地。
  • 末世奴役系统

    末世奴役系统

    张青一个年轻的特种兵,末世来临的是,无意被一块叫做奴役系统的芯片认主。从此之后,奴役一个又一个的潜力人物,而奴役系统,却不仅仅只是奴役那么简单,更多的功能等待这张青去触发,去开启。丧尸,是不是这个时代的主流。张青带着自己奴役到的得力手下,萝莉,淑女,御姐,大傻男,等等一众人行走在各个城市之中。各种丧尸种类......
  • 一生阴阳路

    一生阴阳路

    我是招魂师,无论你相信不相信这个世界上有没有鬼,我都会带你体验,灵异圈的世界。欢迎阅读长篇灵异小说《一生阴阳路》
  • 超级痛苦系统

    超级痛苦系统

    白小狼重生平行世界,这个世界是一个尚武的世界,但是却有着一个坑主人的系统,系统很全能,基本上什么都有,但是想要获得,那就必须承受各种痛苦。原本以为这系统也就这样了,没想到痛苦系统存在的意义并不止这样……“某某,就是你拥有最强的系统吗?不好意思,现在我需要回收!你的系统只是我拥有的系统的子系统而已!”白小狼来到一个玄幻位面,对着这个世界的主角说道。白小狼回收系统后,被剥夺系统的某主角,他的主角光环消失了,然后独自蹲在墙角哭泣。
  • 巨商书架:世界商业巨子推荐的读书计划

    巨商书架:世界商业巨子推荐的读书计划

    阅读是一种享受,写作这样一本书的过程更是一种享受。在享受之余,我们心中也充满了感恩。因为在写作过程中,我们不仅得到同行的帮助,还借鉴了其他人智慧的精华。相信你们劳动的价值不会磨灭,因为它给读者朋友们带来了宝贵的精神财富。
  • 柯南之守护神

    柯南之守护神

    我是一个柯南迷,青山刚昌那家伙人家火影忍者都完结了,他还不完结,真是的我看着毛利兰等新一的模样心好痛,柯南世界还有很多女神需要我来守护,可是不曾想我竟然穿越了,竟然如此就让我保护你们吧!
  • 基础侦探

    基础侦探

    我一直认为平凡的事迹不值得写成书籍。我也认为特殊是过犹不及的,过于特殊就是平凡,不值得写成书籍。为此,我不过多描述罪人们的故事。不过,像是救赎他人之人的故事;嘲笑他人之人的故事;寻找真相之人的故事;寻找自我之人的故事;守望之人的故事;漂泊之人的故事;虚心之人的故事;虚伪之人的故事。我会写一写他们的故事。要写的事有四件:何为意义?(sense)何为正义?(justice)何为真相?(truth)何为信仰?(faith)
  • 从星星爱起

    从星星爱起

    为你落下的最后一滴眼泪,是我最后的尊严。奈何花开,爱上花谢。璀璨时光,纵然世界颠覆,千疮百孔负你一世骄傲,转瞬之间,恍若隔世。若是世态炎凉,千转百回负你一往情深。可知,我早已坠入万丈深渊,无法逃脱。随黄昏来临,我看透一切,待黎明重来,至少在重生之前,让我死一次吧。心已灰死,却从没想过自己会爱上一个奇缘般的星星。叹息。敬你来日携手深爱有归期,我干杯你随意。
  • 千机公子

    千机公子

    前世.活的拘束.今生,以命护情."我叫苏月"玄冥大陆,枫林之中,千机山庄,千机公子,运筹帷幄,决胜千里.风起,卷起半城烟沙,亦,吹开她神秘面纱."七宗罪现世,千机山庄,业无法安静了......"
  • 三界游之宿命轮回

    三界游之宿命轮回

    来自未知的求援,诡异的纸船、断剑,携着平凡的地球少年,穿越时光的束缚,解开一个个未知的谜团!这儿有生死决、轮回果、诸天秘,更有家国情、兄弟义、游子泪,一切的一切敬请期待!